ReMamba: Equip Mamba with Effective Long-Sequence Modeling

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2408.15496
• Title: ReMamba: Equip Mamba with Effective Long-Sequence Modeling
• Authors: Danlong Yuan, Jiahao Liu, Bei Li, Huishuai Zhang, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai, Dongyan Zhao
• Category: cs.CL (Computation and Language)
• Publication Date: August 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.15496
• Code Link: https://github.com/lblankl/ReMamba

Abstract

This paper proposes ReMamba to address the performance limitations of the Mamba architecture in long-context understanding tasks. While Mamba demonstrates excellent performance and high inference efficiency on short-context NLP tasks, its performance significantly lags behind Transformer models when processing long contexts. ReMamba enhances Mamba's long-context understanding capability through selective compression and adaptation techniques in a two-stage forward process, introducing only minimal additional inference overhead. On the LongBench and L-Eval benchmarks, ReMamba achieves improvements of 3.2 and 1.6 points respectively over baseline models, with performance approaching equivalent-scale Transformer models.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Issue: The Mamba model exhibits significant performance degradation when processing long contexts (beyond 2k tokens), failing to effectively preserve distant information
2. Significance: Long-context understanding is a critical capability for large language model development, essential for applications such as document understanding and dialogue systems
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Transformers face quadratic computational complexity and linear memory consumption issues
   • Hybrid architectures mitigate these problems but reduce computational efficiency
   • Existing Mamba improvements (e.g., LongMamba, DeciMamba) show limited effectiveness

Research Motivation

Through experimental investigation, the authors discovered that while Mamba surpasses equivalent-scale Transformers on short-context tasks, it exhibits significant performance gaps on long-context tasks. The fixed state space of this RNN-like architecture limits its capacity to preserve distant information, resulting in severe information forgetting problems.

Core Contributions

1. Problem Identification: Preliminary investigation reveals severe information loss in Mamba, with even random compression achieving similar performance
2. ReMamba Method Proposal: Designs a two-stage selective compression and adaptation mechanism that effectively mitigates long-context information loss
3. Significant Performance Improvement: Achieves improvements of 3.2 and 1.6 points on LongBench and L-Eval respectively, approaching Transformer performance
4. Efficiency Preservation: Adds only one additional forward pass overhead while maintaining constant memory consumption and high inference speed
5. Method Generalizability: Successfully extends to the Mamba2 architecture, demonstrating the method's universality

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Long-context sequence {ti}^L_, where L is the sequence length Output: Natural language generation results based on long-context Objective: Enhance long-context understanding capability of Mamba while maintaining its inference efficiency

Model Architecture

ReMamba adopts a two-stage architecture design:

Stage 1: Selective Compression

Compression Range Definition:

• Relative compression range: range := (s, e), where e = s + p
• Absolute index set: R := S, E, where S = L·s+1, E = L·(s+p)
• Compression ratio: ρ, with K := |R|·ρ hidden representations retained

Importance Scoring Mechanism:

q = Query(hL)
{ki}^E_{i=S} = Key({hi}^E_{i=S})
cosi = (ki · q) / max(||ki||2 · ||q||2, ε)

Top-K Selection:

G = argmax_{A⊂{S,S+1,...,E},|A|=K} Σ_{i∈A} cosi

Compressed Representation Generation:

{vi}^K_{i=1} = Value({hj}, j ∈ G)
Tnew = Cat({ti}^{S-1}_{i=1}, {vi}^K_{i=1}, {ti}^L_{i=E+1})

Stage 2: Selective Adaptation

For selected hidden states, modify Mamba's selective mechanism:

α = ReLU(cos'_{t-1})
Δ^l_{t-1}' = Proj1(h^{l-1}_{t-1})
δ = Δ^l_{t-1}' · α + Θ^l
Δ^l_{t-1} = Softplus(δ)

where Θ^l is a trainable layer-wise bias parameter that controls the influence strength of importance scores on state updates.

Technical Innovations

1. Two-Stage Design: First stage compresses information, second stage integrates it, avoiding the complexity of directly modifying SSM scanning algorithms
2. Selective Mechanism Integration: Cleverly leverages Mamba's inherent selective mechanism to integrate importance scores
3. Differentiable Approximation: Ensures training differentiability by modifying Δ values rather than direct multiplication
4. Gradient Scaling Strategy: Scales gradients proportionally to importance scores, emphasizing learning of critical information

Experimental Setup

Datasets

• Training Data: LongOrca dataset (approximately 500k samples)
  • Long instruction-tuning instances from OpenOrca dataset
  • LongAlpaca-12k long-context alignment data
  • Maximum length truncated to 6000 tokens
• Evaluation Data:
  • LongBench-E (English branch): 13 long-context understanding tasks
  • L-Eval: 6 closed-form long-context tasks

Evaluation Metrics

• LongBench: Task-specific accuracy (e.g., ROUGE, EM, F1)
• L-Eval: Closed-form task accuracy
• Inference Speed: tokens/second
• Memory Consumption: GPU memory usage

Comparison Methods

• Baseline Model: Mamba 2.8B (pretrained and fine-tuned versions)
• Comparison Methods:
  • DeciMamba 2.8B
  • Llama-3B (with linear position interpolation for context extension)
• Ablation Studies: Random selection, fixed selection, multiplicative selection variants

Implementation Details

• Hyperparameters: s=0, p=0.18, ρ=0.009 (optimal configuration for LongBench)
• Training Strategy: LoRA fine-tuning, rank=32
• Optimizer: AdamW, learning rate 2e-5
• Hardware: 8×A100-80GB GPUs, DeepSpeed Zero Stage 3

Experimental Results

Main Results

LongBench Performance Comparison:

L-Eval Performance Comparison:

Ablation Studies

Selection Strategy Comparison:

• Random selection: Performance similar to baseline, confirming information loss hypothesis
• Fixed selection: Slightly superior to random selection
• Multiplicative selection: Shows certain improvements
• Complete ReMamba method: Significantly outperforms all variants

Length Generalization Performance:

• ReMamba outperforms baseline across all lengths from 2k-9k
• Optimal performance length extends from 4k to 6k
• Performance gap increases with context length

Efficiency Analysis

Memory Consumption:

• ReMamba adds only minimal constant memory overhead compared to Mamba
• Significantly lower than Transformer's quadratic memory growth

Inference Speed:

• Comparable to original Mamba speed
• Significantly faster than Transformer (approximately 2-3 times)

Mamba2 Extension Experiments

Applying ReMamba to Mamba2 achieves a 1.6-point improvement on LongBench average score, demonstrating the method's generalizability.

Related Work

Long-Context Modeling

1. Transformer Extensions: Position interpolation, RoPE, and other techniques
2. Mamba Improvements: LongMamba through long-context fine-tuning, DeciMamba through training-free methods
3. Hybrid Architectures: Jamba and other methods combining attention and SSM

Context Compression

1. KV Cache Compression: Memory optimization for Transformers
2. Prompt Compression: Soft prompts and retrieval-augmented generation methods
3. Selective Attention: Methods for dynamic resource allocation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Accurate Problem Diagnosis: Successfully identifies the root cause of Mamba's long-context performance limitations
2. Method Effectiveness: ReMamba significantly improves long-context performance, approaching Transformer levels
3. Efficiency Preservation: Maintains Mamba's inference efficiency advantages while improving performance
4. Method Generalizability: Successfully extends to Mamba2, demonstrating good universality

Limitations

1. Theoretical Upper Bound: Due to fixed state space constraints, Mamba struggles to surpass Transformers on ultra-long contexts
2. Method Limitations: Primarily alleviates information loss through compression without fundamentally changing state update mechanisms
3. Hyperparameter Sensitivity: Requires adjustment of compression parameters for different tasks
4. Evaluation Scope: Primarily evaluated on English datasets; multilingual generalization remains to be verified

Future Directions

1. State Mechanism Improvement: Direct modification of state space update mechanisms
2. Adaptive Compression: Dynamically adjust compression strategies based on content
3. Multimodal Extension: Extend the method to vision-language tasks
4. Theoretical Analysis: Deeper investigation of theoretical foundations and performance boundaries

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Deep Problem Insight: Cleverly proves Mamba's information loss problem through random compression experiments
2. Ingenious Method Design: Two-stage design maintains differentiability while effectively leveraging existing mechanisms
3. Comprehensive Experiments: Includes multiple benchmarks, ablation studies, and efficiency analysis
4. Excellent Engineering Implementation: Open-source code facilitates reproduction and application
5. Clear Writing: Logical structure and accurate technical detail descriptions

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Theoretical Analysis: Lacks deep theoretical explanation for why the method is effective
2. Evaluation Limitations: Primarily evaluated on QA-type tasks; insufficient coverage of other long-context task types
3. Complex Hyperparameters: Requires adjustment of multiple hyperparameters; practical applications may require extensive tuning
4. Baseline Comparison: DeciMamba's poor performance may be related to hyperparameter settings

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new insights and effective solutions for Mamba long-context modeling
2. Practical Value: Simple and effective method, easy to deploy in practical systems
3. Reproducibility: Provides complete code and detailed experimental settings
4. Inspirational Significance: Provides reference for improvements to other sequence modeling architectures

Applicable Scenarios

1. Document Understanding: Long document QA, summarization, and other tasks
2. Dialogue Systems: Scenarios requiring maintenance of long dialogue history
3. Code Understanding: Analysis and generation of long code files
4. Resource-Constrained Environments: Edge computing scenarios requiring efficient inference

References

Core Related Works:

1. Gu, A. and Dao, T. (2024). Mamba: Linear-time sequence modeling with selective state spaces.
2. Dao, T. and Gu, A. (2024). Transformers are ssms: Generalized models and efficient algorithms through structured state space duality.
3. Bai, Y. et al. (2024). Longbench: A bilingual, multitask benchmark for long context understanding.
4. Chen, Y. et al. (2024). Longlora: Efficient fine-tuning of long-context large language models.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality research paper that proposes an innovative and effective solution to the long-context understanding problem in the Mamba architecture. The method design is ingenious, experiments are comprehensive, and it possesses good theoretical and practical value. While certain limitations exist, it makes important contributions to the development of the relevant field.