Linearized Stability of Harada Thin-Shell Wormholes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2407.08945
• Title: Linearized Stability of Harada Thin-Shell Wormholes
• Authors: Hassan Alshal, Leyang Ding, Adelina Hernandez, Leo A. Illing, Ivar Rydstrom
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: July 2024 (arXiv version)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.08945

Abstract

This paper investigates the dynamical properties of thin-shell wormholes constructed from two conformal Killing gravity (Harada gravity) black holes using the Darmois-Israel-Sen junction conditions and Visser's cut-and-paste method. The study examines energy conditions under different values of the new parameter introduced by Harada, which is considered as an alternative to dark energy. Through radial acceleration analysis, the attractive and repulsive characteristics of the wormhole throat are revealed. The dynamics and stability of the wormhole near the linearized radial perturbation static solution at the throat are investigated. Finally, stability regions are determined through concavity tests of the "sound speed" function, which depends on the throat radius and other spacetime parameters, particularly the Harada parameter.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Problem

This paper primarily addresses the stability problem of thin-shell wormholes within the Harada gravity theoretical framework, specifically including:

• How to construct thin-shell wormholes in the new gravitational theory
• How new gravitational parameters affect the energy conditions of wormholes
• The stability characteristics of wormholes under linearized perturbations

2. Problem Significance

The study of wormhole stability has important implications:

• Traversable wormholes in general relativity require violation of the null energy condition; finding stable solutions represents a long-standing challenge
• Harada gravity theory provides a new framework for explaining cosmic acceleration without requiring conventional dark energy
• The existence of wormhole solutions in this theory that do not require exotic matter support has stimulated research interest in thin-shell wormholes

3. Limitations of Existing Methods

• In traditional general relativity, no wormhole solutions have achieved stability under general perturbations
• Existing thin-shell wormhole research primarily focuses on different black holes in de Sitter and anti-de Sitter spacetimes
• Systematic stability analysis of thin-shell wormholes in new gravitational theories is lacking

4. Research Motivation

• Finding stable traversable wormhole solutions in conformal Killing gravity is of particular significance
• A class of wormhole solutions discovered in Harada theory does not require exotic matter or dark energy support
• Exploring the mechanism by which new gravitational parameters influence wormhole stability

Core Contributions

1. Construction of Harada Thin-Shell Wormhole Model: For the first time, thin-shell wormholes based on Harada gravity are constructed using Visser's cut-and-paste technique and Darmois-Israel-Sen junction conditions
2. Systematic Analysis of Energy Conditions: Detailed investigation of violations of weak energy condition (WEC), null energy condition (NEC), and strong energy condition (SEC) under different Harada parameter values
3. Revelation of Attractive-Repulsive Characteristics: Through radial acceleration analysis, the gravitational features of the wormhole throat and their variation with the Harada parameter are clarified
4. Establishment of Linearized Stability Theory: Development of a stability analysis method based on concavity tests of the "sound speed" function
5. Determination of Stability Regions: Systematic mapping of stability regions in parameter space, particularly regarding the influence of the Harada parameter

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of linearized stability of thin-shell wormholes in Harada gravity theory, with inputs being spacetime parameters (mass M, cosmological constant Λ, Harada parameter N) and outputs being stability regions and critical conditions.

Model Architecture

1. Harada Black Hole Metric

Starting from a static spherically symmetric metric:

ds²_H = -f(r)dt² + f(r)⁻¹dr² + r²dθ² + r²sin²(θ)dφ²

where:

f(r) = 1 - 2M/r - Λr²/3 - Nr⁴/5

2. Thin-Shell Construction Method

• Employing the cut-and-paste technique to construct a complete manifold Γ = Γ⁺ ∪ Γ⁻
• Cutting the spacetime region at throat radius R: Γ± := {r± ≤ R | R > r_h}
• Connecting two Harada black hole regions through a timelike hypersurface (thin shell) ∂Γ

3. Junction Conditions

Application of Darmois-Israel-Sen junction conditions:

• Defining manifold coordinates x^μ := (t,r,θ,φ) and shell coordinates ζⁱ := (τ,θ,φ)
• Induced metric: ds²_∂Γ = -dτ² + r²dθ² + r²sin²(θ)dφ²
• Obtaining surface stress through discontinuity in extrinsic curvature

4. Surface Stress-Energy Tensor

Three-dimensional energy-momentum tensor:

S^i_j = -1/(8π)([K^i_j] - δ^i_j K)

where the extrinsic curvature components are:

K±_θθ = K±_φφ = ±(1/R)√(1 - 2M/R - ΛR²/3 - NR⁴/5 + Ṙ²)

Technical Innovations

1. Application to New Gravitational Theory

• First application of Harada gravity theory to thin-shell wormhole research
• Introduction of fourth-order term Nr⁴/5, transcending conventional cosmological constant terms

2. Stability Analysis Method

• Development of concavity tests based on the second derivative of potential function V(R)
• Establishment of relationship between "sound speed" parameter ϑ and stability: ϑ(σ) = dp/dσ

3. Parameter Space Mapping

• Systematic investigation of stability regions in three-parameter (M,Λ,N) space
• Revelation of nonlinear influence of Harada parameter N on stability

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Mass Parameter: M = 1 (fixed)
• Cosmological Constant: Λ = 10⁻² (fixed)
• Harada Parameter: N ∈ {10⁻⁶, 10⁻⁴, 10⁻³, 10⁻², 1, 10} (variable)
• Throat Radius: R₀ ∈ 1, 12 (scanning range)

Analysis Methods

1. Energy Condition Tests: Computing variations of σ, σ+p, σ+2p, σ+3p with R₀
2. Acceleration Analysis: Computing radial acceleration a_r = (6N)/(15r³) + (Λr)/3 - M/r²
3. Stability Tests: Applying concavity condition V''(R₀) > 0

Visualization Strategy

• Two-dimensional parameter plots displaying energy condition violations
• Acceleration plots showing attractive-repulsive transitions
• Stability region plots (blue shaded regions indicating stability)

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Energy Condition Analysis

• Weak Energy Condition (WEC): Always violated (σ₀ < 0)
• Null Energy Condition (NEC): Maintained when f(R₀) < M/R₀ - ΛR₀²/3 - 2NR₀⁴/5
• Strong Energy Condition (SEC): Maintained when f(R₀) > ΛR₀² + 6NR₀⁴/5 - 3M/R₀

2. Total Exotic Matter Content

Calculated exotic matter required to maintain wormhole openness:

Ω_σ = -2R₀√(1 - 2M/R₀ - ΛR₀²/3 - NR₀⁴/5)

3. Attractive-Repulsive Characteristics

• When a_r > 0, the wormhole exhibits attractive properties
• When a_r < 0, the wormhole exhibits repulsive properties
• Attractive-repulsive transitions occur at comparable R values for different N

4. Stability Regions

Key findings:

• Smaller N values (N = 10⁻⁶, 10⁻⁴) produce larger stability regions
• When N approaches mass M, stability regions disappear
• Stability condition: ϑ₀ < complex expression, see equation (28)

Numerical Results

• N = 10⁻⁶: Stability region covers R₀ ∈ 2.5, 8
• N = 10⁻⁴: Stability region shrinks to R₀ ∈ 3, 6
• N = 1: Only minimal stability window exists
• N = 10: Virtually no stability region exists

Experimental Findings

1. Parameter Dependence: Increasing Harada parameter N significantly narrows stability regions
2. Critical Conditions: System loses stability when N ≈ M
3. Nonlinear Effects: Introduction of fourth-order term Nr⁴/5 produces physical effects distinct from second-order cosmological constant terms

Related Work

1. Thin-Shell Wormhole Theory

• Visser's cut-and-paste method provides systematic framework for constructing thin-shell wormholes
• Poisson and Visser established foundational theory for linearized stability analysis
• Extensive research considers thin-shell wormholes of different black holes in dS and AdS spacetimes

2. Harada Gravity Theory

• Harada theory addresses three major obstacles in general relativity
• The theory naturally produces cosmic acceleration without conventional dark energy
• Previous research has discovered wormhole solutions not requiring exotic matter support

3. Wormhole Stability Research

• Traditional research indicates that wormhole stability under general perturbations has not yet been achieved
• This paper represents the first linearized thin-shell wormhole stability analysis in Harada gravity framework
• Comparative studies with other modified gravity theories such as Cotton gravity

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Model Construction: Thin-shell wormhole models in Harada gravity are successfully constructed
2. Energy Condition Characteristics: WEC is always violated, but NEC and SEC can be maintained under specific conditions
3. Existence of Stability: Stable thin-shell wormhole solutions exist within specific parameter ranges
4. Parameter Effects: Harada parameter N has decisive influence on stability; smaller N values favor stability

Limitations

1. Linearized Approximation: Only linearized perturbations are considered; nonlinear stability is not addressed
2. Parameter Restrictions: Extreme black hole configurations must be avoided to maintain throat radius validity
3. Specific Conditions: Stability is achieved only when cosmological constant is small and Harada parameter is far from mass value

Future Directions

1. Nonlinear Stability: Extension to stability analysis under nonlinear perturbations
2. Observational Effects: Investigation of observable characteristics and detection methods for stable wormholes
3. Other Modified Theories: Similar analysis in other modified gravity theories
4. Dynamical Evolution: Consideration of wormhole temporal evolution and dynamic properties

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First application of Harada gravity to thin-shell wormhole research, opening new research directions
2. Methodological Completeness: Systematic application of mature mathematical tools (cut-and-paste, junction conditions, linearized analysis)
3. Result Systematicity: Provides comprehensive parameter space analysis and stability mapping
4. Physical Insights: Reveals profound influence of new gravitational parameters on wormhole physics
5. Numerical Verification: Theoretical predictions verified through detailed numerical calculations

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Limitations: Restricted to linearized stability; lacks analysis of strongly nonlinear regions
2. Parameter Selection: Choice of certain parameter values (e.g., fixed M=1, Λ=10⁻²) may limit result generality
3. Physical Interpretation: Insufficient discussion of physical meaning and observational constraints on Harada parameter
4. Comparative Studies: Lacks systematic comparison with wormhole stability in other modified gravity theories

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides important case study for wormhole physics research in modified gravity theories
2. Methodological Value: Established analytical framework can be generalized to similar theories
3. Practical Significance: Provides new theoretical pathway for finding stable wormhole solutions
4. Reproducibility: Detailed mathematical derivations and numerical results facilitate verification and extension

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Modified gravity theories, wormhole physics, black hole physics research
2. Numerical Simulation: Provides theoretical foundation and parameter constraints for wormhole numerical simulations
3. Observational Cosmology: Provides theoretical support for observational tests of dark energy alternative theories
4. Educational Applications: Serves as advanced teaching case for general relativity and modified gravity theory

References

The paper cites 78 relevant references covering important works in wormhole theory, thin-shell construction, stability analysis, and Harada gravity theory, providing solid theoretical foundation for the research.