Generation of Multipartite Entangled States Based on Double-Longitudinal-Mode Cavity Optomechanical System

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2305.09311
• Title: Generation of multipartite entangled states based on double-longitudinal-mode cavity optomechanical system
• Authors: Xiaomin Liu, Rongguo Yang, Jing Zhang, Tiancai Zhang
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: May 17, 2023 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09311

Abstract

Optomechanical systems represent a promising platform for connecting different "nodes" in quantum networks, making the entanglement generated from such systems highly significant. This paper discusses the parameter dependence of optomechanical entanglement and optical-optical entanglement generated in a double-longitudinal-mode cavity optomechanical system, and proposes two schemes for generating four-body entanglement based on this system. Furthermore, by coupling N cavities using N-1 beam splitters, 2N or 4N-body entangled states can be obtained. These schemes demonstrate scalability in increasing the number of entangled parties. The resulting entanglement structures exhibit specific ladder-like or linear configurations, applicable to future quantum computing and quantum networks.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

This research addresses the scalable generation of multipartite entangled states in quantum networks. Specifically:

1. Interconnecting Heterogeneous Quantum Systems: Hybrid quantum networks require establishing entanglement distribution between different physical systems (atoms, ions, quantum dots, superconducting circuits, etc.)
2. Limitations of Multipartite Entanglement: Existing methods generate entanglement between optical/microwave modes with no more than three parties, failing to meet large-scale quantum network requirements
3. Scalability Challenges: Traditional approaches combining optical parametric processes with beam splitters are limited by complex experimental setups and technical difficulties

Research Significance

• Quantum Network Foundation: Multipartite entanglement is a prerequisite for implementing measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) and constructing practical quantum networks
• System Interconnection: Optomechanical systems are considered promising candidates for interconnecting different components in hybrid quantum systems
• Frequency Flexibility: Capability to handle optical and microwave modes at different frequencies, adapting to heterogeneous system requirements

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Party Number Limitation: Previous work on optical/microwave mode entanglement limited to ≤3 parties
2. Experimental Complexity: Traditional methods require sophisticated experimental apparatus
3. Frequency Constraints: Frequency/time multiplexing methods face challenges in distributing entanglement between different physical systems

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Parameter Analysis: In-depth investigation of parameter dependence of optomechanical and optical-optical entanglement in double-longitudinal-mode cavity optomechanical systems, including effects of detuning, cavity decay, mechanical decay, and temperature
2. Two Scalable Schemes: Proposal of four-body entanglement generation schemes based on beam splitter coupling and orthogonal polarization dual-pump configurations
3. Large-Scale Entanglement Extension: Achievement of scalable generation of 2N or 4N-body entangled states, surpassing existing three-body limitations
4. Controllable Structure: Generated entangled states possess tunable ladder-like or linear structures, suitable for various quantum computing and network applications

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: N double-longitudinal-mode cavity optomechanical systems, each containing two longitudinal cavity modes and one mechanical oscillator Output: 2N or 4N-body continuous variable entangled states Constraints: System parameters must satisfy stability conditions (effective mechanical damping rate Γ_eff > 0)

Double-Longitudinal-Mode Cavity Optomechanical System Model

Fundamental Hamiltonian

The system Hamiltonian is given by:

Ĥ = ℏω₁â₁†â₁ + ℏω₂â₂†â₂ + ℏωₘ/2(q² + p²) - ℏg₀(â₁ + â₂)†(â₁ + â₂)q
    + iℏε₁(â₁†e^(-iωₗt) - â₁e^(iωₗt)) + iℏε₂(â₂†e^(-iωₗt) - â₂e^(iωₗt))

Where:

• â₁†, â₂†: Creation operators for cavity modes 1 and 2
• q, p: Dimensionless position and momentum operators of the mechanical oscillator
• g₀ = √(ℏω₁ω₂/mωₘ)/L: Optomechanical coupling coefficient
• εⱼ = √(2Pκⱼ/ℏωⱼ): Driving strength

Linearized Quantum Langevin Equations

After linearization around steady-state solutions, the evolution equations for fluctuations are obtained:

u̇ = Au + n(t)

where u = (δq, δp, δX₁, δY₁, δX₂, δY₂)ᵀ contains fluctuations in mechanical and optical quadrature components.

Scheme I: Beam Splitter Coupling Scheme

System Configuration

• Two identical double-longitudinal-mode cavity optomechanical systems
• Output optical beams at identical frequencies (a'₁ and a'₃) coupled via beam splitter
• Beam splitter transformation matrix: U_BS = [[cosθe^(iφ), sinθe^(i(φ+π))], sinθ, cosθ]

Entanglement Structure Control

Different entanglement structures achieved by tuning beam splitter parameters (θ, φ):

• θ = π/8 or 3π/8: Linear entanglement structure
• θ = π/4 (50:50 beam splitter): Square entanglement structure

2N-Body Extension

Using N cavity systems and N-1 beam splitters generates 2N-body entangled states with "double-ladder" structure.

Scheme II: Orthogonal Polarization Dual-Pump Scheme

System Configuration

• Single cavity system simultaneously supporting two groups of orthogonal polarization longitudinal modes
• Modes a₁(a₂) and a₃(a₄) share identical frequency but different polarizations (H and V)
• Hamiltonian includes two groups of optomechanical coupling terms

Entanglement Characteristics

• Entanglement between different frequency modes (E₁₂, E₃₄, E₁₄, E₂₃): Follow Stokes/anti-Stokes scattering mechanisms
• Entanglement between identical frequency modes (E₁₃, E₂₄): Mediated through mechanical mode, exhibiting different detuning dependence

4N-Body Extension

Similar to Scheme I, scalable extension to 4N-body entangled states, forming complex three-dimensional entanglement networks containing six groups of ladder structures.

Experimental Setup

System Parameters

• Cavity Length: L = 0.01 m
• Temperature: T = 0.01 K
• Laser Wavelength: λ = 1.33 μm
• Mechanical Frequency Decay: γₘ = 0.1 MHz
• Cavity Decay Rate: κ₁ = κ₂ = κ = 1 MHz
• Effective Mass: m = 5×10⁻⁹ kg
• Input Power: P = 20 mW
• Detuning Relationship: Δ₁ = Δ₂ - 2ωₘ

Evaluation Metrics

Logarithmic negativity quantifies entanglement:

E_N = max[0, -ln2ν₋]

where ν₋ is the minimum symplectic eigenvalue of the partially transposed covariance matrix.

Experimental Results

Parameter Dependence Analysis

Detuning Dependence

• Optimal Condition: All entanglement reaches maximum at Δ₂ = ωₘ (Δ₁ = -ωₘ)
• Stable Region: Entanglement exists only in Δ₂ ≥ ωₘ region, as effective mechanical damping rate becomes negative for Δ₂ < ωₘ
• Optomechanical Entanglement Difference: E₀₁ and E₀₂ exhibit different behaviors; E₀₂ is enhanced at large detunings due to cooling mechanisms

Decay Effects

• Cavity Decay κ: Increased κ reduces all entanglement, but dispersive-like structures appear at large κ
• Mechanical Decay γₘ: Complex effects on optomechanical entanglement with optimal values; always negative impact on optical-optical entanglement

Temperature Robustness

Optical-optical entanglement remains robust at room temperature and even higher temperatures, while optomechanical entanglement is more temperature-sensitive.

Multipartite Entanglement Generation

Four-Body Entanglement

• Scheme I: Square entanglement structure achieved via 50:50 beam splitter
• Scheme II: GHZ-type four-body entangled states generated, containing six types of bipartite entanglement

Scalability Verification

• 2N-Body Scheme: Successfully extended to 8-body, 12-body, etc., forming double-ladder structures
• 4N-Body Scheme: Achieves more complex three-dimensional entanglement network structures

Related Work

Optomechanical Entanglement Research

• Bipartite Entanglement: Previous studies primarily focused on entanglement between two optical modes, such as spatial or longitudinal modes
• Tripartite Entanglement: Few works involved three optical cavity modes or optical-microwave hybrid modes
• Breakthrough in This Work: First realization of scalable optical mode entanglement exceeding three parties

Multipartite Entanglement Generation Methods

• Parametric Process + Beam Splitter: Traditional method, limited by experimental complexity
• Frequency/Time Multiplexing: Can achieve large-scale entanglement but difficult for heterogeneous systems
• Optomechanical Platform: This work pioneering utilizes optomechanical systems for scalable multipartite entanglement

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Parameter Optimization: Identified Δ₂ = ωₘ as optimal entanglement generation condition, revealing dual roles of mechanical decay
2. Scalable Architecture: Successfully achieved scalable generation of 2N and 4N-body entangled states
3. Controllable Structure: Different entanglement topologies realized by tuning beam splitter parameters
4. Practical Value: Provides practically feasible entanglement sources for hybrid quantum networks

Limitations

1. Stability Constraints: Must satisfy stability condition Γ_eff > 0
2. Parameter Sensitivity: Entanglement strength relatively sensitive to system parameters
3. Temperature Limitations: Optomechanical entanglement requires low-temperature environments
4. Experimental Complexity: Large-scale extension requires precise phase and intensity control

Future Directions

1. Cascaded Enhancement: Combine feedback and nonlinear gain media to further enhance entanglement
2. New Degrees of Freedom: Explore new multiplexing dimensions such as frequency and orbital angular momentum
3. Experimental Verification: Validate theoretical predictions on actual optomechanical platforms
4. Application Extension: Investigate specific applications in quantum computing and quantum networks

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides comprehensive theoretical analysis framework from single system to multi-system extension
2. Innovative Breakthrough: First realization of entanglement generation exceeding three parties in optomechanical systems
3. Application-Oriented: Considers practical experimental parameters and constraints
4. Rich Structure Diversity: Generated entangled states possess tunable topological structures

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Experimental Verification: Paper is purely theoretical work without experimental validation
2. Parameter Range Limitations: System instability under certain parameter combinations
3. Insufficient Noise Analysis: Limited analysis of performance under realistic noisy environments
4. Insufficient Comparative Benchmarking: Lack of quantitative comparison with other multipartite entanglement generation methods

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new theoretical foundation for optomechanical quantum information processing
2. Technical Advancement: Promotes development of scalable quantum entanglement generation technology
3. Application Prospects: Provides practical entanglement resource schemes for quantum networks and quantum computing

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Network Nodes: Interface for connecting different physical quantum systems
2. Distributed Quantum Computing: Provides multipartite entanglement resources for MBQC
3. Quantum Sensing Networks: Utilizes multipartite entanglement to enhance sensing precision
4. Quantum Communication: Supports multi-party quantum communication protocols

References

The paper cites 43 related references, primarily including:

• Fundamental quantum entanglement theory (Vidal & Werner, 2002)
• Optomechanical systems review (Aspelmeyer et al., 2014)
• Optomechanical entanglement experiments (Palomaki et al., 2013; Ockeloen-Korppi et al., 2018)
• Multipartite entanglement theory (Armstrong et al., 2014; Ma & Zhang, 2013)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making significant contributions to the field of optomechanical quantum information processing. The paper provides in-depth and comprehensive theoretical analysis, proposes highly innovative and practical schemes, and offers new perspectives and tools for constructing large-scale quantum networks.