In-plane dielectric constant and conductivity of confined water

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2407.21538
• Title: In-plane dielectric constant and conductivity of confined water
• Authors: R. Wang, M. Souilamas, A. Esfandiar, R. Fabregas, S. Benaglia, H. Nevison-Andrews, Q. Yang, J. Normansell, P. Ares, G. Ferrari, A. Principi, A. K. Geim, L. Fumagalli
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.soft, physics.chem-ph
• Publication Date: July 2024
• Corresponding Authors: A. K. Geim (geim@manchester.ac.uk), L. Fumagalli (laura.fumagalli@manchester.ac.uk)
• Affiliated Institutions: Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester; National Graphene Institute, etc.

Abstract

This study employs scanning dielectric microscopy to probe the in-plane electrical properties of water confined between atomically flat surfaces with spacing down to 1 nm. The research reveals that when the confinement exceeds several nanometers, water exhibits an in-plane dielectric constant approaching that of bulk water, but with significantly enhanced protonic conductivity. When confined water becomes only a few molecular layers thick, its in-plane dielectric constant reaches a giant ferroelectric-level value of approximately 1,000, with conductivity peaks reaching several S/m, approaching the characteristic values of superionic liquids.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

Water is fundamental to virtually all life processes on Earth, and its properties have been extensively studied. However, the electrical properties of interfacial water and strongly confined water remain poorly understood, despite their structures differing significantly from bulk water, exhibiting pronounced layered structures.

Limitations of Existing Research

1. Predominance of vertical direction studies: Previous research has primarily focused on dielectric properties perpendicular to surfaces, revealing that confined water becomes non-polarizable in the vertical direction (ε⊥ ≈ 2)
2. Difficulty in measuring in-plane properties: Measurement of the in-plane dielectric constant ε∥ is more challenging than the perpendicular direction, with a lack of suitable experimental techniques
3. Theoretical prediction discrepancies: Theoretical predictions for ε∥ range from giant values to bulk water levels to anomalously small values

Research Motivation

1. Understanding the in-plane electrical properties of confined water is crucial for explaining many physicochemical processes
2. These properties affect intermolecular forces, playing key roles in biochemical processes
3. They hold significant importance for the development of energy storage and generation technologies

Core Contributions

1. Development of new measurement techniques: Improved scanning dielectric microscopy (SDM) technology capable of measuring in-plane electrical properties of nanoconfined water
2. Discovery of two distinct confinement regimes:
   • Moderate confinement (h > 2-3 nm): In-plane dielectric constant approaches bulk water with gradually enhanced conductivity
   • Extreme confinement (h ≤ 2 nm): Ferroelectric-level dielectric constant (~1000) and superionic-level conductivity (~3 S/m)
3. Physical mechanism explanation: Attribution of anomalous electrical properties to severe disorder of hydrogen bond networks induced by strong confinement
4. Extended frequency measurement range: Expansion of measurement bandwidth by approximately 5 orders of magnitude, from kHz to GHz frequencies

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Setup

Device Fabrication

Nanochannel preparation using van der Waals assembly:

• Materials: Atomically flat single crystals of hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) and graphite
• Channel dimensions: Height h = 1-60 nm, width approximately 200 nm
• Structure: Four-layer vdW assembly including graphite bottom electrode, bottom hBN layer, spacer hBN layer, and top hBN layer

Scanning Dielectric Microscopy Technique

Technical Principle:

• AC voltage applied to AFM tip, with mechanical response of electrostatic force converted to local electrical impedance
• Measurement frequency range: 100 Hz - 1.1 GHz

Key Technical Improvements:

1. In-plane electric field generation: Introduction of relatively thick hBN crystals in the device to position the grounding electrode away from the probed water layer
2. Extended measurement bandwidth: Combination of two detection methods for wide-frequency measurements

Measurement Principles

Dielectric Response Analysis

The measured dielectric response is determined by two characteristic frequencies:

• Relaxation frequency fr = σ∥/(2πε0ε∥): Reflects ε∥
• Cutoff frequency fc = ασ∥/(2πε0): Reflects σ∥

where α is a geometric factor determined through numerical simulation.

Data Processing

Three analytical methods employed to verify results:

1. 3D finite element numerical simulation: COMSOL used to calculate detailed electric field distributions
2. Point charge analytical model: AFM tip simplified as a point charge for approximate analytical solutions
3. Equivalent circuit model: RC network describing measurement geometry

Experimental Results

Variation of In-plane Dielectric Constant

Moderate Confinement Regime (h > 5 nm)

• ε∥ = 74 ± 17, comparable to bulk water (εbulk = 80)
• Slight increasing trend with decreasing thickness

Extreme Confinement Regime (h ≤ 2 nm)

• ε∥ increases sharply to 1,030 ± 350
• Exhibits giant dielectric constant characteristic of ferroelectric materials
• Contrasts sharply with vertical direction ε⊥ ≈ 2, displaying extreme dielectric anisotropy

Evolution of In-plane Conductivity

Progressive Enhancement Regime (h = 3-60 nm)

• σ∥ increases with decreasing thickness following 1/h scaling
• Increases from 10⁻³-10⁻⁴ S/m in large channels to 0.1 S/m at h ≈ 3 nm
• Consistent with three-layer model: bulk water + two near-surface high-conductivity layers

Peak Regime (h ≈ 1.5 nm)

• σ∥ reaches peak value of 3 S/m
• Corresponds to 4-5 molecular layer thickness
• Approaches superionic liquid conductivity levels (~10 S/m)

Minimum Channel (h ≈ 1.0 nm)

• σ∥ decreases more than 10-fold compared to peak value
• Consistent with DC measurements in 0.7 nm hBN channels from literature

Spectral Characteristic Analysis

Water layers of different thicknesses display distinctly different dielectric spectral characteristics:

• h = 30 nm: Low-to-high frequency transition occurs in kHz range
• h = 5 nm: Transition frequency elevated to MHz range
• h = 1.5 nm: Transition frequency further elevated with maintained high-frequency plateau

Physical Mechanism Discussion

Disruption of Hydrogen Bond Network

Strong disorder of hydrogen bond networks induced by atomic-scale confinement is the key mechanism:

Geometric Constraint Effects

• Constraints imposed by two limiting surfaces on possible water molecule orientations
• Loss of hydrogen bonding capability

Behavior Similar to Disordered Ice

• Disordered hydrogen-bonded crystals exhibit higher dielectric constants than liquid water
• Water molecule reorientation becomes easier, allowing collective polarization

Promotion of Grotthuss Mechanism

• Dipole reorientation crucial for proton transport via Grotthuss mechanism
• Correlated dipole reorientation in quasi-2D water promotes faster proton transfer

Physical Picture of Two Confinement Regimes

Moderate Confinement (h > 2-3 nm)

Describable as three-layer structure:

• Inner layer: Bulk water unaffected by confinement
• Two near-surface layers: Interfacial water with different electrical properties
• Interface layer thickness hint ≈ 7 Å

Extreme Confinement (h ≤ 2 nm)

• Near-surface layers merge, water develops more pronounced layered structure
• Transition to new state different from both bulk and interfacial water
• Exhibits ferroelectric-level polarization capability and superionic-level conductivity

Theoretical Analysis and Modeling

Three-Layer Capacitive Model

For larger channels, description using three-layer model:

• Dielectric constant: Three capacitors in series
• Conductivity: Three resistors in parallel

Model parameters:

• hint = 7 Å (interface layer thickness)
• σ∥,int ≈ 0.1 S/m (interface conductivity)
• ε∥,int ≈ 150 (interface dielectric constant)

Numerical Simulation Verification

3D finite element calculations using COMSOL:

• Consideration of anisotropic complex dielectric constant
• Inclusion of detailed AFM tip geometry
• Verification of experimental result reliability

Technical Innovation and Methodological Contributions

Broadband Dielectric Spectroscopy Technique

1. Low-frequency segment (< 60 kHz): 2ω detection method
2. High-frequency segment (> 60 kHz): Heterodyne detection technique
3. Calibration procedure: Gain calibration at each frequency point

Measurement Geometry Optimization

• Bottom hBN thickness optimization (50-200 nm) to maximize in-plane field component
• Channel spacing design (800 nm) to avoid crosstalk
• Cross-validation using multiple analytical models

Comparison with Related Work

Contrast with Previous Vertical Direction Studies

• Fumagalli et al. (2018): Discovery of vertical direction ε⊥ ≈ 2
• This work: In-plane direction ε∥ reaching 1000, displaying strong anisotropy

Consistency with Theoretical Predictions

• Zhang et al. (2013), Schlaich et al. (2016): Prediction of strong dielectric anisotropy
• Motevaselian & Aluru (2020): Prediction of super-dielectricity under extreme confinement
• This work experimentally validates these theoretical predictions

Consistency with Other Experiments

• Esfandiar et al. (2017): DC conductivity measurements in 0.7 nm channels
• Qin et al. (2017): High conductivity in 2D nanofluidic ionic channels
• Results of this work consistent with these independent experiments

Application Prospects and Significance

Fundamental Scientific Significance

1. Understanding biochemical processes: Protein folding, nucleic acid interactions, transmembrane ion transport
2. Surface science: Molecular-level understanding of solid-liquid interfaces
3. Nanofluidics: Fluid behavior in nanopores

Technological Application Potential

1. Energy storage: Electric double layers in supercapacitors
2. Energy conversion: Fuel cells, water electrolysis
3. Nanotechnology: Molecular-level device design

Methodological Contribution

• Provision of universal method for measuring local electrical properties of nanoconfined liquids
• Avoidance of averaging effects from distributed confinement strengths in macroscopic measurements

Limitations and Future Directions

Current Limitations

1. Material systems: Primarily limited to hBN channels, requiring validation of universality
2. Temperature conditions: Measurements only at room temperature
3. Theoretical understanding: Lack of complete microscopic theoretical description

Future Research Directions

1. Other material systems: Graphene and other 2D material-formed channels
2. Temperature dependence: Evolution of electrical properties at different temperatures
3. Molecular dynamics simulation: Theoretical verification of microscopic mechanisms
4. Practical applications: Exploration of applications in energy and biotechnology

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Outstanding technical innovation: First direct measurement of in-plane electrical properties of nanoconfined water
2. Ingenious experimental design: Clever geometric design achieving in-plane electric field component
3. Striking results: Discovery of ferroelectric-level dielectric constant and superionic-level conductivity
4. Comprehensive and in-depth analysis: Cross-validation using multiple theoretical models ensuring result reliability
5. Clear physical picture: Provision of reasonable physical mechanism explanation

Shortcomings

1. Insufficient theoretical explanation: Lack of microscopic theory from first principles
2. Limited material systems: Only hBN system studied, universality remains to be verified
3. Missing temperature effects: Temperature effects on electrical properties not considered
4. Long-term stability: Device and measurement long-term stability not discussed

Impact Assessment

1. Extremely high academic value: Opens new field of research on electrical properties of nanoconfined water
2. Far-reaching technical impact: Provides important guidance for nanofluidic device design
3. Interdisciplinary significance: Connects condensed matter physics, chemical physics, and biophysics

Reproducibility

• Detailed experimental method description
• Complete data analysis workflow
• Multiple verification methods ensuring result reliability

Conclusion

This work systematically measures for the first time the in-plane electrical properties of nanoconfined water, discovering two distinctly different confinement regimes: progressive enhancement under moderate confinement and anomalously giant response under extreme confinement. The research reveals the critical role of hydrogen bond network disorder in determining the electrical properties of confined water, providing important insights into water molecule behavior at nanoscale. These findings not only advance understanding of water as a fundamental substance but also establish scientific foundations for related technological applications.