Microscopic Mechanism of Pair-, Charge- and Spin-Density-Wave Instabilities in Interacting D-Dimensional Fermi Liquids

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2312.17208
• Title: Microscopic Mechanism of Pair-, Charge- and Spin-Density-Wave Instabilities in Interacting D-Dimensional Fermi Liquids
• Authors: Dmitry Miserev, Herbert Schoeller, Jelena Klinovaja, Daniel Loss
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el cond-mat.supr-con
• Publication Date: March 28, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17208

Abstract

This paper presents an analytical theory that elucidates the microscopic mechanisms of instabilities in interacting D-dimensional Fermi liquids. The model comprises a D-dimensional electron gas subject to instantaneous, finite-range electron-electron interactions with a range exceeding the average inter-particle spacing. Pairing, charge, and spin susceptibilities are evaluated using both single-loop renormalization group theory and bosonization methods, which yield identical results. For repulsive interactions, intrinsic instabilities of the Fermi liquid toward insulating spin/charge density wave order are identified when the interaction coupling strength reaches a universal critical value. When equal-sized electron and hole pockets coexist, the ground state becomes an excitonic insulator at arbitrarily small repulsive interactions. For attractive interactions, the ground state is a singlet non-BCS superconductor with uniform condensate. When both electron and hole Fermi surfaces are present, an instability toward inter-pocket pairing density wave order at the critical coupling is predicted.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

Strongly correlated phenomena have long posed a persistent challenge to the condensed matter physics community across various systems. Although existing theoretical models provide valuable insights into individual phases, consensus on the microscopic mechanisms of strongly correlated electronic matter in realistic models remains lacking.

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Gap: The reliable microscopic mechanisms for insulating and unconventional superconducting order in D>1 dimensional quantum materials remain unclear
2. Experimental Demand: A theoretical framework is needed to explain quantum phase transitions observed in diverse materials ranging from ultra-clean semiconductor quantum wells to high-temperature superconductors
3. Universality: A universal microscopic model independent of specific material details is required

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Phenomenological frameworks, while useful for exploring various orders (CDW, SDW, PDW), lack microscopic mechanisms
2. BCS theory and its extensions cannot fully explain unconventional superconducting phenomena
3. A unified theoretical framework describing different types of phase transitions is absent

Core Contributions

1. Universal Microscopic Model: Establishes a universal microscopic model describing instabilities in D-dimensional interacting Fermi liquids
2. Dual Theory Verification: Consistent results obtained using both single-loop renormalization group theory and bosonization methods
3. Multiple Phase Transition Predictions:
   • CDW/SDW instabilities under repulsive interactions
   • Excitonic insulator phase transitions
   • Non-BCS superconductivity
   • Pairing density wave (PDW) superconductivity
4. Critical Coupling Determination: Identifies universal critical value $\gamma_c = (D-1)/2$
5. Support for Cuprate Theory: Provides strong theoretical support for PDW superconductivity in cuprate materials

Methodology Details

Model Setup

Consider a zero-temperature, spin-degenerate D-dimensional electron gas (D>1) with two spherical Fermi surfaces:

• Electron pocket: radius $k_e$, centered at momentum $K$
• Hole pocket: radius $k_h$, centered at momentum $-K$

Interaction Hamiltonian

Electrons interact through finite-range forward-scattering density-density interactions:

$U(\tau, r) = \delta(\tau)V(r), \quad \lambda_F \ll r \lesssim R_0$

where $R_0$ is the interaction range, much larger than the Fermi wavelength $\lambda_F$.

Susceptibility Definitions

Three types of static susceptibilities are defined:

• Pairing Susceptibility: $\chi^{(0)}_{P,ab}(r) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} G_a(\tau,r)G_b(\tau,r)d\tau$
• Charge/Spin Susceptibility: $\chi^{(0)}_{C/S,ab}(r) = -2\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} G_a(\tau,r)G_b(-\tau,-r)d\tau$

Renormalization Group Analysis

Using multiplicative renormalization group methods, susceptibilities exhibit power-law form:

$\chi(r) = \chi^{(0)}(r)\left(\frac{r}{R_0}\right)^{\gamma_0}$

where:

• For charge/spin susceptibilities: $\gamma_0 = \gamma_{ab}$
• For pairing susceptibilities: $\gamma_0 = -\gamma_{ab}$

Critical Exponents

Dimensionless coupling constants are defined as: $\gamma_{ee} = \frac{2V_2}{\pi v_e}, \quad \gamma_{hh} = \frac{2V_2}{\pi v_h}, \quad \gamma_{eh} = \frac{4V_2}{\pi(v_e + v_h)}$

where $V_2 = \int_0^{\infty} V(r)dr$ is the interaction matrix element.

Technical Innovations

Dimensional Reduction Technique

A dimensional reduction procedure maps the D-dimensional problem to an effective 1D problem, substantially simplifying Feynman diagram calculations.

Dual Method Verification

1. Renormalization Group Method: Computes critical exponents under weak interaction coupling
2. Bosonization Method: Asymptotically exact in the semiclassical/infrared limit

Non-BCS Mechanism

The instantaneous yet finite-range nature of interactions leads to non-Fermi liquid quantum critical states, contrasting with standard BCS theory.

Experimental Results

Critical Behavior Analysis

The universal critical value is determined as: $\gamma_c = \frac{D-1}{2}$

For different dimensions:

• 2D case ($\gamma_c = 1/2$): Logarithmic divergence accompanied by asymmetric peak structure
• 3D case ($\gamma_c = 1$): Discontinuity at the critical point

Susceptibility Singularities

In momentum space, the singular behavior of susceptibilities is:

$\chi_{C/S,aa}(\delta Q) = \frac{\cos[\frac{\pi}{2}\delta\gamma_{aa} + \vartheta \text{sgn}(\delta Q)]\Gamma(\delta\gamma_{aa})}{\pi v_a[2R_0\lambda_a]^{\gamma_c}|\delta QR_0|^{\delta\gamma_{aa}}}$

where $\delta\gamma_{ab} = \gamma_{ab} - \gamma_c$.

Phase Diagram Predictions

1. Repulsive Interactions ($\gamma_{ab} > 0$):
   • $\gamma_{ab} < \gamma_c$: Fermi liquid stable
   • $\gamma_{ab} > \gamma_c$: CDW/SDW instability
2. Attractive Interactions ($\gamma_{ab} < 0$):
   • Superconducting instability at arbitrarily small coupling
   • PDW order in dual-pocket systems

Physical Picture and Applications

Excitonic Insulator

When electron and hole pockets have equal size ($k_e = k_h$), the system becomes an excitonic insulator at arbitrarily small repulsive interactions:

$\chi_{C/S,eh}(q) = \frac{2\pi^{\frac{D}{2}-1}\Gamma(\frac{\gamma_{eh}}{2})}{\Gamma(\frac{D-\gamma_{eh}}{2})(v_e+v_h)\lambda_F^{D-1}}\left|\frac{2}{qR_0}\right|^{\gamma_{eh}}$

Pairing Density Wave Superconductivity

Under magnetic field, the system exhibits:

• Singlet superconducting order at small wave vector $\Delta k_a$
• PDW order at large wave vector $Q^+_{eh} = k_e + k_h$

Material Application Prospects

1. Cuprate Superconductors: PDW mechanism may explain high-temperature superconductivity
2. Magic-Angle Graphene: Superconductivity following Fermi surface reconstruction
3. Semiconductor Quantum Wells: Metal-insulator transitions at low electron density
4. Transition Metal Dichalcogenides: Excitonic insulator phase transitions

Theoretical Significance and Limitations

Theoretical Advantages

1. Universality: Microscopic mechanisms independent of specific materials
2. Self-Consistency: Two independent methods yield identical results
3. Predictive Power: Provides specific measurable quantities for experiments

Limitations

1. Temperature Effects: Finite temperature cuts off all singularities
2. Long-Range Order Stability: Forward scattering alone is insufficient to stabilize long-range order at finite temperature
3. Higher-Order Corrections: Higher-order calculations needed to determine the complete beta function

Conclusions and Outlook

This paper establishes a universal microscopic theory of instabilities in interacting D-dimensional Fermi liquids, successfully predicting multiple quantum phase transitions. The theory provides a solid theoretical foundation for understanding strongly correlated phenomena in diverse quantum materials ranging from semiconductor quantum wells to high-temperature superconductors.

Future Research Directions

1. Finite-temperature stabilization mechanisms for long-range order
2. Quantum critical behavior of strange metal states
3. Higher-order corrections to electronic spectral functions
4. First-principles calculations of material-specific parameters

This work makes important contributions to the theoretical understanding of strongly correlated electronic systems in condensed matter physics, particularly providing strong theoretical support for the PDW mechanism in cuprate superconductors.