Hunting Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter in Lyman-α Forest

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2409.10617
• Title: Hunting Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter in Lyman-α Forest
• Authors: Akash Kumar Saha, Abhijeet Singh, Priyank Parashari, Ranjan Laha
• Classification: astro-ph.CO astro-ph.HE gr-qc hep-ph hep-th
• Publication Date: October 15, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.10617

Abstract

The identity of dark matter remains an extremely pressing question in contemporary physics. Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) represent one of the most theoretically motivated dark matter candidates. Light-mass PBHs have been constrained through non-detection of Hawking radiation itself, or through non-observation of measurable effects of this radiation on astrophysical and cosmological observables. This paper constrains the contribution of PBHs to the dark matter density through non-detection of effects of Hawking radiation on the temperature evolution of the intergalactic medium (IGM). The study employs the latest IGM temperature data derived from Lyman-α forest observations, providing constraints on the PBH contribution to dark matter for both rotating and non-rotating black holes in the mass range 5×10¹⁵ g - 10¹⁷ g.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

1. Dark Matter Identity Problem: Dark matter constitutes approximately 85% of the current matter content, yet its non-gravitational properties remain undiscovered, making this one of the central questions in modern cosmology and particle physics.
2. Theoretical Motivation for Primordial Black Holes:
   • PBHs represent one of the most theoretically motivated dark matter candidates
   • Do not rely on new particle physics beyond the Standard Model
   • Can form in the early universe through multiple mechanisms
3. Limitations of Existing Constraints:
   • Direct searches for Hawking evaporation radiation have produced stringent constraints on low-mass PBH dark matter
   • New, independent observational methods are needed to further constrain the PBH parameter space

Research Motivation

This paper is the first to use Lyman-α forest observations to constrain the abundance of evaporating PBH dark matter, providing a novel, complementary probe with different systematic uncertainties from other constraint observations.

Core Contributions

1. First Application: First use of Lyman-α forest observations to constrain the abundance of light-mass primordial black hole dark matter
2. New Observational Window: Provides competitive constraints for PBHs in the mass range 5×10¹⁵ g - 10¹⁷ g
3. Dual Analysis Framework: Develops two analytical approaches: "conservative model" and "photoheating model"
4. Rotation Effects: Separately considers both rotating and non-rotating black holes
5. Complementarity Demonstration: Proves the complementarity of this method with existing constraint approaches

Methodology Details

Task Definition

By analyzing the impact of Hawking radiation on the temperature evolution of the intergalactic medium, utilizing Lyman-α forest observational data to constrain the fractional abundance of primordial black holes as dark matter (fPBH).

Theoretical Framework

Hawking Evaporation Energy Injection

The Hawking radiation temperature of a PBH is given by:

TPBH = (1/4πGMPBH) × (√(1-a*²)/(1+√(1-a*²)))

where a* is the reduced spin parameter.

For non-rotating PBHs (a* = 0):

TPBH = 1/(8πGMPBH) = 1.06 × (10¹³ g/MPBH) GeV

Energy Deposition Mechanism

The energy deposition rate injected into the IGM is related to the Hawking evaporation energy injection rate:

(dE/dVdt)dep = fc(z) × (dE/dVdt)inj

where fc(z) is the deposition efficiency for channel c at redshift z.

Analysis Methods

1. Conservative Model

• Completely neglects photoheating effects from astrophysical sources
• Produces relatively weaker constraints but is completely independent of reionization history
• Applies penalties only when PBH contributions exceed temperature measurements

2. Photoheating Model

• Accounts for photoionization and photoheating from reionization sources
• Employs standard χ² analysis
• Produces stricter constraints but depends on reionization modeling

Technical Innovations

1. DarkHistory Code Modifications: Develops two methods to integrate PBH evaporation into the DarkHistory code
2. Multiple Reionization Models: Employs 'Tanh', 'FlexKnot', and 'Trac' models to handle electron fraction constraints
3. Systematic Treatment: Obtains conservative limits by avoiding the helium reionization region

Experimental Setup

Datasets

Three primary Lyman-α forest temperature measurement datasets are employed:

1. Walther et al. (2019):
   • Redshift range: 1.8 < z < 5.2
   • Method: Lyman-α flux power spectrum analysis
   • Data sources: BOSS, XQ-100, Keck/HIRES, Magellan/MIKE
2. Boera et al. (2019):
   • Redshift range: 4 < z < 5.2
   • Method: Flux power spectrum comparison with hydrodynamic simulations
   • Data sources: High-resolution spectra from 15 quasars
3. Gaikwad et al. (2020):
   • Redshift range: 5.4 < z < 5.8
   • Method: Transmission peak width analysis
   • Data sources: 5 quasars with z > 6

Constraints

• Avoids data points at z < 3.6 to circumvent helium reionization
• Selects higher temperature data points to obtain conservative limits
• Employs Planck CMB constraints on free electron fraction

Experimental Results

Primary Constraint Results

Non-rotating PBHs (a* = 0)

• For PBHs with mass 10¹⁶ g: fPBH < 0.1% (conservative model)
• Photoheating model yields stricter constraints but with larger uncertainty bands

Rotating PBHs (a* = 0.9999)

• Constraints show slight variations due to different evaporation spectra of rotating PBHs
• Overall constraint strength is comparable to the non-rotating case

Comparison with Existing Constraints

The constraints in this paper are competitive within the PBH mass range 5×10¹⁵ - 10¹⁷ g and complement the following existing constraints:

• 511 keV gamma-ray line constraints
• Cosmic ray measurements
• X-ray background constraints
• CMB constraints
• Supernova neutrino background constraints

Related Work

Application of Lyman-α Forest in BSM Physics

• Warm dark matter constraints
• Decaying dark matter studies
• Fuzzy dark matter limits
• Dark photon dark matter detection

Other Methods for PBH Constraints

• Direct Hawking radiation searches
• CMB spectral distortions
• 21cm global signal
• Gravitational wave detection
• Microlensing

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Lyman-α forest observations provide a new, competitive method for constraining evaporating PBH dark matter
2. For non-rotating PBHs with mass 10¹⁶ g, constrains their dark matter component to < 0.1%
3. The systematic uncertainties of this method differ from other constraint methods, providing important complementarity

Limitations

1. Mass Range Limitation: Applicable only to PBHs with mass > 5×10¹⁵ g, as lighter PBHs lose mass significantly
2. Reionization Uncertainty: Photoheating model constraints depend on reionization history modeling
3. Monochromatic Mass Distribution Assumption: Assumes all PBHs have identical mass

Future Directions

1. Higher Precision Observations: Future high-resolution quasar measurements will provide more accurate IGM temperature estimates
2. Extended Mass Distributions: Explore constraints on other mass distributions such as lognormal
3. Improved Reionization Modeling: Better reionization models will improve photoheating constraints

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: First application of Lyman-α forest to PBH constraints, opening new research directions
2. Technical Rigor: Detailed theoretical calculations and numerical implementations, including professional modifications to the DarkHistory code
3. Strong Complementarity: Provides independent constraints with different systematic uncertainties from existing methods
4. Dual Verification: Cross-validates results through two different code modification approaches

Weaknesses

1. Data Limitations: Currently available Lyman-α forest temperature data is relatively limited
2. Theoretical Uncertainties: Reionization process modeling still contains substantial theoretical uncertainties
3. Mass Window: Cannot constrain extremely light-mass PBHs

Impact

1. Interdisciplinary Connection: Bridges dark matter physics and observational cosmology
2. Methodological Contribution: Provides new observational windows for PBH constraints
3. Practical Value: Establishes theoretical foundations for future more precise Lyman-α forest observations

Applicable Scenarios

This method is particularly suitable for:

• Constraint studies of PBHs in the mass range 10¹⁵-10¹⁷ g
• PBH constraint verification independent of traditional methods
• Joint analysis combining multiple observational techniques

References

The paper contains abundant references covering PBH theory, Hawking radiation, Lyman-α forest observations, and related constraint studies, providing a comprehensive literature foundation for the field.