Singularity formation in co-dimension one of the dHYM cotangent flow on blow up of $\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^{3}$ at a point

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2409.14404
• Title: Singularity formation in co-dimension one of the dHYM cotangent flow on blow up of $\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^{3}$ at a point
• Author: Ramesh Mete
• Classification: math.DG (Differential Geometry)
• Publication Date: September 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.14404

Abstract

This paper investigates singularity formation in the deformed Hermitian Yang Mills (dHYM) cotangent flow on the blow-up of complex projective space $\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^3$ at a single point. Using the Calabi ansatz method, the author provides an explicit example where the flow develops singularities along the exceptional divisor. Furthermore, the limit satisfies the corresponding singular dHYM equation, providing evidence for Conjecture 1.12 on three-dimensional symmetric manifolds.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Problem: This paper studies the mechanism of singularity formation in the dHYM cotangent flow on three-dimensional complex manifolds, particularly on the blow-up $Bl_{x_0}\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^3$ of $\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^3$ at a single point.
2. Problem Significance:
   • The dHYM equation is an important tool for mirror symmetry in string theory
   • Understanding singularity formation in geometric flows is crucial for comprehending stability conditions in complex geometry
   • This provides the first explicit example of singularity formation in the dHYM cotangent flow in the three-dimensional case
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Previous research has primarily focused on two-dimensional compact Kähler surfaces
   • Lack of concrete examples and explicit constructions in higher dimensions
4. Research Motivation:
   • Verify the correctness of Conjecture 1.12 from reference 11 on three-dimensional symmetric manifolds
   • Understand the geometric mechanism of dHYM instability
   • Provide new insights into higher-dimensional complex geometric flow theory

Core Contributions

1. Explicit Construction: Constructs a concrete example of the dHYM cotangent flow on $Bl_{x_0}\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^3$ where the flow develops singularities on the exceptional divisor
2. Singularity Analysis: Proves that the limit of the flow satisfies the corresponding singular dHYM equation and provides an explicit expression for the new dHYM slope $\zeta$
3. Theoretical Verification: Provides supporting evidence for Conjecture 1.12 from reference 11 in the three-dimensional symmetric case
4. Classification Framework: Identifies and analyzes two types of dHYM instability: instability along co-dimension one and co-dimension two subvarieties

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Study the long-time behavior and singularity formation of the dHYM cotangent flow equation: $\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial t} = \cot \theta_\omega(\chi_\phi) - \cot \hat{\theta}$ where $\chi_\phi := \chi + \sqrt{-1}\partial\bar{\partial}\phi$, on $X = Bl_{x_0}\mathbb{C}\mathbb{P}^3$.

Model Architecture

1. Calabi Symmetry Reduction

Utilize the Calabi ansatz to reduce the problem to a one-dimensional ODE:

• Set $\omega = \sqrt{-1}\partial\bar{\partial}u(\rho)$, $\chi = \sqrt{-1}\partial\bar{\partial}v(\rho)$
• Introduce function $\psi: [1,b] \to \mathbb{R}$ satisfying $\psi(u'(\rho)) = v'(\rho)$
• Boundary conditions: $\psi(1) = q$, $\psi(b) = p$

2. Flow Equation Reduction

The dHYM cotangent flow reduces to: $\dot{\psi}(x,t) = Q(x)(\csc^2 \theta)\left(\frac{\psi''}{1+\psi'^2} + (n-1)\frac{x\psi' - \psi}{x^2 + \psi^2}\right)$ where $Q(x) = u'' \circ u'^{-1}(x)$ is a continuous function.

3. Auxiliary Equation Family

Introduce an auxiliary dHYM equation family: $(\text{Re}(\psi + \sqrt{-1}x)^n)' = c_s(\text{Im}(\psi + \sqrt{-1}x)^n)'$ where $s \in S_n^+$, $c_s = \cot \hat{\theta}(X, \alpha_s, \beta)$.

Technical Innovations

1. Initial Value Selection: Construct a special initial Calabi potential function: $\psi_0(x) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\sqrt{\mu x^2 + \frac{\lambda}{x}}$ where $\mu = \frac{3(p^2b - q^2)}{b^3 - 1}$, $\lambda = 3q^2 - \mu$
2. Comparison Principle: Establish comparison with auxiliary solution $\tilde{\psi}_\xi$, proving $\psi(x,t) \leq \tilde{\psi}_\xi(x)$
3. Monotonicity Analysis: Prove $\dot{\psi}(x,t) \geq 0$, ensuring monotone convergence of the flow

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• $p = 18$, $q = b = 3$ (corresponding to the first type of dHYM instability)
• Kähler class: $\beta = 3[H] - [E]$
• Real $(1,1)$ cohomology class: $\alpha = 18[H] - 3[E]$
• dHYM slope: $c = \cot \hat{\theta} = \frac{5328}{2863}$

Verification Conditions

1. Verify that $(X, \alpha, \beta)$ is dHYM unstable
2. Check that initial value $\psi_0$ satisfies condition (H1)
3. Compute the root $\xi \in (3,6)$ of the quartic polynomial $F(s)$

Experimental Results

Main Results

Core conclusions of Theorem 1.2:

1. Instability Confirmation: The triple $(X, \alpha, \beta)$ is indeed dHYM unstable
2. Flow Existence: The cotangent flow exists for all time and converges to $\chi_\infty$ in the sense of $(1,1)$ currents
3. Singularity Structure: The limit decomposes as: $\chi_\infty = \chi'_\infty + (\xi - 3)[E]$ where $\chi'_\infty \in 18[H] - \xi[E]$ possesses a continuous local potential function
4. New dHYM Equation: $\chi'_\infty$ satisfies on $X \setminus E$: $\text{Re}(\chi'_\infty + \sqrt{-1}\omega)^3 = \zeta \cdot \text{Im}(\chi'_\infty + \sqrt{-1}\omega)^3$ where the new slope $\zeta = \frac{5346 - \xi^3 + 3\xi}{2890 - 3\xi^2} > c$

Key Calculations

• Quartic polynomial: $F(s) = -s^4 + 2887s^2 - 10692s - 2890$
• Unique root: $\xi \in (3,6)$ is the solution of $F(s) = 0$ in this interval
• New slope exceeds original slope: $\zeta > c$, reflecting the "jump" phenomenon after singularity formation

Related Work

1. dHYM Equation Theory: Pioneering work by Jacob-Yau 15, stability theory by Collins-Jacob-Yau 8
2. Geometric Flow Methods: Cotangent flow by Fu-Yau-Zhang 13, mean curvature flow of line bundles by Chan-Jacob 6
3. Blow-up Space Research: dHYM equations on $Bl_{x_0}\mathbb{P}^n$ by Jacob-Sheu 14
4. Singular Solution Theory: Work on Kähler surfaces by Datar-Mete-Song 11

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First explicit example of singularity formation in the dHYM cotangent flow in the three-dimensional case
2. Proves that singularities form along the exceptional divisor (co-dimension one subvariety)
3. Verifies Conjecture 1.12 in the symmetric case
4. Reveals the geometric mechanism of dHYM instability

Limitations

1. Depends on Calabi symmetry assumption, restricting generality
2. Only considers specific parameter choice $p = 2bq$
3. Lacks complete analysis for "second type dHYM instability"
4. Uniqueness of branching for higher dimensions ($n \geq 4$) remains unclear

Future Directions

1. Study singularity formation along higher co-dimension subvarieties
2. Explore more general initial value conditions
3. Analyze singularity behavior of second type dHYM instability
4. Generalize to higher-dimensional compact Kähler manifolds

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Organically combines complex geometry, algebraic geometry, and PDE theory
2. Technical Innovation: Clever application of Calabi ansatz and construction of auxiliary equation family
3. Explicit Construction: Provides concrete computable examples rather than mere existence results
4. Geometric Insight: Reveals deep connections between dHYM instability and subvariety geometry

Weaknesses

1. Generality Restrictions: Strongly dependent on symmetry assumptions
2. Technical Complexity: Proofs of certain key lemmas (e.g., Lemma 3.5) are quite technical
3. Completeness: Analysis of second type instability is insufficiently thorough

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important three-dimensional examples for dHYM theory
2. Methodological Value: Application of Calabi ansatz in complex geometric flows has generalization potential
3. Conjecture Verification: Provides supporting evidence for important conjectures

Applicable Scenarios

1. Stability problem research in complex geometry
2. Singularity analysis of geometric flows
3. Mirror symmetry applications in string theory
4. Numerical condition research in algebraic geometry

References

Primarily references the following important works:

• 11 Datar, V.V., Mete, R. and Song, J.: Minimal slopes and bubbling for complex Hessian equations
• 13 Fu, J., Yau, S.-T. and Zhang, D.: A new flow solving the LYZ equation in Kähler geometry
• 15 Jacob, A. and Yau, S.-T.: A special Lagrangian type equation for holomorphic line bundles
• 8 Collins, T.C., Jacob, A. and Yau, S.-T.: (1,1) forms with specified Lagrangian phase