ODMR on Single TR12 Centers in Diamond

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2104.04746
• Title: ODMR on Single TR12 Centers in Diamond
• Authors: Jonas Foglszinger, Andrej Denisenko, Thomas Kornher, Matthias Schreck, Wolfgang Knolle, Boris Yavkin, Roman Kolesov, Jörg Wrachtrup
• Classification: physics.optics, quant-ph
• Publication Date: April 13, 2021
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.04746

Abstract

This paper presents a comprehensive room-temperature optically detected magnetic resonance (ODMR) study of single TR12 color centers in diamond (zero-phonon line at 471 nm). Known in the literature since 1956, TR12 color centers exhibit strong ODMR signals under optical saturation conditions. These defects were created in high-purity diamond epitaxial layers through standard irradiation and annealing procedures. Based on ODMR spectroscopy, anti-bunching measurements, and coherent population trapping (CPT), an energy level structure is proposed comprising a ground state singlet, an excited state singlet, and an intermediate metastable triplet state. By mapping the fluorescence dependence on external magnetic field and laser excitation polarization, twelve inequivalent orientations of TR12 color centers are identified, and a static Jahn-Teller effect is detected.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Context

1. Quantum Technology Requirements: Point defects in insulators are considered promising candidates for quantum technologies, particularly in quantum sensing and quantum information processing
2. Limitations of Existing Color Centers: While NV centers have been widely applied in quantum computing and sensing, exploration of alternative color centers is needed to expand application domains
3. Research Gap on TR12 Centers: Despite discovery in 1956, TR12 color centers lack detailed spectroscopic and spin property studies at the single-center level

Research Significance

• Solid-state systems such as diamond and silicon carbide inherit mature technologies from the electronics industry
• Among hundreds of known diamond color centers, most lack spin control capabilities
• Color centers that can be artificially created at specified locations are needed for practical applications

Innovation Motivation

This work represents the first single-center ODMR study of TR12 color centers, aiming to:

• Reveal the electronic energy level structure of TR12 centers
• Determine their orientation characteristics in the diamond lattice
• Assess their application potential in quantum technologies

Core Contributions

1. First Single-Center ODMR Study: Comprehensive ODMR characterization of individual TR12 color centers at room temperature
2. Energy Level Structure Model: Proposed a complete energy level structure comprising a ground state singlet, excited state singlet, and intermediate metastable triplet state
3. Orientation Characterization: Identified twelve inequivalent orientations of TR12 centers in the diamond lattice
4. Jahn-Teller Effect Discovery: Detected and explained static Jahn-Teller distortion through fluorescence switching
5. Quantum Application Assessment: Analyzed application prospects of TR12 centers in quantum sensing and quantum information processing

Methodology

Experimental Setup

Sample Preparation

• Ion Implantation: 10/370 keV ¹²C ion implantation into (100)-oriented CVD diamond
• Electron Irradiation: 10 MeV electron irradiation followed by 1-hour annealing at 800°C
• Electron-irradiated color centers exhibit better photostability but random distribution

Experimental Apparatus

• Custom-built confocal microscope system with 410 nm linearly polarized laser excitation
• 3D nanopositioner for sample scanning
• Dual single-photon detectors for fluorescence detection and correlation measurements
• Spectrometer for spectral characterization
• Gold microwave waveguide for microwave radiation
• Variable-position permanent magnet for external magnetic field generation

Measurement Techniques

ODMR Spectroscopy

• Two sharp ODMR lines at 740 MHz and 2533.3 MHz observed at zero field
• Spin Hamiltonian: H = D(S²z - 1/3) + E(S²x - S²y)
• Zero-field splitting parameters: D = 1636.6 MHz, E = 896.6 MHz

Fluorescence Correlation Measurements

• Anti-bunching measurements confirm single-center nature
• Emission state lifetime approximately 4.7 ns at low excitation power
• Long-time photon bunching observed under optical saturation

Coherent Population Trapping (CPT)

• Confirms existence of two long-lived states |Tx⟩ and |Ty⟩
• CPT resonance linewidth estimates long-lived state lifetime at 5-10 μs

Experimental Results

Energy Level Structure Determination

Triplet State Parameters

• Triplet structure determined through ODMR and CPT measurements
• |Tx⟩ and |Ty⟩ are long-lived states (~6.79 μs)
• |Tz⟩ is short-lived state (~375 ns)
• Intersystem crossing rates: γx = γy = 0.095 μs⁻¹, γz ≈ 0

Rabi Oscillations

• Complete Rabi oscillations observed, determining π-pulse duration
• State lifetimes and population rates extracted through fitting

Magnetic Field Dependence

Magnetic Field Mapping

• Fluorescence intensity dependence on external magnetic field plotted
• Dark points correspond to magnetic field directions that do not induce mixing between |Tz⟩ and |Tx⟩/|Ty⟩
• Local z-axis determined to align along diamond (111) direction

Orientation Determination

• Twelve inequivalent orientations proposed based on diamond lattice symmetry
• y-axis lies in the plane formed by two adjacent σ-bonds
• All orientations' magnetic field maps verified through simulation

Polarization Dependence

Optical Dipole

• Polarization-dependent fluorescence measurements reveal single dipole transition
• Dipole direction slightly tilted relative to y-axis
• Dipole directions determined by combining twelve magnetically inequivalent species

Jahn-Teller Effect

Spectral Splitting

• ODMR line splitting into two components under external magnetic field
• Splitting cannot be explained by nuclear spin coupling
• All color centers with identical orientation exhibit identical splitting

Fluorescence Switching

• Telegraph-like switching between two distinct fluorescence levels observed under low optical excitation
• Switching dependence on laser polarization shows two sinusoidal signals with phase difference of approximately 12°
• Switching becomes faster at high excitation power, making it difficult to resolve

Physical Mechanism

Both phenomena can be explained as TR12 color centers jumping between two energetically degenerate stable configurations:

• Local symmetry axes tilted approximately 12° relative to each other
• Optical dipole projection changes lead to different excitation efficiencies
• Symmetry axis rotation causes ODMR line splitting relative to magnetic field

Related Work

Historical Development

• TR12 color centers discovered in 1956 following electron or neutron bombardment
• Primarily bulk measurement studies conducted in the late 20th century
• Negative correlation with nitrogen suggests intrinsic defect origin
• Localized phonon modes support existence of interstitial atoms

Other Diamond Color Centers

• NV Centers: Pioneering work in quantum computing and sensing
• SiV Centers: Silicon vacancies in diamond and silicon carbide
• GeV and SnV Centers: Other Group IV double-vacancy color centers
• Most of hundreds of known color centers lack spin control capabilities

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete Energy Level Structure: Established three-state energy level model for TR12 color centers
2. Lattice Orientations: Clarified twelve inequivalent orientations and their precise directions in diamond
3. Dynamical Parameters: Determined state lifetimes and transition rates
4. Jahn-Teller Effect: Discovered and explained configurational switching phenomenon

Quantum Application Prospects

Quantum Sensing Advantages

• Wide Angular Acceptance: Maintains non-zero ODMR contrast over larger angular ranges compared to NV centers
• Full-Vector Magnetometry: Can serve as nanoscale vector magnetometer for nearly arbitrary magnetic field directions
• High Magnetic Field Measurement: Suitable for measuring magnetic fields from tens of millitesla to tesla range

Quantum Information Processing Advantages

• Nuclear Spin Initialization: Can initialize and readout nearby nuclear spin qubits
• Extended Coherence Time: Ground state singlet does not affect nuclear spins, enabling longer nuclear memory lifetime
• Photonic Interface: Strong zero-phonon line can serve as interface between flying qubits (photons) and stationary qubits (nuclear spins)

Limitations

• ODMR observed in excited triplet state, resonance linewidth fundamentally limited by state lifetime
• Fundamental limitations on sensitivity

Future Research Directions

1. Structure Determination: Determine exact atomic structure of TR12 color centers
2. Temperature and Electric Field Response: Evaluate sensitivity to temperature and electric fields
3. Cavity Enhancement: Enhance zero-phonon line through Purcell effect
4. Nuclear Spin Coupling: Explore coupling mechanisms with ¹³C nuclear spins

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Experimental Comprehensiveness: Multiple spectroscopic techniques (ODMR, fluorescence correlation, CPT) provide complete characterization
2. Theoretical Modeling: Proposed energy level structure model consistent with all experimental observations
3. Technical Innovation: First single-center study of TR12 fills important research gap
4. Application-Oriented: Clearly evaluates quantum technology application potential

Limitations

1. Unknown Structure: Exact atomic structure of TR12 color centers remains undetermined
2. Photostability: Insufficient photostability of ion-implanted color centers
3. Temperature Dependence: Lacks systematic study at low temperatures
4. Coherence Time: Key quantum parameters such as spin coherence time not measured

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new research subject and methodology for diamond color center physics
2. Technical Significance: Offers new candidate system for quantum sensing
3. Methodological Contribution: Establishes paradigm for comprehensive single-center multi-technique characterization

Application Scenarios

1. High Magnetic Field Vector Measurement: Particularly suitable for applications requiring full-angle magnetic field measurement
2. Quantum Network Nodes: Potential candidate as photon-spin interface
3. Fundamental Physics Research: Real-time observation of Jahn-Teller effect provides new tool for solid-state physics

References

The paper cites 23 important references covering:

• Pioneering work on NV center quantum applications
• Research on other diamond color centers (SiV, GeV, SnV)
• Historical literature on TR12 color centers
• Theoretical foundations of coherent population trapping

Summary: Through precise single-center spectroscopy, this paper comprehensively characterizes the optical and spin properties of TR12 color centers, providing a new candidate system for quantum technologies. Despite certain limitations, its unique orientation characteristics and application potential make it an important complement to NV centers.