Strong coupling between a single-photon and a two-photon Fock state

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2401.02738
• Title: Strong coupling between a single-photon and a two-photon Fock state
• Authors: Shuai-Peng Wang, Alberto Mercurio, Alessandro Ridolfo, Yuqing Wang, Mo Chen, Wenyan Wang, Yulong Liu, Huanying Sun, Tiefu Li, Franco Nori, Salvatore Savasta, J. Q. You
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: January 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.02738

Abstract

This paper reports the first experimental observation of strong coupling between a single-photon state and a two-photon Fock state in an ultrastrong-coupling circuit quantum electrodynamics (circuit-QED) system. This strong nonlinear interaction is achieved by introducing a detuned flux qubit as an effective coupler between two modes of a superconducting coplanar waveguide resonator. The ultrastrong light-matter interaction breaks excitation number conservation, while external flux bias breaks parity conservation; the combined effect of both enables strong single-two-photon coupling. When tuning the two-photon resonance frequency of the first mode through the single-photon resonance frequency of the second mode, quantum Rabi-like avoided crossings are observed. In this novel photonic system, threshold-free second harmonic generation with average photon numbers below unity is realized.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

Achieving strong nonlinear coupling between single photons is a long-standing goal in quantum optics and quantum information science, with important implications for all-optical deterministic quantum logic and single-photon frequency conversion applications.

Problem Significance

1. Quantum Information Processing: Strong photon-photon interactions are crucial for implementing quantum computing and quantum communication
2. Nonlinear Optics: Nonlinear effects in conventional materials at single-photon power levels are extremely weak
3. Technical Challenges: Existing methods typically require large numbers of photons or external driving fields to observe nonlinear effects

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Traditional Nonlinear Optics: Requires strong excitation fields and statistical processes
2. Cavity QED Methods: Relies on atomic transitions, introducing additional losses
3. Electromagnetically Induced Transparency: Requires high-power excitation fields

Research Motivation

Leveraging the large dipole moments and small mode volumes of superconducting quantum circuits to achieve strong deterministic photon-photon interactions without any external excitation fields.

Core Contributions

1. First Experimental Observation: Realization of strong coupling between single-photon and two-photon Fock states in a circuit-QED system
2. Novel Physical Mechanism: Combined effect of ultrastrong coupling breaking excitation number conservation and magnetic flux bias breaking parity conservation
3. Quantum Rabi Splitting: Observation of quantum Rabi-like avoided crossings between single and two-photon states
4. Sub-Single-Photon Nonlinearity: Realization of threshold-free second harmonic generation with average photon numbers <1
5. Theoretical Framework: Establishment of generalized master equation theory describing multi-mode ultrastrong coupling systems

Methodology Details

System Design

Device Structure

• Resonator: λ/2 coplanar waveguide resonator supporting multiple modes
• Qubit: Three-junction flux qubit embedded in the resonator
• Coupling Mechanism: Qubit serves as an effective nonlinear coupler between two resonator modes

Hamiltonian

The total system Hamiltonian is:

Hs = Hq + Σn=1,2 [ωn a†n an + gn(a†n + an)σz]

where:

• Hq = -(Δσx + εσz)/2 is the flux qubit Hamiltonian
• ωn is the frequency of the nth mode
• gn is the coupling strength
• σx,z are Pauli matrices

Effective Coupling Mechanism

Nonlinear Coupling

Effective interaction realized through high-order virtual processes:

Veff = geff(|0̃,1⟩⟨2̃,0| + |2̃,0⟩⟨0̃,1|)

Coupling Strength

Theoretically predicted effective coupling strength:

geff = (3√2 g₁² g₂ ωq² sin(2θ)cos(θ)) / (4ω₁⁴ - 5ω₁²ωq² + ωq⁴)

Technical Innovations

1. Parity Breaking: Destruction of system parity symmetry through external magnetic flux bias
2. Ultrastrong Coupling: Utilization of the ultrastrong coupling regime with gi/ωi > 0.1
3. Detuned Operation: Qubit operating far from resonator mode frequencies
4. Multi-Mode Coupling: Simultaneous coupling to two different modes of the resonator

Experimental Setup

Device Parameters

• Resonator Frequencies: ω₁/2π ≈ 5.0 GHz, ω₂/2π ≈ 9.7 GHz
• Coupling Strengths: g₁/2π = 2.815 GHz, g₂/2π = 2.180 GHz
• Ultrastrong Coupling Ratios: g₁/ω₁ = 0.563, g₂/ω₂ = 0.225
• Operating Temperature: 20 mK

Measurement System

• Transmission Spectrum: S₂₁ parameter measured using vector network analyzer
• Second Harmonic: Excited by signal generator, detected by spectrum analyzer
• Interferometric Measurement: Dual-tone phase correlation measurement

Experimental Techniques

1. Cryogenic Environment: Dilution refrigerator providing 20 mK ultra-low temperature
2. Signal Processing: Multi-stage attenuation and amplification with noise isolation
3. Flux Control: On-chip control lines for adjusting external magnetic flux bias

Experimental Results

Quantum Rabi Splitting

Avoided Crossing Observation

• Splitting Frequency: geff/2π = 59 MHz
• Quality Factor: Q = geff/κtot > 4.5
• Visibility: Clear double-peak structure

Frequency Tuning

Achieved through magnetic flux bias adjustment:

ω1,2(δΦext) = ω1,2(0)/√(1 - β1,2 cos(θ)|δΦext|)

Second Harmonic Generation

Sub-Single-Photon Operation

• Average Photon Number: n̄₁ ≈ 0.25
• Conversion Efficiency: η ≈ 0.1
• Threshold-Free Characteristic: Linear dependence on input photon number

Efficiency Optimization

Theory predicts efficiency η = 0.3 can be achieved at n̄₁ = 1.5

Coherent Interference

Dual-Tone Interference

• Visibility: Near-unity interference contrast
• Phase Sensitivity: Periodic amplification and suppression
• Power Dependence: Asymmetric behavior at different frequencies

Key Findings

1. Pure Photonic Process: Qubit population <0.1, primarily photon-photon interaction
2. Coherence: All processes maintain quantum coherence
3. Deterministic: Deterministic photon conversion without statistical averaging

Related Work

Quantum Nonlinear Optics

• Traditional Methods: Dependent on atomic ensembles and strong driving fields
• Cavity QED: Weak nonlinearity in single-atom-cavity systems
• Superconducting Circuits: Advantages of large dipole moments in artificial atoms

Ultrastrong Coupling Research

• Theoretical Development: Non-perturbative effects in quantum Rabi models
• Experimental Progress: Evolution from strong to ultrastrong coupling
• Application Exploration: Quantum simulation and information processing

Innovation of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to achieve strong coupling between different photon number states without external driving fields.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Experimental Verification: Successful observation of strong coupling between single and two-photon Fock states
2. Physical Mechanism: Confirmation of combined effects of ultrastrong coupling and parity breaking
3. Application Prospects: Opening new avenues for quantum nonlinear optics

Application Potential

Quantum Devices

• Deterministic Light Sources: High-efficiency single-photon and photon-pair sources
• Quantum Logic Gates: All-optical controlled-phase gates
• Frequency Conversion: Single-photon-level frequency conversion

Quantum Computing

• Nonlinear Optical Quantum Computing: Key component of NOQC
• Quantum Rabi Oscillations: Quantum state conversion with TR = 2π/geff

Limitations

1. Loss Constraints: Internal losses affect conversion efficiency
2. Frequency Matching: Requires precise ω₂ ≈ 2ω₁ condition
3. Coherence Time: Limited by qubit decoherence

Future Directions

1. Efficiency Enhancement: Through reduction of internal losses and coupling optimization
2. Multi-Photon Extension: Realization of higher-order photon-photon interactions
3. Integrated Applications: Integration with other quantum devices

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

Scientific Contributions

1. Pioneering: First realization of true strong single-photon nonlinear interactions
2. Theoretical Completeness: Provides comprehensive theoretical framework and experimental verification
3. Technical Breakthrough: Achievement of nonlinear optical effects at sub-single-photon level

Experimental Quality

1. Systematicity: Comprehensive characterization from transmission spectra to nonlinear processes
2. Consistency: High agreement between theoretical calculations and experimental results
3. Reproducibility: Detailed experimental parameters and preparation methods

Limitations

Technical Constraints

1. Limited Efficiency: Current conversion efficiency has room for improvement
2. Bandwidth Limitation: Relatively fixed operating frequency range
3. Temperature Requirements: Requires ultra-low temperature environment

Theoretical Simplifications

1. Two-Mode Approximation: Neglects effects of higher-order modes
2. Perturbative Treatment: Approximate handling of certain nonlinear effects

Impact

Academic Impact

1. Field Advancement: Opens new directions for quantum nonlinear optics
2. Theoretical Development: Promotes refinement of ultrastrong coupling theory
3. Interdisciplinary Fusion: Bridges quantum optics and superconducting circuits

Application Prospects

1. Quantum Technologies: Provides new tools for quantum computing and communication
2. Device Development: Inspires design of novel quantum optical devices
3. Industrialization: Provides technical foundation for practical applications

Applicable Scenarios

1. Fundamental Research: Study of quantum many-body physics and nonlinear dynamics
2. Quantum Information: Quantum state preparation and manipulation
3. Quantum Simulation: Simulation platform for complex quantum systems
4. Quantum Sensing: High-precision quantum measurement techniques

References

The paper cites multiple important related works, including:

1. Chang et al., "Quantum nonlinear optics—photon by photon", Nat. Photon. 8, 685 (2014)
2. Kockum et al., "Deterministic quantum nonlinear optics with single atoms and virtual photons", Phys. Rev. A 95, 063849 (2017)
3. Yoshihara et al., "Superconducting qubit–oscillator circuit beyond the ultrastrong-coupling regime", Nat. Phys. 13, 44 (2017)

Summary: This paper achieves an important breakthrough in quantum nonlinear optics, realizing for the first time strong coupling between single-photon and two-photon states without external driving, opening new possibilities for quantum information processing and nonlinear optical applications. Its innovative physical mechanism and solid experimental verification make it a significant milestone in the field.