A Geometric Condition for Uniqueness of Fréchet Means of Persistence Diagrams

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2207.03943
• Title: A Geometric Condition for Uniqueness of Fréchet Means of Persistence Diagrams
• Authors: Yueqi Cao, Anthea Monod (Imperial College London)
• Classification: math.MG (Metric Geometry), stat.ME (Statistics - Methodology)
• Publication Date: July 2022 (arXiv preprint, updated to v3 in January 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.03943

Abstract

Fréchet means are important statistical summaries and centrality measures for data, and have been defined and studied for persistence diagrams in persistent homology. However, the complex geometric structure of the persistence diagram space implies that the Fréchet mean of a given collection of persistence diagrams is not necessarily unique, which impedes theoretical guarantees for empirical means relative to population means. This paper derives variance expressions for collections of persistence diagrams exhibiting multi-matchings between persistence points called groupings. Furthermore, a condition on groupings termed flatness is proposed; it is proven that collections of persistence diagrams exhibiting flat groupings yield unique Fréchet means. Finite-sample convergence results are derived for general groupings, yielding convergence of Fréchet means when groupings are flat. The flat grouping is then interpreted within the recently proposed general framework for Fréchet means in Alexandrov geometry. Finally, it is demonstrated that for manifold-valued data, flat groupings can be constructed by truncating persistence diagrams.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Statistical Analysis Needs in Persistent Homology: Persistent homology, as an important method in topological data analysis, has persistence diagrams as its primary output. With widespread application across scientific disciplines, the study of statistical properties of persistence diagrams has become a core issue.
2. Importance of Fréchet Means: Fréchet means generalize the ordinary arithmetic mean to general metric spaces and have been defined and studied in the persistence diagram space, serving as a key tool for measuring centrality of persistence diagram collections.
3. Challenge of Uniqueness: Due to the complex geometric structure of non-negative curvature in the persistence diagram space $(S_2, W_2)$, Fréchet means are typically non-unique, severely limiting theoretical analysis and practical applications.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Lack of Uniqueness Conditions: Existing research assumes uniqueness of Fréchet means to establish convergence results, but lacks conditions for determining when uniqueness holds.
2. Insufficient Theoretical Guarantees: Unable to provide theoretical guarantees for empirical Fréchet means computed from real data.
3. Computational Complexity: Due to non-uniqueness, existing algorithms may converge to local optima.

Research Motivation

This paper aims to find conditions guaranteeing uniqueness of Fréchet means through geometric analysis, thereby providing a solid theoretical foundation for statistical analysis of persistence diagrams and establishing corresponding convergence theory.

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of Flat Grouping Concept: Defines a "flat grouping" geometric condition for collections of persistence diagrams, which is a sufficient condition for guaranteeing uniqueness of Fréchet means.
2. Derivation of Variance Expressions: Derives precise variance expressions for general groupings (Theorem 8), revealing the impact of diagonal contributions to variance.
3. Proof of Uniqueness Theorem: Proves that collections of persistence diagrams with flat groupings possess unique Fréchet means (Theorem 10).
4. Establishment of Convergence Theory: Derives finite-sample convergence rates for general groupings (Theorem 11), particularly providing convergence guarantees for Fréchet means of flat groupings.
5. Alexandrov Geometry Interpretation: Reinterprets flat groupings within the Alexandrov space theory framework, providing geometric intuition and theoretical insights.
6. Practical Application Method: Demonstrates that flat groupings can be constructed by truncating persistence diagrams, providing a practical method for persistent homology approximation of manifold data.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Given a collection of persistence diagrams $\{D_1, \ldots, D_L\}$, investigate uniqueness conditions for their Fréchet means. The Fréchet function is defined as: $F(D) = \frac{1}{L}\sum_{i=1}^L W_2^2(D, D_i)$ where $W_2$ is the 2-Wasserstein distance.

Core Concepts

1. Grouping

Definition 4: A grouping $G$ is a $K \times L$ formal matrix whose elements are copies of non-diagonal points from $D_1, \ldots, D_L$ and the diagonal $\partial\Omega$. Each row is called a selection.

Groupings essentially represent multi-matchings between persistence diagram points, generalizing the concept of bijective matchings between two persistence diagrams.

2. Variance Expression

Theorem 8: For a grouping $G$, its variance is: $V(G) = \frac{1}{L^2}\sum_{i=1}^K \sum_{1≤w<ℓ≤L} \|G_i^w - G_i^ℓ\|^2 + \sum_{i=1}^K \frac{L-s_i}{L^2s_i}\left(\sum_{1≤w<ℓ≤s_i} \|(G_{j_w}^i)^⊤ - (G_{j_ℓ}^i)^⊤\|^2\right)$

where $s_i$ is the number of non-diagonal points in the $i$-th row. The first term reflects inter-point distance contributions, while the second term embodies the special role of the diagonal.

3. Flat Grouping

Definition 9: A grouping $G$ is flat if there exists $λ > 0$ such that:

• (i) The diameter of each non-trivial selection is bounded: $\|G_i^w - G_i^ℓ\| < λ$
• (ii) Distance between different selections has a lower bound: $\|G_i^w - G_j^ℓ\| > λ$ (for distinct $i,j$)
• (iii) Non-diagonal points are far from the diagonal: $\|G_i^w - \partial\Omega\| > λ$

Technical Innovations

1. Design of Geometric Conditions

The flat grouping condition ingeniously balances three geometric constraints:

• Intra-cluster compactness (condition i)
• Inter-cluster separation (condition ii)
• Boundary separation (condition iii)

This design ensures uniqueness of optimal matchings.

2. Variance Decomposition Technique

By decomposing persistence diagram points into components parallel and perpendicular to the diagonal, precise variance expressions incorporating diagonal effects are computed, representing an important technical breakthrough.

3. Application of Alexandrov Geometry

Leverages geometric properties of non-negative curvature Alexandrov spaces, particularly the concepts of Hilbert subcones and hugging functions, to provide deep geometric interpretation of flat groupings.

Experimental Setup

Datasets

1. Circle Data: Circle of radius 0.5 with 1000 uniformly sampled points
2. Torus Data: Torus with outer radius 0.8 and inner radius 0.3, with 10000 uniformly sampled points

Experimental Design

Bootstrap methodology:

• Draw $B$ subsamples $X_1, \ldots, X_B$ from original dataset $X$
• Compute persistence diagram $D[X_i]$ for each subsample
• Construct flat groupings through truncation
• Compute Fréchet means of truncated persistence diagrams as approximations to $D[X]$

Truncation Strategy

Based on the manifold separation constant $λ(M)$, set truncation threshold at $\frac{1}{2}λ(M)$, removing points too close to the diagonal, ensuring remaining points form flat groupings.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Circle Experiment

• Original 1-dimensional persistence diagram contains 1 main non-diagonal point $(0.0227, 0.8754)$ and 4 near-diagonal points
• 50 subsamples (each with 600 points), truncation threshold 0.2
• Fréchet mean: $(0.0395, 0.8582)$, providing good approximation to the true persistence diagram

Torus Experiment

• Original 1-dimensional persistence diagram contains 2 main non-diagonal points $(0.0382, 0.5220)$ and $(0.0326, 0.8884)$, plus 478 near-diagonal points
• 20 subsamples (each with 4000 points), truncation threshold 0.3
• Fréchet means: $(0.0597, 0.5222)$ and $(0.0537, 0.8887)$, accurately preserving topological features of the torus

Experimental Findings

1. Truncation Effectiveness: Flat groupings can be successfully constructed through appropriate truncation
2. Approximation Quality: Truncated Fréchet means well approximate main topological features of original persistence diagrams
3. Computational Stability: Flat groupings guarantee uniqueness of Fréchet means, avoiding convergence to different local optima

Related Work

Statistics of Persistent Homology

1. Fréchet Mean Theory: Mileyko et al. (2011) first defined Fréchet means for persistence diagrams; Turner et al. (2014) established convergence results under uniqueness assumptions
2. Computational Algorithms: Turner et al. (2014) proposed greedy algorithms; Lacombe et al. (2018) developed algorithms based on optimal transport
3. Probabilistic Approaches: Munch et al. (2015) introduced probabilistic Fréchet means for time-varying persistence diagrams

Alexandrov Geometry

1. General Theory: Le Gouic et al. (2022) established general convergence theory for empirical Fréchet means in Alexandrov spaces
2. Application Examples: This theory has been successfully applied to Gaussian distribution centroids, template deformation models, and other domains
3. Geometric Properties: Turner et al. (2014) proved that $(S_2, W_2)$ is an Alexandrov space of non-negative curvature

Contributions of This Paper

Compared to existing work, this paper provides for the first time geometric conditions for uniqueness of persistence diagram Fréchet means, filling theoretical gaps and offering new understanding within the Alexandrov geometry framework.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Contribution: Flat groupings provide verifiable geometric conditions for uniqueness of persistence diagram Fréchet means
2. Convergence Theory: Establishes finite-sample convergence rates with variance bounds: $E[W_2^2(\bar{D}, D^*)] ≤ σ^2/B$
3. Practical Method: Truncation technique provides feasible approach for constructing flat groupings in practical applications

Limitations

1. Restrictiveness of Conditions: Flat grouping conditions are relatively strict, potentially inapplicable to all persistence diagram collections
2. Information Loss from Truncation: Truncation process may discard important topological information
3. Parameter Selection: Choice of truncation threshold requires prior knowledge or heuristic methods

Future Directions

1. Adaptive Truncation: Develop adaptive truncation methods based on statistical confidence intervals, balancing signal preservation with flatness construction
2. Median Research: Extend theory to Fréchet medians of persistence diagrams, requiring study of geometric properties of $(S_1, W_1)$ space
3. Generalized c-Fréchet Means: Investigate application of more general c-Fréchet mean theory in persistence diagram spaces

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First complete geometric solution to the uniqueness problem for persistence diagram Fréchet means
2. Mathematical Rigor: Complete and rigorous proofs, detailed variance expression derivations, clear geometric intuition
3. Practical Value: Truncation method provides theoretically-grounded approximation algorithms for large-scale persistent homology analysis
4. Interdisciplinary Integration: Successfully combines theoretical tools from topological data analysis, metric geometry, and statistics

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Flat grouping conditions are relatively restrictive, potentially difficult to satisfy in real data
2. Simplified Truncation Strategy: Current truncation methods are relatively crude, potentially requiring more refined signal preservation strategies
3. Computational Complexity: Paper lacks detailed analysis of computational complexity for flatness verification and truncation parameter selection

Impact

1. Theoretical Impact: Establishes important foundation for persistent homology statistics theory, expected to advance related theoretical developments
2. Application Prospects: Provides theoretically-guaranteed methods for large-scale topological data analysis with broad application potential
3. Methodological Contribution: The research paradigm combining geometric conditions with statistical properties is generalizable to other metric spaces

Applicable Scenarios

1. Manifold Learning: Suitable for topological feature extraction and analysis from manifold-sampled data
2. Time-Series Topological Analysis: Applicable to statistical modeling of time-varying topological structures
3. Large-Scale Topological Computation: Provides theoretical guidance for persistent homology approximation under limited computational resources

References

1. Turner, K., Mileyko, Y., Mukherjee, S., & Harer, J. (2014). Fréchet means for distributions of persistence diagrams. Discrete & Computational Geometry, 52(1), 44-70.
2. Le Gouic, T., Paris, Q., Rigollet, P., & Stromme, A. J. (2022). Fast convergence of empirical barycenters in alexandrov spaces and the wasserstein space. Journal of the European Mathematical Society, 25(6), 2229-2250.
3. Mileyko, Y., Mukherjee, S., & Harer, J. (2011). Probability measures on the space of persistence diagrams. Inverse Problems, 27(12), 124007.
4. Munch, E., Turner, K., Bendich, P., Mukherjee, S., Mattingly, J., & Harer, J. (2015). Probabilistic Fréchet means for time varying persistence diagrams. Electronic Journal of Statistics, 9(1), 1173-1204.

Note: This paper represents an important theoretical contribution at the intersection of topological data analysis and metric geometry, providing a solid mathematical foundation for statistical applications of persistent homology. The flat grouping concept and corresponding theoretical framework proposed herein are expected to have profound impact on the field.