Projection hypothesis in the setting for the quantum Jarzynski equality

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2212.07785
• Title: Projection hypothesis in the setting for the quantum Jarzynski equality
• Author: Eiji Konishi (Graduate School of Human and Environmental Studies, Kyoto University)
• Classification: quant-ph cond-mat.stat-mech
• Publication Date: June 21, 2024 (arXiv v8)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.07785

Abstract

Projective quantum measurement is a theoretically accepted process in modern quantum mechanics. However, its projection hypothesis is widely recognized as an experimentally established empirical law. This paper combines two previous theoretical results: first, the Hamiltonian process realization of the projection hypothesis in projective quantum measurement, wherein the complete set of observable trajectories of the center-of-mass of macroscopic quantum mechanical systems is restricted to a set of mutually commuting classical observables; second, the result concerning the work required for event readout (i.e., the information process in projective quantum measurement). Subsequently, a quantum thermodynamic scheme is proposed to simultaneously experimentally verify these two independent theoretical results of projective quantum measurement.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The core problem addressed by this paper is the physical realization mechanism of the projection hypothesis. The projection hypothesis is central to quantum measurement theory, describing how a quantum system collapses from a superposition state to a specific eigenstate after measurement. However, it has long been regarded as an empirical law lacking theoretical derivation from first principles.

Problem Significance

1. Theoretical Completeness: The projection hypothesis is one of the fundamental postulates of quantum mechanics. Clarifying its physical mechanism is crucial for the foundational theory of quantum mechanics.
2. Experimental Verification Requirements: Existing understanding of the projection hypothesis is primarily based on experimental observations, lacking systematic theoretical predictions and experimental verification schemes.
3. Development of Quantum Thermodynamics: Energetic analysis of quantum measurement processes has important value for the development of quantum thermodynamics and quantum information theory.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Black-box Treatment: Existing quantum thermodynamic theories treat the projection hypothesis as a black box, without considering its intrinsic physical mechanism.
2. Lack of Unified Framework: The Hamiltonian realization of the projection hypothesis and the analysis of measurement power consumption lack a unified theoretical framework.
3. Experimental Verification Difficulties: Lack of operational experimental schemes to simultaneously verify theoretical predictions of the projection hypothesis.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Integration: Unified integration of the author's previous results on the Hamiltonian realization of the projection hypothesis (Ref. 6) with results on the work required for event readout (Ref. 10).
2. Quantum Thermodynamic Scheme: Proposed an experimental scheme based on the quantum Jarzynski equality that can simultaneously verify two independent theoretical results.
3. Entropy Production Mechanism: Precisely elucidated the physical origin of σ = 1 nat entropy production during the event readout process.
4. Classical Nature of Work: Clarified the classical nature of work required for event readout within the quantum mechanics framework.
5. Experimental Platform Design: Proposed a Bose-Einstein condensate with superradiant phase transition as an experimental implementation platform.

Detailed Methodology

System Definition

The paper considers four systems divided into two groups:

• Measured System Group (S₀, A')ₛ:
  • S₀: The measured system with discrete observable Ô
  • A': Macroscopic measurement apparatus
• Measurement System Group (ψ, A)ₘ:
  • ψ: Quantum mechanical system with discrete meter variable M̂ (event readout system)
  • A: Spatiotemporally inhomogeneous macroscopic BEC with spontaneously broken spatial translation symmetry

Orbital Superselection Rules

For macroscopic quantum mechanical systems, canonical variables are redefined to make them mutually commuting:

Before Redefinition: Q̂ᵃ, P̂ᵇ = iℏδᵃᵇ

After Redefinition: Q̂ₐ, P̂ᵦ = 0

This redefinition restricts the complete set of orbital observables to a set of mutually commuting classical observables, termed orbital superselection rules.

von Neumann-type Interaction

Define the von Neumann-type interaction Hamiltonian:

Ĥᵥ.ₙ. = -ΛÔ ⊗ P̂ˣ

where Λ is a positive constant and P̂ˣ is the total momentum variable of apparatus A in the x-direction.

Event Readout Power Consumption Mechanism

The event readout process requires entropy production σ = 1 nat, corresponding to power consumption:

Wₑ.ᵣ. = kᵦTσ = kᵦT (σ = 1)

Quantum Thermodynamic Scheme

Five-step Experimental Protocol

The quantum thermodynamic scheme proposed in the paper comprises five sequential steps:

(I) Initial State Preparation: Preparation of the initial quantum state of the entire system, where the combined measured system S is in thermal equilibrium at temperature T.

(II) Coherent State Preparation: Using the time-dependent Hamiltonian of S₀ to prepare a coherent pure state with respect to the discrete observable Ô.

(III) Non-selective Measurement: Non-selective measurement of the discrete observable Ô of S₀ through A'.

(IV) Entanglement Process: Quantum state entanglement process between systems S and M in the eigenbasis of Ô and M̂.

(V) Event Readout: Event readout of M̂ through the dominant von Neumann-type interaction between ψ and A.

Modified Quantum Jarzynski Equality

Original quantum Jarzynski equality: exp(-βW) = exp(-βΔFₑq)

Modified quantum Jarzynski equality: exp(-βW + 3σ) = exp(-βΔFₑq)

Derived thermodynamic inequality: W ≥ ΔFₑq + 3kᵦT

where the additional 3kᵦT term arises from three 1 nat entropy productions: two from the experimenter's energy event readout and one from the O event readout of system M.

Physical Origin of Entropy Production

Direct Description vs. Statistical Description

The paper distinguishes between two descriptions of entropy production:

Direct Description: -dρ/dt = δ(t) Solution: ρ = 1 - θ(t)

Statistical Description: -dρ/dt = δ(t)ρ Solution: ρ = exp(-θ(t))

The self-similar relaxation in the statistical description implies entropy production of σ = 1 nat in the expanded ensemble.

Information-theoretic Origin

The classical single-shot work required for event readout has an information-theoretic origin:

Wₑ.ᵣ. = kᵦTS(ρ̂ₘ||ρ̂ₘ) = -kᵦTS(ρ̂ₛ||ρ̂ₛ)

where the generalized relative von Neumann entropy is: S(ρ̂ₘ||ρ̂ₘ) = 1, S(ρ̂ₛ||ρ̂ₛ) = -1

Experimental Platform Design

Double-slit Experiment Scheme

The paper proposes a double-slit type experiment to measure the event readout work Wₑ.ᵣ.:

• Place system M interacting with system S at slit s₁
• The classical states of system S at s₁ and s₂ are excited state (σ=1) and ground state (σ=0), respectively
• Determine the magnitude of Wₑ.ᵣ. through the temporal interference pattern of the two wave functions on the screen

BEC Implementation Platform

Recommends using photon condensate from equilibrated superradiant phase transition in cavity QED as system A:

• Utilize the spontaneously created non-zero static classical electromagnetic field
• Circumvent the no-go theorem of superradiant phase transition by removing the spatial uniformity assumption of quantum electromagnetic field in the cavity
• Implement phase transition based on magnetostatic instability

Theoretical Innovations

Unified Framework

1. Multi-system Coordination: First incorporates the projective measurement process of four-system coordination into a unified Hamiltonian framework.
2. Information-energy Conversion: Establishes quantitative relationships between information acquisition and energy dissipation in quantum measurement.
3. Quantum-classical Interface: Elucidates the emergence mechanism of classical properties in quantum measurement processes.

Methodological Contributions

1. Orbital Superselection Rules: Provides systematic theoretical treatment for classicalization of macroscopic quantum systems.
2. Expanded Ensemble Description: Reveals the self-similar nature of entropy production in quantum measurement through statistical description.
3. Extension of Quantum Thermodynamics: Extends the quantum Jarzynski equality to include measurement processes.

Related Work Analysis

Quantum Measurement Theory

• von Neumann Theory: Inherits and develops the theoretical framework of von Neumann's quantum measurement theory.
• Decoherence Theory: Forms complementary relationship with Zurek's environment-induced decoherence theory.
• Macroscopic Quantum Theory: Based on Araki's continuous superselection rules theory.

Quantum Thermodynamics

• Information Thermodynamics: Extends Sagawa-Ueda's quantum information thermodynamics theory.
• Fluctuation Theorems: Develops applications of Jarzynski equality in quantum measurement.
• Quantum Work Definition: Deepens operational definitions of work and heat in quantum thermodynamics.

Limitations Analysis

Theoretical Limitations

1. System Complexity: The four-system coordination scheme has relatively high technical difficulty for experimental implementation.
2. Approximation Conditions: The validity of orbital superselection rules depends on the macroscopic nature assumption of the system.
3. Interaction Strength: von Neumann-type interaction requires sufficient strength to neglect free Hamiltonian terms.

Experimental Challenges

1. BEC Preparation: Preparation and control techniques for spatiotemporally inhomogeneous BEC are not yet mature.
2. Superradiant Phase Transition: The theoretically predicted superradiant phase transition has not yet been experimentally confirmed.
3. Measurement Precision: The additional 3kᵦT work requires high-precision energy measurement techniques.

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Derives the projection hypothesis from first principles, possessing important foundational theoretical value.
2. Methodological Innovation: Orbital superselection rules and expanded ensemble description provide new theoretical tools.
3. Experimental Feasibility: Proposes concrete experimental verification schemes, enhancing the testability of the theory.
4. Interdisciplinary Integration: Organically combines quantum mechanics foundations, quantum thermodynamics, and quantum field theory.

Weaknesses

1. High Experimental Threshold: Required experimental conditions and technical level are high, making implementation difficult in the short term.
2. Multiple Theoretical Assumptions: Multiple approximation conditions and idealized assumptions may affect the universality of results.
3. Lack of Numerical Verification: Lacks concrete numerical calculations and simulation verification.

Impact Assessment

1. Foundational Theory Contribution: Provides new theoretical framework and physical picture for quantum measurement theory.
2. Application Prospects: May promote development of quantum thermodynamics and quantum information technology.
3. Experimental Guidance Value: Provides theoretical guidance for future quantum measurement experiments.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Foundational quantum mechanics research and exploration of quantum measurement mechanisms.
2. Quantum Technology: Optimization of measurement processes in quantum computing and quantum communication.
3. Precision Measurement: Development of high-precision quantum sensing and metrology techniques.

Conclusions and Prospects

Through a unified quantum thermodynamic framework, this paper provides the first complete theoretical description of the physical realization mechanism of the projection hypothesis and proposes an operational experimental verification scheme. Although experimental implementation faces technical challenges, this work provides important theoretical foundation for the development of quantum measurement theory and is significant for deeply understanding the physical mechanisms of the quantum-classical interface.

Future research directions may include:

1. Simplifying experimental schemes to reduce technical implementation difficulty.
2. Developing numerical simulation methods to verify theoretical predictions.
3. Exploring similar phenomena in other physical systems.
4. Investigating quantum advantages and resource theory of measurement processes.

References

This paper cites 52 relevant references, covering multiple research fields including quantum measurement theory, quantum thermodynamics, Bose-Einstein condensation, and superradiant phase transitions, reflecting the interdisciplinary characteristics and theoretical depth of the work.