Generalized Charges, Part II: Non-Invertible Symmetries and the Symmetry TFT

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2305.17159
• Title: Generalized Charges, Part II: Non-Invertible Symmetries and the Symmetry TFT
• Authors: Lakshya Bhardwaj, Sakura Schäfer-Nameki (University of Oxford)
• Classification: hep-th, cond-mat.str-el, math-ph, math.CT, math.MP, math.QA
• Publication Date: May 2023 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17159

Abstract

This paper investigates the problem of generalized charges in $d$-dimensional quantum field theories $\mathfrak{T}$ with generalized symmetries $\mathcal{S}$, where symmetries can be either invertible or non-invertible. The main result is that $q$-charges can be characterized by topological defects in the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT), also known as the "sandwich construction." The SymTFT is a $(d+1)$-dimensional topological field theory that encodes the symmetry $\mathcal{S}$ and physical theory through its boundary conditions. This framework applies to arbitrary finite symmetries, including non-invertible categorical symmetries. Mathematically, the topological defects of SymTFT constitute the Drinfeld center of the symmetry category $\mathcal{S}$.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Context

1. Development of Generalized Symmetries: In recent years, the concept of symmetry in quantum field theory has expanded from traditional group symmetries to more general concepts, including higher-form symmetries, higher-group symmetries, and non-invertible symmetries.
2. Need for Charge Theory: For these generalized symmetries, it is necessary to understand how they act on operators in the theory, i.e., to study the structure of generalized charges.
3. Challenges of Non-Invertible Symmetries: While traditional invertible symmetry theory was discussed in Part I, non-invertible symmetries introduce new complexities requiring more powerful mathematical tools.

Research Motivation

1. Unified Framework: Provide a unified framework for understanding all types of generalized symmetries and their charges.
2. Mathematical Rigor: Utilize tools from category theory and topological field theory to provide mathematically rigorous descriptions.
3. Physical Applications: Provide new tools for understanding infrared properties and phase transitions in quantum field theory.

Core Contributions

1. Main Theorem: Establishes a one-to-one correspondence between $q$-charges and $(q+1)$-dimensional topological defects in SymTFT.
2. Physical Interpretation of Drinfeld Center: Establishes direct connections between the Drinfeld center $Z(\mathcal{S})$ and generalized charges.
3. Systematization of Sandwich Construction: Develops the sandwich construction theory for SymTFT, providing a method to separate symmetry from dynamics.
4. Concrete Implementations: Provides detailed studies of specific cases in 2d (fusion category symmetries) and 3d (fusion 2-category symmetries).
5. Gauging Theory: Demonstrates the implementation of gauging operations within the SymTFT framework.

Methodology Details

Core Concept Definitions

Generalized Charges (q-charges):

• $q$-charges describe possible ways generalized global symmetries act on $q$-dimensional operators
• Denoted as $Q_{q+1}$, corresponding to $(q+1)$-dimensional topological operators in SymTFT

Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT):

• A $(d+1)$-dimensional topological field theory $Z(\mathcal{S})$ associated with symmetry $\mathcal{S}$
• Separates symmetry and physical theory through boundary conditions

Sandwich Construction

The core of SymTFT is the sandwich construction, containing two boundary conditions:

1. Symmetry Boundary $B^{\text{sym}}_{\mathcal{S}}$: A topological boundary condition encoding the symmetry structure
2. Physical Boundary $B^{\text{phys}}_{\mathfrak{T}_\sigma}$: Depends on the specific $\mathcal{S}$-symmetric theory $\mathfrak{T}_\sigma$

Upon interval compactification, the original $\mathcal{S}$-symmetric $d$-dimensional theory is recovered.

Construction of Charges

Construction of Uncharged Operators:

• Operators on the physical boundary without any attached bulk topological operators remain invariant under symmetry action

Construction of Charged Operators:

• Constructed through bulk topological operators $Q_{q+1}$ connecting the physical boundary to the symmetry boundary
• The endpoint $E_q$ of $Q_{q+1}$ on the symmetry boundary determines how the symmetry acts

Mathematical Framework

Drinfeld Center: Elements of the Drinfeld center $Z(\mathcal{S})$ of the symmetry category $\mathcal{S}$ are determined by:

• Projections $S^{(Q_p)}_p \in \mathcal{S}$
• Half-braidings $S^{(Q_p)}_{p+q-d}(S_q)$ satisfying consistency conditions

Consistency Conditions: Half-braidings must satisfy commutation relations between fusion and projection: $S^{(Q_p)}_{p+q-d}(S^{(12)}_q) \otimes_{S^{(Q_p)}_{p+q+1-d}(S^{(2)}_{q+1})} S^{(Q_p)}_{p+q-d}(S^{(23)}_q) \simeq S^{(Q_p)}_{p+q-d}(S^{(13)}_q)$

Concrete Implementations

Applications in 2-Dimensional Theories

Fusion Category Symmetries:

• Symmetries described by fusion 1-categories $\mathcal{S}$
• SymTFT is the 3d Turaev-Viro theory
• 0-charges correspond to topological line operators in SymTFT

Specific Examples:

1. Invertible Symmetries: $G^{(0)}$ 0-form symmetries
   • Drinfeld center: $Z(\mathcal{S}^{[\omega]}_{G^{(0)}}) = \bigoplus_{[g]} \text{Rep}^{\omega_g}(H_g)$
   • Where $[g]$ denotes conjugacy classes and $H_g$ is the stabilizer subgroup
2. Ising Symmetry: Intrinsic non-invertible symmetry
   • Simple objects: $\{S^{(\text{id})}_1, S^{(P)}_1, S^{(S)}_1\}$
   • Non-trivial associator structure

Applications in 3-Dimensional Theories

Fusion 2-Category Symmetries:

• Include hierarchical structures of surface operators, line operators, and local operators
• SymTFT is the 4d Douglas-Reutter-Walker theory

Specific Examples:

1. $Z_2$ 0-Form Symmetry:
   • 1-charges: $Q^{(\text{id})}_2, Q^{(Z_2)}_2, Q^{(V)}_2, Q^{(VZ_2)}_2$
   • Implementation in 3d SO(3) gauge theory
2. $Z_2$ 1-Form Symmetry:
   • Obtained through gauging $Z_2$ 0-form symmetry
   • Implementation in 3d $\widetilde{SU}(3)$ gauge theory

Experimental Results and Applications

Theoretical Verification

Recovery of Known Results:

• For invertible symmetries, recovers results from Part I
• For group symmetries, recovers standard representation theory

New Predictions:

• Charge structure of non-invertible symmetries
• Mixing of twisted and untwisted sectors

Concrete Calculation Examples

2d Ising CFT: The paper demonstrates the classification of all conformal primary operators in 2d Ising CFT under Ising symmetry:

• Energy operator $\epsilon$: $Q^{(\text{id},+,-)}_1$
• Spin operators $\psi, \widetilde{\psi}$: $Q^{(P,-,\pm i)}_1$
• Order and disorder operators $(\sigma, \mu)$: $Q^{(\text{id}\oplus P,\mp,\text{ex})}_1$

3d Gauge Theories:

• Magnetic 0-form symmetry in SO(3) gauge theory
• Charge conjugation symmetry in SU(3) gauge theory
• Charge classification of Wilson and 't Hooft lines

Related Work

Theoretical Development

1. Generalized Symmetries: Pioneering work by Gaiotto-Kapustin-Seiberg-Willett
2. Non-Invertible Symmetries: Recent developments in higher-dimensional theories
3. Categorical Symmetries: Related concepts in condensed matter physics

Mathematical Foundations

1. Fusion Category Theory: Work by Etingof-Nikshych-Ostrik and others
2. Drinfeld Center: Applications in topological order
3. Topological Field Theory: Turaev-Viro and Crane-Yetter constructions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Unified Description: Provides a unified mathematical description of charges for all generalized symmetries
2. Computational Tools: SymTFT and Drinfeld center provide concrete computational methods
3. Physical Insights: Reveals deep connections between symmetry, charges, and topological defects

Limitations

1. Finite Symmetries: Current framework restricted to finite (discrete) symmetries
2. Computational Complexity: Calculation of Drinfeld centers in higher dimensions may be highly complex
3. Physical Realization: Implementation of certain theoretical constructions in actual physical systems requires further investigation

Future Directions

1. Continuous Symmetries: Extension to continuous symmetry groups
2. Higher-Dimensional Generalizations: Development of theory for $d \geq 4$
3. Physical Applications: Concrete applications in condensed matter and high-energy physics
4. Phase Transition Theory: Study of quantum phase transitions using charge structure

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Establishes profound mathematical-physical correspondences
2. Universality: Provides a unified framework for handling various symmetries
3. Computational Power: Provides concrete computational methods and numerous examples
4. Innovation: Successfully applies categorical tools to quantum field theory

Weaknesses

1. Abstraction: High mathematical abstraction may limit physical intuition
2. Complexity: Calculations may become extremely difficult for complex symmetries
3. Experimental Verification: Lacks direct experimental verification schemes

Impact

1. Theoretical Physics: Provides foundational framework for non-invertible symmetry theory
2. Mathematical Physics: Promotes cross-disciplinary interaction between category theory and quantum field theory
3. Condensed Matter Physics: Provides new tools for topological order and quantum phase transitions
4. Reproducibility: Detailed calculations and examples make results verifiable

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Theoretical studies of generalized symmetries and topological field theory
2. Classification Problems: Classification of quantum field theories and topological phases
3. Phase Transition Studies: Study of phase transitions using symmetry breaking
4. Education: Serves as teaching material for modern symmetry theory

References

The paper contains 144 references, spanning from classical symmetry theory to recent research on non-invertible symmetries, reflecting the complete development trajectory of the field. Key references include:

• Gaiotto et al. (2015): Foundational work on generalized global symmetries
• Bhardwaj & Schäfer-Nameki (Part I): Treatment of invertible symmetries
• Freed, Moore & Teleman (2022): Mathematical foundations of SymTFT
• Numerous recent studies on non-invertible symmetries

This paper represents an important advance in modern quantum field theory's treatment of symmetry, providing powerful mathematical tools for understanding and computing the charge structure of generalized symmetries. Its impact will continue to manifest across multiple fields including theoretical physics, mathematical physics, and condensed matter physics.