2025-11-19T23:52:14.372101

Logarithmic spirals in 2d perfect fluids

Jeong, Said
We study logarithmic spiraling solutions to the 2d incompressible Euler equations which solve a nonlinear transport system on $\mathbb{S}$. We show that this system is locally well-posed in $L^p, p\geq 1$ as well as for atomic measures, that is logarithmic spiral vortex sheets. In particular, we realize the dynamics of logarithmic vortex sheets as the well-defined limit of logarithmic solutions which could be smooth in the angle. Furthermore, our formulation not only allows for a simple proof of existence and bifurcation for non-symmetric multi branched logarithmic spiral vortex sheets but also provides a framework for studying asymptotic stability of self-similar dynamics. We give a complete characterization of the long time behavior of logarithmic spirals. We prove global well-posedness for bounded logarithmic spirals as well as data that admit at most logarithmic singularities. This is due to the observation that the local circulation of the vorticity around the origin is a strictly monotone quantity of time. We are then able to show a dichotomy in the long time behavior, solutions either blow up (either in finite or infinite time) or completely homogenize. In particular, bounded logarithmic spirals should converge to constant steady states. For logarithmic spiral sheets, the dichotomy is shown to be even more drastic where only finite time blow up or complete homogenization of the fluid can and does occur.
academic

Logarithmic Spirals in 2D Perfect Fluids

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2302.09447
  • Title: Logarithmic spirals in 2d perfect fluids
  • Authors: In-Jee Jeong (Seoul National University), Ayman R. Said (Duke University)
  • Classification: math.AP (Mathematical Analysis)
  • Publication Date: May 31, 2024
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09447

Abstract

This paper investigates logarithmic spiral solutions to the two-dimensional incompressible Euler equations, which satisfy a nonlinear transport system on the circle S\mathbb{S}. The authors establish local well-posedness of this system in LpL^p spaces (p≥1p\geq 1) and for atomic measures (logarithmic spiral vortex sheets). By realizing logarithmic vortex sheet dynamics as a well-defined limit of smooth solutions, the paper provides a framework for studying the existence of asymmetric multi-branched logarithmic spiral vortex sheets, bifurcation phenomena, and asymptotic stability of self-similar dynamics. Based on strict monotonicity of local circulation, the authors completely characterize the long-time behavior of logarithmic spirals, prove global well-posedness for bounded logarithmic spirals, and reveal a dichotomy in solution behavior: either finite-time or infinite-time blow-up, or complete homogenization.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

  1. Physical Phenomena: Logarithmic spirals frequently appear in turbulent jets and mixing layers, particularly at relatively high Reynolds numbers. While applied literature typically models these using algebraic spirals, Prandtl first suggested in 1922 that logarithmic curves might be better contours for these structures.
  2. Mathematical Challenges: Mathematical treatment of logarithmic spiral vortex sheets is extremely difficult. The classical Birkhoff-Rott formula cannot be directly applied; special cancellation mechanisms are required to verify that these formulas indeed yield weak solutions to the Euler equations.
  3. Theoretical Gaps: Existing research primarily focuses on specific symmetric cases (such as Elling-Gnann's m-fold symmetric case, m≥3) or the recent general case of Cieślak-Kokocki-Ożański, but lacks a unified theoretical framework.

Research Motivation

  1. Unified Framework: Provide a unified PDE approach to handle all previously considered cases, making the mathematical treatment more concise.
  2. Long-Time Behavior: Understanding the long-time behavior of solutions to 2D Euler equations is an important open problem in fluid mechanics. Logarithmic spirals provide a special class that can be completely analyzed.
  3. Singularity Formation: Study the singularity formation mechanisms of vortex sheets, which is important for understanding the nature of turbulence.

Core Contributions

  1. Established a Complete Well-Posedness Theory:
    • Local well-posedness in LpL^p spaces (p≥1p\geq 1)
    • Global well-posedness for bounded data and logarithmic singular data
    • Well-posedness for atomic measures (logarithmic spiral vortex sheets)
  2. Discovered Key Monotone Quantities:
    • Strict monotonicity of local circulation Γ(R)=R22∫h(t,θ)dθ\Gamma(R) = \frac{R^2}{2}\int h(t,\theta)d\theta
    • This represents a fundamental distinction from the 0-homogeneous vorticity case
  3. Completely Characterized Long-Time Behavior:
    • Bounded solutions converge to constant steady states
    • Trichotomy for LpL^p data: global existence and convergence, finite-time blow-up, or infinite-time blow-up
    • Dichotomy for Dirac measure data: finite-time blow-up or complete homogenization
  4. Provided a Unified Theoretical Framework:
    • Simplified proofs of existence and bifurcation for asymmetric multi-branched logarithmic spiral vortex sheets
    • Provided a framework for studying asymptotic stability of self-similar dynamics

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Study the two-dimensional incompressible Euler equations with logarithmic spiral symmetry:

\partial_t\omega + u \cdot \nabla\omega = 0 \\ u = \nabla^{\perp}\Delta^{-1}\omega \end{cases}$$ where the vorticity $\omega$ is invariant under the transformation $(r,\theta) \mapsto (\lambda r, \theta + \beta\ln\lambda)$, i.e.: $$\omega(t,r,\theta) = h(t, \theta - \beta\ln r)$$ ### Model Architecture #### Dimension Reduction Through logarithmic spiral symmetry, the 2D PDE system reduces to a one-dimensional transport equation: $$\partial_t h + 2H\partial_\theta h = 0$$ coupled with an elliptic problem: $$4H - 4\beta\partial_\theta H + (1+\beta^2)\partial_\theta^2 H = h$$ defined on $S = \mathbb{R}/(2\pi\mathbb{Z})$. #### Stream Function Ansatz $$\Psi(t,r,\theta) = r^2 H(t, \theta - \beta\ln r)$$ corresponding velocity field: $$\begin{cases} u^r = -r\partial_\theta H(t, \theta - \beta\ln r) \\ u^\theta = 2rH(t, \theta - \beta\ln r) - \beta r\partial_\theta H(t, \theta - \beta\ln r) \end{cases}$$ #### Kernel Function Method The solution to the elliptic equation is represented as $H = K * h$, where the kernel $K$ satisfies: $$4K - 4\beta K' + (1+\beta^2)K'' = 0$$ with boundary conditions: $K(0) = K(2\pi)$, $K'(2\pi) - K'(0) = \frac{1}{1+\beta^2}$ ### Technical Innovations 1. **Discovery of Monotone Quantity**: $$\frac{d}{dt}\int h d\theta = -8\beta\int (H')^2 d\theta$$ This strict monotonicity is key to analyzing long-time behavior. 2. **Limiting Process for Vortex Sheets**: Realize vortex sheets as well-defined limits of smooth solutions, avoiding direct treatment of singular integrals. 3. **Unified Bifurcation Analysis**: Through analysis of the ODE system (1.8), uniformly handle bifurcation phenomena in both symmetric and asymmetric cases. ## Experimental Setup ### Theoretical Verification This is primarily theoretical research, with results verified through rigorous mathematical proofs: 1. **Well-Posedness Proofs**: Using mollification methods and Aubin-Lions lemma 2. **Long-Time Behavior Analysis**: Based on monotone quantities and energy methods 3. **Convergence Proofs**: Through measure convergence and distribution theory ### Specific Case Analysis #### m-Fold Symmetric Dirac Delta Consider $h(t,\cdot) = I_0(t)\sum_{j=0}^{m-1}\delta_{\theta_j(t)}$, where $\theta_j(t) = \theta_0(t) + 2\pi j/m$. The system simplifies to: $$\frac{d}{dt}\theta_0(t) = 2K^m(0)I_0(t)$$ $$\frac{d}{dt}I_0(t) = 2(K^m)'(0)(I_0(t))^2$$ Solution: $I_0(t) = \frac{I_0(0)}{1-2(K^m)'(0)I_0(0)t}$ #### Two Asymmetric Dirac Deltas Self-similar solutions must satisfy the algebraic equation: $$K(0)(K'(-d)-K'(d)) + K(d)(K'(0)-K'(-d)) + K(-d)(K'(d)-K'(0)) = 0$$ ## Experimental Results ### Main Theoretical Results #### Well-Posedness Results - **Theorem 1.1**: Local well-posedness in $L^p$ ($1\leq p \leq \infty$) - **Theorem 1.3**: Global well-posedness for data satisfying $\sup_{p\geq 1}\frac{\|h_0\|_{L^p}}{p} < +\infty$ - **Theorem 1.5**: Well-posedness for logarithmic spiral vortex sheets #### Long-Time Behavior - **Theorem 1.8**: Bounded data converges to constant steady states - **Theorem 1.10**: Trichotomy for $L^p$ data - **Theorem 1.11**: Singularity formation criteria for Dirac measure data ### Bifurcation Analysis Results For the two-Dirac-delta case: - As $\beta \to 0$, there exists a unique asymmetric bifurcation converging to $d = \pi/2$ - For sufficiently large $\beta$, no asymmetric solutions exist - There exists a critical value $\beta_b$ producing bifurcation phenomena ## Related Work ### Historical Development 1. **Prandtl (1922)**: First introduced the concept of logarithmic spiral vortex sheets 2. **Alexander (1971)**: Introduced multi-branched symmetric spirals 3. **Elling-Gnann**: Mathematical proofs for m-fold symmetric cases (m≥3) 4. **Cieślak-Kokocki-Ożański**: Recent progress on the general case ### Related Theories 1. **0-Homogeneous Vorticity Theory**: The case $\beta=0$, requiring m-fold symmetry for well-posedness 2. **Yudovich Theory**: Classical well-posedness theory for 2D Euler equations 3. **Point Vortex Systems**: Dynamics theory for discrete vortex points ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. Established a complete mathematical theory for logarithmic spiral solutions 2. Discovered the monotonicity of local circulation as a key property 3. Completely characterized long-time behavior for various initial data 4. Provided a unified framework for handling symmetric and asymmetric cases ### Limitations 1. **Spatial Decay**: Logarithmic spiral solutions do not decay at spatial infinity, falling outside the standard $L^1 \cap L^\infty$ well-posedness class 2. **Physical Realization**: Requires truncation procedures for realization in finite-energy solutions 3. **Stability Analysis**: While providing a framework, complete stability analysis requires further research ### Future Directions 1. **Viscous Limit**: Study convergence of Navier-Stokes solutions to logarithmic spiral vortex sheets 2. **Stability Theory**: Deeper investigation of stability of logarithmic spirals in 2D Euler equations 3. **Numerical Verification**: Numerical simulations to verify theoretical predictions, particularly bifurcation phenomena ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Mathematical Rigor**: Provides a complete theoretical framework with rigorous proofs for all results 2. **Unification**: Unifies previously scattered results within a single theoretical system 3. **Innovation**: Discovers the monotonicity of local circulation as a key property 4. **Completeness**: Complete analysis from well-posedness to long-time behavior ### Weaknesses 1. **Application Limitations**: Primarily theoretical results; connections to actual fluid phenomena require further development 2. **Technical Complexity**: Some proof techniques are quite complex, potentially limiting generalizability 3. **Absence of Numerical Verification**: Lacks numerical experiments to verify theoretical predictions ### Impact 1. **Theoretical Contribution**: Provides a new paradigm for studying long-time behavior of 2D Euler equations 2. **Methodological Value**: PDE dimension-reduction methods may apply to other symmetry problems 3. **Future Research**: Establishes solid foundations for further research in related fields ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical Fluid Mechanics**: Provides mathematical tools for understanding vortex dynamics 2. **Partial Differential Equations Theory**: Serves as a typical example of nonlinear transport equations 3. **Applied Mathematics**: Provides methods for studying dynamical systems with special symmetries ## References This paper cites 34 important references spanning from Prandtl's pioneering work to the latest theoretical advances, particularly: - Prandtl (1922): Physical concept of logarithmic spirals - Yudovich (1963): Classical theory of 2D Euler equations - Bedrossian & Masmoudi (2015): Pioneering work on long-time behavior - Cieślak, Kokocki & Ożański (2022-2024): Recent progress on logarithmic spiral vortex sheets --- This paper represents significant progress in the theory of 2D incompressible Euler equations. By introducing logarithmic spiral symmetry, it not only solves a mathematically well-posed problem with physical background but also provides new theoretical tools for understanding more general fluid dynamics phenomena.