Tetraquarks from Intrinsic Heavy Quarks

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2405.09018
• Title: Tetraquarks from Intrinsic Heavy Quarks
• Author: R. Vogt (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory & University of California, Davis)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024 (v3)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09018

Abstract

Numerous new tetraquark states containing 1-4 charm or anticharm quarks have been observed in recent years, with many discovered at the LHC. This paper investigates the mechanism of producing these states through intrinsic charm quarks in protons. Although the tetraquark masses obtained by this approach depend on the intrinsic transverse momentum of partons in the state, they show good agreement with experimentally measured masses. These calculations provide insights into the nature of tetraquark candidate states—whether they are bound meson pairs or loosely bound configurations of four independent partons. The paper also investigates the kinematic distributions of these states in rapidity and transverse momentum, and considers possible production cross sections.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Discovery of Tetraquark States: Since the Belle collaboration first discovered X(3872) in 2003, particularly in the LHC era, numerous new tetraquark candidate states have been observed, including states containing different numbers of charm quarks.
2. Theoretical Challenges: Tetraquark states extend beyond the scope of the traditional quark model. While the Standard Model does not forbid such states, their internal structure and production mechanisms remain controversial.
3. Production Mechanism Issues: Existing perturbative QCD approaches have difficulty fully explaining the production characteristics of these states, particularly in certain kinematic regions.

Research Motivation

• Utilize the intrinsic heavy quark model to investigate tetraquark production mechanisms
• Determine the internal structure of tetraquark states (meson pairs vs. tetraquark clusters) through mass distribution calculations
• Predict kinematic distributions and production cross sections of tetraquark states
• Provide theoretical guidance for experimental observations

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Application of Intrinsic Charm Quark Model: Systematically applies the intrinsic heavy quark model developed by Brodsky et al. to tetraquark production research
2. Mass Prediction and Structure Determination: Successfully predicts masses of multiple tetraquark candidate states through different k_T integration ranges and can distinguish between meson pair structures and tetraquark cluster structures
3. Kinematic Distribution Calculations: Provides detailed calculations of rapidity and transverse momentum distributions of tetraquark states at LHC energies, revealing forward-peaked and high-p_T tail characteristics
4. Cross Section Estimation: Provides upper limit estimates of tetraquark production cross sections and compares them with experimental data

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate the process of tetraquark state production through soft interactions from intrinsic heavy quark Fock states in protons, calculating their mass distributions, kinematic distributions, and production cross sections.

Theoretical Framework

Intrinsic Heavy Quark Model Foundation

The proton wave function can be expressed as a superposition of Fock state fluctuations of the fundamental |uud⟩ state: $|\text{proton}\rangle = \alpha_0|uud\rangle + \alpha_1|uudg\rangle + \alpha_2|uudq\bar{q}\rangle + \alpha_3|uudQ\bar{Q}\rangle + \cdots$

The probability distribution for n-particle Fock states is: $dP_{ic}^n = P_{ic}^{0n} N_n \int dx_1 \cdots dx_n \int dk_{x1} \cdots dk_{xn} \int dk_{y1} \cdots dk_{yn} \frac{\delta(1-\sum_{i=1}^n x_i)\delta(\sum_{i=1}^n k_{xi})\delta(\sum_{i=1}^n k_{yi})}{(m_p^2 - \sum_{i=1}^n m_{Ti}^2/x_i)^2}$

Tetraquark Production Mechanisms

Meson Pair Structure Hypothesis

If the tetraquark state is viewed as a bound meson pair, the mass distribution is: $\frac{dP_{ic}^n}{dM_{TQ}^2} = \int \frac{dx_{M1}}{x_{M1}} \frac{dx_{M2}}{x_{M2}} \int dm_{M1}^2 dm_{M2}^2 \int dk_{xM1} dk_{yM1} dk_{xM2} dk_{yM2} \int \frac{dx_{TQ}}{x_{TQ}} \int dk_{xTQ} dk_{yTQ} dP_{ic}^n \times \text{[momentum conservation constraints]}$

Tetraquark Cluster Hypothesis

If the tetraquark state is viewed as a loosely bound cluster of four quarks: $\frac{dP_{ic}^n}{dM_{TQ}^2} = \int \frac{dx_{TQ}}{x_{TQ}} \int dk_{xTQ} dk_{yTQ} dP_{ic}^n \delta\left(\frac{M_{T,TQ}^2}{x_{TQ}} - \sum_{i=4}^7 \frac{m_{Ti}^2}{x_i}\right) \times \text{[momentum conservation constraints]}$

Technical Innovations

1. k_T Range Parameterization: Distinguishes excited and ground states through different transverse momentum integration ranges
2. Structure Discrimination Method: Utilizes mass distribution shapes to determine internal structure of tetraquark states
3. Multi-Fock State Calculations: Systematically considers contributions from 7-particle and 9-particle states
4. Energy Dependence Analysis: Detailed investigation of energy dependence of kinematic distributions

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

Based on tetraquark candidate states in Table I, including:

• Four Charm Quarks: T_ψψ(6600), T_ψψ(6900)
• Two Charm Quarks: X(3872), X_s states, T_cc^-, T_ccs states
• One Charm Quark: T_cs states, T_cs0^a states

Calculation Parameters

• Quark Masses: m_q = 0.01 GeV, m_s = 0.3 GeV, m_c = 1.27 GeV
• k_T Integration Ranges: Four parameter sets (kt1-kt4), corresponding to different binding strengths
• Energy Range: √s = 5, 7, 13 TeV (LHC energies)

Evaluation Metrics

• Mean and width of mass distributions
• Rapidity and transverse momentum distributions
• Production cross section estimates

Experimental Results

Mass Prediction Results

Meson Pair Structure States

Tetraquark Cluster States

Kinematic Distribution Characteristics

Rapidity Distribution

• Exhibits forward-peaked behavior at LHC energies
• Average rapidity increases with energy: at √s=7 TeV, ⟨y⟩~6-7
• Rapidity distribution differences between different mass states approximately 0.1 units

Transverse Momentum Distribution

• Integrated over full rapidity: ⟨p_T⟩ ~ 3-4 GeV
• In 2.5<y<5 interval: ⟨p_T⟩ ~ 20-50 GeV, increasing with energy
• Exhibits hard spectrum characteristics, differing from perturbative QCD expectations

Cross Section Estimates

• 7-particle states: 10.2 nb ≤ σ ≤ 465 nb
• States containing s quarks: 0.10 μb ≤ σ ≤ 4.6 μb
• J/ψ Formation Factor Correction: Requires additional 2% suppression factor

Related Work

Tetraquark Theory Research

• Gell-Mann (1964): Early proposal of multiquark state possibility
• Jaffe (1977): Q²Q̄² mesons in bag model
• Recent extensive theoretical work on tetraquark spectroscopy and decays

Intrinsic Heavy Quark Research

• Brodsky et al. (1980-1981): Establishment of intrinsic charm quark model
• Inclusion of intrinsic charm quarks in global PDF analyses
• Explanation of forward charm quark production in fixed-target experiments

Experimental Discoveries

• Belle, BESIII: Earliest tetraquark state discoveries
• LHC collaborations: Discovery of numerous new states
• Only X(3872) officially listed by PDG

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Mass Predictions: The intrinsic charm quark model reasonably predicts tetraquark candidate state masses with errors at the few-hundred MeV level
2. Structure Discrimination: Calculations indicate that X(3872), X_s, and T_cc^- are more consistent with meson pair structures, while T_ccs and T_cs states are more consistent with tetraquark cluster structures
3. Kinematic Characteristics: Tetraquark states at LHC energies exhibit forward-peaked and high-p_T characteristics, significantly differing from perturbative QCD production mechanisms
4. Cross Section Magnitude: The cross section contribution from intrinsic charm quarks is relatively small but may dominate in specific kinematic regions

Limitations

1. Mass Resolution: The model can only predict masses at the few-hundred MeV level, unable to achieve experimental MeV precision
2. Width Overestimation: Calculated widths are much larger than experimental values
3. Simplified Assumptions: Adopts minimal Fock state assumptions, neglecting higher-order contributions
4. Parameter Sensitivity: Results are sensitive to k_T integration range selection

Future Directions

1. Bottom Quark Tetraquarks: Extension of the method to bottom quark systems
2. Heavy-Ion Collisions: Investigation of tetraquark production and dissociation in hot medium
3. Fixed-Target Experiments: Search for intrinsic charm quark signals at lower energies
4. Precision Calculations: Improvement of theoretical methods to enhance prediction accuracy

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: First systematic application of the intrinsic heavy quark model to tetraquark research, providing a new theoretical perspective
2. Physical Insights: Distinguishes internal structures of tetraquark states through different calculation schemes, providing valuable information for understanding the nature of these states
3. Computational Completeness: Detailed calculations of mass, kinematic distributions, and cross sections form a complete theoretical framework
4. Experimental Relevance: Predicted kinematic characteristics provide guidance for experimental searches for intrinsic charm quark signals

Shortcomings

1. Precision Limitations: Due to adoption of simple aggregation models, unable to achieve high precision matching with experiments
2. Parameter Tuning: Requires adjustment of k_T ranges to fit different states, lacking first-principles parameter determination
3. Insufficient Experimental Verification: Most predictions lack sufficient experimental verification except for X(3872)
4. Competing Mechanisms: Insufficient discussion of competition with other production mechanisms (e.g., perturbative QCD)

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools and perspectives for tetraquark research
2. Experimental Guidance: Provides kinematic guidance for LHC and future experiments in searching for tetraquark signals
3. Method Generalization: The method can be extended to research on other exotic hadron states

Applicable Scenarios

• Forward production of tetraquark states in high-energy proton-proton collisions
• Charm quark physics research in fixed-target experiments
• Intrinsic heavy quark research at electron-ion colliders
• Production mechanisms of exotic hadron states in heavy-ion collisions

References

The paper cites 76 important references covering multiple aspects including experimental discoveries of tetraquark states, theoretical models, and intrinsic heavy quark research, reflecting the development and current status of the field. Key references include:

• Pioneering work by Brodsky et al. on intrinsic heavy quarks
• Tetraquark state discovery papers from Belle, LHCb and other experimental collaborations
• Important review articles on tetraquark state theoretical research
• Related work on intrinsic charm quarks in global PDF analyses