Free-fermion models and the two-dimensional Ising models under the zero field and imaginary field $i(\pi/2)k_BT$

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2406.00232
• Title: Free-fermion models and the two-dimensional Ising models under the zero field and imaginary field $i(\pi/2)k_BT$
• Authors: De-Zhang Li (Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macau Greater Bay Area Quantum Science Center), Xin Wang (City University of Hong Kong), Xiao-Bao Yang (South China University of Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.stat-mech, math-ph, math.MP
• Publication Date: June 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00232v2

Abstract

This paper transforms the classical two-dimensional Ising model on honeycomb, triangular, and Kagomé lattices into the formulation of free-fermion models. Exact solutions under both zero magnetic field and imaginary magnetic field $i(\pi/2)k_BT$ are investigated. Through decorated lattice techniques, star-triangle transformations, and weak-graph expansion methods, each Ising model is precisely mapped to an eight-vertex model on a square lattice. Under zero magnetic field, all Ising models correspond to even free-fermion models; under imaginary magnetic field, the honeycomb lattice corresponds to an even free-fermion model, while the triangular and Kagomé lattices correspond to odd free-fermion models. Notably, the exact solution for the Kagomé lattice under the imaginary magnetic field $i(\pi/2)k_BT$ is obtained for the first time.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of the Ising Model: The Ising model is a classical model in condensed matter physics and statistical mechanics, serving as a central tool for studying phase transitions since the 1920s. The one-dimensional case was solved by Ising himself, while the zero-field case on the two-dimensional square lattice was first exactly solved by Onsager in 1944.
2. Complex Lattice Structures: Although mature solution methods exist for the square lattice Ising model, exact solutions on other two-dimensional lattices (such as honeycomb, triangular, and Kagomé lattices) present greater challenges, particularly in the presence of external magnetic fields.
3. Specificity of Imaginary Magnetic Field: The imaginary magnetic field $i(\pi/2)k_BT$ introduced by Lee and Yang is one of the few non-zero magnetic field cases that can be exactly solved, possessing significant theoretical importance.

Research Motivation

1. Unified Theoretical Framework: Seeking a unified method to handle Ising models on different lattice structures
2. Advantages of Free-Fermion Formulation: Free-fermion models provide powerful mathematical tools for systematically solving complex statistical mechanics problems
3. Discovery of New Solutions: Particularly, the exact solution for the Kagomé lattice under imaginary magnetic field has not been previously reported

Core Contributions

1. Established systematic mapping methods: Mapped Ising models on honeycomb, triangular, and Kagomé lattices to free-fermion models
2. Obtained new exact solutions: First reported the exact solution for the Kagomé lattice Ising model under imaginary magnetic field $i(\pi/2)k_BT$
3. Revealed classification patterns: Demonstrated that the zero-field case corresponds to even free-fermion models, while the imaginary-field case classification depends on lattice structure
4. Calculated residual entropy: Provided expressions for residual entropy of frustrated systems under imaginary magnetic field
5. Re-derived known results: Reobtained five known exact solutions using a unified method, verifying the correctness of the approach

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Study the Ising model with Hamiltonian $H = \sum_{\langle ij\rangle} J_{ij}s_is_j - H_{ex}\sum_{i=1}^N s_i$, where $s_i = \pm 1$ and $H_{ex}$ can be either 0 or $i(\pi/2)k_BT$.

Core Technical Methods

1. Decorated Lattice Technique

Auxiliary spins $\tilde{s}$ are inserted between adjacent spin pairs while preserving the partition function: $e^{-\beta Js_1s_2} = A\sum_{\tilde{s}=\pm 1} e^{-\beta \tilde{J}\tilde{s}(s_1+s_2)}$

where the transformation parameters are:

• $\cosh(2\beta\tilde{J}) = e^{-2\beta J}$
• $A = \frac{1}{2}e^{\beta J}$

2. Star-Triangle Transformation

Converts triangular internal interactions $(J_1, J_2, J_3)$ to star-shaped structure $(J'_1, J'_2, J'_3)$:

$\cosh(2\beta J'_i) = \cosh(2\beta J_j)\cosh(2\beta J_k) - \sinh(2\beta J_j)\sinh(2\beta J_k)\coth(2\beta J_l)$

where $(i,j,k,l)$ are cyclic permutations of $(1,2,3,1)$.

3. Weak-Graph Expansion

Rearranges the weights of the sixteen-vertex model through transformation matrix $M$: $\{\tilde{\omega}_1, \tilde{\omega}_2, \ldots, \tilde{\omega}_{16}\}^T = \frac{1}{4}M\{\omega_1, \omega_2, \ldots, \omega_{16}\}^T$

Symmetric sixteen-vertex models ($\omega_i = \omega_{i+1}$ for odd $i$) are transformed into even eight-vertex models, while antisymmetric models are transformed into odd eight-vertex models.

Free-Fermion Conditions

• Even free-fermion condition: $\tilde{\omega}_1\tilde{\omega}_2 + \tilde{\omega}_3\tilde{\omega}_4 = \tilde{\omega}_5\tilde{\omega}_6 + \tilde{\omega}_7\tilde{\omega}_8$
• Odd free-fermion condition: $\tilde{\omega}_9\tilde{\omega}_{10} + \tilde{\omega}_{11}\tilde{\omega}_{12} = \tilde{\omega}_{13}\tilde{\omega}_{14} + \tilde{\omega}_{15}\tilde{\omega}_{16}$

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

• Lattice Types: Honeycomb, triangular, and Kagomé lattices
• Magnetic Field Conditions: Zero field ($H_{ex} = 0$) and imaginary field ($H_{ex} = i(\pi/2)k_BT$)
• Interactions: Anisotropic nearest-neighbor interactions $J_{ij}$

Computational Methods

1. Apply decorated lattice technique to construct vertex models
2. Use star-triangle transformations to simplify lattice structure
3. Obtain eight-vertex models through weak-graph expansion
4. Verify free-fermion conditions
5. Apply known exact solutions of free-fermion models

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Honeycomb Lattice

• Zero Field: Even free-fermion model with exact solution: $\lim_{N\to\infty} \frac{1}{N}\ln Z = \frac{3}{4}\ln 2 + \frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^{2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi} \ln[\text{complex integral expression}] d\theta d\phi$
• Imaginary Field: Remains an even free-fermion model with similar solution form but different coefficients

2. Triangular Lattice

• Zero Field: Even free-fermion model
• Imaginary Field: Odd free-fermion model with residual entropy $S = 0.161533$

3. Kagomé Lattice (New Result)

• Zero Field: Even free-fermion model
• Imaginary Field: Odd free-fermion model with exact solution obtained for the first time: $\lim_{N\to\infty} \frac{1}{N}\ln Z = i\frac{\pi}{2} + \frac{1}{6}\ln[16|2S_1^2S_2^2S_3^2 + S_1^2S_2^2 + S_1^2S_3^2 + S_2^2S_3^2 - 2S_1S_2S_3C_1C_2C_3|]$

where $C_i = \cosh(2\beta J_i)$, $S_i = \sinh(2\beta J_i)$

• Residual Entropy: When $J_1 = J_2 = J_3 > 0$, $S = \frac{1}{6}\ln 3 = 0.183102$

Important Findings

1. Classification Pattern: Zero-field cases uniformly correspond to even free-fermion models; imaginary-field case classification depends on lattice geometry
2. Specificity of Kagomé Lattice: The solution under imaginary field possesses an exceptionally simple logarithmic form, requiring no double integration
3. Residual Entropy Comparison: The residual entropy of the Kagomé lattice under imaginary field is half that of the zero-field case

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Classical Results: Onsager's square lattice solution (1944), Lee-Yang's imaginary field theory (1952)
2. Other Lattices: Honeycomb lattice (Husimi & Syôzi, 1950), triangular lattice (Wannier, 1950), Kagomé lattice (Syôzi, 1951)
3. Vertex Models: Fan-Wu's free-fermion theory (1969-1970)

Innovations in This Work

• First systematic unification of multiple lattice Ising models within the free-fermion framework
• Discovery of new exact solution for Kagomé lattice under imaginary magnetic field
• Establishment of correspondence between magnetic field type and free-fermion model type

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established systematic correspondence between two-dimensional Ising models and free-fermion models
2. Obtained new exact solutions for the Kagomé lattice under imaginary magnetic field, enriching the family of exactly solvable models
3. Revealed the phenomenon of non-zero residual entropy in frustrated systems under imaginary magnetic field

Limitations

1. Method Applicability: Currently applicable only to specific imaginary field value $i(\pi/2)k_BT$
2. Real Magnetic Fields: Cases with genuine (non-imaginary) magnetic fields remain unsolved
3. Computational Complexity: Certain cases still require numerical evaluation of double integrals

Future Directions

1. Extension to Other Fields: Explore method applications at other special magnetic field values
2. Three-Dimensional Generalization: Investigate method possibilities in three-dimensional lattice systems
3. Other Statistical Problems: Apply to other lattice statistical problems such as dimer coverings

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: Provides a unified framework for handling complex lattice Ising models
2. New Results: First report of exact solution for Kagomé lattice under imaginary magnetic field
3. Theoretical Completeness: Systematically re-derives known results, verifying method correctness
4. Mathematical Elegance: The Kagomé lattice solution exhibits exceptionally concise form, suggesting its special status

Weaknesses

1. Physical Interpretation: Insufficient discussion of physical significance of imaginary magnetic field
2. Scope of Application: Limited to specific magnetic field values, restricting practical utility
3. Technical Details: Physical motivation for certain technical steps insufficiently explained

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Adds new members to the family of exactly solvable models
2. Method Value: Proposed mapping techniques may be applicable to other related problems
3. Inspirational Significance: Simplicity of Kagomé lattice solution may hint at deeper mathematical structures

Applicable Scenarios

• Theoretical research in statistical mechanics
• Exact analysis of phase transition phenomena
• Theoretical modeling of frustrated magnetic systems
• Classical correspondence studies of quantum many-body systems

References

1. Onsager, L. Phys. Rev. 65, 117 (1944) - Exact solution of square lattice Ising model
2. Lee, T. D. & Yang, C. N. Phys. Rev. 87, 410 (1952) - Imaginary field theory
3. Fan, C. & Wu, F. Y. Phys. Rev. 179, 560 (1969) - Free-fermion model theory
4. Baxter, R. J. Exactly solved models in statistical mechanics (Academic Press, 1982) - Review of exactly solvable models