2025-11-13T06:13:10.918331

Quantum fluctuation-induced first-order breaking of time-reversal symmetry in unconventional superconductors

Shi

Spontaneous time-reversal symmetry breaking in superconductors with competing non-degenerate pairing channels is an exotic quantum phase transition that could give rise to robust topological superconductivity and unusual magnetism. It is proposed mostly in two-dimensional systems and is signaled by a nonzero relative phase between the two superconducting order parameters, hence it should particularly be prone to order-parameter phase fluctuations. Nevertheless, the existing understanding of it is still at the mean-field level. Here, we illustrate the non-negligible effects of the phase fluctuations on such quantum phase transitions using the hole-doped square-lattice $t$-$J$ model as an example. We derive the phase fluctuation-corrected free energy and show that under the quantum phase fluctuations, the time-reversal asymmetric $s+id$ phase region splits off a dome featuring a first-order border with the $d$ phase, indicating the possibility of a phase separation into the time-reversal symmetric and asymmetric phases. The phase fluctuations also narrow the range of the $s+id$ phase considerably. We further discuss the implications of our findings for recent experiments on disorder-induced first-order quantum breakdown of superconductivity and promising high-temperature topological superconductivity in twisted cuprate Josephson junctions.

academic

Quantum fluctuation-induced first-order breaking of time-reversal symmetry in unconventional superconductors

基本信息

论文ID: 2510.09234
标题: Quantum fluctuation-induced first-order breaking of time-reversal symmetry in unconventional superconductors
作者: Yin Shi (Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics and Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences)
分类: cond-mat.supr-con (凝聚态物理-超导)
发表时间: October 13, 2025
论文链接: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09234

摘要

本文研究了非常规超导体中自发时间反演对称性破缺的量子相变。在具有竞争性非简并配对通道的超导体中，这种相变可能产生稳健的拓扑超导性和异常磁性。作者使用空穴掺杂的方格子t-J模型，推导了相位涨落修正的自由能，发现量子相位涨落使时间反演不对称的s+id相区域分裂出一个圆顶结构，该结构与d相之间存在一阶边界，表明可能出现时间反演对称和不对称相的相分离。

研究背景与动机

问题定义

核心问题: 现有对自发时间反演对称性破缺超导态的理解仍停留在平均场理论层面，忽略了序参量相位涨落的重要影响
重要性: 时间反演对称性破缺的超导态本身可能具有拓扑非平凡性，有望实现受量子退相干保护的稳健量子计算机
现有局限:
- 以往理论处理均基于平均场近似
- 忽略了二维系统中特别重要的动力学序参量相位涨落
- 缺乏对量子相位涨落如何影响相变性质的深入理解

研究动机

时间反演破缺超导相由两个序参量间的非零相对相位标志，特别容易受到序参量相位涨落影响
量子序参量相位涨落对准二维超导体的超导基态有显著影响
需要建立包含长程序参量相位涨落的理论框架

核心贡献

理论框架创新: 建立了包含长程序参量相位涨落与电荷密度涨落耦合的自洽理论框架
相图修正: 发现量子相位涨落导致s+id相区域分裂出圆顶结构，与d相形成一阶边界
相变性质改变: 证明了量子涨落可以将二阶相变改变为一阶相变
实验指导: 为理解扭转铜氧化物约瑟夫森结中的时间反演对称性破缺提供理论依据

方法详解

任务定义

研究方格子t-J模型中竞争性s波和d波超导配对通道间的量子相变，特别关注序参量相位涨落对时间反演对称性破缺相变的影响。

模型架构

哈密顿量构建

采用包含长程库仑相互作用的t-J模型： $H = -\sum_{rr'\sigma} \tilde{t}_{r-r'}c^\dagger_{r\sigma}c_{r'\sigma} - \frac{J}{2}\sum_{\langle rr'\rangle} b^\dagger_{rr'}b_{rr'} + \sum_q \frac{V_q}{2N}\rho^\dagger_q\rho_q$

其中：

$c_{r\sigma}$ : 自旋为σ的电子湮灭算符
$b_{rr'} = c_{r\downarrow}c_{r'\uparrow} - c_{r\uparrow}c_{r'\downarrow}$ : 单重态对湮灭算符
$V_q = e^2/(2\epsilon_b\epsilon_0 aq)$ : 二维库仑势

路径积分形式化

通过Hubbard-Stratonovich变换解耦相互作用后的作用量： $S = \int_0^{1/T} d\tau \left\{\sum_{rr'} \psi^\dagger_r(\tau)[\delta_{rr'}(\partial_\tau + \phi_r(\tau)\tau_3) - \tilde{t}_{r-r'}\tau_3 + \Delta_{rr'}(\tau)\tau_+ + \Delta^*_{rr'}(\tau)\tau_-]\psi_{r'}(\tau) + \frac{2}{J}\sum_{\langle rr'\rangle}|\Delta_{rr'}(\tau)|^2 - \sum_q \frac{|\phi_q(\tau)|^2}{2NV_q}\right\}$

相位涨落处理

采用规范变换 $\psi_r(\tau) \to \psi_r(\tau)e^{i\theta_r(\tau)\tau_3}$ 和 $\Delta_{rr'}(\tau) \to \Delta_{r-r'}e^{i[\theta_r(\tau)+\theta_{r'}(\tau)]}$ ，将作用量按 $\theta_r(\tau)$ 和 $\phi_r(\tau)$ 的小时空梯度展开至二次项。