Status of DVMP, DVCS and GPDs

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 1410.4450
• Title: Status of DVMP, DVCS and GPDs
• Author: P. Kroll (Fachbereich Physik, Universität Wuppertal & Institute für Theoretische Physik, Universität Regensburg)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Submission Date: October 16, 2014 (arXiv submission)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/1410.4450

Abstract

This paper reviews the analysis of deeply virtual meson production (DVMP) within the handbag approach framework, with detailed discussion of the parametrization of generalized parton distributions (GPDs), focusing primarily on GPDs H and E. The article demonstrates the application of GPDs extracted from DVMP to other hard exclusive processes (such as deeply virtual Compton scattering, DVCS), and evaluates the Ji sum rule.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Theoretical description of hard exclusive processes: Understanding the physical mechanisms of exclusive meson lepton production and deeply virtual Compton scattering under conditions of large virtual photon virtuality Q² and large energy W
2. Extraction and application of GPDs: Extracting generalized parton distributions from experimental data and applying them to predictions of other hard exclusive processes
3. Investigation of nucleon internal structure: Studying the angular momentum distribution of partons within the nucleon through GPDs and understanding nucleon spin structure

Research Significance

• QCD theory verification: Hard exclusive processes provide an important avenue for verifying QCD factorization theorems
• Nucleon structure probing: GPDs provide richer information about nucleon internal structure compared to traditional parton distribution functions (PDFs)
• Understanding experimental data: Existing experimental data show significant deviations from asymptotic expectations, requiring theoretical explanation

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Failure of asymptotic theory: Leading twist results severely disagree with experiments in the kinematic region accessible to current experiments
2. Uncontrollable power corrections: Higher-order QCD corrections cannot be handled systematically
3. Model dependence of parametrization: GPD parametrization carries substantial theoretical uncertainty

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete GPD parametrization scheme: Based on double distribution representation, systematically parametrizing H, E, H̃, Ẽ, H_T, Ē_T and other GPDs
2. Developed modified perturbative approach: Incorporating quark transverse momentum and Sudakov suppression in the handbag method to effectively handle power corrections
3. Extracted GPDs from DVMP data: Systematically analyzed ρ⁰, φ, π⁺ and other meson production data to extract GPD parameters
4. Achieved universal application of GPDs: Successfully applied extracted GPDs to other processes such as DVCS, verifying theoretical consistency
5. Evaluated nucleon angular momentum distribution: Based on the Ji sum rule, provided quantitative results for parton angular momentum within the nucleon

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study hard exclusive lepton production processes: $ep → e'pM$ (M is a meson) and $ep → e'pγ$ (DVCS), where:

• Input: Experimentally measured cross sections, asymmetries, spin density matrix elements
• Output: Parametric forms and numerical results of GPDs
• Constraints: QCD factorization, polynomiality, positivity and other theoretical constraints

Theoretical Framework

Handbag Approach

Process amplitude factorizes into convolution of hard subprocess and soft hadronic matrix elements:

M = ∫ dx H(x,ξ,Q²) ⊗ GPD(x,ξ,t)

Double Distribution Representation of GPDs

K^i(x,ξ,t) = ∫₋₁¹ dρ ∫₋₁₊|ρ|¹⁻|ρ| dη δ(ρ + ξη - x) r^i(ρ,η,t) + D^i(x,t)Θ(ξ² - x²)

Where:

• First term: Double distribution integral
• Second term: D-term contribution

Zero Skewness GPD Parametrization

K^i(ρ,ξ=0,t) = k^i(ρ) exp[t f^i(ρ)]

Profile functions adopt Regge form:

f^i(ρ) = -α'ᵢ ln ρ + Bᵢ

Modified Perturbative Approach

Sudakov Suppression

Subprocess amplitude calculation in impact parameter space:

H^Vi₀λ,₀λ = ∫ dτd²b Ψ̂^V(τ,-b)F̂^i₀λ,₀λ(x,ξ,τ,Q²,b) × αₛ(μᵣ) exp[-S(τ,b,Q²)]

Transverse Momentum Effects

Incorporating quark transverse momentum k_⊥ to regularize infrared divergences, achieving transition from theoretical 1/Q⁶ to effective 1/Q⁴ scaling behavior.

Technical Innovations

1. ρ-t correlation: Implementing momentum fraction-momentum transfer correlation through profile functions, reflecting spatial-momentum correlations within the nucleon
2. Unified treatment of various GPDs: Establishing a complete GPD system encompassing H, E, H̃, Ẽ, H_T, Ē_T
3. π-pole handling: For π⁺ production, treating π-pole contributions through single-particle exchange to avoid limitations of perturbative estimates

Experimental Setup

Data Sets

• HERA data: H1 and ZEUS ρ⁰, φ production data (small skewness ξ < 0.1, small -t < 0.5 GeV²)
• HERMES data: π⁺ production, transverse spin asymmetry, DVCS data
• COMPASS data: Transverse target spin asymmetry data
• Nucleon form factor data: Electromagnetic form factors of proton and neutron

Evaluation Metrics

• Longitudinal cross section σ_L: Primarily controlled by GPD H
• Transverse target spin asymmetry A_UT: Probing GPD E
• Spin density matrix elements (SDMEs): Providing additional GPD information
• Angular momentum sum rules: Verifying theoretical consistency

Fitting Strategy

1. Sequential extraction: First extracting H from ρ⁰, φ data, then extracting E from asymmetries
2. Constraint conditions: Utilizing PDF, form factor, and lattice QCD results as constraints
3. Error propagation: Considering Hessian error propagation from PDFs to GPDs

Experimental Results

Main Results

GPD H Extraction

• Gluon trajectory intercept: δ_g = α_g - 1, determined from energy dependence σ_L ∝ W^(4δ_g)
• Q² dependence: δ_g = 0.10 + 0.06 ln(Q²/Q₀²) - 0.0027 ln²(Q²/Q₀²)
• Scaling behavior: In Q² = 4-100 GeV² range, achieving transition from theoretical 1/Q⁶ to experimental 1/Q⁴ behavior

GPD E Extraction

• Valence quark contribution: Determined through nucleon form factor analysis
• Sea quark constraints: Utilizing positivity bounds to constrain strange quark contributions
• Transverse asymmetry: A_UT^(sin(φ-φ_s)) ∼ Im⟨E⟩*⟨H⟩ providing E information

DVCS Predictions

• Cross section calculation: Good agreement between theory and experiment in HERA kinematics
• Beam charge asymmetry: A_C primarily controlled by BH-DVCS interference, verifying H convolution correctness
• Beam spin asymmetry: A_LU^(sinφ) probing H̃, with recoil detector data more reliable

Angular Momentum Distribution Results

At scale μ² = 4 GeV²:

J^u = 0.230₋₀.₀₂₄^(+0.009)
J^d = -0.004₋₀.₀₁₇^(+0.011)
J^g = 0.187...0.265

Total angular momentum satisfies ∑J^i = 1/2 (nucleon spin).

Ablation Studies

• Profile function comparison: Regge form vs. complex forms show minor differences in small -t region
• D-term impact: Potentially important for strong growth in small W region of ρ⁰ production, but current understanding is limited
• π-pole contribution: Dominates unnatural parity cross section in ω production

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Lattice QCD calculations of GPDs: Providing first-principles theoretical constraints
2. Partial wave decomposition method: Kumerički-Mueller approach through Regge trajectory parametrization
3. Color dipole model: Phenomenological approach by Frankfurt-Strikman and others

Advantages of This Work

• Systematicity: Establishing a complete GPD parametrization system
• Consistency: Achieving unified description of DVMP and DVCS
• Practicality: Providing GPD parameters usable for predictions in other processes

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Validity of handbag approach: Effectively describes experimental data in small skewness and small -t regions
2. Importance of power corrections: Sudakov suppression and transverse momentum effects are crucial for explaining experiments
3. Universality of GPDs: GPDs extracted from DVMP successfully applied to DVCS
4. Nucleon spin structure: Gluons carry approximately 40% of nucleon angular momentum

Limitations

1. Large skewness region: Significant discrepancies between theoretical predictions and experiments in JLab kinematics (large ξ, small W)
2. Soft physics contributions: Potentially uncontrollable soft physics effects in certain kinematic regions
3. Model dependence: GPD parametrization retains certain model dependence

Future Directions

1. Complete GPD evolution: Requiring inclusion of complete GPD evolution equations
2. More precise experiments: Requiring higher precision DVCS transverse asymmetry data
3. Theoretical improvements: Better understanding of physics mechanisms in large skewness region

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Establishing a systematic GPD theoretical framework
2. Sufficient experimental verification: Covering multiple exclusive processes and observables
3. Deep physical insights: Revealing spatial-momentum correlations within the nucleon
4. Methodological innovation: Modified perturbative approach effectively handles power corrections

Weaknesses

1. Large skewness theoretical defects: Theory predictions fail in JLab kinematics
2. Insufficient D-term understanding: Theoretical explanation for certain experimental phenomena remains incomplete
3. Limited sea quark GPD constraints: Lower precision in determining E^sea and E^g

Impact

• Theoretical contribution: Establishing important theoretical foundation for GPD physics
• Experimental guidance: Providing theoretical prediction framework for future experiments such as EIC
• Cross-field applications: Methods generalizable to other hard exclusive processes

Applicable Scenarios

• Hard exclusive processes with small skewness (ξ < 0.1) and small momentum transfer (-t < 0.5 GeV²)
• Phenomenological analysis in HERA and HERMES kinematic regions
• Quantitative studies of nucleon structure and angular momentum decomposition

References

The paper contains 92 references covering important works in GPD theory, experimental measurements, lattice QCD and related fields, providing comprehensive literature review for this research area.