2025-11-10T02:39:01.920030

Steady Ring-Shaped Vortex Sheets

Meyer, Seis
In this work, we construct traveling wave solutions to the two-phase Euler equations, featuring a vortex sheet at the interface between the two phases. The inner phase exhibits a uniform vorticity distribution and may represent a vacuum, forming what is known as a hollow vortex. These traveling waves take the form of ring-shaped vortices with a small cross-sectional radius, referred to as thin rings. Our construction is based on the implicit function theorem, which also guarantees local uniqueness of the solutions. Additionally, we derive asymptotics for the speed of the ring, generalizing the well-known Kelvin--Hicks formula to cases that include surface tension.
academic

Steady Ring-Shaped Vortex Sheets

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2409.08220
  • Title: Steady Ring-Shaped Vortex Sheets
  • Authors: David Meyer (Instituto de Ciencias Matemáticas, Madrid), Christian Seis (Universität Münster)
  • Classification: math.AP (Analysis of PDEs)
  • Submitted Journal: Journal of the European Mathematical Society (JEMS)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.08220

Abstract

This paper constructs traveling wave solutions to the two-phase Euler equations with vortex sheets present at the two-phase interface. The inner phase exhibits uniform vorticity distribution, possibly representing a vacuum, forming so-called hollow vortices. These traveling waves manifest as ring-shaped vortices with small cross-sectional radius, termed slender rings. The construction is based on the implicit function theorem, which also guarantees local uniqueness of solutions. Furthermore, asymptotic formulas for the ring velocity are derived, generalizing the celebrated Kelvin-Hicks formula to include surface tension effects.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Description

  1. Core Problem: Construct steady-state ring-shaped vortex sheet solutions to the three-dimensional incompressible Euler equations, particularly "slender ring" vortices with small cross-sectional radius
  2. Physical Background: Vortex rings are ubiquitous in nature, such as smoke rings from Mount Etna, bubble rings produced by dolphins and whales, and similar phenomena
  3. Mathematical Challenge: Vortex sheets are ill-posed in the Hadamard sense, as Kelvin-Helmholtz instability causes small perturbations to grow exponentially

Research Significance

  1. Theoretical Importance: First rigorous establishment of existence for vortex rings with surface tension and hollow vortices
  2. Historical Position: Since Hill's spherical vortex in 1894, rigorous mathematical construction of ring-shaped vortices has been an important problem in fluid mechanics
  3. Physical Application: Provides mathematical foundation for understanding vortex ring phenomena observed in nature

Limitations of Existing Methods

  1. Classical Results: Work by Fraenkel (1970) and Norbury (1972) limited to cases without surface tension
  2. Technical Difficulties: Singularities of vortex sheets make standard PDE theory difficult to apply directly
  3. Asymptotic Formulas: Classical Kelvin-Hicks formula does not account for surface tension effects

Core Contributions

  1. First Construction: Rigorous construction of ring-shaped vortex sheet solutions and hollow vortices with surface tension
  2. Theoretical Framework: Systematic construction method based on the implicit function theorem, guaranteeing local uniqueness
  3. Asymptotic Formula: Generalization of the Kelvin-Hicks formula to include surface tension effects
  4. Mathematical Techniques: Development of new techniques for handling singular integral kernels and overdetermined boundary problems

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Construct axisymmetric steady traveling wave solutions (U,P)(U, P) satisfying:

  • Two-phase Euler equations: ρ(U−cˉez)⋅∇U+∇P=0\rho(U-\bar{c}e_z) \cdot \nabla U + \nabla P = 0
  • Incompressibility condition: div U=0\text{div } U = 0
  • Interface conditions: Continuous normal velocity, Young-Laplace pressure jump
  • Ring geometry: Cross-section approximately a disk Bϵ(R,0)B_\epsilon(R,0), where ϵ≪R\epsilon \ll R

Core Mathematical Framework

1. Stream Function Equation

Transform the problem into an elliptic boundary value problem for the stream function ψ\psi:

\xi r & \text{in } \Omega \\ 0 & \text{in } \Omega^c \end{cases}$$ #### 2. Overdetermined Boundary Problem Key innovation: formulate the vortex sheet condition as an overdetermined boundary problem: - Dirichlet condition: $\psi - \frac{\bar{W}}{2}r^2 = \bar{\gamma}$ on $\partial\Omega$ - Jump condition: $[\rho(\frac{1}{r}\partial_n\psi - \bar{c}n \cdot e_r)^2] + 2\bar{\sigma}H = \bar{B}$ on $\partial\Omega$ #### 3. Small Parameter Expansion Introduce small parameter $\epsilon = \epsilon/R \ll 1$, using blow-up variables: $$q(r,z) = \frac{1}{\epsilon}(r-R, z)$$ ### Technical Innovations #### 1. Integral Equation Method Reformulate the exterior problem as an integral equation: $$\int_{\partial\Omega_\theta} K_{\theta,\epsilon}(y,\tilde{y}) \mu_{\theta,\epsilon}(\tilde{y}) d\mathcal{H}^1(\tilde{y}) = \frac{W}{2}(1+\epsilon(\chi_\theta)_1(y))^2 + \gamma$$ where the kernel $K_{\theta,\epsilon}$ is based on the fundamental solution of the elliptic operator. #### 2. Lyapunov-Schmidt Reduction Handle degeneracy caused by translation invariance: - Decompose the jump condition as $F = F_1 + F_2$ - $F_1$: Projection onto the $y_1$ direction, handled via reduction parameter $S$ - $F_2$: Orthogonal complement space, apply implicit function theorem #### 3. Asymptotic Analysis Fine asymptotic expansion of the kernel function: $$K_{\theta,\epsilon}(y,\tilde{y}) = \frac{1}{2\pi}\left(\log\frac{1}{|y-\tilde{y}|} + \log\frac{1}{\epsilon} + \log(8) - 2\right) + O(\epsilon)$$ ## Experimental Setup ### Parameter Ranges - **Aspect Ratio**: $\epsilon = \epsilon/R \ll 1$ - **Density Ratio**: $\rho = \frac{1}{(4\pi)^2}\frac{\bar{\Gamma}_{int}^2}{\bar{\Gamma}_{ext}^2}\frac{\rho_{int}}{\rho_{ext}} \geq 0$ - **Weber Number**: $\text{We} = \frac{\rho_{ext}\bar{\Gamma}_{ext}^2}{\epsilon\bar{\sigma}}$, satisfying specific growth conditions ### Function Space Setup - Geometric perturbation: $\theta \in H^k(\partial B)$ with $k \geq 5$ - Stream function: $\varphi_{int} \in H^{k+1/2}(\Omega_\theta)$, $\varphi_{ext} \in H^k(H_{1/\epsilon})$ - Constraints: Volume conservation, fixed center of mass, symmetry ## Main Results ### Existence Theorem (Theorem 1.3) For parameters satisfying the conditions, there exists $\epsilon_0 > 0$ such that for all $\epsilon \in (0,\epsilon_0)$, there exists a solution $(\theta, \varphi_{int}, \varphi_{ext}, W, \gamma, \nu)$. ### Asymptotic Formula The velocity of the ring satisfies the generalized Kelvin-Hicks formula: $$W = \frac{1}{4\pi}\left(\log\frac{8R}{\epsilon} - \frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{4}\frac{\bar{\Gamma}_{int}^2}{\bar{\Gamma}_{ext}^2}\frac{\rho_{int}}{\rho_{ext}}\right) + \frac{\pi R}{\bar{\Gamma}_{ext}\rho_{ext}}\epsilon\bar{\sigma}_\epsilon + o(1)$$ ### Uniqueness In the appropriate solution class, the solution is locally unique, guaranteed by the implicit function theorem. ## Technical Details ### Key Estimates 1. **Kernel Function Bound**: $\|K_{\theta,\epsilon}f\|_{H^k} \lesssim |\log\epsilon|\|f\|_{H^{k-1}}$ 2. **Geometric Quantity Regularity**: Curvature $h_{\theta,\epsilon}$ is smooth in $H^{k-2}(\partial B)$ 3. **Error Estimate**: $\|E_{\theta,\epsilon}(S)\|_{H^{k-1}} \lesssim (1+|S|)|\log\epsilon|(\epsilon^2 + \|\theta\|_{H^k}^2)$ ### Degeneracy Handling Fourier symbol of the linearized operator: $$\lim_{\epsilon \to 0} \frac{1}{\beta_\epsilon}\left(8\rho + \frac{1}{2\pi^2}\right)(1-|k|) - 1 + k^2$$ Degeneracy is avoided through condition (1.43). ## Related Work ### Historical Development 1. **Hill (1894)**: First explicit spherical vortex solution 2. **Fraenkel (1970)**: Slender ring vortices with small cross-section 3. **Norbury (1972)**: Thick ring vortices 4. **Recent Progress**: Contributions by Cao et al., Burton, Ambrosetti-Struwe, and others ### Technical Comparison - **Advantages**: First treatment of surface tension and hollow vortices - **Methods**: Overdetermined boundary problems vs. variational methods - **Scope**: Generalization of classical Kelvin-Hicks formula ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. Successfully constructed ring-shaped vortex sheet solutions with surface tension 2. Established asymptotic velocity formulas including surface tension effects 3. Proved local existence, uniqueness, and smoothness of solutions ### Limitations 1. **Small Cross-Section Restriction**: Method applies only to $\epsilon \ll 1$ 2. **Parameter Constraints**: Weber number must satisfy specific growth conditions 3. **Local Nature**: Only guarantees local existence and uniqueness ### Future Directions 1. **Bifurcation Analysis**: Study bifurcation phenomena at critical Weber numbers 2. **Stability Analysis**: Analyze linear stability of solutions 3. **Numerical Verification**: Develop high-precision numerical methods to verify theoretical results ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Breakthrough**: First rigorous treatment of vortex sheet problems with surface tension 2. **Technical Innovation**: Development of systematic methods for handling singular integral kernels 3. **Mathematical Rigor**: Complete theory of existence, uniqueness, and regularity 4. **Physical Significance**: Provides mathematical explanation for natural phenomena ### Weaknesses 1. **Technical Complexity**: Requires advanced Sobolev space theory, potentially limiting applications 2. **Parameter Restrictions**: Multiple technical assumptions may be overly restrictive 3. **Computational Verification**: Lacks numerical experiments supporting theoretical results ### Impact 1. **Academic Value**: Provides new perspective on classical problems in fluid mechanics 2. **Methodological Contribution**: Techniques for handling overdetermined boundary problems have general applicability 3. **Application Potential**: Lays foundation for engineering applications of vortex dynamics ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical Fluid Mechanics**: Mathematical theory of vortex dynamics 2. **Oceanography**: Modeling of oceanic vortex structures 3. **Atmospheric Science**: Theoretical analysis of atmospheric vortices ## References The paper contains 57 references, spanning from classical works by Hill, Kelvin, and Hicks to modern partial differential equation theory, reflecting both deep historical heritage and integration of contemporary mathematical techniques. --- **Overall Assessment**: This is a high-quality mathematical analysis paper that successfully resolves a classical problem in fluid mechanics. While technically demanding, its theoretical contributions and methodological innovations possess significant academic value.