A Constant self-consistent scattering lifetime in superconducting Strontium Ruthenate

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2404.06262
• Title: A Constant self-consistent scattering lifetime in superconducting Strontium Ruthenate
• Author: Pedro L. Contreras E. (Department of Physics, Universidad de los Andes, Venezuela)
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con cond-mat.dis-nn cond-mat.stat-mech
• Research Field: Condensed Matter Physics - Theory of Unconventional Superconductivity
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06262

Abstract

This numerical study investigates triplet-pairing unconventional superconductor strontium ruthenate (Sr₂RuO₄) and discovers a self-consistent constant scattering superconducting lifetime for two different disorder parameter values (antisitic strength and stoichiometric impurities). This finding is significant for experimentalists, as expressions for ultrasonic attenuation and electronic thermal conductivity depend on the superconducting scattering lifetime, and the constant lifetime provides excellent fits to non-equilibrium experimental data. Furthermore, the study reveals a minute imaginary part of the self-energy, analogous to the Miyake-Narikiyo minute gap observed beyond the single elastic scattering limit and below the 1.0 meV zero-gap threshold.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core question addressed in this research is: Why does the superconducting scattering lifetime τₛ in the unconventional superconductor strontium ruthenate remain constant in the presence of disorder?

Research Significance

1. Experimental data fitting requirements: Fitting non-equilibrium experimental data for ultrasonic attenuation and electronic thermal conductivity requires the use of constant scattering lifetimes
2. Missing theoretical explanation: Although constant scattering lifetime phenomena are observed experimentally, self-consistent theoretical explanations are lacking
3. Understanding unconventional superconductivity: Contributes to understanding the scattering mechanisms in time-reversal symmetry-breaking triplet superconductors

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Non-self-consistent treatment: Previous studies predominantly employed phenomenological constant lifetime assumptions without self-consistent calculations
2. Single-parameter studies: Lack of systematic investigation of different disorder parameter combinations
3. Theory-experiment disconnect: Theoretical calculations struggle to explain the constant lifetime phenomena observed experimentally

Core Contributions

1. First self-consistent proof: Numerically demonstrates self-consistently the existence of constant superconducting scattering lifetime in strontium ruthenate
2. Multi-parameter analysis: Systematically investigates scattering lifetime behavior under two different disorder parameter combinations
3. Minute gap discovery: Identifies Miyake-Narikiyo-like minute gap structures beyond the single scattering limit
4. Theoretical support for experimental data: Provides theoretical foundation for fitting ultrasonic attenuation and electronic thermal conductivity experimental data

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The research objective is to calculate the scattering lifetime of strontium ruthenate under different disorder parameters using self-consistent Green's function methods and verify its constancy.

Input: Disorder parameters (c, Γ₊), zero-gap parameter Δ₀, Fermi level εF Output: Self-consistent scattering lifetime τₛ and imaginary part of self-energy ImΣ̃Constraints: Self-consistency conditions and physical reasonableness

Model Architecture

1. Self-consistent Equation System

The core self-consistent equation is:

Σ̃(ω + i0⁺) = ω + iπΓ₊ g(Σ̃)/(c² + g²(Σ̃))

Where:

• g(Σ̃) = ⟨Σ̃/√(Σ̃² - |Δ|²(kₓ,kᵧ))⟩FS is the Fermi surface averaged function
• c = (πNFU₀)⁻¹ is the dimensionless antisite strength parameter
• Γ₊ = ndis/(π²NF) is the stoichiometric impurity concentration parameter

2. Scattering Lifetime Calculation

The scattering lifetime is calculated via:

1/τₛ = 2Im[Σ̃(ω + i0⁺)]

3. Order Parameter Model

Employs the Miyake-Narikiyo triplet order parameter:

Δ(kₓ,kᵧ) = Δ₀d(kₓ,kᵧ)
d(kₓ,kᵧ) = [sin(kₓa) + i sin(kᵧa)]ẑ

Technical Innovations

1. Reduced phase space analysis: Introduces (ReΣ̃, ImΣ̃) reduced phase space to visualize scattering behavior
2. Multi-parameter scanning: Systematically scans zero-gap parameter Δ₀ from 0 to 1.0 meV
3. Self-consistent numerical solution: Addresses numerical challenges in handling rapidly varying dependent variable Σ̃

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Fermi level: εF = 0.4 meV
• Hopping parameter: t = 0.4 meV
• Zero-gap range: Δ₀ = 0.0-1.0 meV (step size 0.1 meV)

Disorder Parameter Combinations

1. Dilute disorder: c = 0.2, Γ₊ = 0.05 meV
2. Rich disorder: c = 0.4, Γ₊ = 0.20 meV
3. Comparative parameters: c = 0.2, Γ₊ = 0.10, 0.15 meV

Numerical Methods

• Uses rationalized Planck units (ℏ = kB = c = 1)
• Tight-binding model for anisotropic Fermi surface
• Self-consistent iterative solution of nonlinear equation systems

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Dilute Disorder Case (c = 0.2, Γ₊ = 0.05 meV)

• Constant frequency interval: Real frequency (0.00, 0.26) meV
• Superconducting imaginary part: ImΣ̃ = 0.362 meV
• Normal state imaginary part: ImΣ̃ = 0.149 meV
• Lifetime ratio: τₛ/τₙ = 0.390

2. Rich Disorder Case (c = 0.4, Γ₊ = 0.20 meV)

• Constant frequency interval: Real frequency (0.00, 0.36) meV
• Superconducting imaginary part: ImΣ̃ = 0.749 meV
• Normal state imaginary part: ImΣ̃ = 0.524 meV
• Lifetime ratio: τₛ/τₙ = 0.686

Minute Gap Phenomena

Minute gap structures observed at Δ₀ = 0.8, 0.9, 1.0 meV:

• Gap increases with increasing Δ₀
• Manifests as sharp decrease in imaginary part in reduced phase space
• Analogous to the Miyake-Narikiyo predicted minute gap

Experimental Findings

1. Enhanced superconducting scattering: Collision frequency in superconducting state is approximately twice that of normal state
2. Disorder concentration effects: Rich disorder leads to larger scattering rates and wider constant frequency intervals
3. Smooth phase transitions: Phase transition points exhibit smooth transitions, reflecting the non-local nature of triplet superconductivity

Related Work

Theoretical Background

1. Miyake-Narikiyo model: Provides theoretical foundation for Sr₂RuO₄ triplet order parameter
2. Green's function formalism: Provides framework for calculating non-equilibrium transport properties
3. Self-consistent scattering theory: Establishes theoretical description of disordered superconductors

Experimental Connections

1. Ultrasonic attenuation experiments: Angle-resolved ultrasonic attenuation measurements by Lupien et al.
2. Thermal conductivity measurements: Directional magnetic field thermal conductivity experiments by Tanatar et al.
3. Specific heat experiments: Verification of gap structure anisotropy

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Existence of constant lifetime: Constant superconducting scattering lifetime observed under both disorder parameter regimes
2. Self-consistency verification: Numerical calculations confirm the self-consistency of constant lifetime
3. Experimental data support: Provides theoretical foundation for fitting ultrasonic attenuation and thermal conductivity experimental data

Physical Picture

The migration and aggregation of strontium atoms in the lattice form a metallic state with constant lifetime, a phenomenon observable under both dilute and rich disorder conditions.

Limitations

1. Parameter range restrictions: Study primarily focuses on regions beyond c = 0
2. Model simplifications: Employs relatively simple tight-binding model
3. Temperature effects: Does not account for finite temperature effects

Future Directions

1. Three-dimensional effects: Consider the quasi-two-dimensional nature of Sr₂RuO₄
2. Multi-orbital effects: Include contributions from α, β, γ Fermi surface sheets
3. Experimental verification: Quantitative comparison with additional experimental data

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First self-consistent explanation of constant scattering lifetime phenomenon
2. Numerical rigor: Employs comprehensive self-consistent calculation methods
3. Practical value: Directly serves experimental data analysis
4. Physical insight: Reveals unique scattering mechanisms in triplet superconductors

Weaknesses

1. Model limitations: Tight-binding model may be oversimplified
2. Parameter selection: Physical justification for certain parameter choices insufficient
3. Experimental comparison: Lacks direct quantitative comparison with latest experimental data
4. Mechanism explanation: Microscopic mechanism explanation for constant lifetime remains incomplete

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new computational framework for unconventional superconductor theory
2. Experimental guidance: Helps experimentalists better understand and analyze data
3. Method generalization: Self-consistent calculation methods generalizable to other unconventional superconductors

Applicable Scenarios

1. Unconventional superconductors: Particularly suitable for time-reversal symmetry-breaking superconductors
2. Transport property calculations: Provides foundation for calculating ultrasonic attenuation, thermal conductivity, and other properties
3. Disorder effect research: Provides tools for investigating disorder effects in superconductors

References

This paper cites 67 important references, covering experimental discoveries, theoretical models, and transport property measurements of Sr₂RuO₄, reflecting the complete development trajectory of this research field.

Summary: This is an important work in unconventional superconductor theory that self-consistently explains for the first time the constant scattering lifetime phenomenon in strontium ruthenate through rigorous numerical calculations, providing a solid theoretical foundation for experimental data analysis and advancing understanding of scattering mechanisms in triplet superconductors.