Spin-hydrodynamics of electrons in graphene and magnetization due to thermal vorticity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2409.07764
• Title: Spin-hydrodynamics of electrons in graphene and magnetization due to thermal vorticity
• Author: Amaresh Jaiswal (National Institute of Science Education and Research, India)
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall hep-ph hep-th nucl-th
• Publication Date: September 2024 (arXiv preprint, last revised December 31, 2024)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.07764

Abstract

This paper investigates the relativistic spin-hydrodynamics framework within the context of electron hydrodynamics in graphene. The author develops a spin-hydrodynamics model for (2+1)-dimensional fermionic systems under small spin polarization conditions. The analysis confirms that thermal vorticity satisfying global equilibrium conditions is also a solution to the spin-hydrodynamics equations. Furthermore, the magnetization of the system under global equilibrium is calculated, and a novel phenomenon—thermal vorticity magnetization—is introduced, which can be experimentally observed in graphene.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Rise of electron hydrodynamics: The hydrodynamic behavior of electrons in solid-state systems has attracted widespread attention, with graphene serving as an ideal platform for exploring electron hydrodynamics due to its simple band structure.
2. Unique properties of graphene: Quasiparticles in graphene exhibit "relativistic" dispersion relations E(p) = ±v_F|p|, where v_F is the Fermi velocity. This linear dispersion relation describes massless fermions.
3. Development of relativistic spin hydrodynamics: Spin polarization phenomena observed in heavy-ion collisions have promoted the development of relativistic spin hydrodynamics. However, due to the extremely short lifetime of the fireball, certain key predictions are difficult to verify experimentally.

Research Motivation

1. Need for verification platform: Graphene electron hydrodynamics provides an ideal platform for verifying global equilibrium solutions of relativistic spin hydrodynamics, avoiding the short-lifetime issues in heavy-ion collisions.
2. Theoretical refinement: A complete spin-hydrodynamics framework for (2+1)-dimensional systems is needed.
3. Prediction of new phenomena: Exploration of observable effects caused by thermal vorticity, particularly magnetization phenomena.

Core Contributions

1. Established a spin-hydrodynamics framework for (2+1)-dimensional fermionic systems applicable to graphene electron systems under small spin polarization conditions.
2. Proved the validity of thermal vorticity solutions: Confirmed that thermal vorticity satisfying global equilibrium conditions is also a solution to the (2+1)-dimensional spin-hydrodynamics equations.
3. Calculated system magnetization under global equilibrium: Derived analytical expressions for the magnetization tensor.
4. Proposed the novel phenomenon of thermal vorticity magnetization: A new effect caused by thermal vorticity that can be experimentally observed in graphene.
5. Designed experimental implementation schemes: Proposed specific methods to realize thermal vorticity states through radial temperature gradients.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Density Operator and Equilibrium State

Within the quantum statistical mechanics framework, local thermodynamic equilibrium is defined as the state that maximizes entropy S = -Tr(ρ̂ln ρ̂), where ρ̂ is the density operator:

ρ̂_LE = (1/Z_LE) exp[-∫σ dσμ(T̂μνβν - (1/2)ωαβŜμ,αβ - αN̂μ)]

Global equilibrium conditions require that the Lagrange multipliers satisfy:

• ∂μβν = ωνμ
• ∂μωνγ = 0
• ∂μα = 0

This leads to the definition of thermal vorticity:

ϖμν = -(1/2)(∂μβν - ∂νβμ) = const.

Distribution Function

For particles and antiparticles, a spin density matrix is introduced:

f⁺_rs(x,p) = (1/2m)ūr(p)X⁺_us(p)
f⁻_rs(x,p) = -(1/2m)v̄s(p)X⁻_vr(p)

where the matrix X± is defined as:

X± = [exp(β·p ∓ α)exp(±(1/2)ω:Σ) + I]⁻¹

Conservation Law Calculations

Under the small polarization approximation, through Taylor expansion:

Charge current:

N^μ = nu^μ

Energy-momentum tensor:

T^μν = (ε + P)u^μu^ν - Pg^μν

Spin tensor:

S^λ,μν = w u^λω^μν

where the thermodynamic quantities are:

n = (T²/π)[Li₂(-e⁻α) - Li₂(-e^α)]
ε = (2T³/π)[-Li₃(-e⁻α) - Li₃(-e^α)]
P = ε/2
w = (T²/4π)ln(2 + 2cosh α)

Magnetization Tensor

The magnetization tensor is defined as:

M^μν = m∫(d²p/2(2π)²|p|)tr[m^μν₊X₊ - m^μν₋X₋]

Upon calculation:

M^μν = (ge/8π)T tanh(α/2)ω^μν

Experimental Setup

Construction of Thermal Vorticity Solution

Considering rigid vortex motion of fluid in two-dimensional space, the hydrodynamic velocity components are defined as:

u⁰ = γ, u¹ = -γΩy, u² = γΩx

where Ω is the constant rotation velocity and γ = 1/√(1-Ω²r²) is the local Lorentz γ factor.

The temperature and chemical potential distributions are:

T = T₀γ, μ = μ₀γ

This leads to a constant thermal vorticity matrix:

ω^μν = ϖ^μν = [0   0      0   ]
               [0   0      Ω/T₀]  
               [0  -Ω/T₀   0   ]

Experimental Implementation Scheme

The following approach is proposed to realize the thermal vorticity state:

1. Initial condition setup: Establish a radially increasing temperature gradient on the graphene surface: T = T₀/√(1-Ω²r²)
2. Heat source configuration: Use Joule heating from nanowires as an external heat source to maintain the required temperature gradient.
3. Evolution process: After turning off the external heat source, hydrodynamic evolution drives the system toward the nearest equilibrium state (thermal vorticity state).

Experimental Results

Thermal Vorticity Magnetization

Under the thermal vorticity solution, the magnetization tensor is:

M^μν = (ge/8π)tanh(α/2)(Ω/√(1-Ω²r²))[0   0   0]
                                       [0   0   1]
                                       [0  -1   0]

Main Findings

1. Radial dependence of magnetization: Thermal vorticity magnetization increases with radial distance from the vortex center.
2. Saturation effect: Although net number density increases with α, magnetization exhibits tanh(α/2) saturation behavior due to Pauli blocking effects.
3. Barnett-like effect: This phenomenon is similar to the Barnett effect observed in solids but originates from thermal vorticity.

Solution Verification

Direct calculation verifies that the thermal vorticity solution satisfies all hydrodynamic equations of motion:

• Comoving derivatives: ṅ = 0, ε̇ = 0, Ṗ = 0, ẇ = 0, θ = 0
• Pressure gradient balances fluid acceleration: (1/(ε+P))∂αP = u̇α

Related Work

Graphene Electron Hydrodynamics

• Experimental verification of quantum critical scattering rates and dual-current modes
• Confirmation of relativistic hydrodynamic behavior similar to quark-gluon plasma

Relativistic Spin Hydrodynamics

• Successfully explained global spin polarization in heavy-ion collisions
• Sign issues in longitudinal spin polarization may originate from systems not reaching global equilibrium

Thermal Vorticity Theory

• Widely applied as a global equilibrium solution in heavy-ion physics
• This work represents the first application to condensed matter systems

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical framework established: Successfully constructed a (2+1)-dimensional spin-hydrodynamics theory applicable to graphene.
2. Validity of thermal vorticity solutions: Demonstrated that thermal vorticity is a valid solution to spin-hydrodynamics equations in (2+1) dimensions.
3. Prediction of new phenomena: Thermal vorticity magnetization represents a new observable physical phenomenon.
4. Experimental feasibility: Proposed specific schemes to realize thermal vorticity states through temperature gradients.

Limitations

1. Small polarization approximation: The theoretical framework is based on small spin polarization assumptions, limiting its applicability range.
2. Non-dissipative approximation: Current work is based on non-dissipative formulas, not accounting for dissipative effects such as rotational viscosity.
3. Neglect of external fields: Does not include the effects of external magnetic fields on graphene electrons.
4. Idealized conditions: Experimental realization requires precise temperature distribution control, imposing high technical requirements.

Future Directions

1. Dissipative effects: Exploration of new transport coefficients such as rotational viscosity and bulk thermal conductivity.
2. Magnetohydrodynamics: Incorporation of external magnetic field effects through spin-magnetohydrodynamics framework.
3. Microscopic theory connection: Establishment of relationships between transport coefficients and graphene microscopic theory.
4. Experimental verification: Conduct actual experimental measurements of thermal vorticity magnetization in graphene.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First application of relativistic spin hydrodynamics to graphene systems, opening new research directions.
2. Mathematical rigor: Derivation from quantum statistical mechanics with rigorous procedures and theoretically sound results.
3. Physical insight: The predicted thermal vorticity magnetization phenomenon has clear physical imagery and experimental significance.
4. Interdisciplinary significance: Connects high-energy physics, nuclear physics, and condensed matter physics, promoting cross-disciplinary collaboration.

Weaknesses

1. Experimental challenges: The proposed temperature gradient scheme may face technical difficulties in practical implementation.
2. Effect magnitude: Thermal vorticity magnetization may be small, requiring high-precision measurement techniques for experimental detection.
3. Theoretical completeness: Lacks systematic treatment of dissipative effects and external fields.
4. Numerical estimates: Absence of specific numerical predictions limits experimental guidance.

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new theoretical tools and research perspectives for graphene physics.
2. Experimental inspiration: May stimulate related experimental research to verify relativistic hydrodynamics predictions.
3. Method generalization: The established framework can be extended to other two-dimensional material systems.
4. Fundamental physics: Deepens understanding of spin-orbit coupling and topological effects.

Application Scenarios

1. Basic research: Spin transport research in graphene and other two-dimensional materials.
2. Device applications: Magnetization control in spintronics devices.
3. Theory verification: Experimental verification platform for relativistic hydrodynamics theory.
4. Cross-disciplinary fields: Bridge connecting high-energy physics theory with condensed matter experiments.

References

The paper cites 85 relevant references, primarily including:

• Experimental and theoretical research on graphene electron hydrodynamics
• Theoretical development of relativistic spin hydrodynamics
• Spin polarization phenomena in heavy-ion collisions
• Foundations of quantum statistical mechanics and relativistic field theory

Key references include pioneering work by Florkowski et al. on spin hydrodynamics, thermal vorticity theory by Becattini et al., and reviews on graphene hydrodynamics by Lucas and Narozhny.