Generalised holonomies and K(E$_9$)

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2107.02445
• Title: Generalised holonomies and K(E$_9$)
• Authors: Axel Kleinschmidt, Hermann Nicolai
• Categories: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), math.RT (Mathematics - Representation Theory)
• Publication Date: July 2021 (arXiv:2107.02445v3, last updated October 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.02445

Abstract

This paper provides a comprehensive investigation of the representation theory structure of K(E$_9$), the involution subalgebra of the affine Kac-Moody algebra E$_9$. The authors revisit previously discovered infinite sequences of unfaithful representations and provide detailed descriptions of their associated ideals, with particular emphasis on the two chiral versions that can be constructed for each representation. The paper demonstrates that in each such unfaithful representation, the action of K(E$_9$) decomposes into a direct sum of two mutually commuting ("chiral" and "anti-chiral") parabolic subalgebras with Levi subalgebra $\mathfrak{so}(16)_+\oplus\mathfrak{so}(16)_-$. Furthermore, the paper clarifies the consistency conditions for lifting these representations to unfaithful representations of K(E$_{10}$).

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Killing Spinor Equations in Supergravity: The Killing spinor equation plays a central role in studying supersymmetric supergravity solutions, expressing the vanishing condition of the gravitino supersymmetry variation
2. Proposal of Generalized Holonomy Groups: The literature proposes SO(16)$_+$ × SO(16)$_-$ ⊂ SO(32) ⊂ SL(32,ℝ) as a candidate generalized holonomy group for maximal supergravity
3. Problems at the Group Level: These conjectures face difficulties at the group level, failing to include the correct R-symmetry groups that appear upon dimensional reduction, particularly the Spin(16) symmetry in D=3 maximal supergravity

Research Motivation

1. Resolving Holonomy Group Issues: The holonomy groups discussed in existing literature are merely "shadows" of larger structures
2. Kac-Moody Symmetries: Research on K(e$_{10}$) reveals that its involution subalgebra admits a 32-dimensional representation (spin-1/2) and a 320-component representation (spin-3/2)
3. Theoretical Unification: Seeking a theoretical framework that provides a common origin for IIA and IIB fermions

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Construction of Chiral Representations: Detailed descriptions of the ideal structures of K(E$_9$) unfaithful representations, particularly chiral and anti-chiral versions
2. Parabolic Algebra Decomposition Theorem: Proof that the action of K(E$_9$) in each unfaithful representation decomposes into a direct sum of two mutually commuting parabolic subalgebras
3. Clarification of Lifting Conditions: Explicit formulation of consistency conditions for lifting K(E$_9$) representations to K(E$_{10}$) representations
4. Revelation of Generalized Holonomy Structure: Demonstration that the true generalized holonomy group has the form Q = (Spin(16)$_+$ ⋉ U$_+$) × (Spin(16)$_-$ ⋉ U$_-$)

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

The paper is based on representation theory of the affine Kac-Moody algebra e$_9$ and its involution subalgebra K(e$_9$).

Core Construction Methods

1. Filtered Algebra Construction

The filtered basis of K(e$_9$) is given by:

X^{IJ}_n := 1/2(t^n + t^{-n}) ⊗ X^{IJ} for n ≥ 0
Y^A_n := 1/2(t^n - t^{-n}) ⊗ Y^A for n > 0

2. Parabolic Algebra Embedding

Through variable substitution u = (1∓t)/(1±t), define parabolic Lie algebras:

N = ℝ[[u²]] ⊗ ⟨X^{IJ}⟩ ⊕ uℝ[[u²]] ⊗ ⟨Y^A⟩

3. Truncated Representation Construction

Finite-dimensional representations via quotient algebras:

• Set A^{IJ}{2k} = S^A{2k-1} = 0 for k > k₀ = N/2
• Obtain graded representation W_N = ⊕^N_ V_i

Construction of Chiral Ideals

Ideal Relations

For truncation parameter k₀, higher-order generators satisfy:

(±1)ⁿX^{IJ}_n = Σ^{k₀}_{m=0} (±1)ᵐc_{n,m}X^{IJ}_m
(±1)ⁿY^A_n = Σ^{k₀}_{m=1} (±1)ᵐd_{n,m}Y^A_m

where the coefficients are:

c_{n,m} = ∏_{0≤j≤k₀, j≠m} (n²-j²)/(m²-j²)
d_{n,m} = (n/m) ∏_{1≤j≤k₀, j≠m} (n²-j²)/(m²-j²)

Chiral Ideal Definition

i± = ⊕_{n>k₀} ℝI±_n ⊕ ⊕_{n>k₀} ℝJ±_n ⊂ k

where:

I±_n := X_n - Σ^{k₀}_{m=0} (±1)^{n+m}c_{n,m}X_m
J±_n := Y_n - Σ^{k₀}_{m=1} (±1)^{n+m}d_{n,m}Y_m

Main Theoretical Results

Theorem 1: Completeness of Ideals

Lemma: i₊ + i₋ = k

This indicates that the sum of chiral ideals covers the entire K(e₉) algebra.

Theorem 2: Commutativity of Chiral Quotient Algebras

Proposition: For any finite-dimensional representation defined by truncation conditions, the quotient algebra q decomposes into a direct sum of two mutually commuting subalgebras:

q = q₊ ⊕ q₋, [q₊, q₋] = 0

Both algebras are parabolic with so(16)± as their Levi subalgebras.

Theorem 3: Generalized Holonomy Group Structure

The quotient group Q has the form:

Q = (Spin(16)₊ ⋉ U₊) × (Spin(16)₋ ⋉ U₋)

where U± are N-step nilpotent groups.

Concrete Examples

Spin-1/2 Representation

• Corresponds to the restriction of the 32-dimensional representation of K(E₁₀) to K(E₉)
• Chiral decomposition realized through two-dimensional chiral matrix Γ(δ) = Γ₀Γ₁
• Generator form: 1/2(1±Γ(δ))Γ(α̊)

Spin-3/2 Representation

• Corresponds to the 320-component gravitino representation
• Polarization tensor: X_(α) = -1/2α_aα_b + 1/4G_
• Truncation conditions: A₄ = A₆ = ··· = 0, S₃ = S₅ = ··· = 0

Higher-Order Spinor Representations

The paper also analyzes spin-5/2 and spin-7/2 representations, demonstrating systematic truncation patterns and ideal relations.

Conditions for Lifting to K(E$_{10}$)

Berman Relations

K(E₁₀) is generated by ten Berman generators x₁,...,x₁₀ satisfying:

[xᵢ, xⱼ] = 0 if i and j disconnected
[xᵢ[xᵢ, xⱼ]] = -xⱼ if i and j connected

Lifting Ansatz

For "doubled" representations S₊ ⊕ S₋, seek the form:

x₁ = (0 B; C 0), x₂ = (X₂ 0; 0 X₂), xᵢ = (Xᵢ 0; 0 Xᵢ)

Consistency Conditions

Key Berman relations require:

[x₁, [x₁, x₂]] = -x₂, [x₂, [x₂, x₁]] = -x₁

This leads to constraints on B and C:

{BC, X₂} - 2BX₂C = -X₂
{CB, X₂} - 2CX₂B = -X₂
[X₂, [X₂, B]] = -B, [X₂, [X₂, C]] = -C

Physical Significance and Applications

Applications in Supergravity

1. D=2 Maximal Supergravity: K(E₉) plays an important role in two-dimensional maximal supergravity
2. Physical Interpretation of Chirality: Mathematical chirality ± corresponds to spacetime chirality
3. Correct Embedding of R-Symmetry: Resolves topological obstructions in embedding Spin(16) into SL(32)

Significance in M-Theory

1. E₁₀ Symmetry Conjecture: Provides insights into fermionic extensions of the E₁₀ symmetry conjecture in M-theory
2. Emergence of Spacetime: May offer new perspectives on spacetime emergence and alternative algebraic concepts

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Achievements

1. Systematized K(E₉) Representation Theory: Provides complete classification and structural understanding of unfaithful representations
2. Revealed True Generalized Holonomy Group: Demonstrates that holonomy groups in the literature are merely shadows of larger structures
3. Established Bridge from Affine to Hyperbolic Cases: Provides systematic methods for understanding K(E₁₀) representations

Theoretical Significance

1. Development of Kac-Moody Algebra Representation Theory: Provides new construction methods for finite-dimensional representations of infinite-dimensional Lie algebras
2. Mathematical Foundations of Supergravity Theory: Provides rigorous mathematical framework for symmetry structures in supergravity
3. Algebraic Structure of M-Theory: Provides new mathematical tools for non-perturbative structures in M-theory

Future Directions

1. Complete Classification of K(E₁₀) Representations: Search for all possible K(E₁₀) unfaithful representations
2. Generalization to Higher-Dimensional Cases: Study more complex cases such as K(E₁₁)
3. Deepening Physical Applications: Explore concrete applications in string theory and M-theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Mathematical Rigor: The paper is mathematically rigorous with complete proofs for all theorems
2. Strong Systematicity: Provides systematic understanding of K(E₉) representation theory
3. Clear Physical Motivation: Clear connections to supergravity and M-theory
4. Technical Innovation: The construction method for chiral ideals is innovative

Technical Highlights

1. Filtered Algebra Method: Clever use of filtered structures to construct finite-dimensional representations
2. Chiral Decomposition: Systematic treatment of algebraic chiral decomposition
3. Ideal Theory: Deep analysis of kernels and quotient structures of representations

Limitations

1. Primarily Limited to Affine Case: Although lifting to K(E₁₀) is discussed, main results remain in the affine algebra setting
2. Specificity of Physical Applications: While physical motivation is present, concrete physical applications require further development
3. Computational Complexity: Calculations for higher-order cases become highly complex

Impact Assessment

1. Academic Value: Important contributions to both Kac-Moody algebra representation theory and supergravity theory
2. Technical Impact: Methods provided may be applicable to research on other infinite-dimensional algebras
3. Long-term Significance: Provides important tools for understanding algebraic structures in M-theory

This work represents significant progress at the intersection of Kac-Moody algebra representation theory and supergravity theory, providing a new mathematical framework for understanding the role of infinite-dimensional symmetries in physics.