2025-11-21T00:34:15.372501

Implementing the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithms for QUBO problems Across Quantum Hardware Platforms: Performance Analysis, Challenges, and Strategies

Pihkakoski, Babu, Taipale et al.

Quantum computers are expected to offer significant advantages in solving complex optimization problems that are challenging for classical computers. Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problems represent an important class of problems with relevance in finance and logistics. The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is a prominent candidate for solving QUBO problems on near-term quantum devices. In this paper, we investigate the performance of both the standard QAOA and the adaptive derivative assembled problem tailored QAOA (ADAPT-QAOA) to solve QUBO problems of varying sizes and hardnesses with a focus on its practical applications in financial feature selection problems. Our main observation is that ADAPT-QAOA significantly outperforms QAOA with hard problems (trade-off parameter Î± = 0.6) when comparing approximation ratio and time-to-solution. However, the standard QAOA remains efficient for simpler problems. Additionally, we investigate the practical feasibility and limitations of QAOA by scaling analysis based on the real-device calibration data for various hardware platforms. Our estimates indicate that standard QAOA implemented on superconducting quantum computers provides a shorter time-to-solution compared to trapped-ion devices. However, trapped-ion devices are expected to yield more favorable error rates. Our findings provide a comprehensive overview of the challenges, trade-offs, and strategies for deploying QAOA-based methods on near-term quantum hardware.

academic

Implementing the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithms for QUBO problems Across Quantum Hardware Platforms: Performance Analysis, Challenges, and Strategies

基本信息

论文ID: 2510.12336
标题: Implementing the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithms for QUBO problems Across Quantum Hardware Platforms: Performance Analysis, Challenges, and Strategies
作者: Teemu Pihkakoski, Aravind Plathanam Babu, Pauli Taipale, Petri Liimatta, Matti Silveri
分类: quant-ph (量子物理)
发表时间: 2024年10月14日
论文链接: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12336v1

实际应用价值：QUBO问题在金融风险评估、特征选择等实际场景中具有重要意义
量子优势探索：量子计算机有望在解决复杂优化问题方面提供显著优势
硬件适配性：近期量子设备的实际性能评估对量子算法的实用化至关重要

现有方法局限性

经典求解器：在问题规模增大时遇到收敛困难，需要更多时间和内存资源
标准QAOA：在困难问题上的性能有限
硬件评估不足：缺乏基于真实设备校准数据的系统性性能分析

研究动机

填补量子算法性能与当前量子硬件能力之间的差距，为量子优化算法的实际部署提供指导策略。

核心贡献

算法性能对比：系统比较了标准QAOA和ADAPT-QAOA在不同难度QUBO问题上的性能
硬件平台评估：基于真实设备校准数据，评估了超导和离子阱量子计算机的理论性能
实际应用导向：专注于金融特征选择问题的实际应用场景
综合分析框架：提供了部署QAOA方法的挑战、权衡和策略的全面概述

方法详解

任务定义

QUBO问题：最小化目标函数 $f_{QUBO}(x) = \sum_i Q_{ii}x_i + \sum_{i<j} Q_{ij}x_ix_j$

特征选择问题：最小化 $f_{FS}(x) = -(1-\alpha)\sum_i Q_{ii}x_i + \alpha\sum_{i<j} Q_{ij}x_ix_j$

其中α∈0,1是权衡参数，控制问题难度。

模型架构

标准QAOA

初始化：所有量子比特初始化为等权叠加态 $|\psi_0\rangle = \left(\frac{|0\rangle + |1\rangle}{\sqrt{2}}\right)^{\otimes n}$
成本层和混合层： $U_C(\gamma_k) = e^{-i\gamma_k \hat{H}_C}, \quad U_M(\beta_k) = e^{-i\beta_k \hat{H}_M}$
迭代优化：逐层添加QAOA层并优化变分参数

ADAPT-QAOA

自适应混合器选择：从混合器池中选择最优混合器
- 全局混合器： $P_{XY} = \{\sum_i X_i\} \cup \{\sum_i Y_i\}$
- 单量子比特混合器： $P_{single} = \bigcup_i \{X_i, Y_i\}$
- 双量子比特混合器： $P_{two} = \bigcup_{i \neq j} \{\mu_i \nu_j | \mu,\nu \in \{X,Y,Z\}\}$
梯度准则：选择能量梯度最大的混合器 $g_l = \left|\sum_i \langle\psi^{(k-1)}|e^{i\hat{H}_C\gamma_0}[\hat{H}_C, A_l]e^{-i\hat{H}_C\gamma_0}|\psi^{(k-1)}\rangle\right|$