In the first part of this paper we prove that the flow associated to a dispersive Burgers equation with a non local term
of the form $|D|^{α-1} \partial_x u$, $α\in [1,+\infty[$ is Lipschitz from bounded sets of $H^s_0(\mathbb{T};\mathbb{R})$ to $C^0([0,T],H^{s-(2-α)^+}_0(\mathbb{T};\mathbb{R}))$ for $T>0$ and $s>\lceil \fracα{α-1}\rceil-\frac{1}{2}$, where $H^s_0$ are the Sobolev spaces of functions with $0$ mean value, proving that the result obtained in [37] is optimal on the torus. The proof relies on a paradifferential generalization of a complex Cole-Hopf gauge transformation introduced by T.Tao in [43] for the Benjamin-Ono equation.
For this we prove a generalization of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula for flows of hyperbolic paradifferential equations and prove the stability of the class of paradifferential operators modulo more regular remainders, under conjugation by such flows. For this we prove a new characterization of paradifferential operators in the spirit of Beals [9].
In the second part of this paper we use a paradifferential version of the previous method to prove that a re-normalization of the flow of the one dimensional periodic gravity capillary equation is Lipschitz from bounded sets of $H^s$ to $C^0([0,T],H^{s-\frac{1}{2}})$ for $T>0$ and $s>3+\frac{1}{2}$. This proves that the result obtained in [37] is optimal for the water waves system.
Regularity results on the flow maps of periodic dispersive Burgers type equations and the Gravity-Capillary equations
- Paper ID: 2103.03576
- Title: Regularity results on the flow maps of periodic dispersive Burgers type equations and the Gravity-Capillary equations
- Author: Ayman Rimah Said
- Classification: math.AP (Analysis of PDEs), math-ph (Mathematical Physics), math.MP (Mathematical Physics)
- Submission Date: March 6, 2021; Last Updated: January 1, 2023
- Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.03576v2
This paper is divided into two parts. The first part establishes that the flow map of the dispersive Burgers equation with nonlocal term ∣D∣α−1∂xu (α∈[1,+∞[) is Lipschitz continuous from bounded sets in H0s(T;R) to C0([0,T],H0s−(2−α)+(T;R)), where T>0 and s>⌈α−1α⌉−21, with H0s denoting the Sobolev space of zero-mean functions. This proves that the results obtained in 37 are optimal on the torus. The second part employs similar quasidifferential methods to establish that the renormalized version of the flow map for the one-dimensional periodic gravity-capillary equation is Lipschitz continuous from bounded sets in Hs to C0([0,T],Hs−21), where T>0 and s>3+21.
The core problem addressed in this paper concerns the regularity of flow maps for dispersive Burgers-type equations and gravity-capillary equations. These equations take the form:
∂tu+u∂xu+∣D∣α−1∂xu=0
where D=R or T, α∈[0,2[, and ∣D∣ is a Fourier multiplier with symbol ∣ξ∣.
- Distinction between semilinear and quasilinear: According to the definition in 31, a partial differential equation is called semilinear if its flow map is regular (at least C1); it is called quasilinear if its flow map is not Lipschitz.
- Precise analysis of dispersive effects: Previous studies only analyzed uniform continuity of flow maps, failing to reveal the specific effects of dispersive terms. This paper aims to determine the precise influence of parameter α through more refined regularity analysis of flow maps.
- Optimality questions: Uncertainties exist in the literature regarding whether results are optimal. For instance, in 39, equation (1.1) is shown to be quasilinear for α∈[0,3[ and becomes semilinear for α=3 (KdV equation), suggesting that previous results may be suboptimal.
- Previous tests only analyzed uniform continuity of flow maps, unable to reveal dispersive effects
- For the torus case, subtle issues with low frequencies must be addressed
- Traditional Cole-Hopf transformation methods encounter technical difficulties in this setting
- Optimal regularity results: Establishes that the Lipschitz regularity of the flow map for the dispersive Burgers equation is optimal, precisely characterizing the relationship between the loss of derivatives and the dispersive parameter α.
- Quasidifferential Cole-Hopf transformation: Develops a quasidifferential generalization of the complex Cole-Hopf gauge transformation introduced by T. Tao in the Benjamin-Ono equation.
- Generalization of Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula: Proves a generalization of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula for hyperbolic quasidifferential equations and establishes stability of quasidifferential operator classes under conjugation by such flows modulo more regular remainder terms.
- Beals-type characterization: Provides a new characterization of quasidifferential operators in the spirit of Beals 9.
- Application to water wave equations: Applies the methods to the one-dimensional periodic gravity-capillary equation, establishing optimality of results for water wave systems from 37.
The paper studies regularity of flow maps for two classes of equations:
- Dispersive Burgers equation:
\partial_t v + v\partial_x v + |D|^{\alpha-1}\partial_x v = 0 \\
v(0,\cdot) = v_0(\cdot)
\end{cases}$$
2. **Gravity-capillary equation**:
$$\begin{cases}
\partial_t \eta = G(\eta)\psi \\
\partial_t \psi = -g\eta + H(\eta) + \frac{1}{2}(\partial_x \psi)^2 + \frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial_x \eta \partial_x \psi + G(\eta)\psi}{1+(\partial_x \eta)^2}
\end{cases}$$
### Core Technical Methods
#### 1. Gauge Transform
For zero-mean functions, the transformation is applied:
$$w = \text{Op}(a)u, \quad a = e^{\frac{1}{i\alpha}\xi|\xi|^{1-\alpha}U}$$
where $U$ is the real-valued periodic antiderivative of $u$.
The key innovation is expressing this operator as a time-one value of a flow map for a hyperbolic equation:
$$a = e^{iT_p}, \quad p = -\frac{1}{\alpha}\xi|\xi|^{1-\alpha}V \in \Gamma^{2-\alpha}_{\lceil\frac{\alpha}{\alpha-1}\rceil}(\mathbb{T})$$
#### 2. Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff Formula Generalization
For quasidifferential operators, a formal Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff series is established:
$$e^{i\tau T_p} T_b e^{-i\tau T_p} = \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} \frac{\tau^k}{k!} L^k_{iT_p} T_b$$
where $L^k_{iT_p} T_b = [iT_p, [\cdots, [iT_p, T_b]\cdots]]$ ($k$ times).
#### 3. Stability of Symbol Classes
Proves the existence of $b^p_\tau \in W^{\rho,\infty}S^{\beta}_{1-\delta,\delta}(\mathbb{T})$ such that:
$$e^{i\tau T_p} \circ T_b \circ e^{-i\tau T_p} = \text{Op}(b^p_\tau)$$
### Technical Innovations
1. **Use of quasidifferential framework**: Unlike pseudodifferential operators, the continuity of quasidifferential operators (Theorem A.2) ensures that controlling infinitely many seminorms is unnecessary.
2. **Gaussian mollification technique**: Employs Gaussian functions $\phi_\epsilon(D)$ for mollification, exploiting their analytic properties and explicit moment calculations.
3. **Novel symbol estimation methods**: Develops estimation techniques similar to Beals [9] but adapted for quasidifferential operators.
## Experimental Setup
### Theoretical Verification Methods
This is purely theoretical work, verified through the following approaches:
1. **Constructive proofs**: Establishes optimality of results through explicit construction of counterexamples
2. **Energy estimates**: Employs standard energy methods to obtain Lipschitz estimates
3. **Symbol calculus**: Utilizes symbol calculus rules for quasidifferential operators
### Key Estimates
For $t \in [0,T]$, the main results provide:
$$\|(u-v)(t)\|_{H^{s-(2-\alpha)^+}} \leq e^{Ct e^{Ct\|(u,v)\|_{L^\infty_t W^{\lceil\frac{\alpha}{\alpha-1}\rceil-1,\infty}_x}}} \|v_0\|_{H^s} \|u_0-v_0\|_{H^{s-(2-\alpha)^+}}$$
## Experimental Results
### Main Theoretical Results
#### Theorem 1.3 (Dispersive Burgers Equation)
For $\alpha \in ]1,2[$, $s \in ]\lceil\frac{\alpha}{\alpha-1}\rceil - \frac{1}{2}, +\infty[$, the flow map
$$B(u_0,r) \cap H^s_0(\mathbb{T};\mathbb{R}) \to C^0([0,T], H^{s-(2-\alpha)^+}_0(\mathbb{T};\mathbb{R}))$$
is Lipschitz.
#### Theorem 1.6 (Gravity-Capillary Equation)
For $s \in ]3+\frac{1}{2}, +\infty[$, the renormalized flow map satisfies:
$$\|(η,ψ)^* - (η',ψ')^{*'}(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s \times H^{s-\frac{1}{2}}} \leq C\|(η_0,ψ_0)^* - (η'_0,ψ'_0)^{*'}\|_{H^s \times H^{s-\frac{1}{2}}}$$
### Optimality Proofs
Optimality of results is established through construction of specific Ansätze:
- Exploitation of time reversibility
- Construction of solutions with separated supports
- Proof that derivative loss cannot be improved
## Related Work
### Historical Development
1. **Cole-Hopf transformation**: Classical linearization method for viscous Burgers equation
2. **Tao's complex transformation**: Complex Cole-Hopf transformation used by T. Tao [43] for the Benjamin-Ono equation
3. **Molinet's work**: Results in [32] for the Benjamin-Ono equation on the circle
4. **Work of Alazard et al.**: Quasilinearization and symmetrization of water wave equations in [2,6]
### Innovations of This Paper
- Generalizes Tao's method to general dispersive parameter $\alpha$
- Develops techniques applicable to quasidifferential operators
- Provides precise optimality results
## Conclusions and Discussion
### Main Conclusions
1. Establishes that regularity results for dispersive Burgers equation flow maps are optimal on the torus
2. Establishes a generalization of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula within the quasidifferential operator framework
3. Applies results to water wave equations, establishing optimality of previous results
### Limitations
1. Results apply only to the periodic case (torus)
2. Relatively high regularity assumptions required: $s > \lceil\frac{\alpha}{\alpha-1}\rceil - \frac{1}{2}$
3. Methods are essentially one-dimensional
### Future Directions
1. **Iterative application**: Gauge transformations can be applied iteratively to eliminate higher-order terms
2. **Global Cauchy problems**: Used in subsequent work [38] to address global Cauchy-type problems
3. **Multidimensional generalizations**: Exploration of method applicability in higher dimensions
## In-Depth Evaluation
### Strengths
1. **Strong technical innovation**: The generalization of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula within the quasidifferential operator framework represents an important technical contribution
2. **Optimal results**: Optimality is established through construction of counterexamples, which is important in PDE theory
3. **Unified methodology**: A single set of techniques simultaneously handles both the dispersive Burgers equation and water wave equations
4. **Theoretical depth**: Involves multiple mathematical branches including quasidifferential operator theory and harmonic analysis
### Weaknesses
1. **Technical complexity**: Proofs involve substantial technical details that may affect accessibility of results
2. **Limited application scope**: Primarily theoretical results with practical applications requiring further verification
3. **High regularity requirements**: Relatively strong regularity assumptions are needed
### Impact
1. **Theoretical contribution**: Provides new tools for flow map regularity theory of quasilinear PDEs
2. **Technical value**: Developed techniques may apply to other nonlinear dispersive equations
3. **Completeness**: Resolves an important open problem in the field (optimality)
### Applicable Scenarios
- Theoretical analysis of dispersive nonlinear PDEs
- Mathematical foundations of water wave theory
- Applications of quasidifferential operator theory
- Precise analysis of flow map regularity
## References
Key references include:
- [9] R. Beals: Characterization of pseudodifferential operators and applications
- [32] L. Molinet: Global Well-Posedness in L² for the periodic Benjamin-Ono equation
- [37] A. R. Said: A geometric proof of the Quasi-linearity of the Water-Waves system
- [43] T. Tao: Global well-posedness of the Benjamin-Ono equation in H¹(ℝ)
---
This paper makes important contributions to quasilinear PDE theory, particularly in precise analysis of flow map regularity. Despite technical complexity, the optimality of results and innovation of methods make it a significant work in the field.