Regular Black Holes in Isothermal Cavity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2012.03349
• Title: Regular black holes in isothermal cavity
• Author: Athanasios G. Tzikas (Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies & Goethe University Frankfurt)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: June 9, 2021 (v3 version)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2012.03349

Abstract

This paper investigates the thermodynamic behavior of static neutral regular (non-singular) black holes confined within a finite isothermal cavity. The cavity confinement enables the study of black hole systems within the canonical or grand canonical ensemble. The paper derives the reduced action for the general metric of regular black holes in the cavity, considering the canonical ensemble case. The new action expression includes quantum corrections at short distances and reduces to the action of singular black holes in the cavity in the large distance limit. Applying this formulation to non-commutative Schwarzschild black holes, the phase structure of the system is investigated. A small/large stable regular black hole phase transition is discovered within the cavity, which exists neither in the classical Schwarzschild black hole system in the cavity nor in asymptotically flat regular black holes without a cavity. This phase transition is analogous to the liquid/gas phase transition of a Van der Waals gas.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

1. Singularity Problem: Classical general relativity predicts singularities at black hole centers, a fundamental defect of the theory
2. Quantum Gravity Effects: Existing quantum gravity candidate theories struggle to effectively resolve the singularity problem
3. Thermodynamic Behavior: Black hole thermodynamics exhibits rich phase transition phenomena, such as Hawking-Page phase transitions and Van der Waals-type phase transitions in AdS charged black holes

Research Motivation

1. Regular Black Holes: Replace curvature singularities with regular cores while recovering general relativity at large distances
2. Cavity Systems: Study canonical ensemble thermodynamics of black holes through isothermal cavity confinement
3. Phase Transition Research: Explore novel phase transition behavior of regular black holes in cavities

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Previous research primarily focused on black hole phase transitions in AdS spacetime
• Lack of systematic study of regular black hole systems in cavities
• Classical black hole-cavity systems only exhibit Hawking-Page type phase transitions

Core Contributions

1. Derived the reduced action for regular black holes in cavities, including short-distance quantum correction terms
2. Established the thermodynamic framework for regular black hole-cavity systems, applicable to the canonical ensemble
3. Discovered novel small/large black hole phase transitions, analogous to the liquid/gas phase transition of Van der Waals gases
4. Demonstrated the equivalence between cavities and AdS spacetime, showing similar roles in constraining and stabilizing black holes

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

Non-commutative Geometry Foundation

The core feature of non-commutative geometry is the existence of a minimum cutoff length, described through commutation relations: $[x^\mu, x^\nu] = i\theta^{\mu\nu}$ where $\sqrt{\theta}$ has length dimension, approaching the Planck length $\sqrt{\theta} \sim 10^{-33}$ cm.

Regular Black Hole Metric

Consider a spherically symmetric Euclidean line element: $ds^2 = b(r)^2d\tau^2 + a(r)^2dr^2 + r^2d\Omega^2$

For non-commutative Schwarzschild black holes, the mass density distribution is Gaussian: $\rho(r) = \frac{M}{(4\pi\theta)^{3/2}}\exp(-r^2/4\theta)$

The metric function is: $b^2(r) = 1 - \frac{4M}{r\sqrt{\pi}}\gamma(3/2, r^2/4\theta)$ where $\gamma(3/2, r^2/4\theta)$ is the lower incomplete gamma function.

Boundary Conditions

The black hole-cavity system must satisfy:

1. Horizon Condition: $b(r_+) = 0$ and $\frac{b'(r)}{a(r)}\big|_{r_+} = 1$
2. Cavity Wall Temperature: $T^{-1} = \beta = 2\pi b(r_c)$
3. Regularity Condition: $\frac{1}{a^2(r)}\big|_{r_+} = 0$

Reduced Action Derivation

Complete Einstein-Hilbert Action

$I = -\int_M d^4x\sqrt{g}\left(\frac{R}{16\pi} + L_m\right) - \frac{1}{8\pi}\int_{\partial M} d^3x\sqrt{h}(K-K_0)$

Decomposed into three parts:

• Gravitational action $I_g$
• Matter action $I_m$
• Surface action $I_s$

Key Contribution of Matter Action

For anisotropic fluids, the matter Lagrangian is: $L_m = 2p_r - p_\perp = -\rho + \frac{r}{2}\rho'$

This represents the key difference of regular black holes relative to classical black holes.

Final Reduced Action

After complex calculations, the reduced action for non-commutative black holes is obtained: $I^* = \beta r_c\left(1-\sqrt{1-\frac{r_+\gamma(r_c)}{r_c\gamma(r_+)}}\right) + \text{quantum correction terms} - \pi r_+^2$

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Planck units: $c = \hbar = G = k_B = 1$
• Non-commutative parameter: $\theta$ (minimum length scale)
• Cavity radius: $r_c$ (fixed)
• Black hole horizon: $r_+$ (variable)

Thermodynamic Quantities Calculation

Computed through the reduced action:

1. Temperature: Obtained by solving $\frac{\partial I^*}{\partial r_+} = 0$
2. Entropy: $S = \pi r_+^2$ (area law)
3. Specific Heat: $C = -\beta^2\left(\frac{\partial^2 I}{\partial\beta^2}\right)$
4. Free Energy: $F = I^*/\beta$

Experimental Results

Phase Transition Behavior Analysis

Critical Cavity Radius

A critical value $r_i \approx 10.913\sqrt{\theta}$ exists, determining the system's phase transition behavior:

1. $r_c > r_i$: Temperature exhibits two extrema, small/large black hole phase transition exists
2. $r_c = r_i$: Critical point, two extrema merge
3. $r_c < r_i$: Monotonic behavior, no phase transition

Temperature-Horizon Relationship

• For $r_c > r_i$: Temperature curve exhibits local maximum and minimum
• Differs from asymptotically flat case (only one extremum)
• Similar to regular black holes in AdS space

Specific Heat Analysis

Specific heat diverges at phase transition points:

• $C > 0$: Thermally stable regions (small and large black holes)
• $C < 0$: Thermally unstable region (intermediate state)
• Two divergence points correspond to phase transition boundaries

Free Energy Behavior

• $r_c > r_i$: Free energy exhibits two extrema, intermediate branch unstable
• $r_c < r_i$: Free energy monotonically decreasing, system stable
• Swallow-tail structure indicates first-order phase transition

Comparison with Classical Systems

Related Work

Regular Black Hole Theory

• Bardeen black holes, non-commutative black holes, and other models
• Replacing point mass sources with anisotropic fluids
• Short-distance regularity, large-distance classical behavior

Black Hole Thermodynamics

• Hawking-Page phase transitions (AdS black holes)
• Van der Waals-type phase transitions (charged AdS black holes)
• Extended phase space thermodynamics

Cavity Systems

• Pioneering work by Braden et al.
• Classical black hole-cavity system research
• Analogy with AdS spacetime

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Novel Phase Transitions: Regular black holes in cavities exhibit small/large black hole phase transitions, analogous to Van der Waals gases
2. Quantum Corrections: The reduced action includes short-distance quantum corrections, reducing to the classical limit at large distances
3. Cavity Effects: Cavities provide constraints that alter phase transition properties, similar to AdS spacetime
4. Stable Remnants: Thermally stable black hole remnants exist in small cavity cases

Physical Significance

• Quantum Gravity Effects: Minimum length provided by non-commutative geometry avoids singularities
• Phase Transition Mechanism: Cavity constraints and quantum corrections jointly induce novel phase transitions
• Holographic Correspondence: Cavity systems may provide alternative implementations of AdS/CFT correspondence

Limitations

1. Semiclassical Approximation: Based on effective field theory, neglecting complete quantum gravity effects
2. Model-Specific: Primarily focused on non-commutative Schwarzschild black holes
3. Static Case: Does not consider dynamical evolution and backreaction

Future Directions

1. Other Regular Black Hole Models: Extension to Bardeen, Hayward, and other regular black holes
2. Charged Cases: Study of charged regular black hole-cavity systems
3. Dynamical Analysis: Consideration of dynamical processes including black hole evaporation and cavity feedback
4. Holographic Applications: Exploration of cavity system applications in holographic theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic study of regular black hole-cavity systems, filling theoretical gaps
2. Rigorous Methodology: Derivation from Einstein-Hilbert action, complete and self-consistent
3. Physical Insights: Discovery of equivalence between cavities and AdS spacetime in constraining black holes
4. Detailed Analysis: Comprehensive phase diagrams and thermodynamic quantity analysis

Weaknesses

1. Model Limitations: Primarily based on specific non-commutative black hole models
2. Experimental Verification: Lack of observational verification possibilities
3. Missing Dynamics: Does not consider temporal evolution of the system
4. Approximation Accuracy: Semiclassical treatment may omit important quantum effects

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new research framework for regular black hole thermodynamics
2. Methodological Value: Reduced action method generalizable to other gravitational systems
3. Interdisciplinary Connections: Establishes deep connections between black hole physics and statistical physics
4. Future Applications: Provides new tools for quantum gravity and holographic theory

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Black hole thermodynamics, quantum gravity theory
2. Numerical Simulations: Black hole phase transitions and critical phenomena research
3. Educational Applications: Demonstrating how quantum corrections modify classical predictions
4. Interdisciplinary Research: Cross-disciplinary studies between statistical physics and gravitational theory

References

The paper cites 35 important references, covering:

• Foundational literature on regular black hole theory
• Classical works on black hole thermodynamics
• Related cavity system research
• Non-commutative geometry theory literature

Summary: This paper makes important contributions at the intersection of regular black hole theory and black hole thermodynamics, discovering novel phase transition phenomena and providing new perspectives for understanding quantum gravity effects in black hole thermodynamics. Despite some theoretical limitations, its methodology and conclusions establish a solid foundation for further development in this field.