Dissipative Superfluidity in a Molecular Bose-Einstein Condensate

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2406.08868
• Title: Dissipative Superfluidity in a Molecular Bose-Einstein Condensate
• Authors: Hongchao Li, Xie-Hang Yu, Masaya Nakagawa, Masahito Ueda
• Classification: cond-mat.quant-gas
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08868

Abstract

Building upon recent experimental realizations of dipolar molecular Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC), this paper develops a theory of superfluid transport in dissipative BECs. The study demonstrates that weak uniform two-body losses can induce phase rigidity, enabling superfluid transport of bosons even in the absence of repulsive inter-particle interactions. As a consequence of weak U(1) symmetry, a generalized f-sum rule holds in dissipative superfluids. The research further shows that dissipation enhances the stability of molecular BECs with dipolar interactions and discusses possible experimental signatures of dissipative superfluidity.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Problem

Conventional superfluid theory attributes phase rigidity primarily to repulsive inter-particle interactions. The central question addressed in this paper is: can superfluidity be realized without repulsive interactions in open quantum systems with dissipation?

2. Importance of the Problem

• Experimental Motivation: Recently realized heteronuclear molecular BECs inevitably suffer from two-body losses due to chemical reactions. The impact of this intrinsic dissipation on superfluidity urgently requires theoretical clarification.
• Fundamental Physics: Although superfluidity and Bose-Einstein condensation frequently occur together, neither is necessary nor sufficient for the other. Understanding dissipation's influence on superfluidity has important fundamental significance.
• Quantum Simulation: Dipolar molecular quantum gases provide a platform for realizing clean and controllable long-range interaction systems.

3. Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional superfluid theory primarily addresses closed systems, with dissipation typically considered destructive to the phase coherence of superfluidity.
• Lack of a comprehensive theoretical framework for superfluid transport in open quantum systems.
• Insufficient understanding of how dissipation affects quantum depletion and normal fluid density.

4. Research Motivation

Inspired by developments in microwave shielding technology and the first experimental realization of heteronuclear molecular BEC, this work aims to establish a complete theory of dissipative superfluidity and reveal the physical mechanisms underlying dissipation-induced superfluidity.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework: Establishes a theory of superfluid transport in dissipative BECs based on Schwinger-Keldysh theory.
2. Key Finding: Demonstrates that weak uniform two-body losses can induce phase rigidity, enabling superfluidity even without interactions.
3. Generalized f-Sum Rule: Derives a generalized f-sum rule applicable to dissipative open quantum systems.
4. Stability Analysis: Reveals how dissipation enhances the stability of molecular BECs with dipolar interactions.
5. Experimental Predictions: Provides observable experimental signatures of dissipative superfluidity.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigate the superfluid transport properties of a bosonic system in a dissipative environment with two-body losses, including superfluid density, quantum depletion, excitation spectrum, and stability.

Theoretical Framework

1. System Hamiltonian

The system is described by a three-dimensional bosonic molecular gas with electric dipole-dipole interactions:

$H = \int d^3r \left[\frac{1}{2m}\nabla a_r^\dagger \nabla a_r + \frac{U_R}{2}(a_r^\dagger)^2(a_r)^2 + c_{dd}\int d^3r' a_{r_1}^\dagger a_{r_2}^\dagger \frac{1-3\cos^2\theta}{|r_{12}|^3} a_{r_2} a_{r_1}\right]$

2. Lindblad Master Equation

The dissipative dynamics are described by the Lindblad equation:

$\frac{d\rho}{dt} = L\rho = -i[H,\rho] - \frac{\gamma}{2}\int d^3r \left(\{L_r^\dagger L_r, \rho\} - 2L_r\rho L_r^\dagger\right)$

where the Lindblad operator $L_r = a_r^2$ describes two-body losses at position r.

3. Schwinger-Keldysh Path Integral

The action on the Schwinger-Keldysh contour:

$S = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt \left[\int d^3r(\phi_+^* i\partial_t\phi_+ - \phi_-^* i\partial_t\phi_-) - H_+ + H_- + \frac{i\gamma}{2}\int dr(\bar{L}_{r+}L_{r+} + \bar{L}_{r-}L_{r-} - 2L_{r+}\bar{L}_{r-})\right]$

Core Technical Innovations

1. Dissipation-Induced Phase Rigidity Mechanism

Through field decomposition $\phi_\alpha(r,t) = \phi_0(t)(1+\varphi_\alpha(r,t))e^{i\theta_\alpha(r,t)}$ and integration over amplitude modes, the effective action for phase modes is obtained:

$S_{eff} = S_+ - S_-, \quad S_\alpha = -\int dtd^3r \frac{\phi_0^2}{2m}(\nabla\tilde{\theta}_\alpha)^2$

where $\nabla\tilde{\theta}_\alpha := \nabla\theta_\alpha + \psi(r)$, with $\psi(r)$ describing particle loss to the environment.

2. Superfluid Density Calculation

The superfluid density is directly obtained from the effective action:

$\rho_s(t) = |\phi_0(t)|^2 = n_0(t)$

This indicates that all condensed bosons participate in superfluid transport.

3. Quantum Depletion Analysis

Through Bogoliubov analysis and phase rigidity calculations, the quantum depletion density is obtained:

• Weak Dissipation Limit ($U_R \gg \gamma$): $n_D = \frac{(mn U_R)^{3/2}}{3\pi^2}\left(h_1 + h_2\eta\left(\frac{\gamma}{U_R}\right)^2 + O\left(\frac{\gamma}{U_R}\right)^3\right)$
• Weak Interaction Limit ($U_R \ll \gamma$): $n_D = \frac{(γn)^{3/2}m^{3/2}}{24\pi^{5/2}}\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{4}\right)\left(1 + \frac{6U_R}{\gamma}\frac{\Gamma(3/4)^2}{\Gamma(1/4)^2} + O\left[\left(\frac{U_R}{\gamma}\right)^2\right]\right)$

Experimental Setup

Numerical Simulation Parameters

• Trapping Frequencies: $\omega_x = \omega_y = 2\pi \times 108$ Hz, $\omega_z = 100\omega_x$
• Boson Mass: $m = 2.59 \times 10^{-22}$ g
• Dissipation Rate: $\gamma = 3 \times 10^{-13}$ cm³/s
• Dipolar Interaction Strength: $\varepsilon_{dd} = 0.833$ (based on experimental data)

Evaluation Methods

1. Quantized Vortex Formation: Observe nucleation of quantized vortices by stirring the BEC.
2. Angular Momentum Measurement: Measure superfluid density using synthetic gauge fields.
3. Spectral Function Measurement: Verify the excitation spectrum through angle-resolved measurements.

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Dissipation-Induced Superfluidity

Numerical simulations show that in the purely dissipative case (without interactions), quantized vortex formation can be observed through stirring, confirming dissipation-induced superfluidity.

2. Zero Normal Fluid Density

Theoretical calculations show that if starting from a BEC at absolute zero, the normal fluid density remains zero under dissipative dynamics, i.e., $n_s = n$ (all bosons participate in superfluid transport).

3. Enhanced Stability

Dissipation maintains system stability under the condition $\varepsilon_{dd} < 1 + \sqrt{3\gamma/U_R}$, expanding the stable region.

4. Excitation Spectrum

The complex frequency excitation spectrum is: $\omega_{1,2} = -2i\gamma n \pm \sqrt{\varepsilon_k(\varepsilon_k + 2\tilde{U}_R(k)n) - \gamma^2n^2}$

Spectral Function Analysis

The spectral function exhibits different behavior in weak dissipation and weak interaction limits:

• Weak Dissipation Limit: Spectral function strongly depends on measurement direction.
• Weak Interaction Limit: Spectral function is nearly independent of polarization direction.

Related Work

This work builds upon the following research foundations:

1. Dipolar Molecular BEC Experiments: Heteronuclear molecular BEC first realized by Bigagli et al.
2. Open Quantum System Theory: Application of Schwinger-Keldysh formalism to dissipative systems.
3. Superfluid Theory: Phase rigidity and f-sum rules of conventional superfluids.
4. Quantum Zeno Effect: Mechanisms of dissipation-induced effective interactions.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Dissipation Can Induce Superfluidity: Weak uniform two-body losses produce phase rigidity and enable superfluidity even without interactions.
2. Generalized f-Sum Rule Holds: As a consequence of weak U(1) symmetry.
3. Enhanced Stability: Dissipation effectively enhances the stability of dipolar BECs.
4. New Mechanism for Quantum Depletion: Dissipation itself can generate quantum depletion.

Physical Mechanism

Dissipation induces superfluidity through the following mechanism:

• Two-body losses preferentially remove particles from regions with density higher than average.
• This selective loss suppresses density fluctuations.
• Suppression of density fluctuations leads to phase rigidity and superfluidity.

Limitations

1. Quasi-Stationary Approximation: Requires $\gamma n(0)T \ll 1$.
2. Uniform Loss Assumption: Neglects spatial inhomogeneity.
3. Weak Dissipation Condition: Theory primarily applies to weak dissipation regimes.

Future Directions

1. Theoretical development for strong dissipation regimes.
2. Effects of non-uniform losses.
3. Finite temperature effects.
4. Specific experimental verification schemes.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic exposition of a complete theory of dissipation-induced superfluidity.
2. Mathematical Rigor: Rigorous derivations based on Schwinger-Keldysh theory.
3. Experimental Relevance: Directly addresses the latest molecular BEC experiments.
4. Physical Insight: Reveals the constructive role of dissipation, challenging conventional wisdom.

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope: Primarily restricted to weak dissipation regimes.
2. Experimental Verification: Lacks direct experimental verification.
3. Technical Presentation: Some mathematical derivations are overly complex, affecting readability.

Impact

1. Fundamental Physics: Provides new perspectives for understanding superfluidity in open quantum systems.
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers theoretical guidance for molecular BEC experiments.
3. Application Prospects: May inspire new quantum device designs.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Dipolar molecular BEC experiments.
2. Quantum gas systems with intrinsic losses.
3. Superfluid research in open quantum systems.
4. Quantum simulation platforms.

References

Key references include:

1. Bigagli et al., Nature 631, 289 (2024) - Molecular BEC experiments.
2. Sieberer et al., Rep. Prog. Phys. 79, 096001 (2016) - Open quantum system theory.
3. Ueda, Fundamentals and New Frontiers of Bose-Einstein Condensation (2010) - Superfluid theory foundations.

Overall Assessment: This is an important work in theoretical physics that systematically establishes a theory of dissipative superfluidity for the first time, providing a new theoretical framework for understanding superfluidity in open quantum systems. While further experimental verification is needed, its theoretical innovations and physical insights possess significant academic value.