Chaotic interactions between dark matter and dark energy

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2304.06614
• Title: Chaotic interactions between dark matter and dark energy
• Author: E. Aydiner (İstanbul University)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), nlin.CD (Nonlinear Dynamics)
• Publication Timeline: Written in March 2023, revised in March 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06614

Abstract

This research treats dark matter and dark energy as a grand canonical system—an open, non-equilibrium, coupled interactive system. The author proposes for the first time a more realistic interaction scheme to explain the dynamics between coupled interactive thermodynamic systems. Based on this new interaction pattern, new theorems are proposed to define interactions, including mutual interactions and self-interactions. These theorems are proven based on the thermodynamic law of energy conservation. Through numerical solutions of the interaction equations, phase space diagrams and Lyapunov exponents are obtained, demonstrating that the interaction between dark matter and dark energy is chaotic.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Fundamental Cosmological Issues: Dark matter and dark energy constitute approximately 95% of the universe, yet their physical nature and interaction mechanisms remain incompletely understood
2. Limitations of Traditional Methods: Existing interaction models (such as Lotka-Volterra type) may be unable to fully describe the interactions between dark matter and dark energy
3. Missing Theoretical Framework: Lack of an interaction theoretical framework based on rigorous thermodynamic principles

Research Motivation

1. Nonlinear Nature: The universe is inherently nonlinear, and this nonlinearity leads to chaotic dynamics
2. Fractal Geometry: The universe exhibits fractal geometric structure from microscopic to macroscopic scales
3. Theory Refinement: New theories beyond standard methods are needed to reveal deeper physical laws

Significance

• Addressing singularities, cosmic coincidence, Hubble tension and other problems in cosmology
• Providing a new theoretical framework for understanding cosmic evolution
• Potentially revealing new laws in physics

Core Contributions

1. Proposes New Interaction Theory: Establishes a new theoretical framework describing dark matter and dark energy interactions based on the first law of thermodynamics
2. Establishes Two Fundamental Theorems:
   • Theorem 1: Energy conservation equation describing interactions
   • Theorem 2: Evolution equations defining non-holonomic time-varying parameters
3. Proves Chaotic Behavior: Demonstrates through numerical calculations that dark matter-dark energy interactions possess chaotic characteristics
4. Introduces New Physical Concepts: Introduces concepts such as hidden symmetry, vector attractor field, and vector attractor torque
5. Universal Conclusions: Proves that all coupled interactive thermodynamic systems exhibit chaotic dynamics

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Study the interaction dynamics of dark matter and dark energy as open, non-equilibrium, coupled thermodynamic systems, establishing a rigorous theoretical framework based on the law of energy conservation.

Theoretical Framework

Review of Traditional Methods

Traditional continuity equations:

dρ_dm/dt + 3H(ρ_dm + p_dm) = X
dρ_de/dt + 3H(ρ_de + p_de) = -X

where X is the interaction coupling term.

New Interaction Theory

Theorem 1: Interaction Equations

dx₁/dt = Γ₁x₂ - x₁
dx₂/dt = Γ₂x₁ - x₂

where:

• x₁, x₂ represent energy flows between systems
• Γ₁, Γ₂ are time-varying energy transfer rate parameters

Proof Highlights:

1. Based on the first law of thermodynamics: dU = δQ - pδV + μδN
2. For constant volume systems, energy conservation manifests as coupled energy flows
3. The internal energy change of system 1 is determined by system 2, and vice versa

Theorem 2: Self-Interaction Equations

dΓ₁/dt = 1 - x₁x₂
dΓ₂/dt = 1 - x₁x₂

Proof Highlights:

1. Introduces the concept of vector attractor torque: τ⃗ = c(dΓ/dt)ẑ
2. Considers vector fields and torques on self-interaction loops
3. Derives evolution equations for non-holonomic variables through integration

Complete Interaction Equations

Combining both theorems yields the complete three-dimensional dynamical system:

dx₁/dt = x₂x₃ - x₁
dx₂/dt = (x₃ - q)x₁ - x₂
dx₃/dt = 1 - x₁x₂

where q = Γ₁ - Γ₂ is the control parameter.

Technical Innovations

1. Separation of Interaction and Self-Interaction: First distinguishes between inter-system interactions and intra-system self-interactions
2. Introduction of Hidden Variables: Identifies hidden vector fields and symmetries in interactive systems
3. Rigorous Thermodynamic Foundation: Based on energy conservation law rather than arbitrarily chosen interaction terms
4. Vector Field Description: Introduces concepts such as vector attractor fields and torques to describe self-interaction loops

Experimental Setup

Numerical Methods

• Runge-Kutta method implemented in FORTRAN 90
• Linearization algorithm for solving nonlinear coupled equations
• Wolf algorithm for computing Lyapunov exponents

Parameter Settings

• Control parameter q range: 0 < q < 40
• Focused analysis at q = 3.46 for phase space behavior
• Initial conditions chosen to ensure non-intersecting orbits

Analysis Metrics

1. Phase Space Trajectories: Projections on x₁-x₂, x₁-x₃, and x₂-x₃ planes
2. Lyapunov Exponent Spectrum: Three Lyapunov exponents λ₁, λ₂, λ₃ as functions of control parameter q
3. Chaotic Attractors: Attractor structures in three-dimensional phase space

Experimental Results

Main Results

Phase Space Analysis

1. x₁-x₂ Plane (Figure 4): Attractor exists near x₂ = 0, with trajectories extending rightward without self-intersection
2. x₁-x₃ Plane (Figure 5): Attractor center located near x₃ = 0, with trajectories extending in the x₁ direction
3. x₂-x₃ Plane (Figure 6): Attractor located near x₂ = 0-0.5 and x₃ = 1
4. Three-Dimensional Phase Space (Figure 7): Shows complete chaotic attractor structure with non-intersecting trajectories

Lyapunov Exponent Analysis

• Chaotic Region: For q < 25, positive Lyapunov exponents exist, indicating chaotic behavior
• Non-Chaotic Region: For q > 25, Lyapunov exponents fluctuate near zero
• Critical Transition: Transition from chaos to non-chaos occurs at q ≈ 25

Key Findings

1. Universal Chaoticity: Dark matter and dark energy interactions exhibit chaotic behavior within specific parameter ranges
2. Parameter Dependence: Chaotic behavior strongly depends on the control parameter q
3. Physical Significance: When Γ₁ ≫ Γ₂ or Γ₁ ≪ Γ₂, the system may lose chaotic characteristics

Related Work

Traditional Interaction Models

1. Lotka-Volterra Type Models: Chaotic universe theory proposed by the author in 2018
2. Phenomenological Models: Interaction terms in the form X = γρ_dm ρ_de
3. Standard Thermodynamic Methods: Traditional treatment based on continuity equations

Innovations in This Work

1. Theoretical Rigor: Based on the first law of thermodynamics rather than empirical formulas
2. Completeness: Simultaneously considers interactions and self-interactions
3. Universality: Generalizable to all coupled thermodynamic systems

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Chaotic Interactions: Interactions between dark matter and dark energy are inherently chaotic
2. Hidden Symmetries: All coupled interactive systems possess hidden symmetries expressible through self-interaction loops
3. New Physical Laws: Dynamics of all coupled interactive particles and thermodynamic systems are chaotic
4. New Definition of Chaos: Chaos is the minimal action of coupled, synchronized, self-organized interactive systems
5. Self-Organization Nature: All self-organized systems are manifestations of chaotic behavior

Limitations

1. Parameter Determination: Appropriate parameter ranges need to be determined through fitting with the ΛCDM model
2. Cosmological Verification: Requires comparison with observational data (such as scale factor, density parameters, etc.)
3. Experimental Verification: Theoretical predictions need experimental or observational confirmation

Future Directions

1. ΛCDM Compatibility: Study the model's compatibility with standard gravitational theory
2. Cosmological Applications: Analyze effects on different periods of cosmic evolution
3. Fundamental Problems: Explore solutions to singularities, flatness, monopole problems, etc.
4. Experimental Verification: Seek experimental methods to verify theoretical predictions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Theoretical Innovation: First to propose dark matter-dark energy interaction theory based on rigorous thermodynamic principles
2. Mathematical Rigor: All theorems have rigorous proofs based on energy conservation law
3. Conceptual Breakthrough: Introduces new concepts such as self-interaction and hidden symmetry
4. Universal Significance: Conclusions generalizable to all interactive systems
5. Sufficient Numerical Verification: Theory predictions verified through phase space analysis and Lyapunov exponent calculations

Weaknesses

1. Physical Interpretation: Physical meaning of self-interaction loops requires deeper explanation
2. Parameter Physical Meaning: Specific physical meaning and value range of control parameter q need cosmological constraints
3. Missing Observational Verification: Lacks comparison and verification with actual observational data
4. Scope Definition: Applicable conditions and limitations of the theory need clearer specification

Impact

1. Theoretical Physics Contribution: Provides new theoretical framework for interactive system theory
2. Cosmological Significance: May offer new approaches to solving dark matter-dark energy interaction problems
3. Interdisciplinary Value: Important implications for statistical thermodynamics, nonlinear dynamics, and other fields
4. Practical Prospects: Potentially applicable to research on other complex interactive systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Cosmological Research: Theoretical modeling of dark matter-dark energy interactions
2. Statistical Physics: Study of interactions in non-equilibrium thermodynamic systems
3. Complex Systems: Dynamical analysis of biological, social, and other complex networks
4. Nonlinear Dynamics: Research on chaotic behavior in coupled oscillator systems

References

The paper cites 60 related references, primarily including:

• Classical literature on dark matter discovery (Rubin et al.)
• Important works on dark energy discovery (Riess, Perlmutter, et al.)
• Cosmological observational data (WMAP, Planck Collaboration)
• Theoretical research on dark matter-dark energy interactions
• Related work in nonlinear dynamics and chaos theory

This paper proposes an entirely new theoretical framework for understanding the interactions between dark matter and dark energy. While further work is needed in physical interpretation and observational verification, its theoretical innovation and potential impact merit attention.