Superconductivity in kagome metal YRu3Si2 with strong electron correlations

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2109.11478
• Title: Superconductivity in kagome metal YRu3Si2 with strong electron correlations
• Authors: Chunsheng Gong, Shangjie Tian, Zhijun Tu, Qiangwei Yin, Yang Fu, Ruitao Luo, and Hechang Lei
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con (Condensed Matter Physics - Superconductivity), cond-mat.str-el (Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2021 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.11478

Abstract

This paper presents a detailed investigation of the physical properties of YRu3Si2, which features a Ru kagome lattice, in both the normal and superconducting states. Resistivity and magnetization measurements demonstrate that YRu3Si2 is a type-II bulk superconductor with Tc ~ 3.0 K. Specific heat measurements further suggest that the superconductivity may originate from weak to moderate electron-phonon coupling. On the other hand, the large Kadowaki-Woods ratio and Wilson ratio indicate the presence of strong electron correlation effects in this system, which may be related to the characteristic flat bands of the kagome lattice.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Superconductivity in kagome metals: The kagome lattice, with its unique two-dimensional structure (corner-sharing triangles), provides an ideal platform for studying magnetic frustration, electron correlations, and topological electronic states
2. Interplay between electron correlations and topological properties: Exploring the relationship between electron correlation effects and band topology in kagome metals
3. Discovery of novel kagome superconductors: Identifying and characterizing new kagome superconductor materials to deepen understanding of correlated topological phenomena

Significance

• The kagome lattice exhibits special electronic structure features: Dirac points, flat bands, and van Hove singularities
• These topological features may lead to various exotic correlated topological phenomena, such as giant anomalous Hall effect and magnetic Weyl semimetal states
• The combination of superconductivity and topological properties may produce novel quantum states

Existing Research Limitations

• Experimental studies on the interplay between electron correlation effects and band topology in kagome metals are limited
• The number of known kagome superconductors is restricted, such as the AV3Sb5 (A = K, Rb, Cs) series and RT3B2 series
• The superconducting properties of YRu3Si2 have not been thoroughly investigated, particularly in comparison with LaRu3Si2

Core Contributions

1. Systematic characterization of YRu3Si2 superconducting properties: Determined the type-II bulk superconductor characteristics with Tc ~ 3.0 K
2. Revealed weak to moderate electron-phonon coupling mechanism: Obtained λe-ph = 0.50(2) through specific heat measurements and McMillan formula calculations
3. Confirmed the presence of strong electron correlation effects: Demonstrated through analysis of Kadowaki-Woods ratio and Wilson ratio
4. Established potential connection between superconducting properties and kagome flat bands: Provided experimental foundation for understanding correlated topological phenomena in kagome metals

Methodology Details

Experimental Methods

This study employs comprehensive experimental characterization techniques:

Sample Preparation

• Polycrystalline YRu3Si2 samples prepared by arc-melting method
• Raw materials: Y metal chips (99.9%), Ru powder (99.9%), Si powder (99.9%)
• Excess Ru added to prevent formation of YRu2Si2 phase
• Multiple remelting cycles under argon atmosphere to improve homogeneity

Structural Characterization

• Powder X-ray Diffraction (PXRD): Using Bruker D8 diffractometer with Cu Kα radiation
• Rietveld Refinement: Using TOPAS4 software to determine lattice parameters

Physical Property Measurements

• Electrical Transport Measurements: Using Quantum Design PPMS-14T system
• Magnetization Measurements: Using Quantum Design MPMS3 system
• Specific Heat Measurements: PPMS system, temperature range 2-300 K

Crystal Structure Analysis

YRu3Si2 adopts the hexagonal layered CeCo3B2-type structure:

• Space group: P63/m (No. 176)
• Lattice parameters: a = 0.5542(1) nm, c = 0.7150(7) nm
• Key feature: Ru atoms form a distorted kagome layer with two different Ru-Ru bond lengths (0.2692 nm and 0.2858 nm)

Experimental Results

Superconducting Properties Characterization

Magnetization Measurements

• Superconducting Transition Temperature: Tc = 2.98 K (ZFC mode, μ0H = 1 mT)
• Superconducting Volume Fraction: ~110% (T = 1.8 K), confirming bulk superconductivity
• Superconductor Type: Confirmed as type-II superconductor by differences between ZFC and FC curves and hysteresis loops

Critical Magnetic Field Determination

Determined through magnetization and resistivity measurements:

• Lower Critical Field: μ0Hc1(0) = 28.0(3) mT
• Upper Critical Field: μ0Hc2(0) = 0.655(2) T (G-L formula fitting)
• Thermodynamic Critical Field: μ0Hc(0) = 0.42(9) T

Superconducting Characteristic Parameters

• Coherence Length: ξGL = 22.43(2) nm
• Penetration Depth: λGL = 24.80(3) nm
• G-L Parameter: κGL = 1.11(4) > 1/√2, confirming type-II superconductor

Electrical Transport Properties

Normal State Resistivity

• Metallic Behavior: ρ(T) decreases monotonically with temperature
• Residual Resistivity Ratio: RRR = ρ(300K)/ρ(4K) ≈ 8.6
• Low-Temperature Fitting: ρ(T) = ρ0 + AT² + BT⁵
  • ρ0 = 4.99(5) μΩ cm
  • A = 2.38(7)×10⁻³ μΩ cm K⁻²
  • B = 5.9(4)×10⁻⁸ μΩ cm K⁻⁵

Superconducting Transition

• Onset Transition Temperature: Tc,onset = 3.0 K
• Transition Width: ΔTc = 0.082 K, indicating good sample quality

Specific Heat Measurements

Superconducting State Specific Heat

• Thermodynamic Tc: 2.84 K (equal entropy construction method)
• Specific Heat Jump: ΔCele/γTc = 1.21(4) < 1.43 (BCS weak coupling limit)
• Sommerfeld Coefficient: γ = 27.5(8) mJ mol⁻¹ K⁻²

Electron-Phonon Coupling

• Debye Temperature: ΘD = 460(26) K
• Coupling Constant: λe-ph = 0.50(2) (McMillan formula, μ* = 0.13)
• Confirmed as weak to moderate coupling superconductor

Electron Correlation Effects

Magnetization Analysis

Magnetization under μ0H = 0.5 T can be fitted by: χ(T) = χ(0)1-(T/TE)² + C/(T+T0)

Fitting parameters:

• χ(0) = 5.56(2)×10⁻⁴ emu mol⁻¹ Oe⁻¹
• TE = 640(10) K
• Effective magnetic moment: μeff = 0.1113(3) μB/Ru

Correlation Strength Indicators

• Kadowaki-Woods Ratio: A/γ² = 3.15(2) μΩ cm mol² K² J⁻²
  • Far exceeds transition metal values (0.4), but smaller than heavy fermion systems (10)
• Wilson Ratio: RW = 1.49(4) > 1
  • Exceeds free electron gas expectation, indicating strong electron correlations

Related Work

Kagome Superconductor Series

1. Laves Phase Superconductors: Cubic MgCu2-type structure, Tc range 0.07-10 K
2. RT3B2 Series: Hexagonal layered structure with transition metals forming kagome layers
3. AV3Sb5 Series: Recently discovered kagome superconductors with coexisting CDW and superconductivity

Comparison with LaRu3Si2

• Structural Similarity: Both adopt CeCo3B2-type structure
• Tc Difference: YRu3Si2 (3.0 K) < LaRu3Si2 (7.8 K)
• Upper Critical Field: YRu3Si2 (0.655 T) < LaRu3Si2 (~4 T)
• Electron Correlations: Both exhibit strong correlation characteristics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. YRu3Si2 is a type-II bulk superconductor with Tc ~ 3.0 K
2. The superconducting mechanism is weak to moderate strength BCS electron-phonon coupling
3. Significant strong electron correlation effects exist in the system
4. Correlation effects may be related to kagome flat bands

Physical Picture

The origin of strong electron correlation effects may be:

• Enhanced density of states near the Fermi level due to characteristic flat bands of the kagome lattice
• Enhanced localization of flat band electrons strengthens electron-electron interactions
• This correlation effect coexists with superconductivity, forming a unique electronic state

Limitations

1. Polycrystalline Samples: Restricts investigation of anisotropic properties
2. Ru Impurities: May affect accurate determination of certain physical quantities
3. Lack of Theoretical Models: Requires deeper theoretical calculations for support

Future Directions

1. Single Crystal Growth: Obtain high-quality single crystals for anisotropy studies
2. Band Structure Calculations: Theoretical calculations to verify the role of kagome flat bands
3. Pressure Tuning: Study effects of pressure on superconducting and correlation properties
4. Spectroscopic Studies: Direct observation of electronic structure using ARPES and other techniques

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Systematicity: Multiple experimental techniques comprehensively characterize superconducting properties
2. Reliable Data: Good consistency in experimental results with thorough error analysis
3. Clear Physical Picture: Establishes connection between superconductivity and electron correlations
4. In-Depth Comparative Analysis: Comparison with LaRu3Si2 highlights material characteristics

Weaknesses

1. Limited Mechanistic Explanation: Insufficient discussion of microscopic mechanisms underlying the relationship between electron correlations and superconductivity
2. Insufficient Theoretical Support: Lacks first-principles calculations and other theoretical verification
3. Sample Quality: Existence of polycrystalline samples and impurity phases limits research precision

Impact

1. Enriches kagome superconductor family: Provides new research subject for the field
2. Validates correlation-topology coupling: Experimentally confirms importance of strong correlation effects in kagome metals
3. Guides subsequent research: Provides experimental benchmark for exploration of related materials

Applicable Scenarios

This research is applicable to:

• Superconducting mechanism studies in condensed matter physics
• Experimental characterization of strongly correlated electron systems
• Physical property tuning in kagome materials
• Candidate material screening for topological superconductors

References

This paper cites 46 important references, primarily including:

• Topological property studies of kagome materials (Ye et al., Nature 2018)
• AV3Sb5 superconductor series (Ortiz et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 2020)
• Related research on LaRu3Si2 (Li et al., Phys. Rev. B 2011)
• Superconductivity theory foundations (McMillan, Phys. Rev. 1968; Werthamer et al., Phys. Rev. 1966)