Effect of torsion in long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2403.09105
• Title: Effect of torsion in long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments
• Authors: Papia Panda, Dinesh Kumar Singha, Monojit Ghosh, Rukmani Mohanta
• Categories: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Submission Date: March 14, 2024 (arXiv submission)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09105

Abstract

This study investigates the effects of curved spacetime on neutrino oscillations. In curved spacetime, the influence of curvature on fermionic fields is represented through the spin connection. The spin connection contains a non-universal "torsion" component, expressed in terms of vector and axial-vector current densities of fermions. The contraction of the torsion component with the tetrad field (connecting the flat internal space metric and spacetime metric) is termed torsion. When neutrinos propagate through ordinary matter backgrounds with curved spacetime, the Hamiltonian of neutrino oscillations is modified by torsion coupling constants λ'₂₁ and λ'₃₁. This work aims to investigate the effects of λ'₂₁ and λ'₃₁ in the DUNE and P2SO experiments, including: (i) discussing the impact of torsion coupling constants on neutrino oscillation probabilities, (ii) estimating the constraining capabilities of P2SO and DUNE on these parameters, and (iii) investigating changes in physical sensitivities in the presence of torsion.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

In the Standard Model (SM), neutrinos are considered massless due to the absence of right-handed neutrino partners that would prevent mass acquisition through the conventional Higgs mechanism. However, experimental evidence confirms that neutrinos do oscillate, requiring non-zero neutrino masses and thus necessitating mechanisms beyond the Standard Model.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Completeness Requirement: Existing neutrino oscillation theory typically neglects gravitational effects, but all fermions and bosons are subject to gravity. Therefore, all known physical interactions, including gravity, should be considered in neutrino oscillation calculations.
2. Curved Spacetime Effects: In curved spacetime, fermionic properties are affected. The traditional Dirac equation requires modification to accommodate the effects of spacetime curvature on fermionic propagation, involving the concept of spin connection.
3. Experimental Verification Opportunity: The forthcoming long-baseline neutrino experiments DUNE and P2SO provide the best opportunity to verify torsion effects, as they feature longer baselines and larger statistical samples.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

Previous research primarily focused on the effects of torsion on neutrino oscillation probabilities but lacked systematic studies of experimental sensitivity. This paper provides the first quantitative estimation of neutrino oscillation experiment sensitivity in the presence of gravity.

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete theoretical framework for torsion neutrino oscillations: Based on the Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble (ECSK) formalism, derived neutrino oscillation probability expressions incorporating torsion effects.
2. Systematically analyzed experimental constraints on torsion parameters: Provided the first quantitative assessment of DUNE and P2SO experiment capabilities in constraining torsion coupling constants λ'₂₁ and λ'₃₁.
3. Revealed differential effects of torsion on different oscillation channels: Found that appearance channels are primarily sensitive to λ'₂₁, while disappearance channels are mainly sensitive to λ'₃₁.
4. Assessed torsion's impact on physical sensitivities: Analyzed changes in CP violation, mass ordering, and θ₂₃ octant sensitivities in the presence of torsion.

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

Based on ECSK gravitational theory, the spin connection can be written as:

A^{ab}_μ = ω^{ab}_μ + Λ^{ab}_μ

where ω^{ab}_μ is the pure gravitational component and Λ^{ab}_μ is the non-universal "torsion" component.

Modified Hamiltonian

In the presence of torsion, the total Hamiltonian for neutrino oscillations is:

H_total = H_vac + H_mat + H_tor

The torsion term is:

H_tor = Σᵢ λᵢ ν†ᵢ P_L νᵢ ñ

Effective Mass-Squared Differences

Torsion effects result in effective mass-squared differences:

Δm̃²₃₁ = Δm²₃₁ + 2Enₑλ'₃₁
Δm̃²₂₁ = Δm²₂₁ + 2Enₑλ'₂₁

Oscillation Probability Expression

The appearance probability can be decomposed into three terms:

P_{νμ→νₑ} = P₁ + P₂ + P₃

• P₁: Leading term, independent of λ'₂₁
• P₂: First subleading term, dependent on both λ'₂₁ and λ'₃₁
• P₃: Second subleading term, independent of λ'₃₁

Experimental Setup

DUNE Experiment Configuration

• Baseline: 1300 km (FNAL to SURF)
• Detector: Four 10 kt liquid argon time projection chambers (LArTPC)
• Beam Power: 1.2 MW
• Running Time: 13 years total (6.5 years neutrino mode + 6.5 years antineutrino mode)

P2SO Experiment Configuration

• Baseline: 2595 km (Protvino to Super-ORCA)
• Detector: Several Mt fiber detector volume
• Beam Power: 450 KW (4×10²⁰ POT)
• Running Time: 6 years total (3 years neutrino mode + 3 years antineutrino mode)

Simulation Tools

GLoBES software was used for simulations with modifications to the probability engine to include torsion effects. Poisson log-likelihood formula was employed to calculate χ².

Oscillation Parameters

True values from Table II were used, including:

• θ₁₂ = 33.41°, θ₁₃ = 8.58°, θ₂₃ = 42°
• δ_CP = 230°
• Δm²₂₁ = 7.41×10⁻⁵ eV², Δm²₃₁ = ±2.507×10⁻³ eV²

Experimental Results

Impact on Oscillation Probabilities

1. Appearance Channel: The effect of λ'₂₁ is far greater than λ'₃₁, consistent with theoretical expectations, as the P₁ term is independent of λ'₂₁, but P₂ and P₃ terms are modified by λ'₂₁.
2. Disappearance Channel: The effect of λ'₃₁ is more significant, primarily through the Δ̃ in the leading term.
3. Oscillation Extremum Shift: Torsion coupling causes significant displacement of oscillation maximum/minimum positions.

Torsion Parameter Constraints

Single-parameter constraints (2σ confidence level):

• DUNE: |λ'₂₁| < 0.040 G_F, |λ'₃₁| < 0.043 G_F
• P2SO: |λ'₂₁| < 0.022 G_F, |λ'₃₁| < 0.016 G_F

Two-parameter constraints (2σ confidence level):

• DUNE: |λ'₂₁| < 0.080 G_F, |λ'₃₁| < 0.080 G_F
• P2SO: |λ'₂₁| < 0.130 G_F, |λ'₃₁| < 0.100 G_F

Background Effect Analysis

The large background in P2SO (primarily from misidentified muons) significantly limits its measurement capability for λ'₂₁, while DUNE performs better in this regard.

Physical Sensitivity Changes

1. CP Violation: Primarily affected by λ'₂₁, with minor influence from λ'₃₁
2. Mass Ordering: Shows minimal variation in DUNE, while λ'₂₁ and λ'₃₁ exhibit opposite trends in P2SO
3. Octant: Primarily affected by λ'₂₁, with sensitivity decreasing as the parameter varies from negative to positive values
4. Atmospheric Parameter Precision: Precision measurements of θ₂₃ and Δm²₃₁ are virtually unaffected

Related Work

Theoretical Development

The application of torsion gravitational theory in neutrino physics has a rich theoretical foundation, including:

• Torsion effects in Einstein-Cartan theory
• Dirac equation modifications in curved spacetime
• Spin connection and tetrad field formalism

Experimental Constraints

Existing experimental constraints on torsion coupling:

• Electron-electron sector: |λ^V_e λ^A_e| < 1.917×10⁻⁸ GeV⁻²
• Lepton-quark sector: |λₑλ_q| < 1.429×10⁻⁷ GeV⁻²

The constraints obtained in the neutrino sector in this paper are consistent in order of magnitude with the above results.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Framework: Successfully established three-flavor neutrino oscillation theory incorporating torsion effects, revealing differential sensitivities of different oscillation channels to torsion parameters.
2. Experimental Constraining Capability: P2SO outperforms DUNE in single-parameter constraints, but DUNE performs better in the two-parameter case, primarily due to background issues in P2SO.
3. Physical Impact: Torsion effects primarily influence CP violation and octant sensitivity, with variable impacts on mass ordering depending on the experiment.

Limitations

1. Theoretical Assumptions: Neglects torsion coupling of right-handed neutrinos, assuming their contribution is negligible
2. Experimental Conditions: Large background in P2SO limits its capability in certain measurements
3. Parameter Correlations: Two-parameter analysis reveals strong correlations, resulting in significantly weakened constraints

Future Directions

1. More Precise Theoretical Calculations: Consider higher-order corrections and complete left-right-handed neutrino coupling
2. Experimental Optimization: Improve background suppression capabilities in P2SO
3. Other Experimental Verification: Seek evidence of torsion effects in other types of neutrino experiments

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic study of torsion effects' sensitivity in long-baseline neutrino experiments, filling a gap in the field.
2. Rigorous Methodology: Based on the mature ECSK theoretical framework with complete mathematical derivations and clear physical pictures.
3. Experiment-Oriented: Detailed analysis targeting specific DUNE and P2SO experiments with strong practical value.
4. Comprehensive Analysis: Not only investigates parameter constraints but also analyzes impacts on various physical sensitivities.

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Simplification: Neglecting right-handed neutrino coupling may underestimate certain effects.
2. Experimental Limitations: Background issues in P2SO somewhat limit the generalizability of results.
3. Parameter Degeneracy: Strong correlations in two-parameter analysis suggest additional information is needed to fully determine torsion parameters.

Impact

1. Academic Value: Opens new directions for cross-disciplinary research between gravity and neutrino physics.
2. Experimental Guidance: Provides important reference for design and data analysis of future long-baseline experiments.
3. Theoretical Development: Advances phenomenological studies of particle physics in curved spacetime.

Applicable Scenarios

This research is particularly suitable for:

• Precision measurements in long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments
• Theoretical research at the intersection of gravity and particle physics
• Indirect detection of new physics beyond the Standard Model

References

The paper cites 71 references covering multiple aspects including neutrino physics, gravitational theory, and experimental techniques, reflecting the interdisciplinary nature of the research and solid theoretical foundation.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions to the frontier interdisciplinary field of gravitational effects on neutrino oscillations. The research methodology is rigorous, the analysis comprehensive, and the work has significant implications for future experiments.