2025-11-23T19:31:17.813110

A Monte Carlo approach to bound Trotter error

Blunt, Ivanov, Bay-Smidt

Trotter product formulas are a natural and powerful approach to perform quantum simulation. However, the error analysis of product formulas is challenging, and their cost is often overestimated. It is established that Trotter error can be bounded in terms of spectral norms of nested commutators of the Hamiltonian partitions [Childs et al., Phys. Rev. X 11, 011020], but evaluating these expressions is challenging, often achieved by repeated application of the triangle inequality, significantly loosening the bound. Here, we show that the spectral norm of an operator can be upper bounded by the spectral norm of an equivalent sign-problem-free operator, which can be calculated efficiently to large system sizes using projector Monte Carlo simulation. For a range of Hamiltonians and considering second-order formulas, we demonstrate that this Monte Carlo-based bound is often extremely tight, and even exact in some instances. For the uniform electron gas we reduce the cost of performing Trotterization from the literature by an order of magnitude. For the Pariser-Parr-Pople model for linear acene molecules, which has $\mathcal{O}(N^2)$ long-range interaction terms, we show that it suffices to use $\mathcal{O}(N^{0.57})$ Trotter steps and circuit depth $\mathcal{O}(N^{1.57})$ to implement Hamiltonian simulation. We hope that this approach will lead to a better understanding of the potential accuracy of Trotterization in a range of important applications.

academic

A Monte Carlo approach to bound Trotter error

基本信息

论文ID: 2510.11621
标题: A Monte Carlo approach to bound Trotter error
作者: Nick S. Blunt, Aleksei V. Ivanov, Andreas Juul Bay-Smidt
分类: quant-ph physics.chem-ph
发表时间: October 14, 2025
论文链接: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11621

核心问题：Trotter乘积公式在量子模拟中的误差分析困难，导致其成本被系统性高估
重要性：量子模拟是量子计算最有前景的应用之一，Trotterization是实现量子模拟的简单自然方法
现有局限性：
- 现有的Trotter误差界限基于嵌套对易子的谱范数，但计算这些表达式在计算上具有挑战性
- 通常使用三角不等式来简化计算，但这会显著放松界限
- 在容错量子计算的资源估计研究中，Trotterization的性能被显著低估

研究动机

作者认为Trotterization的性能被低估的原因有两个：

Trotter电路可以有效并行化，减少电路深度和体积
Trotter误差分析非常困难，乘积公式的误差经常被高估数个数量级

核心贡献

理论贡献：证明了任意算子的谱范数可以被等价无符号问题算子的谱范数上界： $\|A\| \leq \|\text{abs}(A)\|$
方法创新：提出使用投影蒙特卡罗方法（FCIQMC）来高效计算无符号问题算子的谱范数
实际应用：
- 对均匀电子气体，将文献中Trotterization成本降低了一个数量级
- 对Pariser-Parr-Pople模型的线性苊分子，证明只需 $O(N^{0.57})$ 个Trotter步骤
基准结果：为多个重要哈密顿量提供了精确的Trotter误差范数基准

方法详解

核心理论基础

谱范数上界定理：对于矩阵 $A$ ，定义 $\text{abs}(A)$ 为元素为 $|A_{ij}|$ 的矩阵，则： $\|A\| \leq \|\text{abs}(A)\|$

证明要点：

利用谱范数定义： $\|A\| = \max_{\|v\|_2=1} \|Av\|_2$
通过Cauchy-Schwarz不等式建立不等式关系
关键在于 $\|\text{abs}(A)\|$ 可以通过Perron-Frobenius定理高效计算

Trotter误差界限

对于哈密顿量 $H = T + V$ ，二阶Trotter公式： $S_2(t) = e^{-iVt/2}e^{-iTt}e^{-iVt/2}$

误差界限为： $\|S_2(t) - U(t)\| \leq W t^3$

其中： $W_{VTV} = \frac{1}{12}\|[[V,T],T]\| + \frac{1}{24}\|[[V,T],V]\|$

蒙特卡罗计算方法

FCIQMC算法：

状态更新： $C_i(\tau + \Delta\tau) = C_i(\tau) - \Delta\tau \sum_j (A_{ij} - S\delta_{ij})C_j(\tau)$
无符号问题处理：设置 $A \rightarrow -\text{abs}(A)$ 消除符号问题
本征值估计：使用shift估计器和mixed估计器