Comment on paper: Evidence for Dirac flat band superconductivity enabled by quantum geometry, Nature 614, 440 (2023)

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2303.06054
• Title: Comment on paper: Evidence for Dirac flat band superconductivity enabled by quantum geometry, Nature 614, 440 (2023)
• Authors: V. R. Shaginyan, A. Z. Msezane, G. S. Japaridze
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con (Superconductivity), cond-mat.str-el (Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Publication Date: March 2023 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.06054

Abstract

This paper is a commentary on the Nature journal publication regarding Dirac flat band superconductivity in twisted bilayer graphene. The authors argue that absolute flat bands persist in the superconducting state only as $T_c \to 0$, whereas when $T_c > 0$, the flat band disappears because it must be corrected by the superconducting state. Consequently, many results concerning strong-coupling superconductivity in flat bands discussed in the Nature article were predicted and explained years earlier. The authors emphasize that the distortion of flat bands at $T_c > 0$ must be considered, whereby the bands become tilted and the carrier velocity becomes finite as $v_F \propto T_c$, contrary to the "extremely slow" velocity claimed in the Nature article.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

This paper raises academic questions regarding the research on Dirac flat band superconductivity in twisted bilayer graphene (tBLG) published in Nature 614, 440 (2023). The original article claims that in flat band superconductors, the group velocity of carriers $v_F$ is extremely slow and suggests that superconductivity based on flat bands has not been sufficiently studied.

Research Motivation

1. Correcting conceptual misconceptions: The Nature article contains conceptual errors in describing carrier velocity in flat band superconductors
2. Clarifying historical contributions: Theoretical predictions and analyses of flat band superconductivity actually began approximately 30 years ago
3. Providing correct theoretical framework: Offering more accurate explanations based on topological fermion condensation quantum phase transition theory

Limitations of Current Understanding

The main issues with the Nature article are:

• Incorrectly assuming that $v_F$ remains extremely slow in flat band superconductors
• Neglecting the interaction between flat bands and the superconducting state
• Failing to consider flat band distortion under finite $T_c$ conditions

Core Contributions

1. Clarifying flat band-superconducting state relationship: Demonstrating that absolute flat bands exist only when $T_c \to 0$, with finite $T_c$ causing flat band disappearance and distortion
2. Establishing correct scaling relationships: Revealing the relationship $T_c \propto v_F \propto 1/N_s$, where $N_s$ is the density of states at the Fermi level
3. Providing historical theoretical foundation: Demonstrating 30 years of theoretical development in flat band superconductivity and existing theoretical predictions
4. Correcting conceptual errors: Pointing out that carrier velocity under finite $T_c$ conditions is not "extremely slow" but rather proportional to $T_c$

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

This paper is based on topological fermion condensation quantum phase transition theory, which predicts:

1. Flat band formation mechanism: Flat band emergence through topological fermion condensation quantum phase transitions
2. Superconducting coupling: Superconducting gap $\Delta \propto g$, where $g$ is the superconducting coupling constant
3. Flat band-superconducting state coupling: Flat bands must be coordinated with the superconducting state, resulting in mutual modulation

Key Physical Picture

Absolute Flat Band Conditions

• When the coupling constant $g$ is finite, $T_c$ becomes finite
• The flat band disappears because it must be modulated by the superconducting state
• The flat band becomes slightly tilted with rounded endpoints

Velocity-Temperature Relationship

Experimental measurements reveal the critical relationship: $T_c \propto v_F \propto \frac{1}{N_s}$

This contrasts with conventional superconductivity theory expectations: $T_c \propto \frac{1}{v_F} \propto N_s$

Technical Innovations

1. Unified theoretical description: Incorporating heavy fermion metals, high-temperature superconductors, and strongly correlated Fermi systems into a unified framework
2. Topological phase transition mechanism: Providing microscopic mechanisms for flat band formation based on topological fermion condensation
3. Experimental verification: Validating theory through experimental data from magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene and $\text{Bi}_2\text{Sr}_2\text{CaCu}_2\text{O}_{8+x}$

Experimental Evidence

Magic-Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene

• Measurements of Fermi velocity $v_F$ as a function of $T_c$ confirm the $T_c \propto v_F$ relationship
• Observation of flat band distortion and tilting at finite $T_c$

High-Temperature Superconductor Comparison

• $\text{Bi}_2\text{Sr}_2\text{CaCu}_2\text{O}_{8+x}$ exhibits similar behavior
• Challenges the conventional high-temperature superconductivity theory relationship $T_c \propto 1/v_F$

Experimental Verification of Theoretical Predictions

• Rounding phenomenon at flat band endpoints 10
• Thermodynamic, transport, and relaxation properties of strongly correlated Fermi systems

Related Work

Historical Development Timeline

1. Early theoretical foundations (1990-1994):
   • Khodel & Shaginyan (1990): Superfluidity in fermion condensation systems 2
   • Volovik (1991): New type of normal Fermi liquid 3
   • New approaches to microscopic Fermi system theory 4
2. Systematic theoretical development (2000-2020):
   • Systematic studies of scaling behavior in heavy fermion metals 5
   • Monographs on strongly correlated Fermi systems 6
   • Quasiparticle dispersion and linewidth studies 10
3. Recent progress (2020-2023):
   • Quantum geometric effects in twisted multilayer systems 7
   • Superconducting effects of flat band shapes 9
   • Special physics of heavy fermion metals 11

Relationship to the Nature Article

The Nature article overlooks this rich theoretical foundation, incorrectly claiming that flat band superconductivity "has not been sufficiently studied," when in fact related theory has developed over 30 years.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Coexistence conditions for flat bands and superconducting states: Absolute flat bands maintain the superconducting state only when $T_c \to 0$ and $v_F \to 0$
2. Finite temperature effects: When $T_c > 0$, flat bands disappear and become distorted, becoming tilted
3. Correct scaling relationships: $T_c \propto v_F$, contrary to the claim of "extremely slow" carrier velocity
4. Theoretical completeness: Flat band superconductivity possesses a complete theoretical framework and experimental verification

Specific Criticisms of the Nature Article

Conceptual Errors

The Nature article's claim that "carrier group velocity $v_F$ is extremely slow" is incorrect, leading to conceptual misconceptions.

Neglecting Historical Contributions

The article incorrectly implies that flat band superconductivity is a new discovery, overlooking 30 years of theoretical development.

Incomplete Theory

Failing to consider the interaction between flat bands and the superconducting state, as well as flat band distortion under finite $T_c$ conditions.

Limitations

1. Theoretical complexity: Topological fermion condensation theory is relatively complex and requires more experimental verification
2. Material specificity: Specific implementations in different material systems may vary
3. Experimental technical requirements: High-precision experimental techniques are needed to verify theoretical predictions

Future Directions

1. Additional material systems: Verifying theoretical predictions in other flat band materials
2. Quantum geometric effects: Deeper investigation of quantum geometry's role in flat band superconductivity
3. Transport properties: Systematic study of transport and thermodynamic properties in flat band systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Academic rigor: Based on solid theoretical foundations and extensive literature support
2. Conceptual clarity: Accurately identifying conceptual errors in the Nature article
3. Historical completeness: Comprehensive review of the development history of flat band superconductivity theory
4. Experimental support: Providing experimental evidence from multiple material systems

Scientific Value

1. Error correction function: Timely correction of errors in high-impact journal articles
2. Theoretical contribution: Emphasizing the importance of topological fermion condensation theory in understanding flat band superconductivity
3. Guiding significance: Providing correct theoretical frameworks for subsequent research

Shortcomings

1. Critical nature: As a commentary article, primarily critical rather than constructively contributive
2. Theoretical depth: Lacking new theoretical insights, mainly clarifying existing theory
3. Experimental details: Lacking detailed experimental analysis and new experimental suggestions

Impact Assessment

Academic Impact

• Correcting conceptual errors in important journals
• Maintaining historical accuracy in theoretical development
• Providing correct guidance for flat band superconductivity research

Practical Value

• Helping researchers avoid conceptual pitfalls
• Providing theoretical guidance for experimental design
• Promoting correct integration of theory and experiment

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical research: Theoretical modeling of flat band superconductivity
2. Experimental design: Experimental research on flat band materials such as twisted bilayer graphene
3. Teaching reference: Teaching strongly correlated electron systems and unconventional superconductivity
4. Review writing: Reference for review articles on flat band physics and superconductivity

References

This paper cites 12 important references spanning from 1990 to 2023, covering the development of flat band superconductivity theory, particularly:

• 2-4: Foundational works in flat band superconductivity theory
• 5,6,11: Systematic theoretical development and reviews
• 9,10: Theoretical predictions of flat band distortion
• 12: Latest experimental verification work

Summary: This is an important academic commentary that timely corrects conceptual errors regarding flat band superconductivity in a Nature journal article, emphasizing the significance of 30 years of theoretical development in this field, and providing correct theoretical guidance for subsequent research. While primarily critical in nature, its academic value lies in maintaining accuracy and historical completeness in scientific research.