Exact Regular Black Hole Solutions with de Sitter Cores and Hagedorn Fluid

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2408.02699
• Title: Exact Regular Black Hole Solutions with de Sitter Cores and Hagedorn Fluid
• Authors: Vitalii Vertogradov, Ali Övgün
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: December 9, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.02699

Abstract

This paper presents three exact solutions to Einstein's field equations, each describing a different black hole model. The first solution introduces a black hole with a variable equation of state $P = k(r)ρ$, which can represent either singular or regular black holes depending on parameters $M_0$ and $w_0$. The second solution describes a black hole with Hagedorn fluid, related to the late stages of black hole formation, and exhibits similarities to the first solution under specific conditions. Furthermore, the authors investigate shadows produced by these black hole solutions to constrain their parameters. Recognizing that astrophysical black holes are dynamic, the authors develop a third dynamical solution that addresses gravitational collapse and suggests the possibility of naked singularity formation.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: Traditional black hole solutions (such as Schwarzschild black holes) contain singularities at the center, which is physically unreasonable. This research aims to construct regular black hole solutions that eliminate central singularities and study their dynamic evolution during gravitational collapse.
2. Importance of the Problem:
   • The singularity problem is one of the fundamental issues in general relativity
   • With the success of LIGO gravitational wave detection and EHT black hole imaging, more precise black hole models are needed
   • Regular black holes may provide new understanding of black hole interior structure
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • Most existing regular black hole models are static solutions
   • Lack of descriptions of dynamic evolution processes
   • Insufficient integration with observational constraints
4. Research Motivation: To construct black hole models that can describe regular centers while handling dynamic evolution, and to constrain them through black hole shadow observations.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed three new exact black hole solutions:
   • Regular black hole solution with variable equation of state
   • Black hole solution with Hagedorn fluid
   • Dynamical solution describing gravitational collapse
2. Established a regular black hole model with de Sitter core, eliminating singularities in the Kretschmann scalar through an exponential factor
3. Discovered singularity-regularity oscillation phenomenon, where black holes can transition between singular and regular states during evolution
4. Constrained black hole parameters using EHT observational data, providing observational tests for theoretical models

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Study regular black hole solutions in spherically symmetric static spacetime, as well as black hole formation and evolution during dynamic gravitational collapse.

Model Architecture

First Solution: Regular Black Hole with de Sitter Core

Metric Form:

ds² = -f(r)dt² + f⁻¹(r)dr² + r²dΩ²

where:

f(r) = 1 - 2M(r)/r

Equation of State:

P = k(r)ρ, where k(r) = r/R - 1

Mass Function:

M(r) = M₀ - (w₀/2)(Rr² + R²r + R³/2)e^(-2r/R)

Regularity Condition:

w₀ = 4M₀/R³

Second Solution: Hagedorn Fluid Black Hole

Hagedorn Equation of State:

P̄ = P₀ + ρ₀ ln(ρ/ρ₀)

Approximate Solution:

M(r) = M₀ - (2βρ₀/15)(r² + 8βr/15 + 32β²/225)e^(15/4(1-r/β))

Third Solution: Dynamical Black Hole

Eddington-Finkelstein Coordinates:

ds² = -(1 - 2M(v,r)/r)dv² + 2dvdr + r²dΩ²

Mass Function:

M(r,v) = M₀(v) - (w₀(v)/2)(Rr² + R²r + R³/2)e^(-2r/R)

Technical Innovations

1. Exponential Correction Mechanism: The $e^{-2r/R}$ factor recovers Schwarzschild behavior at large r while eliminating singularities at the center
2. Parameter Correlation Condition: Establishes the regularity condition $w₀ = 4M₀/R³$, ensuring the Kretschmann scalar remains finite
3. Dynamic Evolution Framework: Handles time-dependent gravitational collapse in Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates
4. Singularity-Regularity Oscillation: Discovers the novel phenomenon where black holes can repeatedly transition between states during evolution

Experimental Setup

Observational Data

• EHT Sagittarius A Observations*: Used to constrain black hole shadow radius
• Mass-Distance Ratio Priors: From Keck and VLTI observations

Evaluation Metrics

• Shadow Radius $r_{sh}$: Size of the shadow produced by the black hole
• Photon Sphere Radius $r_{ph}$: Radius of the photon orbit
• Confidence Levels: 68% (1σ) and 95% (2σ)

Parameter Constraint Method

By solving the photon sphere condition:

f'(r_ph)r_ph = 2f(r_ph)

and the shadow size relation:

sin²ω = b²(r_ph)/b²(r_o)

Experimental Results

Main Results

de Sitter Core Black Hole Constraints

• Upper Limit on Parameter R: At 68% confidence level, $R ≤ 0.9$
• Shadow Radius Variation: Decreases with increasing R, from 5.196 to 4.761

Hagedorn Fluid Black Hole Constraints

• Upper Limit on Parameter β: At 68% confidence level, $β ≤ 1.8$
• Nonlinear Behavior: Shadow radius first decreases then increases, displaying complex geometric structure

Curvature Scalar Analysis

All solutions maintain finite curvature invariants at the center:

Ricci Scalar:

lim(r→0) R = 8w₀ (finite)

Kretschmann Scalar:

lim(r→0) K = 512M₀²/(3R⁶) (finite when regularity condition is satisfied)

Naked Singularity Formation Condition

In the dynamical solution, the condition for naked singularity formation is:

ξ ≤ 1/8, where ξ = 2M₀₀ - w₀₀R³/2

Related Work

History of Regular Black Hole Research

1. Sakharov-Gliner Model: Earliest concept of de Sitter core
2. Bardeen Black Hole: First practical regular black hole model
3. Nonlinear Electrodynamics Approach: Contributions by Ayon-Beato and Garcia

Hagedorn Fluid Applications

• Early Universe Cosmology: Explaining early universe evolution
• Hadron Physics: Describing high-density hadronic matter states
• Black Hole Thermodynamics: Related to late stages of black hole formation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully constructed three classes of regular black hole solutions, each capable of avoiding central singularities under specific conditions
2. Discovered singularity-regularity oscillation phenomenon, indicating that black holes can alter their internal structure during evolution
3. Established an observational constraint framework, limiting theoretical parameter ranges through EHT data
4. Revealed complex behavior of dynamic black holes, including the possible formation of naked singularities

Limitations

1. Spherical Symmetry Assumption: Real black holes may possess rotation and other complex structures
2. Special Matter Sources: Requires specific forms of energy-momentum tensor
3. Energy Conditions: Violated in certain regions
4. Observational Verification Difficulty: Direct observation of singularity-regularity transitions is challenging

Future Directions

1. Thermodynamic Properties Study: Analyze thermodynamic behavior of regular black holes
2. Dynamic Shadow Calculation: Develop analytical methods for dynamic black hole shadows
3. Rotating Generalizations: Construct regular black hole solutions with angular momentum
4. Physical Mechanism Exploration: Understand the physical reasons for singularity-regularity transitions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Theoretical Innovation: First discovery of singularity-regularity oscillation phenomenon in black hole evolution
2. Mathematical Rigor: Provides complete exact solutions and detailed curvature analysis
3. Close Observational Connection: Utilizes latest EHT observational data to constrain theoretical parameters
4. Systematic and Complete Methodology: Comprehensive study from static to dynamic, from regular to singular

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Physical Explanation: Lacks deep physical mechanism analysis of singularity-regularity transitions
2. Energy Condition Issues: Energy condition violations in certain regions require more careful discussion
3. Limited Numerical Verification: Primarily relies on analytical results, lacking numerical simulation verification
4. Unverified Practical Utility: Astrophysical application value of theoretical models requires further assessment

Impact

1. Significant Theoretical Contribution: Provides new research directions for regular black hole theory
2. Observational Application Value: Offers theoretical predictions for future black hole observations
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects gravitational theory, black hole physics, and observational astrophysics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Black Hole Physics Research: Provides new tools for regular black holes and singularity problems
2. Gravitational Collapse Analysis: Applicable to theoretical research of spherically symmetric gravitational collapse
3. Observational Data Interpretation: Can be used to interpret black hole observation results from EHT and similar facilities
4. Alternative Gravity Theories: Provides testing platform for modified gravity theories

References

This paper cites 84 important references, spanning from classical Oppenheimer-Snyder models to the latest EHT observational results, reflecting the comprehensiveness and timeliness of the research. Key references include Bardeen's pioneering work on regular black holes, Hagedorn's hadron spectrum theory, and recent EHT observation reports.

Overall Evaluation: This is an important paper with significant innovations in regular black hole theory, providing not only new mathematical solutions but also discovering new phenomena in black hole evolution. Although physical interpretation and practical applicability require further refinement, its theoretical contributions and observational connections make it an important advance in the field.