Probabilistic enumeration and equivalence of nonisomorphic trees

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2305.16453
• Title: Probabilistic enumeration and equivalence of nonisomorphic trees
• Author: Benedikt Stufler (Vienna University of Technology)
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics), math.PR (Probability Theory)
• Publication Date: May 2023, revised October 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16453

Abstract

This paper presents a novel probabilistic proof of Otter's asymptotic formula for the number of unlabeled trees with a given number of vertices. Furthermore, it establishes a new approximation result demonstrating that the total variation distance between random Pólya trees and random unlabeled trees converges to zero as the number of vertices approaches infinity. To demonstrate that the approach extends beyond trees, the author generalizes the results to tree-like graph classes.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Context

1. Classical tree enumeration: Cayley's theorem provides the counting formula for labeled trees $u_n = n^{n-2}$, but enumeration of unlabeled trees is considerably more complex
2. Significance of Otter's formula: Otter's 1948 asymptotic formula for the number of unlabeled trees is a classical result in combinatorics
3. Absence of probabilistic approaches: Existing proofs of Otter's formula rely primarily on generating functions and analytic combinatorics, lacking a probabilistic perspective

Research Motivation

1. Methodological innovation: Providing the first probabilistic proof of Otter's formula, enriching the methodology of combinatorial enumeration
2. Equivalence problem: Resolving the fundamental question of the relationship between random Pólya trees and random unlabeled trees
3. Result transfer: Providing stronger theoretical foundations for transferring properties from rooted trees to unrooted trees
4. Generalization potential: Demonstrating the universality of the proof method and extending it to more general graph classes

Core Contributions

1. Provides a new probabilistic proof of Otter's asymptotic formula: Avoiding the traditional dissymmetry equation approach
2. Proves asymptotic equivalence of random trees: $\lim_{n→∞} d_{TV}(F(A_n), F_n) = 0$
3. Establishes stronger approximation theory: Directly proving equivalence rather than requiring additional small tree approximations as in previous work
4. Extends to degree-restricted trees and tree-like graph classes: Demonstrating the universality of the method
5. Provides precise convergence rates: For $1/2 < α < 1$, establishes exponential convergence rates

Methodology Details

Core Idea

The author transforms the tree enumeration problem into an orbit counting problem under the action of symmetric groups through symmetry analysis.

Key Definitions

1. Symmetry set: $Sym(U)[V] = \{(T,σ) | T ∈ U[V], σ ∈ S[V], σ.T = T\}$
2. Fixed point classification: $Sym_k(U)[V]$ denotes symmetries with exactly $k$ fixed points
3. Generating function relations: Establishing connections between exponential generating functions

Main Technical Approach

1. Symmetry Decomposition

Decomposing the generating function of unlabeled trees as: $F(z) = Sym_0(U)(z) + U(H(z))$

where:

• $U(z) = \sum_{n≥1} \frac{n^{n-2}}{n!}z^n$ is the exponential generating function of labeled trees
• $H(z) = z\exp(\sum_{i≥2} A(z^i)/i)$ corresponds to symmetries fixing only the root

2. Probabilistic Representation

Introducing independent random variables $X_1, X_2, ...$, whose probability generating function is: $E[z^X] = ρz\exp(1 + \sum_{i≥2} A((ρz)^i)/i)$

and an independent random variable $N$ satisfying $E[z^N] = 2U(z/e)$.

3. Asymptotic Analysis

Utilizing moderate deviation inequalities for random walks and Stirling's formula to obtain: $[z^n]F(z) ∼ \frac{1}{\sqrt{2π}}E[X]^{3/2}n^{-5/2}ρ^{-n}$

Equivalence Proof Strategy

1. Fixed point control: Proving that the probability of fixed point numbers deviating from the expected value $n/E[X]$ by more than $n^α$ is exponentially small
2. Conditional comparison: Comparing probabilities in rooted and unrooted cases when fixed point numbers lie within reasonable ranges
3. Second-order analysis: Utilizing second-order asymptotic expansions of Pólya trees to control error terms

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

This is primarily a theoretical work, with experimental components including:

1. Constant computation: Verifying $c_A ≈ 0.439924$, $ρ ≈ 0.338321$
2. Convergence rate verification: Validating exponential convergence rates through explicit calculations
3. Extension verification: Verifying theoretical results in degree-restricted cases

Mathematical Tools

1. Moderate deviation inequalities: Controlling tail probabilities of random walks
2. Generating function analysis: Establishing connections between combinatorial structures and probability distributions
3. Singularity analysis: Deriving asymptotic behavior from singularity properties of generating functions

Main Results

Theorem 1.1 (Probabilistic Proof of Otter's Formula)

$f_n ∼ c_F n^{-5/2}ρ^{-n}$ where $c_F = 2πc_A^3$, $c_A = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2π}}E[X]^{1/2}$.

Theorem 1.2 (Asymptotic Equivalence)

$\lim_{n→∞} d_{TV}(F(A_n), F_n) = 0$

More precisely, for $1/2 < α < 1$, there exist constants $c, C > 0$ such that: $|P(F(A_n) ∈ E) - P(F_n ∈ E)| ≤ \exp(-cn^{2α-1}) + P(F(A_n) ∈ E)Cn^{α-1}$

Extended Results

1. Degree-restricted trees: For degree set $Ω$, $\lim_{n→∞} d_{TV}(F(\tilde{A}_n^Ω), F_n^Ω) = 0$
2. Subcritical graph classes: For graph classes $C$ satisfying certain conditions, $\lim_{n→∞} d_{TV}(F(C_n^•), C_n) = 0$

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Cayley (1889): Counting formula for labeled trees
2. Pólya (1937): General counting theory and Pólya trees
3. Otter (1948): Asymptotic formula for unlabeled trees
4. Harary (1955): Alternative proof using dissymmetry equations

Modern Development

1. Analytic combinatorics methods: Singularity analysis by Flajolet-Sedgewick
2. Probabilistic methods: Research on properties of random trees
3. Transfer theorems: Result transfer from rooted to unrooted trees

Novelty of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to:

• Provide a probabilistic proof of Otter's formula
• Establish the strongest form of random tree equivalence
• Avoid complex dissymmetry equations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Methodological contribution: Successful application of probabilistic methods in combinatorial enumeration
2. Theoretical breakthrough: Establishing complete equivalence between random Pólya trees and random unlabeled trees
3. Technical innovation: Clever combination of symmetry analysis and moderate deviation inequalities

Limitations

1. Technical complexity: The proof requires deep knowledge of probability theory and combinatorics
2. Generalization constraints: Extending to non-tree structures requires additional technical conditions
3. Computational complexity: Precise computation of constants remains difficult

Future Directions

1. Unlabeled planar graphs: Extending the method to more complex graph classes
2. Functional convergence: Studying limiting processes of contour functions
3. Algorithmic applications: Applying theoretical results to random generation algorithms

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical depth: Solving a classical problem in combinatorics from a novel perspective
2. Technical innovation: Cleverly combining symmetric group theory, probability theory, and generating function methods
3. Result strength: Not only reproving classical results but obtaining stronger equivalence theorems
4. Method universality: Successfully extending to degree-restricted and graph class cases

Weaknesses

1. Proof complexity: Numerous technical details with high barriers to understanding
2. Practical applications: Primarily theoretical contributions with limited direct applicability
3. Computational aspects: Limited assistance for practical problems such as computing constants

Impact

1. Academic value: Providing important examples for interdisciplinary research between combinatorics and probability theory
2. Methodological significance: Demonstrating the powerful potential of probabilistic methods in enumerative combinatorics
3. Subsequent research: Providing new technical tools for related problem investigations

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical research: Asymptotic analysis of combinatorial structures
2. Randomized algorithms: Random generation and analysis of tree structures
3. Probabilistic combinatorics: Properties of large random structures

References

The paper cites 32 important references spanning from Cayley's classical work to modern developments in probabilistic combinatorics, particularly:

• Otter (1948): Original asymptotic formula
• Pólya (1937): Foundational counting theory
• Flajolet & Sedgewick (2009): Analytic combinatorics methods
• Author's previous work: Limit theory of random trees

This paper has significant theoretical value, not only providing a new proof of a classical result but more importantly establishing fundamental equivalences in random tree theory, laying a solid foundation for further development in this field.