Spin-spin interaction mediated by chiral phonons

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2405.08554
• Title: Spin-spin interaction mediated by chiral phonons
• Author: Takehito Yokoyama (Tokyo Institute of Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall (Condensed Matter Physics - Mesoscopic and Hall Effects)
• Publication Date: July 12, 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08554

Abstract

This paper investigates the interaction between two magnetic impurities on the surface of a two-dimensional insulator in the presence of chiral phonons using second-order perturbation theory. The study demonstrates that this exchange interaction originates from the angular momentum of phonons and is mediated through spin-chiral phonon coupling (analogous to spin-orbit coupling). Analytical expressions for the interaction of acoustic and optical phonons are derived. Due to the bosonic nature of phonons, the exchange interaction is always positive. The research reveals that the exchange interaction for both acoustic and optical phonons decays as a power law with the distance between two magnetic impurities and is proportional to system temperature at high temperatures.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed in this paper is: How do chiral phonons mediate spin-spin interactions between magnetic impurities, and what are the microscopic mechanisms and characteristic scaling laws of this interaction?

Research Significance

1. Emerging Physical Phenomena: Chiral phonons are circularly polarized ionic vibration modes possessing angular momentum and magnetic moments, capable of generating effective magnetic fields (approximately 0.01 T in tellurium, reaching 100 T in cerium trichloride)
2. Experimental Observations Requiring Theoretical Explanation: Recent experiments have reported long-range exchange interactions through 30 nm thick insulators, hypothesized to be mediated by elliptically polarized phonons
3. Filling Theoretical Gaps: Traditional spin-spin interactions are primarily studied in electronic systems, while the mechanisms of boson-mediated interactions remain unclear

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Electron-mediated exchange interactions in insulators exhibit exponential decay
• Lack of systematic theoretical studies on phonon-mediated (particularly chiral phonon-mediated) magnetic interactions
• Characteristic scaling laws of boson-mediated interactions remain unestablished

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Establishment: First systematic investigation of spin-spin interaction mechanisms mediated by chiral phonons
2. Analytical Expressions Derivation: Separate derivation of exchange interaction formulas for acoustic and optical phonon cases
3. Bosonic Characteristics Revelation: Demonstration that exchange interactions are always positive due to the bosonic nature of phonons (contrasting with oscillatory behavior of RKKY interactions)
4. Scaling Relationship Establishment: Discovery of power-law behavior in the distance and temperature dependence of interaction strength

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of the effective interaction between two localized spins S₁ and S₂ on the surface of a two-dimensional insulator in the presence of chiral phonons, with the system Hamiltonian as input and effective exchange coupling strength as output.

Model Architecture

1. System Hamiltonian

Phonon Part:

H₀ = Σ_{qν} ωqν a†_{qν} a_{qν}

where a†{qν} (a{qν}) are phonon creation (annihilation) operators for wave vector q and mode ν.

Angular Momentum Representation: The z-direction angular momentum of chiral phonons is:

Lz = (1/2) Σ_{q,ν} ν φ†_{qν} τ₂ φ_{qν}

where ν = ± labels circularly polarized modes, and τ₂ is the Pauli matrix.

2. Spin-Phonon Coupling

Employing spin-orbit coupling form:

V = λLz Σᵢ δ(r-Rᵢ)Sᵢᶻ

where λ is the coupling strength and Rᵢ is the spin position.

3. Phonon Green's Function

Defining the phonon Green's function:

D(q,τ,ν) = -⟨Tτ[φ_{qν}(τ)φ†_{qν}]⟩

After Fourier transformation:

D(q,ωₙ,ν) = 1/(ω²ₙ + ω²_{qν}) (-ωqν  ωₙ)
                                    (-ωₙ  -ωqν)

Technical Innovations

1. Second-Order Perturbation Theory Treatment

Computing effective interactions through second-order correction to free energy:

δF = (λ²/8)S₁ᶻS₂ᶻT Σₙ,ν tr[τ₂D(R₁-R₂,ωₙ,ν)τ₂D(R₂-R₁,ωₙ,ν)]

2. Acoustic Phonon Case (ωqν = vₐq)

Utilizing modified Bessel functions I₀, K₀ and Struve function L₀, obtaining Green's function components:

D₀(R,ωₙ,ν) = -1/(2πvₐ)[1/R - π|ωₙ|/(2vₐ)I₀(ωₙR/vₐ) + πωₙ/(2vₐ)L₀(ωₙR/vₐ)]
D₂(R,ωₙ,ν) = ωₙ/(2πv²ₐ)K₀(|ωₙ|R/vₐ)

3. Optical Phonon Case (ωqν = ω₀)

D₀(R,ωₙ,ν) = -1/(2π) × ω₀/(ω²ₙ + ω²₀) × ΛJ₁(ΛR)/R
D₂(R,ωₙ,ν) = 1/(2π) × ωₙ/(ω²ₙ + ω²₀) × ΛJ₁(ΛR)/R

Experimental Setup

Parameter Estimation

• Coupling strength: λ = 10 meV/nm²
• Temperature: T = 300 K
• Acoustic phonon velocity: vₐ = 10⁴ m/s
• Optical phonon frequency: ω₀ = 10 meV
• Cutoff wave vector: Λ = 10¹⁰/m
• Typical distance: R = 1 nm

Evaluation Metrics

• Magnitude of exchange coupling strength
• Power-law exponent of distance dependence
• Temperature dependence relationship

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Acoustic Phonon Exchange Interaction

Jₐᶻ = (λ²/8π²vₐR³)xF(x)

where x = TR/vₐ and F(x) is a composite function containing modified Bessel functions.

Scaling Behavior:

• R < ξₜ (ξₜ = vₐ/T is thermal coherence length): Jₐᶻ ∼ T²/R
• R > ξₜ: Jₐᶻ ∼ T/R²
• Numerical estimate: Jₐᶻ ∼ 10⁻² eV

2. Optical Phonon Exchange Interaction

Jᵒᶻ = (λ²/32π²) × (ΛJ₁(ΛR))²/(R²T sinh²(ω₀/2T))

Asymptotic Behavior:

• T → 0: Jᵒᶻ ∼ e^(-ω₀/T)/T
• T → ∞: Jᵒᶻ ∼ T
• R → 0: Jᵒᶻ ∼ constant
• R → ∞: Jᵒᶻ ∼ R⁻³cos²(ΛR - 3π/4)
• Numerical estimate: Jᵒᶻ ∼ 10⁻⁴ eV

Key Findings

1. Positive Exchange Coupling: Jᶻ > 0 in all cases, reflecting bosonic characteristics
2. Power-Law Decay: Contrasting with exponential decay of electron-mediated interactions
3. Temperature Dependence: Zero at zero temperature, linear growth at high temperatures
4. Oscillatory Behavior: Optical phonon case exhibits RKKY-like oscillations at large distances, but without sign changes

Related Work

Chiral Phonon Research Progress

• Zhang & Niu (2014-2015): Establishing theoretical foundations of chiral phonons
• Experimental Observations: Zhu et al. (2018) observed chiral phonons in molybdenum disulfide
• Magnetic Field Effects: Nova et al. (2017) reported effective magnetic fields generated by chiral phonons

Spin-Phonon Coupling

• Traditional research primarily focuses on RKKY interactions in electronic systems
• Recent studies begin addressing phonon-mediated magnetic interactions
• This paper is the first systematic investigation of angular momentum effects of chiral phonons

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Mechanism Clarification: Chiral phonons mediate exchange interactions through coupling of their angular momentum with spin
2. Bosonic Characteristics: Interactions are always positive without RKKY-style sign oscillations
3. Scaling Relationships: Established power-law dependence on distance and temperature
4. Experimentally Testable: Provides criteria for distinguishing phonon and electron contributions (power-law vs. exponential decay)

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: Assumes coupling strength λ as constant, which may have temperature dependence in reality
2. Two-Dimensional Restriction: Only considers two-dimensional systems; three-dimensional cases may differ
3. Perturbative Approximation: Only second-order terms considered; strong coupling cases require higher-order corrections
4. Idealized Assumptions: Neglects disorder, defects, and other realistic factors

Future Directions

1. Experimental Verification: Measurement of exchange coupling strength at different distances and temperatures
2. Three-Dimensional Extension: Investigation of chiral phonon effects in three-dimensional systems
3. Strong Coupling Theory: Development of theoretical methods beyond perturbation theory
4. Device Applications: Exploration of potential applications in spintronics devices

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic investigation of magnetic interactions mediated by chiral phonons, filling an important theoretical gap
2. Mathematical Rigor: Employs standard Green's function methods and perturbation theory with rigorous derivations
3. Physical Insight: Clearly elucidates the fundamental distinction between boson- and fermion-mediated interactions
4. Practical Value: Provides experimentally testable predictions and criteria

Weaknesses

1. Missing Experimental Comparison: Lacks direct comparison with existing experimental data for verification
2. Rough Parameter Estimation: Key parameter estimates (e.g., coupling strength) lack sufficient justification
3. Limited Applicability: Assumptions of two-dimensionality and weak coupling restrict result generality
4. Insufficient Mechanism Discussion: Limited discussion of chiral phonon generation mechanisms and material dependence

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides important theoretical foundation for chiral phonon physics with expected high citation rate
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers theoretical guidance and predictions for related experimental design
3. Technical Application: May inspire design concepts for novel spintronics devices
4. Field Advancement: Contributes to development of the emerging field of phononic spintronics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Two-Dimensional Magnetic Materials: Such as magnetic 2D materials/insulator heterostructures
2. Chiral Crystals: Material systems with chiral phonon modes
3. Spintronics Devices: Device applications requiring long-range magnetic coupling
4. Quantum Magnetism Research: Theoretical tools for studying novel quantum magnetic phenomena

References

The paper cites 44 important references, covering:

• Theoretical foundations of chiral phonons (Zhang & Niu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 2014-2015)
• Experimental observations (Zhu et al., Science 2018; Chen et al., Nat. Phys. 2019)
• RKKY interactions (Ruderman & Kittel, 1954; Kasuya, 1956; Yosida, 1957)
• Condensed matter field theory methods (Altland & Simons; Nagaosa)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions to the emerging field of chiral phonons. Despite certain limitations, its theoretical innovation and experimental guidance value make it an important reference in this field.