Hard Exclusive Processes Involving Kaons

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 1901.11380
• Title: Hard exclusive processes involving kaons
• Author: P. Kroll (Universität Wuppertal)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: January 31, 2019
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.11380

Abstract

This paper investigates exclusive kaon electroproduction and kaon-induced exclusive Drell-Yan processes within the handbag approach framework. The approach is based on factorization of hard subprocess amplitudes and soft generalized parton distributions (GPDs). The kaon-hyperon transition GPDs appearing in the analysis are related to proton GPDs through flavor symmetry, which are extracted from pion electroproduction analysis. Similar to hard processes involving pions, transverse GPDs play an important role in the studied processes—the transverse cross section is larger than (or approximately equal to in the Drell-Yan process) the longitudinal cross section. For the first time, the evolution of transverse GPDs is considered, though the analysis shows this is a minor effect within the photon virtuality range of interest. The theoretical predictions of cross sections are in reasonable agreement with the scarce available electroproduction data.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Theoretical Framework for Hard Exclusive Meson Electroproduction: The handbag approach is based on the factorization property of process amplitudes into hard subprocess amplitudes and soft hadronic matrix elements (parameterized by GPDs). This factorization has been rigorously proven to hold at leading twist accuracy in the generalized Bjorken region (large photon virtuality Q, large final-state hadron invariant mass W, fixed Bjorken-x, and small Mandelstam-t).
2. Limitations of Existing Research:
   • Naive asymptotic results cannot be directly applied in the kinematic range accessible to current experiments
   • Large power corrections to the asymptotically dominant amplitude for longitudinally polarized photons are necessary
   • Contributions from transverse photons are asymptotically suppressed by 1/Q² but are actually quite strong
3. Insufficiency of Kaon Process Research: Compared to extensive studies of pion and ρ/φ meson processes, hard exclusive processes involving kaons have received less attention both theoretically and experimentally, with only limited forward kaon electroproduction separated cross section data from Jefferson Lab.

Research Motivation

1. Verification of GPD Universality: Utilize the GPD set extracted from pion electroproduction analysis to study kaon reactions, testing the applicability of these GPDs to kaon data
2. Predictions for Future Experiments: Provide theoretical predictions for JLab experiment E12-09-011 and J-Parc kaon-induced exclusive Drell-Yan process experiments
3. Refinement of Theoretical Framework: For the first time, consider evolution effects of transverse GPDs in kaon processes

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Study of Hard Exclusive Kaon Processes: Complete analysis of kaon electroproduction and kaon-induced Drell-Yan processes within the generalized handbag approach framework
2. Establishment of Flavor Symmetry Relations: Connect kaon-hyperon transition GPDs to proton GPDs through flavor symmetry
3. First Consideration of Transverse GPD Evolution: Include for the first time the scale evolution effects of transverse GPDs in kaon processes
4. Provision of Experimental Predictions: Provide theoretical predictions and comparisons for existing and future kaon-related experiments

Methodology Details

Process Definition

Two main processes are studied:

1. Kaon Electroproduction: γ*(q,μ)p(p,ν) → K+(q',0)Λ(p',ν')
2. Kaon-Induced Drell-Yan Process: K-(q,0)p(p,ν) → γ*(q',μ')Λ(p',ν')

Theoretical Framework

Generalized Handbag Approach

Within the generalized Bjorken region, the process amplitude is given by the convolution of subprocess amplitudes and appropriate flavor combinations of GPDs:

Helicity Amplitudes (Kaon Electroproduction):

M₀₊,₀₊ = √(1-ξ²) (e₀/Q)[<H̃ₖ>₀ - ξ²/(1-ξ²)<Ẽₖⁿ·ᵖ>₀]
M₀₋,₀₊ = (e₀/Q)√(-t+t₀)/(m+m_Λ) ξ<Ẽₖⁿ·ᵖ>₀
M₀₋,₊₊ = (e₀μₖ/Q²)√(1-ξ²)<H_T^K>₊
M₀₊,±₊ = (e₀μₖ/Q²)√(-t+t₀)/(m+m_Λ)<Ē_T^K>₊

where the skewness ξ is related to Bjorken-x by: ξ = x_B/(2-x_B)

GPD Parameterization

Flavor Symmetry Relations:

K_i^K ≃ -1/√6[2K_i^u - K_i^d]

Zero Skewness GPDs:

K_i^a(z,ξ=0,t) = K_i^a(x,ξ=t=0)exp[(b_i^a - α'_i^a ln(x))t]

Transverse Density Parameterization (satisfying Soffer bound):

δᵃ = N_{HT}^a √x(1-x)[qᵃ(x) + Δqᵃ(x)]

Kaon Wave Function

Twist-2 Wave Function:

Ψ_{K,-+} = (8π²f_K)/(√2N_c) (ζ_K²)/(ττ̄) Φ_K(τ)exp[-ζ_K²k_⊥²/(ττ̄)]

Distribution Amplitude:

Φ_K(τ) = 6ττ̄[1 + a_1^K C_1^{3/2}(2τ-1) + a_2^K C_2^{3/2}(2τ-1) + ...]

Kaon Pole Term

Pole contributions are treated as single boson exchange contributions with residue:

ρ_K = √2 g_{KNΛ} F_{KNΛ}(t) Q² F_K^{s.l.}(Q²)

Technical Innovations

1. Retention of Quark Transverse Momentum: Preserve quark transverse momentum in the subprocess, implicitly accounting for the transverse size of the meson
2. Sudakov Factors: Include Sudakov factors to account for gluon radiation from color charge separation
3. Evolution Effects: For the first time include scale evolution in transverse GPDs, using numerical methods to solve evolution equations
4. Application of Flavor Symmetry: Connect kaon processes to known proton GPDs through SU(3) flavor symmetry

Experimental Setup

Data Sets

• Jefferson Lab Data: Separated cross section data for K+Λ electroproduction from Hall A, FPI-2, and E93-018 experiments
• Kinematic Range: Q² = 2.0-5.5 GeV², W = 1.84-3.14 GeV
• Prediction Targets: JLab experiment E12-09-011 and J-Parc Drell-Yan experiments

Evaluation Metrics

• Longitudinal and Transverse Cross Sections: dσ_L/dt, dσ_T/dt
• Interference Cross Sections: dσ_/dt, dσ_/dt
• Quadruple Differential Cross Section (Drell-Yan): d⁴σ/(dtdQ'²dcosθdφ)

Parameter Settings

• Mass Parameters: μ_K = 2 GeV (initial scale μ₀ = 2 GeV)
• Kaon Parameters: f_K = 159 MeV, ζ_K = 0.853 GeV⁻¹
• Gegenbauer Coefficients: a₁^K = 0.086±0.04, a₂^K = -0.159±0.07
• Coupling Constants: g_{KNΛ} = -14.5±1.3

Experimental Results

Main Results

Kaon Electroproduction

1. Cross Section Predictions vs. Data: Theoretical predictions are in reasonable agreement with scarce Jefferson Lab data
2. Transverse Dominance: Even in forward scattering, the transverse cross section dominates the longitudinal cross section, which differs from π+ production
3. Kaon Pole Suppression: The kaon pole is farther from the physical region than the pion pole, leading to suppressed contributions

Suppression Factor:

dσ_L(K+)/dσ_L(π+) ~ (t-m_π²)²/(t-m_K²)² ≈ (m_π/m_K)⁴ = 0.63×10⁻²

Drell-Yan Process

1. Longitudinal Cross Section: Shows deeper forward dip compared to spacelike region
2. Transverse Cross Section: Comparable in magnitude to longitudinal cross section, differing from the pion case
3. Evolution Effects: At Q'² = 14 GeV², considering evolution reduces the transverse cross section by only ~8%

Ablation Studies

1. GPD Contribution Analysis:
   • Longitudinal cross section primarily from H̃ and pole term contributions
   • Transverse cross section primarily from H_T contribution (~90%), with Ē_T contributing ~10%
2. Evolution Effect Assessment: Evolution of transverse GPDs is a minor effect within the current experimental energy range

Case Analysis

Typical Kinematic Point (W = 3.14 GeV, Q² = 3.0 GeV²):

• Longitudinal cross section begins with forward dip, caused by negative contributions from pole-H̃ interference
• Transverse cross section decreases monotonically with no pronounced structure
• Interference terms are relatively small

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Pion Electroproduction: Extensive theoretical and experimental studies providing GPD parameters for this work
2. ρ⁰ and φ Meson Production: Successful applications within the same theoretical framework
3. Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering: Another verification of GPD universality

Advantages of This Work

1. First Systematic Study: First complete theoretical analysis of hard exclusive kaon processes
2. Evolution Effects: First inclusion of scale evolution of transverse GPDs
3. Predictive Power: Provides reliable theoretical predictions for future experiments

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Theoretical Predictions: The generalized handbag approach successfully describes kaon electroproduction data
2. Importance of Transverse Effects: Transverse GPDs play a crucial role in kaon processes
3. Minor Evolution Effects: Within the current experimental energy range, transverse GPD evolution is a minor effect
4. Effective Flavor Symmetry: The method of connecting different processes through flavor symmetry is successful

Limitations

1. Scarce Data: Very limited available experimental data restricts theoretical verification
2. Unknown Sea Quark Contributions: Currently no clear signal of sea quark GPD contributions
3. Wandzura-Wilczek Approximation: Twist-3 wave functions are treated approximately
4. Large-t Region Uncertainty: Extrapolation of GPDs in the large momentum transfer region has uncertainties

Future Directions

1. Beyond WW Approximation: Include complete two-body and three-body twist-3 contributions
2. Sea Quark Effects: Study sea quark GPD contributions as more precise data becomes available
3. Additional Processes: Extend to other hard exclusive processes involving strange quarks
4. J/Ψ Excitation: Study excitation of charmonium states in Drell-Yan processes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides a complete theoretical framework for hard exclusive kaon processes
2. Methodological Innovation: First consideration of transverse GPD evolution in such processes
3. Experimental Predictions: Provides valuable theoretical predictions for multiple future experiments
4. Technical Rigor: Numerical methods and parameterizations are carefully verified

Weaknesses

1. Limited Experimental Verification: Theoretical verification is insufficient due to scarce data
2. Parameter Uncertainties: Certain parameters (e.g., Gegenbauer coefficients) have significant uncertainties
3. Approximate Treatment: Room for improvement in twist-3 contributions and higher-order corrections

Impact

1. Field Contribution: Fills a gap in theoretical research of hard exclusive kaon processes
2. Practical Value: Provides important guidance for experiment design and data analysis
3. Method Generalization: The methods used can be generalized to other strange hadron processes

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-Energy Electron Scattering Experiments: Kaon electroproduction experiments at facilities like JLab
2. Fixed-Target Experiments: Kaon beam experiments at J-Parc and similar facilities
3. Theoretical Research: GPD phenomenology and QCD factorization studies

References

The paper includes 41 references covering GPD theory, experimental data, numerical methods, and other aspects, providing comprehensive citations to important literature in the field.

Overall Assessment: This is a pioneering paper of significant importance in the research of hard exclusive kaon processes. The theoretical methods are rigorous, the predictions are in good agreement with limited experimental data, and it provides a solid foundation for future experimental and theoretical research.