Stable degeneration of families of klt singularities with constant local volume

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2405.19273
• Title: Stable degeneration of families of klt singularities with constant local volume
• Author: Zhiyuan Chen
• Classification: math.AG (Algebraic Geometry)
• Publication Date: May 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19273

Abstract

This paper proves that for locally stable families of klt singularities with constant local volume, the ideal sequences of minimizing valuations of the normalized volume function form ideal families with flat cosupport, which induce a degeneration to a locally stable family of K-semistable log Fano cone singularities. The proof employs a family version of the method developed by C. Xu and Z. Zhuang, who proved finite generation via Kollár models and multiple degenerations.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: This paper investigates the stable degeneration problem for families of klt singularities. Specifically, for a family of klt singularities, how to construct a family version of the K-semistable degeneration induced by minimizing valuations.
2. Problem Significance:
   • This is an important component of the Minimal Model Program (MMP) in algebraic geometry
   • klt singularities are local analogues of Fano varieties and play a foundational role in birational geometry
   • Resolves the family version of the stable degeneration conjecture proposed by Li-Xu
3. Limitations of Existing Work:
   • Previous stable degeneration conjectures applied only to individual singularities
   • Lack of systematic methods for handling families of singularities
   • New techniques needed to address flatness and compatibility in families
4. Research Motivation:
   • Generalize the stable degeneration theory from single points to families
   • Provide theoretical foundations for studying moduli spaces of singularities
   • Establish family versions of K-stability theory

Core Contributions

1. Main Theorem: Proves that for locally stable families of klt singularities with constant local volume, there exist ideal sequence families such that the degenerations on fibers induce families of K-semistable log Fano cone singularities.
2. Construction Method: Develops methods for constructing families of Kollár models, which are key tools for proving finite generation of valuations of high rational rank.
3. Technical Innovations:
   • Establishes family versions of multiple equivariant degeneration theory
   • Develops family theory of special valuations
   • Proves compatibility of valuation degenerations
4. Application Examples: Provides complete analysis of families of equisingular plane curves, demonstrating concrete applications of the theory.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Setup

Given a locally stable family of klt singularities $\pi: (X,\Delta) \to S$ with a section $x: S \to X$ such that the local volume function $s \mapsto \widehat{\text{vol}}(x_s; X_s, \Delta_s)$ is locally constant, construct its K-semistable degeneration family.

Core Technical Framework

1. Construction of Families of Kollár Models

For a DVR base $S = \text{Spec}(A)$, the main result (Theorem 5.1) proves the existence of a locally stable family of Kollár models: $f: (Y,E) \to (X,\Delta)$ such that $v^m_\eta \in QM(Y_\eta, E_\eta)$ and $v^m_s \in QM(Y_s, E_s)$, where $v^m_\eta, v^m_s$ are the minimizing valuations on the generic and special fibers respectively.

2. Degeneration of Ideal Sequences

Construct ideal sequences $I_\bullet$ such that:

• $I_{\eta,\bullet} = \mathfrak{a}_\bullet(v^m_\eta)$ (ideal sequences on the generic fiber)
• $I_{s,\bullet}$ computes the same lc threshold on the special fiber
• Possess the flat cosupport property

3. Theory of Special Valuations

Utilize properties of special valuations (Lemma 3.10):

• A valuation $v$ is special if and only if there exists a qdlt Fano-type model such that $v \in QM(Y,E)$
• Special valuations have finitely generated associated graded rings
• Stable under small perturbations

Technical Innovations

1. Family Version of Multiple Degenerations

• Generalizes Xu-Zhuang's multiple degeneration theory to the family setting
• Establishes compatibility of valuations across different fibers
• Proves flatness of the degeneration process

2. Geometric Realization of Valuation Degenerations

Through construction of appropriate models $f: (Y,E) \to (X,\Delta)$, realizes valuation degenerations in families: $QM_\zeta(Y_\eta, E_\eta) \cong QM_z(Y_s, E_s)$

3. Treatment of Seminormal Bases

For seminormal bases $S$, generalizes results from the DVR case to the general case using valuation criteria (Lemma A.1).

Experimental Setup

Main Example: Equisingular Plane Curves

Data Configuration

Consider plane curves $C \subset \mathbb{A}^2$ over an algebraically closed field $k$, which are unibranch at the origin with Puiseux characteristic $(a,b,\ldots)$.

Analysis Method

1. Compute the log canonical threshold: $\text{lct}_0(\mathbb{A}^2; C) = \frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{b}$
2. Determine the type of minimizing valuations
3. Construct K-semistable degenerations

Evaluation Criteria

• Formulas for computing local volume
• Verification of K-semistability
• Flatness of families

Experimental Results

Main Results

Complete Statement of Theorem 5.4

For locally stable families of klt singularities over a seminormal base $S$, if the local volume function is locally constant, there exist ideal sequences $\mathfrak{a}_\bullet \subset \mathcal{O}_X$ such that:

1. Flatness: $\mathfrak{a}_\lambda/\mathfrak{a}_{>\lambda}$ is flat over $S$
2. Fiber Compatibility: Each fiber recovers the ideal sequences of minimizing valuations
3. Existence of Degeneration: Induces a family of K-semistable log Fano cone singularities

Specific Results for Plane Curves (Lemma 5.7)

For unibranch plane curves with Puiseux characteristic $(a,b)$:

$\widehat{\text{vol}}(0; \mathbb{A}^2, \lambda C) = \begin{cases} ab\left(\frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{b} - \lambda\right)^2 & \text{if } \frac{1}{a} - \frac{1}{b} \leq \lambda < \frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{b} \\ 4(1 - \lambda a) & \text{if } 0 \leq \lambda < \frac{1}{a} - \frac{1}{b} \end{cases}$

Theoretical Findings

1. Representability Results (Corollary 5.5)

Establishes theoretical foundations for moduli spaces of klt singularities with constant local volume, providing local stratifications.

2. Constructive Proofs

Not only proves existence of degenerations but also provides explicit construction methods.

3. Geometric Intuition

Provides geometric intuition and computational verification of the theory through plane curve examples.

Related Work

Development of the Stable Degeneration Conjecture

1. Li-Xu (2018): Proposed the original conjecture
2. Blum (2018), Xu (2020): Proved existence and quasi-monomiality of minimizing valuations
3. Xu-Zhuang (2021, 2025): Completed the proof for single points
4. This paper: Generalizes to families

Evolution of Technical Methods

• Kollár Model Theory: Generalized from single points to families
• Multiple Degenerations: Establishes family versions of the theory
• Special Valuations: Develops family compatibility theory

Relationship to Other Work

The methods in this paper provide foundational tools for studying moduli spaces of singularities and family theories of K-stability.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully generalizes the stable degeneration conjecture to families
2. Establishes general methods for constructing families of Kollár models
3. Lays foundations for moduli space theory of singularities

Limitations

1. Base Restrictions: Requires the base to be seminormal
2. Constant Condition: Requires the local volume function to be locally constant
3. Technical Complexity: The proof involves multiple deep techniques

Future Directions

1. Generalize to more general bases
2. Study the non-constant local volume case
3. Apply to concrete geometric problems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Significant Theoretical Impact: Completes an important family version of a conjecture
2. Technical Innovation: Develops multiple new technical tools
3. Complete Structure: Forms a complete system from theory to applications
4. Clear Exposition: Technical details are handled appropriately

Weaknesses

1. Strong Assumptions: The constant local volume assumption is restrictive
2. Computational Complexity: Concrete applications involve substantial calculations
3. Limited Generalizability: Extensions to more general settings are not obvious

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important tools for birational geometry
2. Application Prospects: Has applications in singularity classification and moduli space research
3. Technical Value: Developed methods applicable to other problems

Applicable Scenarios

• Singularity theory research in algebraic geometry
• Development of K-stability theory
• Advancement of the Minimal Model Program
• Construction of moduli space theory

References

Key Literature

1. XZ25 C. Xu and Z. Zhuang. "Stable degenerations of singularities"
2. Li18 C. Li. "Minimizing normalized volumes of valuations"
3. LX18 C. Li and C. Xu. "Stability of valuations: higher rational rank"
4. Kol23 J. Kollár. "Families of varieties of general type"

Technical Foundations

• Kollár model theory
• Valuation theory and local volume
• K-stability theory
• Flatness theory for families

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality algebraic geometry theory paper that successfully resolves the family version of the stable degeneration conjecture, an important problem. The paper has high technical depth and significant theoretical significance, laying solid foundations for further development in related fields. Although technically complex, the paper has clear structure and rigorous argumentation, making it an important contribution to the field.