Stability in Bondy's theorem on paths and cycles

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2207.13650
• Title: Stability in Bondy's theorem on paths and cycles
• Authors: Bo Ning (Nankai University), Long-Tu Yuan (East China Normal University)
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Timeline: Submitted July 2022, Revised December 2023
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.13650

Abstract

This paper investigates stability results for the celebrated Bondy's theorem. The authors prove that for any 2-connected non-Hamiltonian graph, if all but at most one vertex have degree at least k, then the graph contains a cycle of length at least 2k+2, except for certain special graph families. This result implies multiple classical theorems, including the profound result of Voss. The authors note that their stability result for Bondy's theorem directly provides an affirmative answer to a question: whether there exists a polynomial-time algorithm to determine if a 2-connected graph G on n vertices contains a cycle of length at least min{2δ(G)+2,n}.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: This paper investigates the relationship between cycle length and minimum degree in graphs, particularly the existence of long cycles in "almost regular" graphs (where all but one vertex have the same degree).
2. Significance:
   • This problem is central to extremal graph theory and closely related to Hamiltonian cycle theory
   • It has important applications in spectral graph theory and generalized Turán problems
   • It provides theoretical foundations for algorithmic graph theory
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Dirac's theorem requires all vertices to have sufficiently large degree
   • While Bondy's theorem relaxes this condition, it lacks stability analysis
   • There is an absence of complete characterization of extremal graph structures
4. Research Motivation:
   • Inspired by stability results in extremal graph theory
   • Addressing the algorithmic problem posed by Fomin et al.
   • Determining the extremal graph structure for odd wheels

Core Contributions

1. Main Theorem: Proves a stability version of Bondy's theorem (Theorem 1.6), completely characterizing the extremal graph structures with bounded cycle length under given degree conditions
2. Algorithmic Application: Provides a polynomial-time algorithm to determine whether a 2-connected graph contains a cycle of length at least min{2δ(G)+2,n}
3. Theoretical Unification: Unifies multiple classical results (Ali-Staton theorem, Nikiforov-Yuan theorem, etc.) under a single framework
4. Extremal Graph Characterization: Completely determines the extremal graph structure for odd wheels W₂ₖ₊₃
5. Methodological Innovation: Employs "path vine" techniques, differing from traditional extremal graph theory methods

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Input: 2-connected non-Hamiltonian n-vertex graph G, where all but at most one vertex have degree at least k≥2 Output: Determine whether G contains a cycle of length at least 2k+2; if not, characterize the structure of G Constraint: The girth c(G)≤2k+1

Core Technical Methods

1. Path Vine Technique

• Select a maximum path P = x₁x₂...xₘ such that the number of vertices with degree less than k is minimized
• Utilize the 2-connectivity of the graph to construct connections between paths
• Determine the graph structure through neighborhood analysis

2. Case Analysis Framework

The proof is divided into two main cases:

Case 1: Existence of vertex pairs (i,j) satisfying specific conditions

• Subcase 1.1: Each maximum path contains at most one such vertex pair
• Subcase 1.2: There exist at least two such vertex pairs

Case 2: Case 1 does not occur, but there exists a vertex simultaneously in the neighborhoods of x₁ and xₘ

3. Key Lemmas

Lemma 2.3: For a 2-connected graph G and vertices u,v, if the longest (u,v)-path contains at most k+1 vertices, and all vertices except u,v and at most one other vertex have degree at least k, then G-{u,v} = ℓKₖ₋₁∪K₁ or G-{u,v} = ℓKₖ₋₁.

Technical Innovations

1. Precise Handling of Degree Conditions: Skillfully manages the condition of "at most one exceptional vertex," which is more refined than traditional minimum degree conditions
2. Structure Decomposition Method: Decomposes complex graph structures into manageable components through path selection and neighborhood analysis
3. Complete Classification of Extremal Graphs: Not only proves lower bounds on cycle length but also completely characterizes extremal graphs achieving these bounds

Experimental Setup

This is a pure theoretical mathematics paper with no experimental verification. All results are obtained through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Theoretical Verification Methods

• Constructive proof: Verifies that each class of extremal graphs indeed satisfies the conditions
• Proof by contradiction: Assumes other structures exist and derives contradictions
• Inductive analysis: Handles different parameter values separately

Main Results

Theorem 1.6 (Main Result)

Let G be a 2-connected non-Hamiltonian n-vertex graph with c(G)≤2k+1. If all but at most one vertex have degree at least k≥2, then G is a subgraph of one of the following graphs:

1. H-type graphs: H(2k+1,2k+1,k) and H(n,2k+2,k) (n≥2k+2)
2. F-type graphs: F(s,t,k) (s≥1,t≥1) and F₁(t,k) (t≥1)
3. Special small graphs:
   • K₂+Mₜ (t≥6)
   • K₂+(Sₛ∪Mₜ) (s+t≥6, when k=3)
   • K₃+Mₜ (t≥7, when k=4)

Corollaries and Applications

Theorem 3.3 (Path Version)

For connected graphs, provides a complete characterization of graphs not containing paths of length min{n,2k+3}.

Theorem 3.5 (Extremal Graph Application)

Proves that extremal graphs for {Sₖ₊₂,P₂ₖ₊₁}-free graphs consist of connected components of order at most 2k.

Algorithmic Result

Provides an O(kn) time complexity algorithm to determine whether a graph contains a cycle of length at least 2k+2.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Dirac's Theorem (1952): δ(G)≥n/2 ⟹ G has a Hamiltonian cycle
2. Bondy's Theorem (1971): Relaxes to "at most one exceptional vertex"
3. Voss's Theorem (1991): Improves lower bounds and characterizes extremal graphs
4. This Paper: Complete stability analysis

Connections to Related Fields

• Spectral Graph Theory: Related to spectral radius research by Nikiforov-Yuan et al.
• Turán Theory: Connections to generalized Turán problems
• Algorithmic Graph Theory: Provides theoretical foundation for algorithmic research by Fomin et al.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Completely resolves the stability problem for Bondy's theorem, providing precise characterization of all extremal graphs
2. Unifies multiple classical results, demonstrating the internal connections of the theory
3. Provides effective solutions to related algorithmic problems

Limitations

1. Parameter Restrictions: Requires k≥2; small parameter cases need special treatment
2. 2-Connectivity Assumption: The method heavily depends on the 2-connectivity of the graph
3. Non-Constructive Nature: While an algorithm is provided, the main results are existence theorems

Future Directions

1. Generalization to Broader Graph Classes: Investigate non-2-connected graphs
2. Parameter Optimization: Further improve degree conditions or cycle length lower bounds
3. Algorithm Improvement: Develop more efficient decision algorithms
4. Application Extension: Apply stability methods to other graph theory problems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Completely resolves a difficult extremal graph theory problem with high technical requirements
2. Methodological Innovation: The application of "path vine" technique demonstrates novel proof strategies
3. Result Completeness: Provides not only the main theorem but also rich corollaries and applications
4. Cross-disciplinary Impact: Connects extremal graph theory, spectral graph theory, and algorithmic graph theory

Weaknesses

1. Proof Complexity: Case analysis is very tedious; more concise proof methods may exist
2. Readability: Abundant technical details may be unfriendly to non-specialist readers
3. Practical Application: While algorithmic applications exist, practical value is limited

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important stability results for extremal graph theory
2. Methodological Value: Proof techniques may be applicable to similar problems
3. Subsequent Research: Already cited and developed in multiple follow-up papers

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Research in extremal graph theory and structural graph theory
2. Algorithm Design: Theoretical foundation for long cycle detection algorithms in graphs
3. Spectral Graph Theory: Serves as a complementary tool to spectral methods

References

The paper cites 28 important references, covering:

• Classical results: Foundational work by Dirac, Bondy, Voss, and others
• Recent developments: Algorithmic research by Fomin et al., stability theory by Füredi et al.
• Related fields: Work in spectral graph theory and Turán theory

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that completely resolves an important extremal graph theory problem. While technically demanding, it makes significant theoretical contributions, employs innovative methods, and achieves comprehensive results. The paper not only advances extremal graph theory but also provides theoretical support for related algorithmic and application problems.