SymTh for non-finite symmetries

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2402.14813
• Title: SymTh for non-finite symmetries
• Authors: Fabio Apruzzi, Francesco Bedogna, Nicola Dondi
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Timeline: Submitted February 2024, revised December 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14813

Abstract

Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) is a convenient tool for studying finite generalized symmetries of a given quantum field theory (QFT), particularly capable of encoding all symmetry structures and properties, including anomalies. Recently, this tool has also been applied to non-finite symmetries. This paper adopts a different approach, considering free theories in the bulk rather than topological field theories, termed Symmetry Theory (SymTh). The authors investigate topological operators and free boundary conditions, proposing a procedure analogous to the SymTFT sandwich construction to obtain physical QFTs. Applications span multiple examples, from abelian p-form symmetries to 2-groups, as well as solvable cases of group-like symmetries in quantum mechanics. Finally, the authors derive the SymTh of Q/Z non-invertible symmetries from dimensional reduction of IIB supergravity on cones, and provide a UV explanation via membranes in IIB supergravity backgrounds for quantum Hall states decorated with non-invertible Q/Z topological defects.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: Traditional Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) is primarily applicable to finite generalized symmetries, with limitations in handling continuous symmetries (such as U(1) symmetry) and non-invertible symmetries.
2. Importance of the Problem:
   • Continuous symmetries are ubiquitous in physics, such as electromagnetic duality and axion physics
   • Non-invertible symmetries represent a recent research hotspot, closely related to quantum Hall effects and topological phase transitions
   • A unified framework is needed to describe both finite and non-finite symmetries
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • SymTFT is based on topological field theory, primarily encoding flat configurations
   • Description of non-flat configurations of continuous symmetries is not sufficiently natural
   • Lacks mechanisms for handling dynamical gauging
4. Research Motivation: Inspired by holography and geometric constructions, the authors propose a bulk description based on weakly-coupled Maxwell theory that naturally captures non-flat configurations of continuous symmetries and permits dynamical gauging.

Core Contributions

1. Proposes SymTh Framework: Replaces topological field theory with non-topological free theories (primarily Maxwell theory) to describe symmetries
2. Develops Generalized Sandwich Construction: Establishes an interval compactification procedure for non-topological bulk theories analogous to SymTFT
3. Systematically Studies Boundary Conditions: Analyzes the effects of Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions on symmetry projections
4. Multi-dimensional Applications: From 2D Maxwell/Yang-Mills to higher-dimensional 2-groups and Q/Z non-invertible symmetries
5. String Theory Derivation: Derives SymTh action from dimensional reduction of IIB supergravity
6. UV Explanation via Membranes: Provides UV description of quantum Hall states using membranes in string theory

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study continuous and non-invertible symmetries of d-dimensional quantum field theories by encoding these symmetry properties through (d+1)-dimensional non-topological "symmetry theories," including the action of symmetry operators, anomalies, and fusion rules.

Model Architecture

1. Basic SymTh Construction

For U(1)^(p) p-form symmetries, the authors propose (p+1)-form Maxwell theory:

$S_{d+1} = -\frac{1}{2}\int_{M_{d+1}} da_{p+1} \wedge *da_{p+1}$

where $a_{p+1}$ is a (p+1)-form gauge field.

2. Topological Operators

Two classes of topological operators are defined:

• $U_\alpha(\Sigma_{d-p-1}) = e^{i\alpha \int_{\Sigma_{d-p-1}} *_{d+1}f_{p+2}}$
• $U_\beta(\Sigma_{p+2}) = e^{i\beta \int_{\Sigma_{p+2}} f_{p+2}}$

where $f_{p+2} = da_{p+1}$.

3. Boundary Condition Classification

• Dirichlet Condition: $\delta a_{p+1}|_{\partial M_{d+1}} = 0$, allowing Wilson surfaces $W_q(M_{p+1})$ to terminate at the boundary
• Neumann Condition: $*_{d+1}f_{p+2}|_{\partial M_{d+1}} = 0$, allowing dual Wilson surfaces to terminate at the boundary
• Modified Neumann Condition: Includes boundary couplings, implementing dynamical gauging

Technical Innovations

1. Non-topological Bulk Theory: Unlike SymTFT, retains dynamical terms, capable of describing strong coupling and renormalization effects
2. Symmetry Projection via Boundary Conditions: Different boundary conditions select which topological operators project to the boundary
3. Generalized Sandwich Construction: Through decomposition of classical solutions and quantum fluctuations, achieves interval compactification in the $L \to 0$ limit
4. Monopole Sector: Utilizes boundary behavior dominated by topological terms to avoid strong coupling issues

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Cases

1. 2D Maxwell Theory: Serves as SymTh for 1D quantum mechanics U(1) symmetry
2. 2D Yang-Mills: Handles non-abelian 0-form symmetries
3. 4D Continuous 2-group: Two 1-form gauge fields coupled via Chern-Simons term
4. Q/Z Non-invertible Symmetry: Symmetry of 4D axion-Maxwell theory

Computational Methods

• Exact calculation of partition functions in 2D theories
• Verification of Ward identities
• Derivation of topological operator action laws
• Dimensional reduction of string theory backgrounds

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. 2D Maxwell Theory Verification

For partition function on cylindrical topology: $Z(\Sigma_{b,g} | g_1, \ldots, g_b) = \sum_{n \in \mathbb{Z}} \left[\prod_{i=1}^b e^{in\alpha_i}\right] e^{-\frac{g^2}{2}A(\Sigma_{b,g})(n-\frac{\theta}{2\pi})^2}$

Successfully reproduces symmetry properties of boundary quantum mechanics.

2. Topological Operator Action

Verifies linking number law: $\langle U_\alpha(\Sigma_{d-p-1})W_q(M_{p+1})\rangle = e^{iq\alpha \text{Link}(\Sigma_{d-p-1},M_{p+1})}\langle W_q(M_{p+1})U_\alpha(\tilde{\Sigma}_{d-p-1})\rangle$

3. Boundary Ward Identities

For quantum mechanical systems, boundary projections of topological operators correctly implement symmetry transformations: $U_{e^{i\alpha}}(t_-)O(t)U_{e^{i\alpha}}^{-1}(t_+) = e^{iq\alpha}O(t)$

IIB Supergravity Derivation

From dimensional reduction of 10D IIB supergravity on the cone $T^{1,1} \sim S^2 \times S^3$, successfully obtains the SymTh action for Q/Z symmetry:

$S_{\text{SymTh}} = \int_{M_5} \left(-\frac{1}{2}da_1 \wedge *_5 da_1 - \frac{1}{2}dc_1 \wedge *_5 dc_1 - \frac{1}{2}db_2 \wedge *_5 db_2 - \frac{1}{2}dc_0 \wedge *_5 dc_0 + \frac{1}{2}a_1 \wedge dc_1 \wedge dc_1 + b_2 \wedge dc_1 \wedge dc_0\right)$

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. SymTFT Development: Framework for finite symmetries established by Gaiotto et al.
2. Continuous Symmetry Generalization: BF theory approach by Brennan-Sun, Antinucci-Benini et al.
3. Non-invertible Symmetries: Study from holographic and membrane perspectives
4. 2-group Symmetries: Research mixing discrete and continuous symmetries

Advantages of This Work

• Provides a unified framework for handling both finite and non-finite symmetries
• Naturally incorporates dynamical effects and renormalization
• Direct connection to string theory/holographic constructions
• Capable of handling non-flat symmetry configurations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Effectiveness of SymTh Framework: Non-topological bulk theories effectively encode continuous and non-invertible symmetries
2. Critical Role of Boundary Conditions: Different boundary conditions determine which symmetries project to the physical boundary
3. Natural String Theory Realization: Q/Z symmetry naturally emerges from IIB supergravity
4. UV Origin of Membranes: Quantum Hall states have clear string theory membrane origins

Limitations

1. Weak Coupling Assumption: Framework primarily applies to weakly-coupled effective regions
2. Dependence on Topological Properties: Although the bulk theory is non-topological, it still depends on properties of topological operators
3. Higher-dimensional Generalization: Some constructions require further development for higher-dimensional generalization
4. Complete Classification: Complete classification of all possible boundary conditions and symmetries remains incomplete

Future Directions

1. Conformal Boundary Theories: Study of bulk theory coupled to conformal field theories
2. Membrane Worldvolume Theory: Complete analysis of membrane worldvolume theory and quantum Hall states
3. Categorification: Establish categorical formulation of non-finite symmetries
4. Defect Condensation: Study condensation phenomena of topological defects

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Conceptual Innovation: SymTh concept provides new perspective for symmetry research, naturally unifying finite and non-finite cases
2. Technical Rigor: Mathematical derivations are rigorous, with detailed analysis from 2D exact solutions to higher-dimensional constructions
3. Physical Insight: Reveals deep connections between boundary conditions and symmetry projections
4. String Theory Connection: Natural connection to high-energy theory strengthens the foundational nature of the framework

Weaknesses

1. Computational Complexity: Non-topological theories are computationally more complex than SymTFT, limiting application scope
2. Strong Coupling Region: Treatment of strong coupling cases still requires development
3. Limited Examples: Relatively few examples of high-dimensional non-invertible symmetries
4. Experimental Verification: Lacks direct connection to condensed matter or other experimental systems

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important supplement and development to generalized symmetry theory
2. Cross-disciplinary Connection: Connects topological field theory, string theory, and condensed matter physics
3. Methodological Value: Generalization of sandwich construction has broad application prospects
4. Future Development: Establishes foundation for systematic study of non-invertible symmetries

Applicable Scenarios

1. Continuous Symmetry Systems: Particularly suitable for theories with U(1) or non-abelian continuous symmetries
2. Axion Physics: Direct application value for axion-Maxwell theories
3. Holographic Duality: Important applications in holographic dualities such as AdS/CFT
4. Topological Phase Transitions: Can be used to study topological phase transitions involving symmetry breaking

References

The paper cites extensive related work, primarily including:

• Foundational work on SymTFT by Gaiotto et al. 1-14
• Recent advances in continuous symmetry generalization 15-17
• Research on non-invertible symmetries and 2-groups 21-27, 47-58
• Related work in string theory and holographic duality 28, 62-67

Summary: The SymTh framework proposed in this paper provides an important new tool for studying non-finite symmetries with potential applications across multiple branches of theoretical physics. While computational complexity and strong coupling treatment require further development, its conceptual innovation and natural connection to string theory make it an important contribution to the field.