Non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in the photonic synthetic frequency dimension

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2406.00321
• Title: Non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in the photonic synthetic frequency dimension
• Authors: Dali Cheng, Kai Wang, Charles Roques-Carmes, Eran Lustig, Olivia Y. Long, Heming Wang, Shanhui Fan (Stanford University, McGill University)
• Classification: physics.optics, cond-mat.other, quant-ph
• Publication Date: June 1, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00321

Abstract

Non-Abelian gauge fields provide a conceptual framework for describing particles with spin. The theoretical importance of non-Abelian gauge field theory has motivated experimental synthesis and exploration. This paper demonstrates non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in a photonic system for the first time. In gauge field research, lattice models are crucial for understanding their effects in extended systems. The research utilizes a synthetic frequency dimension platform to investigate lattice physics in a scalable and programmable manner. The experiments observe Dirac cones at time-reversal invariant momenta and reversal of eigenstate trajectory directions associated with these Dirac cones, both of which are unique signatures of non-Abelian gauge fields in lattice systems.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Theoretical Importance: Non-Abelian gauge fields are fundamental concepts in modern physics, widely applied in electrodynamics, condensed matter physics, and particle physics, particularly in describing particle interactions with intrinsic spin degrees of freedom
2. Experimental Challenges: Despite their theoretical significance, realizing non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in photonic systems has remained challenging
3. Existing Limitations: Non-Abelian lattice gauge fields have previously been realized only in cold atom and circuit systems; demonstration in photonic systems has not yet been achieved

Research Motivation

1. Filling a Gap: First realization of non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in a photonic system
2. Technical Advantages: Photonic systems offer strong programmability, large bandwidth, and excellent scalability
3. Application Prospects: Provides new opportunities for topological physics research and photonic spin/pseudospin control

Core Contributions

1. First Demonstration: First demonstration of SU(2) non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in photonic synthetic frequency dimensions
2. Theory Verification: Confirmed two unique signatures of non-Abelian gauge fields: Dirac cones at time-reversal invariant momenta and reversal of eigenstate trajectory directions
3. Experimental Method Innovation: Developed complete tomographic reconstruction method for eigenstates in photonic synthetic frequency lattices
4. Platform Establishment: Established a programmable photonic platform for studying non-Abelian lattice physics

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Implementation and verification of non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in photonic systems, specifically including:

• Input: Laser beams in specific polarization states
• Output: Band structure measurements and eigenstate trajectory reconstruction
• Constraints: Must satisfy the physical characteristics of non-Abelian gauge fields

Theoretical Model

Lattice Hamiltonian

The system employs a Hamiltonian for spin-1/2 particles on a two-dimensional square lattice:

$\hat{H} = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{x,y}\left[\hat{a}_{x+1,y}^{\dagger}e^{iA_x}\hat{a}_{x,y} + \hat{a}_{x,y+1}^{\dagger}e^{iA_y}\hat{a}_{x,y} + \text{H.c.}\right]$

where $A_x$ and $A_y$ are gauge potentials along the x and y directions. The gauge field is non-Abelian when $[A_x, A_y] \neq 0$.

Reciprocal Space Representation

In reciprocal space, the Hamiltonian is written in Yang-Mills form:

$\hat{H}(k_x, k_y) = \cos(k_x\sigma_0 - A_x) + \cos(k_y\sigma_0 - A_y)$

The experiment employs $A_x = (\pi/2)\sigma_z$ and $A_y = (\pi/2)\sigma_x$.

Experimental Architecture

Synthetic Frequency Lattice

Synthetic frequency dimensions are constructed using a fiber ring resonator:

• One-Dimensional Lattice: Short-range and long-range couplings are generated through $\Omega_R$ and $M\Omega_R$ frequency modulation
• Two-Dimensional Equivalence: One-dimensional long-range coupled lattices are equivalent to two-dimensional lattices with twisted boundary conditions

Key Components

1. Polarization Controller: Implements programmable SU(2) rotations $U_1 = e^{-i\pi\sigma_y/4}$ and $U_2 = \sigma_z$
2. Electro-Optic Modulator: Applies polarization-dependent transmission coefficients to two orthogonal polarizations
3. Alternating Modulation Scheme: Modulation signals contain both $\Omega_R$ and $M\Omega_R$ frequency components

Technical Innovations

Non-Abelian Implementation

• Polarization as Pseudospin: Horizontal and vertical polarizations serve as photonic pseudospin basis
• Path-Dependent Rotation: Path-dependent spin rotations are achieved through non-commuting gauge potentials
• Observable Physical Effects: The non-commutativity of non-Abelian gauge potentials is gauge-invariant and produces observable physical effects

Unique Signature Identification

1. Dirac Cone Criterion: Proven that Dirac points at time-reversal invariant momenta appear if and only if $[A_x, A_y] \neq 0$
2. Topological Charge Detection: Topological charge of Dirac points is detected through changes in the winding direction of eigenstate trajectories

Experimental Setup

Experimental Apparatus

• Laser: Continuous-wave laser with center wavelength 1542.057 nm and linewidth 2.8 kHz
• Resonator: Fiber ring resonator with free spectral range $\Omega_R = 2\pi \times 4$ MHz
• Modulation System: Electro-optic phase modulators based on lithium niobate waveguides with 5 GHz bandwidth
• Detection System: 5 GHz bandwidth photodetector coupled with oscilloscope

Measurement Parameters

• Band Structure Measurement: Modulation strength $g = 0.14\Omega_R$
• Eigenstate Measurement: Modulation strength $g = 0.06\Omega_R$
• Loss Compensation: Erbium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA) partially compensates for loop losses

Calibration Procedures

1. Polarization Controller Calibration: Rotation matrices determined through known polarization state inputs
2. Transmission Coefficient Calibration: Polarization-dependent transmittance of free-space beam splitters measured
3. Basis Alignment: Systematic errors from polarization basis definition differences eliminated

Experimental Results

Band Structure Measurements

Main Findings

Experiments successfully observed:

• Linear Band Crossings: Dirac cones appear at the Γ point $(k_x, k_y) = (0,0)$ and M point $(k_x, k_y) = (\pi, \pi)$ when $\phi \in \{0, \pi\}$
• Band Gap Structure: When $\phi = \pi/2$, sampling lines avoid Dirac points and band gaps appear in the band structure
• Theory Agreement: Experimental results show high consistency with theoretical predictions and numerical simulations

Quantitative Analysis

• Measured time-dependent transmission spectra $\xi(\delta\omega, t)$ clearly display resonance features
• Resonance positions correspond to band energies of the lattice Hamiltonian
• Non-uniform signal intensity reflects variations in eigenstate overlap with input polarization states

Eigenstate Tomographic Reconstruction

Method Innovation

Developed eigenstate reconstruction technique based on projection measurements:

• Multiple Polarization Inputs: Six different input polarization states (H, V, X, Y, L, R) employed
• Stokes Parameter Extraction: Stokes parameters of eigenstates obtained through differential measurements
• Trajectory Reconstruction: Eigenstate trajectories on the Bloch sphere reconstructed

Key Observations

1. Direction Reversal: Eigenstate trajectories corresponding to $\phi = \pi/2$ and $\phi = -\pi/2$ wind in opposite directions
2. Topological Features: Trajectory direction changes reflect the topological charge of Dirac points
3. Experimental Verification: Results completely consistent with theoretical predictions

Robustness Analysis

• Beyond Weak Modulation Approximation: Non-Abelian features persist in the strong modulation regime at $g \sim 0.1\Omega_R$
• Higher-Order Effects: Although higher-order terms in $g$ must be considered, key physical features remain stable

Related Work

Gauge Field Physics

1. Theoretical Foundation: Yang-Mills theory provides the mathematical framework for non-Abelian gauge fields
2. Lattice Models: Kogut et al. established the foundations of lattice gauge theory
3. Topological Physics: Gauge fields are closely related to topological phase transitions, quantum Hall effects, etc.

Artificial Gauge Fields

1. Cold Atom Systems: Wu et al. realized two-dimensional spin-orbit coupling in Bose-Einstein condensates
2. Circuit Systems: Wu et al. demonstrated non-Abelian gauge fields in circuit networks
3. Photonic Systems: Previous work primarily focused on Abelian gauge field implementations

Synthetic Dimensions

1. Concept Development: Yuan et al. systematically elucidated the concept of synthetic dimensions in photonics
2. Application Extension: Synthetic dimensions have important applications in topological insulators, topological lasers, etc.
3. Technical Advantages: Provides a scalable platform for studying high-dimensional physics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First Demonstration: First realization and verification of non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in a photonic system
2. Theory Verification: Confirmed two unique physical signatures of non-Abelian gauge fields
3. Method Establishment: Developed complete tomographic reconstruction method for eigenstates in synthetic frequency lattices
4. Platform Value: Established a programmable photonic platform for studying non-Abelian physics

Physical Significance

• Time-Reversal Breaking: Non-Abelian gauge fields lead to breaking of time-reversal symmetry, producing Dirac points at time-reversal invariant momenta
• Gauge Invariance: The non-commutativity of non-Abelian gauge potentials is gauge-invariant and produces observable physical effects
• Topological Properties: Topological charge of Dirac points is manifested through winding characteristics of eigenstate trajectories

Limitations

1. Modulation Strength: Experiments conducted in the strong modulation regime, deviating from weak modulation theory approximation
2. System Complexity: Requires precise polarization control and modulation systems
3. Loss Effects: Resonator losses have certain impact on measurement accuracy

Future Directions

1. Complex Hamiltonians: Extension to systems with non-Abelian scalar and non-Hermitian gauge potentials
2. Dynamical Effects: Investigation of Zitterbewegung effects and non-Abelian Aharonov-Bohm effects
3. Topological Features: Exploration of spin-orbit coupling butterfly patterns, triplet states, and Hofstadter moth structures
4. Large-Scale Systems: Utilization of photonic system scalability to study large-scale systems exceeding $10^5$ lattice sites

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Pioneering Contribution: First realization of non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in photonic systems, filling an important gap
2. Theoretical Rigor: Provides strict mathematical proof of Dirac cone emergence conditions
3. Experimental Completeness: Simultaneous measurement of band structure and eigenstates provides a complete physical picture
4. Method Innovation: Developed tomographic reconstruction method has universal applicability
5. Technical Advancement: Ingeniously designed experimental apparatus with high measurement precision

Limitations

1. Theoretical Approximation: Experimental conditions exceed the weak modulation theory framework, requiring more precise theoretical description
2. System Complexity: Relatively complex experimental system may limit its generalization
3. Parameter Range: Verification only within specific parameter ranges; universality requires further testing

Impact Assessment

1. Academic Value: Provides new experimental platform for non-Abelian physics and topological photonics
2. Technical Value: Tomographic reconstruction method applicable to other synthetic dimension systems
3. Application Prospects: Offers new insights for photonic spin/pseudospin control and topological photonic devices
4. Reproducibility: Detailed experimental method description ensures good reproducibility

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Non-Abelian gauge field theory, topological physics, quantum simulation
2. Technical Applications: Topological photonic devices, quantum information processing, photonic spintronics
3. Interdisciplinary Research: Intersection of condensed matter physics, atomic-molecular-optical physics, and quantum optics

References

This paper cites 62 important references covering multiple fields including gauge field theory, topological physics, synthetic dimensions, and cold atom systems, providing solid theoretical foundation and experimental comparison for the work.

Summary: This is a pioneering work of significant importance in the photonics field, achieving the first realization of non-Abelian lattice gauge fields in a photonic system, opening new directions for topological photonics and quantum simulation. The work makes important contributions in theory, experiment, and methodology, and is expected to have profound impact on related fields.