2025-11-10T02:49:49.989060

Isospin-based EWP-tree Relations

Bhattacharya, Bouchard, Jean et al.

In 1998, it was shown that, if flavor SU(3) symmetry [SU(3)$_F$] is assumed in charmless $B \to PP$ decays ($P$ is a light pseudoscalar meson), some reduced matrix elements involving electroweak penguin (EWP) operators are related to those involving tree operators. Similarly, EWP diagrams are related to tree diagrams. These SU(3)$_F$ EWP-tree relations were recently used in global analyses of $B \to PP$ decays. They have also been used over the years in analyses of the $B \to ÏK$ puzzle, even though the $B \to ÏK$ amplitudes are related by isospin symmetry [SU(2)$_I$], and not the full SU(3)$_F$. In this paper, we show that, even if only SU(2)$_I$ is assumed, there are still EWP-tree relations. In $ÎS=0$ decays, these relations are similar to those of SU(3)$_F$, and can be used to take into account the EWP contributions in the extraction of the CP phase $Î±$ from $B \to ÏÏ$ decays. In $ÎS=1$ decays, the SU(2)$_I$ EWP-tree relations are quite different from those of SU(3)$_F$; when these are used to analyze the $B \to ÏK$ puzzle, one now finds a 4-5$Ï$ discrepancy with the SM, much larger than what was previously found. We argue that, if one analyzes a set of hadronic $B$ decays whose amplitudes are related by isospin, one must use the SU(2)$_I$ EWP-tree relations for that set of decays in the analysis.

academic

Isospin-based EWP-tree Relations

基本信息

论文ID: 2510.13969
标题: Isospin-based EWP-tree Relations
作者: Bhubanjyoti Bhattacharya, Marianne Bouchard, Alexandre Jean, David London, Ipsita Ray
分类: hep-ph (高能物理-唯象学)
发表时间: 2025年10月15日
论文链接: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13969

摘要

本文研究了在强子B介子衰变中电弱企鹅算符(EWP)与树算符之间的关系。1998年，在假设味道SU(3)对称性的条件下，建立了无粲B→PP衰变中EWP算符与树算符的关系。本文证明即使仅假设同位旋SU(2)对称性，这种EWP-树关系仍然存在。对于ΔS=0衰变，SU(2)I关系与SU(3)F类似；对于ΔS=1衰变，两者显著不同。使用SU(2)I EWP-树关系分析B→πK谜题时，发现与标准模型的偏差达到4-5σ，远大于之前的结果。

研究背景与动机

问题背景

B介子衰变的理论挑战: 强子B介子衰变的理论计算存在很大不确定性，需要借助群论等工具来关联不同过程
EWP-树关系的重要性: 电弱企鹅算符与树算符之间的关系可以减少独立参数的数量，简化分析
对称性选择的问题: 之前的B→πK分析使用了SU(3)F EWP-树关系，但B→πK振幅实际上只通过同位旋SU(2)I相关

研究动机

理论一致性: 如果分析的衰变过程振幅仅通过同位旋相关，应该使用相应的SU(2)I EWP-树关系
B→πK谜题: 重新审视长期存在的B→πK观测量不一致问题
CP相位α提取: 改进从B→ππ衰变中提取CP相位的方法

核心贡献

推导了SU(2)I EWP-树关系: 首次系统地推导了仅假设同位旋对称性下的EWP-树关系
发现ΔS=0和ΔS=1衰变的不同行为: ΔS=0衰变的SU(2)I关系类似SU(3)F，而ΔS=1衰变显著不同
重新评估B→πK谜题: 使用正确的SU(2)I关系后，发现与标准模型的偏差达到4-5σ
证明了B→πK观测量关系的严格性: 在SU(2)I下，某个观测量组合δπK=0是精确成立的

方法详解

理论框架

弱哈密顿量

无粲B→PP衰变的弱哈密顿量为： $H_W = \frac{G_F}{\sqrt{2}} \sum_{q=d,s} \left( \lambda_u^{(q)} \sum_{i=1}^2 c_i Q_i^{(q)} - \lambda_t^{(q)} \sum_{i=3}^{10} c_i Q_i^{(q)} \right)$

其中包含树算符Q1,Q2、胶子企鹅算符Q3-Q6和电弱企鹅算符Q7-Q10。

SU(2)I变换性质

在同位旋对称性下，算符的变换性质：

ΔS=0衰变: 弱哈密顿量变换为O_{1/2}^{3/2}或O_{1/2}^{1/2}
ΔS=1衰变: 弱哈密顿量变换为O_0^1或O_0^0

EWP-树关系推导

ΔS=0衰变

以B→ππ为例，关键的约化矩阵元为： $\langle 2||H_W^{3/2}||1/2 \rangle = \lambda_u^{(d)} A_{3/2,2}^u - \lambda_t^{(d)} A_{3/2,2}^t$

通过分析算符的SU(2)I变换性质，得到EWP-树关系： $A_{3/2,2}^t = \frac{3}{2} \frac{c_9 + c_{10}}{c_1 + c_2} A_{3/2,2}^u$

转换为图解关系： $P_{EW} + P_{EW}^C = -\frac{3}{2} \frac{c_9 + c_{10}}{c_1 + c_2} (T + C)$

ΔS=1衰变

B→πK衰变的SU(2)I EWP-树关系显著不同： $P_{EW} + P_{EW}^E = -\frac{3}{2} \frac{c_9 + c_{10}}{c_1 + c_2} (C + A)$ $P_{EW}^C - P_{EW}^E = -\frac{3}{2} \frac{c_9 + c_{10}}{c_1 + c_2} (T - A)$