Violation of Bell inequalities in an analogue black hole

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2404.16497
• Title: Violation of Bell inequalities in an analogue black hole
• Authors: Giorgio Ciliberto, Stephanie Emig, Nicolas Pavloff, Mathieu Isoard
• Classification: quant-ph, cond-mat.quant-gas
• Publication Date: April 2024 (arXiv preprint, updated October 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16497

Abstract

This paper quantitatively evaluates entanglement and nonlocality signals at zero and finite temperatures in an analogue black hole system realized in a quasi-one-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) flow. The inherent Lorentz invariance violation of the analogue system enables the observation of three-mode quantum correlations. The paper investigates corresponding two-particle and three-particle Bell inequality violations. Results demonstrate that the long-wavelength modes of the system are maximally entangled, realizing a superposition of continuous-variable Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, whose entanglement properties resist partial trace operations.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Analogue Gravity Physics: The analogue gravity field aims to provide laboratory models for general relativistic phenomena that cannot be directly observed in traditional gravitational environments, particularly black hole superradiance and Hawking radiation.
2. Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality: In analogue black hole systems, the quantum nature of Hawking radiation manifests as the production of correlated quasiparticle pairs, providing a unique platform for studying quantum entanglement and nonlocality.
3. Technical Challenges: Existing research primarily focuses on bipartite entanglement, while studies of three-particle or multipartite quantum correlations remain relatively scarce, particularly regarding Bell inequality violations in continuous-variable systems.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Refinement: Systematically investigate quantum entanglement properties in analogue black holes, particularly nonlocality in three-mode systems.
2. Experimental Guidance: Provide theoretical predictions and quantitative assessments for future BEC analogue black hole experiments.
3. Fundamental Physics: Explore how Lorentz invariance violation affects the properties of quantum entanglement.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Theoretical Analysis: First systematic study of two-particle and three-particle Bell inequality violations in BEC analogue black holes.
2. GHZ State Structure Discovery: Demonstrates that long-wavelength modes possess the structure of continuous-variable GHZ states and remain entangled after partial trace operations.
3. Temperature Effect Quantification: Provides detailed analysis of finite temperature effects on quantum entanglement and nonlocality.
4. Comparison of Multiple Black Hole Configurations: Investigates three different analogue black hole configurations: waterfall, delta-peak, and flat profiles.
5. Optical Equivalent Model: Establishes an optical equivalent system composed of parametric down-conversion and beam splitters.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate quantum entanglement and nonlocality in analogue black hole systems realized in quasi-one-dimensional BEC flows, specifically including:

• Input: Parameters of the BEC background flow (Mach number, temperature, etc.)
• Output: Nonlocality measures such as CHSH parameter, Svetlichny parameter, Mermin parameter
• Constraints: Validity conditions of the one-dimensional mean-field approximation

Model Architecture

1. Physical System Description

The system is described by quantum field operators $\hat{\Psi}(x,t)$ satisfying: $i\hbar\partial_t\hat{\Psi} = -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\partial_x^2\hat{\Psi} + [U(x) + g\hat{n} - \mu]\hat{\Psi}$

Employing the Bogoliubov approximation: $\hat{\Psi}(x,t) = \Phi(x) + \hat{\psi}(x,t)$

2. Scattering Matrix Description

Outgoing modes are related to incoming modes through the scattering matrix S(ω): $\begin{pmatrix} \hat{c}_0 \\ \hat{c}_1 \\ \hat{c}_2^\dagger \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} S_{00} & S_{01} & S_{02} \\ S_{10} & S_{11} & S_{12} \\ S_{20} & S_{21} & S_{22} \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} \hat{b}_0 \\ \hat{b}_1 \\ \hat{b}_2^\dagger \end{pmatrix}$

where mode 2 possesses negative norm and requires inverse quantization.

3. Pseudo-spin Operators

Discrete pseudo-spin operators are employed via the GKMR formalism: $\hat{\Pi}^{(j)}_x = \int_0^{+\infty} dq (|q\rangle_j {}_j\langle q| - |-q\rangle_j {}_j\langle -q|)$$\hat{\Pi}^{(j)}_y = i\int_0^{+\infty} dq (|q\rangle_j {}_j\langle -q| - |-q\rangle_j {}_j\langle q|)$$\hat{\Pi}^{(j)}_z = \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} dq |q\rangle_j {}_j\langle -q|$

Technical Innovations

1. Continuous-Variable Bell Inequalities: Extension of discrete-variable Bell inequalities to continuous-variable systems through pseudo-spin operator discretization.
2. Three-Mode Analysis: Transcends traditional two-mode analysis limitations by systematically investigating three-mode quantum correlations.
3. Wigner Function Method: Utilizes Wigner transform techniques to calculate expectation values of pseudo-spin operators on Gaussian states.
4. Genetic Algorithm Optimization: Employs genetic algorithms for numerical optimization of multi-parameter Bell operator expectation values.

Experimental Setup

System Parameters

• Waterfall Configuration: Downstream Mach number $m_d = 2.9$ (corresponding to Technion 2019 experiment)
• Temperature Range: $T = 0$ to $T = 0.2 g n_u$
• Frequency Range: $\omega \in [0, \Omega]$, where $\Omega$ is the threshold frequency

Evaluation Metrics

1. PPT Entanglement Measure: $\Lambda^{(i|j)} \in ]-\infty, 1]$
2. CHSH Parameter: $B^{(i|j)} = \max_{a,a',b,b'} \langle\hat{B}^{(i|j)}\rangle$
3. Svetlichny Parameter: $S^{(0|1|2)} = \max \langle\hat{S}^{(0|1|2)}\rangle$
4. Mermin Parameter: $M^{(0|1|2)} = \max |\langle\hat{M}^{(0|1|2)}\rangle|$

Comparison Configurations

• Waterfall configuration
• Delta-peak configuration
• Flat profile configuration

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Bipartite Nonlocality

• At zero temperature, the CHSH parameter reaches a maximum value of approximately 2.25 in the waterfall configuration ($m_d = 2.9$)
• Modes (0|2) and (1|2) both exhibit entanglement, while modes (0|1) remain separable
• Bell inequality violations are more sensitive to temperature than entanglement itself

2. Tripartite Nonlocality

• In the zero-temperature long-wavelength limit, the Svetlichny parameter reaches the upper bound $2\sqrt{2}$
• The Mermin parameter achieves a maximum value of 4 at $\omega = 0, T = 0$
• The system exhibits characteristics of the GHZ paradox

3. Temperature Effects

• Finite temperature significantly suppresses nonlocality signals
• At $T = 0.1 g n_u$, tripartite nonlocality essentially vanishes
• Entanglement measures demonstrate greater resistance to temperature than Bell parameters

Ablation Studies

Analysis of different Mach number configurations reveals:

• $m_u > 0.6$: Entanglement primarily concentrated in modes (0|2)
• $m_u < 0.2$: Entanglement primarily concentrated in modes (1|2)
• In limiting cases $m_u \to 0,1$: System degenerates to EPR states

Key Findings

GHZ State Structure

In the zero-temperature long-wavelength limit, the incoming vacuum state can be expressed as: $|0_{\omega=0}\rangle_{in} = \sum_{l,m,n} C_{l,m,n} (|x_l^+, x_m^-, x_n^-\rangle + |x_l^-, x_m^+, x_n^+\rangle)$

This represents a superposition of infinitely many degenerate GHZ states, explaining why entanglement persists after partial tracing.

Related Work

Analogue Gravity Field

• Surface Gravity Waves: Water tank experiments by Weinfurtner et al.
• Optical Systems: Fiber optics event horizon simulation by Philbin et al.
• BEC Experiments: Pioneering work by Steinhauer et al. at Technion

Continuous-Variable Quantum Information

• Pseudo-spin Methods: Banaszek-Wodkiewicz and GKMR pseudo-spin approaches
• Bell Inequalities: Extensions from CHSH to Svetlichny inequalities
• Entanglement Measures: PPT criterion, logarithmic negativity, entanglement entropy, etc.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. BEC analogue black holes can generate significant bipartite and tripartite quantum entanglement
2. Long-wavelength modes possess unique continuous-variable GHZ state structures
3. Lorentz invariance violation enables three-mode entanglement
4. Temperature is the primary limiting factor for observing quantum nonlocality

Limitations

1. Temperature Sensitivity: Tripartite nonlocality is extremely sensitive to temperature, making experimental observation challenging
2. Theoretical Approximations: Based on Gaussian state assumptions, neglecting nonlinear feedback effects
3. Measurement Challenges: Experimental measurement of certain quantum correlation functions is technically complex

Future Directions

1. Nonlinear Effects: Investigation of non-Gaussian corrections to quantum correlations
2. Alternative Platforms: Extension to other analogue systems such as exciton-polaritons
3. Experimental Implementation: Development of more precise quantum correlation measurement techniques

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Systematic investigation of quantum information properties in analogue black holes
2. Mathematical Rigor: Employs mature quantum optics tools such as Wigner functions
3. Physical Insights: Discovery of novel continuous-variable GHZ state structures
4. Experimental Relevance: Parameter selection aligns with actual BEC experimental conditions

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Feasibility: Observation of tripartite nonlocality presents significant technical challenges
2. Approximation Limitations: One-dimensional mean-field approximation may underestimate certain quantum effects
3. Generalizability: Results primarily target specific BEC systems with limited transferability

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important theoretical foundation for cross-disciplinary research between analogue gravity and quantum information
2. Practical Value: Offers explicit theoretical predictions for future BEC quantum simulation experiments
3. Reproducibility: Detailed mathematical derivations and clear numerical methods facilitate verification and extension

Applicable Scenarios

1. Fundamental Research: Quantum gravity, analogue gravity physics
2. Quantum Technology: Continuous-variable quantum information processing
3. Experimental Physics: Ultracold atoms, BEC quantum simulation

References

The paper cites 116 related references covering multiple domains including analogue gravity, quantum information, and BEC physics, particularly:

• Hawking (1975) black hole radiation theory
• BEC analogue black hole experiments by Steinhauer et al.
• Theoretical foundations of Bell inequalities and quantum entanglement
• Mathematical tools for continuous-variable quantum information