2025-11-25T02:13:16.692132

When Support Hides Progress: Insights from a Physics Tutorial on Solving Laplace's Equation Using Separation of Variables in Cartesian Coordinates

Kashyap, Devaty, Singh

The electrostatic potential in certain types of boundary value problems can be found by solving Laplace's Equation (LE). To develop students' ability for solving problems that can be solved effectively using Laplace's equation in an upper-level electricity and magnetism course, we developed and validated a tutorial focused on finding electrostatic potential in a Cartesian coordinate system. The tutorial was implemented across three instructors' classes, accompanied by scaffolded pretest and posttest. We also conducted think-aloud interviews with advanced students using both unscaffolded and scaffolded versions of the pretest and posttest. Findings reveal common student difficulties that were included in the tutorial as a guide to help address them. The difference in the performance of students from the pretest to the posttest was similar on the scaffolded version of the tests for all three instructors' classes and interviewed students. Equally importantly, interviewed students demonstrated greater differences in scores from the pretest and posttest on the unscaffolded versions, suggesting that the scaffolded version of the tests may have obscured evidence of actual learning from the tutorial. While a scaffolded test is typically intended to guide students through complex reasoning by breaking a problem into sub-problems and offering structured support, it can limit opportunities to demonstrate independent problem-solving and evidence of learning from the tutorial. Additionally, one instructor's class underperformed relative to others even on the pretest. This instructor had mentioned that the tests and tutorial were not relevant to their current course syllabus and offered a small amount of extra credit for attempting to help education researchers, highlighting how this type of instructor framing of instructional tasks can negatively impact student engagement and performance.

academic

When Support Hides Progress: Insights from a Physics Tutorial on Solving Laplace's Equation Using Separation of Variables in Cartesian Coordinates

基本信息

论文ID: 2510.11968
标题: When Support Hides Progress: Insights from a Physics Tutorial on Solving Laplace's Equation Using Separation of Variables in Cartesian Coordinates
作者: Jaya Shivangani Kashyap, Robert Devaty, Chandralekha Singh (University of Pittsburgh)
分类: physics.ed-ph (物理教育研究)
机构: Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh
研究类型: 物理教育研究，教学工具开发与评估

摘要

本研究开发并验证了一个针对高年级电磁学课程的教程，帮助学生掌握使用拉普拉斯方程求解静电势的方法。研究在三个不同教师的课堂中实施了该教程，并配合脚手架式的前测和后测。同时对高年级学生进行了思维出声访谈，使用了有脚手架和无脚手架两个版本的测试。研究发现了学生的常见困难，并将其纳入教程设计中。重要的是，访谈学生在无脚手架版本测试中显示出更大的前后测差异，表明脚手架版本的测试可能掩盖了学生从教程中获得的实际学习效果。此外，一位教师的学生表现相对较差，该教师曾表示测试和教程与当前课程大纲无关，仅提供少量额外学分，这突出了教师对教学任务的框架表述对学生参与度和表现的重要影响。