AdS solutions with spindle factors

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2409.04536
• Title: AdS solutions with spindle factors
• Author: Minwoo Suh (Kumoh National Institute of Technology)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: September 2024 (arXiv:2409.04536v2, updated October 14, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.04536

Abstract

This paper provides spindle interpretations for known supergravity solutions, including the $AdS_3\times\Sigma\times S^1\times KE_2^+\times T^2$ solution in IIB supergravity and the $AdS_2\times\Sigma\times S^1\times KE_4^+\times T^2$ solution in eleven-dimensional supergravity, where $\Sigma$ is a spindle factor. For the $AdS_3$ solution, the internal space $\Sigma\times S^1\times KE_2^+$ was previously referred to as the $\mathscr{Y}^{p,q}$ manifold, which shares the same topology as the $Y^{p,q}$ manifold. Unlike previously known spindle solutions, the gauge supergravity origin and field theory duals of these solutions remain unclear. The author performs flux quantization calculations and computes the holographic central charge and the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of the presumed black hole solutions, respectively.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Problem: This paper aims to provide new geometric interpretations for known anti-de Sitter (AdS) supergravity solutions, particularly identifying spindle structures within them. A spindle is a weighted projective space $WCP^1_{[n_-,n_+]}$ with orbifold singularities.
2. Significance:
   • Spindle solutions are important in the AdS/CFT correspondence, describing the geometry of membranes wrapped on orbifolds
   • These solutions are closely related to the properties of holographically dual field theories
   • They are valuable for understanding topological structures and quantization conditions in supergravity
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • Previous "minimal" spindle solutions arise from four- and five-dimensional minimal gauge supergravity with clear gauge supergravity origins
   • The solutions studied in this paper come from more complex geometries whose gauge supergravity origins and field theory duals remain unclear
4. Research Motivation:
   • To refine understanding of spindle structures in Gauntlett-Kim (GK) geometries
   • To establish topological connections with known $Y^{p,q}$ manifolds
   • To provide geometric foundations for finding corresponding field theory duals

Core Contributions

1. Geometric Reinterpretation: Provides new spindle geometric interpretations for known AdS solutions in reference 8
2. Topological Analysis: Proves that the internal space of the $AdS_3$ solution has the same topology as the $Y^{p,q}$ manifold
3. Flux Quantization: Completes comprehensive flux quantization analysis for the $Q=0$ case
4. Holographic Calculations: Computes the holographic central charge for the $AdS_3$ solution and the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy for the $AdS_2$ solution
5. Global Completion: Performs global analysis on the $AdS_2$ solution for the first time (previously only local forms were available)

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The core task of this paper is to reinterpret known supergravity solutions, identify their spindle structures, and perform corresponding physical quantity calculations. Specifically:

• Input: Metrics and fluxes of known local supergravity solutions
• Output: Global description of spindle geometry, quantization conditions, physical observables
• Constraints: Supergravity equations, topological consistency, flux quantization conditions

Model Architecture

Spindle Structure of the AdS₃ Solution

For the $AdS_3$ solution in IIB supergravity, the author rewrites the metric as:

$\frac{1}{L^2}ds_{10}^2 = \frac{\beta}{y^{1/2}}\left[ds_{AdS_3}^2 + \frac{1}{4\beta^2y^2U}dy^2 + \frac{U}{4(1-Q^2y^2)}dz^2 + \frac{1-Q^2y^2}{4\beta^2}\left(D\psi - \frac{y(1-Q^2y)}{1-Q^2y^2}dz\right)^2 + \frac{1}{\beta^2}ds_{S^2}^2 + \frac{y}{\beta^2}ds_{T^2}^2\right]$

where the key two-dimensional surface is: $ds_\Sigma^2 = \frac{1}{4\beta^2y^2U}dy^2 + \frac{U}{4(1-Q^2y^2)}dz^2$

Spindle Structure of the AdS₂ Solution

For the $AdS_2$ solution in eleven-dimensional supergravity, the corresponding two-dimensional surface is: $ds_\Sigma^2 = \frac{9\beta}{yU}dy^2 + \frac{U}{1-Qy^3}dz^2$

Technical Innovations

1. Completing the Square Technique: Clearly separates the spindle geometric structure by completing the square for $D\psi$
2. Euler Characteristic Calculation: Utilizes the Gauss-Bonnet theorem to compute topological invariants of the spindle
3. Charge Quantization: Determines the topological charge of the spindle through integration of gauge field strengths
4. Parameter Relations: Establishes explicit correspondence between geometric parameters and topological integers $(n_+,n_-)$

For the $AdS_3$ solution, the key relations are: $\chi(\Sigma) = \frac{1}{n_+} + \frac{1}{n_-}$ (Euler characteristic) $Q = \frac{1}{n_+} - \frac{1}{n_-}$ (charge quantization, anti-twist class)

Experimental Setup

Parameter Constraints

• $AdS_3$ solution: $0 < \beta^2 < 1$, $0 \leq Q^2 \leq \frac{1}{1-\beta^2}$
• $AdS_2$ solution: $\frac{n_-}{2} < n_+ < 2n_-$ (ensures positive-definiteness of the geometry)

Special Case Analysis

Focuses on the $Q=0$ case, where:

• The three-form flux vanishes
• Only the self-dual five-form flux is non-trivial
• The geometric structure is more concise, facilitating exact calculations

Quantization Conditions

Determines quantization parameters $N$ and $M$ by requiring flux integrals to be integers: $N_{(D)} = \frac{1}{(2\pi\ell_s)^4 g_s}\int_D F_{(5)} \in \mathbb{Z}$

Experimental Results

Main Results

Holographic Central Charge of the AdS₃ Solution

$c = \frac{24n_+n_-(n_+-n_-)^2NM}{(n_++n_-)^2}$

This result is consistent with calculations in reference 8, but now has a clear spindle geometric interpretation.

Bekenstein-Hawking Entropy of the AdS₂ Solution

$S_{BH} = \frac{8\sqrt{6}\pi^2}{\sqrt{\text{vol}_{KE_4^+}}} \frac{n_-(n_++n_-)^2(n_+-2n_-)^2(2n_+-n_-)^3\sqrt{n_+(2n_+^2-3n_+n_-+n_-^2)}}{n_+^2-n_+n_-+n_-^2} MN^{1/2}$

Topological Classification

• The $AdS_3$ solution belongs to the anti-twist class spindle
• The $AdS_2$ solution belongs to the twist class spindle
• This forms an interesting contrast with the classification of minimal spindle solutions

Flux Quantization Verification

All computed flux integrals yield integer values, verifying the self-consistency of quantization conditions.

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Minimal Spindle Solutions: Pioneering work by Ferrero et al. 1,2 established spindle solutions in four- and five-dimensional minimal gauge supergravity
2. GK Geometry: Gauntlett-Kim geometry provides a systematic framework for constructing supersymmetric AdS solutions 3,4,5
3. $Y^{p,q}$ Manifolds: Spindle structures in five-dimensional Sasaki-Einstein manifolds have recently been identified 14

Uniqueness of This Paper

• First identification of spindle structures in complex geometries with additional $T^2$ factors
• Provides concrete proof of topological equivalence with known $Y^{p,q}$ manifolds
• Completes previously missing global analysis of the $AdS_2$ solution

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully identifies the spindle geometric structure of AdS solutions in reference 8
2. Establishes topological connections with $Y^{p,q}$ manifolds, supporting observations in reference 14
3. Completes comprehensive physical analysis for the $Q=0$ case

Limitations

1. Gauge Supergravity Origin Unclear: Unlike minimal spindle solutions, the low-dimensional effective theory for these solutions remains undetermined
2. Field Theory Dual Missing: Currently unable to explicitly identify corresponding holographic dual field theories
3. $Q\neq 0$ Case: Analysis of more general cases remains incomplete

Future Directions

1. Finding Field Theory Duals: Through extremization principles, gravitational blocks, or equivariant localization methods
2. Gauge Supergravity Origin: Identifying corresponding low-dimensional effective theories
3. Twist Class Differences: Understanding the differences in twist class between $AdS_2$ and $AdS_3$ solutions
4. Generalization to $Q\neq 0$: Completing analysis for more general parameter cases

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Deep Geometric Insight: Successfully identifying spindle structures in complex geometries demonstrates profound geometric intuition
2. Rigorous Calculations: Flux quantization and physical quantity calculations are careful and comprehensive
3. Precise Topological Analysis: Calculations of Euler characteristics and charge quantization provide solid foundations for subsequent research
4. Clear Presentation: Mathematical derivations are well-organized and physical descriptions are accurate

Weaknesses

1. Incomplete Physical Picture: Lack of field theory duals makes physical interpretation incomplete
2. Limited Scope of Application: Only considers the special case $Q=0$
3. Relationship with Known Results: While establishing connections with $Y^{p,q}$, deeper physical meanings remain to be explored

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new examples and methods for studying spindle geometries in AdS/CFT
2. Technical Value: Geometric analysis techniques serve as reference for related research
3. Future Potential: Establishes geometric foundations for discovering new holographic dual relationships

Applicable Scenarios

• Geometric analysis in supergravity theory
• Construction of new solutions in AdS/CFT correspondence
• Research in topological field theory and holographic duality
• Compactification problems in string theory

References

This paper is primarily based on the following key references:

• 1,2 Pioneering work by Ferrero et al. on minimal spindle solutions
• 8 Original paper by Donos, Gauntlett, Kim on transgression AdS solutions
• 14 Latest findings by Ferrero on spindle structures of $Y^{p,q}$ manifolds
• 9 Non-spindle form analysis of related $AdS_3$ solutions