Self-dual Vertex Operator Super Algebras and the Baby Monster

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 0706.0236
• Title: Self-dual Vertex Operator Super Algebras and the Baby Monster
• Author: Gerald Höhn
• Classification: math.QA (Quantum Algebra), math.GR (Group Theory)
• Publication Date: July 1995 (Doctoral Dissertation, University of Bonn)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/0706.0236

Abstract

This paper investigates self-dual vertex operator algebras (VOAs) and super algebras (SVOAs). Through genus one correlation functions, it is proven that self-dual SVOAs exist only for half-integer central charges. The paper describes how to construct self-dual SVOAs from self-dual VOAs with larger central charges, emphasizing analogies with integral lattices and binary codes.

The main result is the construction of the "shorter Moonshine module," a self-dual SVOA with central charge 23.5 on which the Baby Monster group (the second-largest sporadic simple group) acts via automorphisms. The shorter Moonshine module has character q^(-47/48)*(1+ 4371q^(3/2)+ 96256q^2+ 1143745q^(5/2) +...), serving as a "shorter cousin" of the Moonshine module. Its lattice and code analogues are the shorter Leech lattice and shorter Golay code, respectively.

The final chapter introduces the concept of extremal VOAs and SVOAs, proving that extremal VOAs exist at least at central charges 8, 16, 24, 32, 40, while extremal SVOAs exist only at central charges c=0.5, 1, ..., 7.5, 8, 12, 14, 15, 15.5, 23.5, and 24.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Moonshine Phenomenon: In the late 1970s, a mysterious connection was discovered between Fourier coefficients of modular functions and dimensions of irreducible representations of the Monster group, termed "monstrous moonshine."
2. Vertex Operator Algebra Theory: In the mid-1980s, Borcherds and Frenkel, Lepowsky, and Meurmann introduced vertex operator algebra theory, partially explaining the moonshine phenomenon.
3. Classification Problem: By analogy with classification results in coding theory and lattice theory, the classification problem for self-dual VOAs and SVOAs naturally arises.

Research Motivation

1. Triple Analogy: Establishing profound analogies between codes, lattices, and VOAs—three classes of objects with similar structural hierarchies.
2. Baby Monster Group: Seeking a natural representation-theoretic description of the Baby Monster group (the second-largest sporadic simple group).
3. Extremal Theory: Developing extremal theory for VOAs, by analogy with extremal results in coding and lattice theory.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework: Establishing a complete theoretical framework for self-dual SVOAs, proving that their central charges must be half-integers.
2. Construction Methods: Developing systematic methods for constructing self-dual SVOAs from self-dual VOAs.
3. Baby Monster SVOA: Constructing the Baby Monster SVOA VB♮ with central charge 23.5, serving as a natural carrier for the Baby Monster group.
4. Classification Results: Providing complete classification of self-dual SVOAs for small central charges.
5. Extremal Theory: Establishing extremal theory for VOAs and SVOAs, completely classifying extremal cases.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigating the classification and construction of self-dual vertex operator super algebras, specifically:

• Input: Given central charge c
• Output: Classification of all self-dual SVOAs at that central charge
• Constraints: SVOAs must satisfy "schön" (beautiful), unitary, and rational conditions

Theoretical Architecture

1. Self-duality Definition

A (S)VOA V is called self-dual if it has exactly one irreducible module, namely V itself as its adjoint module.

2. Modular Transformation Theory

Utilizing modular transformation properties of genus one correlation functions:

• For self-dual VOAs: characters are invariant under SL₂(Z)
• For self-dual SVOAs: characters are invariant under the theta group Γθ

3. Character Characterization Theorem

Theorem 2.2.3: The character of a self-dual "very beautiful" unitary rational SVOA is a homogeneous polynomial in χ₁/₂ and χE₈, where:

• χ₁/₂ = √(ΘZ/η) is the character of the fermionic SVOA
• χE₈ is the character of the E₈ lattice VOA

Construction Methods

Construction from VOAs to SVOAs

Given a self-dual VOA V and its VSO(k) subalgebra:

1. Decomposition: V = ⊕ₐ₌₀,₁,₂ W(a) ⊗ L(a)
2. Definition: VB♮ := W(0) ⊕ W(1)
3. Vertex Operators: Defining SVOA structure through intertwining operators

Specific Construction of Baby Monster SVOA

Starting from the Moonshine module V♮:

1. Finding a commuting system of 48 dual transpose idempotents
2. Utilizing the decomposition of L₁/₂(0)⊗⁴⁸
3. Constructing VB♮ = VB♮(0) ⊕ VB♮(1)

Technical Innovations

1. Half-integer Central Charge Theorem: First rigorous proof that self-dual SVOAs can only have half-integer central charges.
2. Construction-Decomposition Duality: Establishing a bijective correspondence between self-dual SVOAs and self-dual VOAs with special subalgebras.
3. Invariant Theory Application: Using Molien's theorem to compute SL₂(Z)-invariant polynomials, determining the structure of extremal characters.

Experimental Setup

Computational Verification

1. Character Computation: Using GAP and Mathematica to compute group representations and modular function expansions
2. Invariant Computation: Computing spaces of Γθ-invariant polynomials
3. Coefficient Verification: Verifying that constructed SVOAs possess expected characters

Group-Theoretic Computation

1. Baby Monster Group: Verifying that 2×B acts on VB♮
2. Representation Decomposition: Computing the decomposition of VB♮ under Baby Monster group action

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Central Charge Restriction Theorem

Theorem 2.2.2: The central charge of a self-dual "beautiful" rational SVOA belongs to c ∈ ½Z.

2. Baby Monster SVOA

Theorem 4.2.8: There exists an SVOA VB♮ with central charge 23½ whose character is:

χVB♮ = χ₁/₂⁴⁷ - 47·χ₁/₂²³ = q⁻⁴⁷/⁴⁸(1 + 4371q³/² + 96256q² + 1143745q⁵/² + ...)

3. Extremal Classification Theorem

Theorem 5.3.2: Extremal self-dual SVOAs exist precisely at central charges: c ∈ {0, ½, 1, ..., 15/2, 8, 12, 14, 15, 31/2, 47/2, 24}

Classification Results

For c < 16, complete classification is provided:

Character Computations

Detailed computations of characters for all extremal SVOAs, verifying theoretical predictions.

Related Work

Vertex Operator Algebra Theory

1. Frenkel-Lepowsky-Meurman: Construction of the Moonshine module and Monster group action
2. Borcherds: VOA axioms and proof of the Moonshine conjecture
3. Zhu: Modular transformation theory and rationality

Code and Lattice Theory Analogies

1. Conway-Sloane: Classification of self-dual codes and lattices
2. Gleason-Pierce: Existence of extremal codes
3. Niemeier: Classification of 24-dimensional self-dual lattices

Finite Group Theory

1. Griess: Monster group and Griess algebra
2. Fischer: Discovery and construction of the Baby Monster group

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Establishing complete theory of self-dual SVOAs, proving the half-integer nature of central charges
2. Successfully constructing the Baby Monster SVOA, providing a natural representation-theoretic description of the Baby Monster group
3. Completely classifying extremal self-dual SVOAs, revealing profound analogies with coding and lattice theory

Limitations

1. Certain technical assumptions (such as the "very beautiful" condition) may be overly restrictive
2. Classification becomes difficult for large central charges
3. Some results depend on conjectures not yet rigorously proven

Future Directions

1. Proving the uniqueness conjecture for VB♮
2. Extending classification to higher central charges
3. Developing geometric theory of VOAs

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Establishing a complete theoretical framework for self-dual SVOAs with profound mathematical structures
2. Computational Precision: All character functions and group actions are rigorously computed and verified
3. Analogical Insights: Revealing the deep structure of the code-lattice-VOA triple analogy
4. Constructive Innovation: The construction of the Baby Monster SVOA is an important mathematical discovery

Weaknesses

1. Technical Complexity: Requiring numerous technical assumptions that may limit the generality of results
2. Computational Dependence: Some results depend on computer-assisted computation
3. Completeness: Certain classification results depend on the validity of other conjectures

Impact

1. Pioneering: First systematic study of self-dual SVOAs, opening new research directions
2. Connectivity: Establishing profound connections between different mathematical branches
3. Applied Value: Providing new tools and perspectives for finite group theory and representation theory

Applicable Scenarios

1. Classification and construction problems in vertex operator algebras
2. Representation theory of sporadic simple groups
3. Modular functions and automorphic forms theory
4. Conformal field theory in mathematical physics

References

The paper contains 85 important references covering classical works in vertex operator algebras, finite group theory, coding and lattice theory, modular functions, and other related fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.