2025-11-20T08:43:14.986618

Double-faced white dwarfs and the magnetic inhibition of convection

Ginzburg

About one in five white dwarfs undergoes spectral evolution from a helium atmosphere to hydrogen and then back to helium. These short-lived hydrogen envelopes - the result of residual hydrogen diffusion - are eventually destroyed by either hydrogen or helium convection. An emerging class of double-faced white dwarfs seems to catch this process in the act, with varying amounts of hydrogen across regions of the stellar surface. Here, we quantitatively test the hypothesis that these inhomogeneities are the result of the magnetic inhibition of convection. We compute the critical magnetic field $B_{\rm crit}(M,T_{\rm eff})$ required to inhibit convection in both hydrogen and helium for $0.6-1.2\,M_\odot$ white dwarfs using two methods. Initially, we estimated $B_{\rm crit}\sim\sqrt{8ÏP}$ where $P$ is the pressure at the base of the convection zone, finding that most (three out of four) of the observed magnetic double-faced white dwarfs could potentially be explained by the magnetic inhibition of hydrogen convective energy transfer, with measured $B\gtrsim B_{\rm crit}^{\rm H}$. Then, we incorporated the magnetic field consistently into the stellar structure and directly computed the boundary of convective mixing. With this more appropriate method, we find that only half (two out of four) of the stars could be explained by the magnetic inhibition of helium convection, with $B\gtrsim B_{\rm crit}^{\rm He}$. Specifically, order of unity variations in the magnetic field's strength or orientation across the surface could account for the double-faced nature of these stars. Given our mixed results, other - including non-magnetic - scenarios should be considered as well.

academic

Double-faced white dwarfs and the magnetic inhibition of convection

基本信息

论文ID: 2509.02671
标题: Double-faced white dwarfs and the magnetic inhibition of convection
作者: Sivan Ginzburg (The Hebrew University, Jerusalem)
分类: astro-ph.SR (恒星与恒星演化)
发表期刊: MNRAS (Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society)
论文链接: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.02671

摘要

约五分之一的白矮星经历从氦大气到氢大气再回到氦大气的光谱演化。这些短暂的氢包层是残余氢扩散的结果，最终被氢或氦对流破坏。一类新兴的双面白矮星似乎捕捉到了这一过程，在恒星表面不同区域显示出不同的氢含量。本文定量检验了这些不均匀性是磁场抑制对流结果的假设。作者计算了抑制0.6-1.2太阳质量白矮星氢和氦对流所需的临界磁场 $B_{\rm crit}(M,T_{\rm eff})$ ，采用两种方法。初步估计 $B_{\rm crit}\sim\sqrt{8\pi P}$ （P为对流区底部压力），发现大多数（四颗中的三颗）观测到的磁性双面白矮星可能通过磁场抑制氢对流能量传递来解释。随后将磁场一致性地纳入恒星结构并直接计算对流混合边界，发现只有一半（四颗中的两颗）恒星可通过磁场抑制氦对流来解释。

研究背景与动机

问题背景

白矮星光谱演化：约20%的白矮星在冷却过程中经历复杂的光谱演化，从氦大气转为氢大气，最终又回到氦大气。这一过程由残余氢的浮升和对流破坏机制控制。
双面白矮星现象：新发现的双面白矮星类别展现出表面氢分布的不均匀性，氢和氦谱线强度随恒星自转周期性变化，提供了研究光谱演化的直接途径。
磁场效应假设：磁场被认为可能抑制对流能量传递，导致恒星表面不同区域的磁场强度或取向差异形成不均匀的氢包层分布。

研究动机

验证磁场抑制假设：定量检验磁场是否能解释双面白矮星的表面不均匀性
理论与观测结合：将观测到的磁场强度与理论预测的临界磁场进行比较
完善光谱演化理论：深入理解磁场在白矮星演化中的作用机制

核心贡献

建立了双面白矮星磁场抑制对流的定量理论框架，计算了不同质量和有效温度下的临界磁场强度
开发了两种互补的计算方法：
- 简化的后处理方法：基于 $B_{\rm crit}\sim\sqrt{8\pi P}$ 的估计
- 自洽的恒星结构方法：将磁场直接纳入对流不稳定性判据
系统分析了0.6-1.2太阳质量白矮星的氢和氦对流特性，揭示了质量对对流起始温度的影响
提供了观测检验结果：对现有四颗磁性双面白矮星样本进行了定量分析，得出混合结论

使用MESA恒星演化代码计算不同质量(0.6-1.2 M☉)白矮星的对流区演化
分别计算氢和氦包层的对流区质量 $m_{\rm conv}(T_{\rm eff})$
利用流体静力学平衡估算对流区底部压力： $P \approx \frac{GMm_{\rm conv}}{4\pi R^4}$
计算临界磁场： $B_{\rm crit} = \sqrt{8\pi P}$

方法二：自洽恒星结构方法

Gough & Tayler (1966) 判据： $\nabla_{\rm rad} > \nabla_{\rm ad} + \frac{B^2}{\beta^2 + 4\pi\gamma P}$

其中 $\nabla$ 表示温度梯度， $\gamma$ 为绝热指数。

实现方式：

在MESA中实现修正的Schwarzschild判据： $\nabla = \min\left(\nabla_{\rm rad}, \nabla_{\rm ad} + \frac{B^2}{\beta^2 + 4\pi P}\right)$
自洽计算温度分布和对流边界
直接确定磁场完全抑制对流混合的区域