2025-11-10T02:35:05.131638

A variant of the Erdős-Gyárfás problem for $K_8$

Yip
Recently, Alon initiated the study of graph codes and their linear variants in analogy to the study of error correcting codes in theoretical computer science. Alon related the maximum density of a linear graph code which avoids images of a small graph $H$ to the following variant of the Erdős-Gyárfás problem on edge-colourings of $K_n$. A copy of $H$ in an edge-colouring of $K_n$ is even-chromatic if each colour occupies an even number of edges in the copy. We seek an edge-colouring of $K_n$ using $n^{o(1)}$ colours such that there are no even-chromatic copies of $H$. Such an edge-colouring is conjectured to exist for all cliques $K_t$ with an even number of edges. To date, edge-colourings satisfying this property have been constructed for $K_4$ and $K_5$. We construct an edge-colouring using $n^{o(1)}$ colours which avoids even-chromatic copies of $K_8$. This was the smallest open case of the above conjecture, as $K_6, K_7$ each has an odd number of edges. We also study a stronger condition on edge-colourings, where for each copy of $H$, there is a colour occupying exactly one edge in the copy. We conjecture that an edge-colouring using $n^{o(1)}$ colours and satisfying this stronger requirement exists for all cliques $K_t$ regardless of the parity of the number of its edges. We construct edge-colourings satisfying this stronger property for $K_4$ and $K_5$. These constructions also improve upon the number of colours needed for the original problem of avoiding even-chromatic copies of $K_4$ and $K_5$.
academic

A variant of the Erdős-Gyárfás problem for K8K_8

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2409.16778
  • Title: A variant of the Erdős-Gyárfás problem for K8K_8
  • Author: Fredy Yip (Trinity College, University of Cambridge)
  • Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
  • Publication Date: September 2024 (arXiv v2: October 13, 2025)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.16778v2

Abstract

This paper investigates a variant of the Erdős-Gyárfás problem in graph code theory proposed by Alon. In edge colorings of the complete graph KnK_n, a copy of graph HH is called even-chromatic if each color occupies an even number of edges in that copy. The goal is to construct edge colorings of KnK_n using no(1)n^{o(1)} colors such that no even-chromatic copy of HH exists. This paper constructs such a coloring for K8K_8, which is the smallest unresolved case in this conjecture. Additionally, the paper studies the stronger unique-chromatic property and provides improved constructions for K4K_4 and K5K_5.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

  1. Graph Code Theory: Alon generalized the concept of error-correcting codes from theoretical computer science to graph theory, introducing the concept of graph codes, where graphs are represented as binary vectors and graph addition corresponds to symmetric difference of edge sets.
  2. Linear Graph Code Density Problem: For a forbidden graph HH, the maximum density dHlin(n)d^{lin}_H(n) of linear HH-graph codes is closely related to Ramsey theory problems.
  3. Erdős-Gyárfás Variant Problem: The original problem asks for the minimum number of colors needed to edge-color KnK_n such that every copy of KtK_t receives at least ss colors. The variant studied in this paper requires avoiding even-chromatic copies.

Research Significance

  1. Theoretical Value: Connects graph code theory with Ramsey theory, providing new research directions for combinatorial mathematics.
  2. Technical Challenge: K8K_8 is the smallest unresolved case in this conjecture, and its resolution has important milestone significance.
  3. Methodological Innovation: The proposed inductive construction method is general and may apply to larger cliques.

Core Contributions

  1. Main Result: Proves that rK8(n)=eO(log⁡2/3n)=no(1)r_{K_8}(n) = e^{O(\log^{2/3} n)} = n^{o(1)}, i.e., there exists a K8K_8-odd edge coloring using no(1)n^{o(1)} colors.
  2. Improved Results:
    • For K4K_4: uK4(n)=eO(log⁡1/2n)u_{K_4}(n) = e^{O(\log^{1/2} n)}
    • For K5K_5: uK5(n)=eO(log⁡1/2n)u_{K_5}(n) = e^{O(\log^{1/2} n)}, improving the log⁡log⁡n\log \log n factor from previous results
  3. Theoretical Framework: Proposes an inductive construction method based on amalgamation operations.
  4. New Concepts: Introduces the unique-chromatic property and proves polynomial lower bounds for non-complete graphs.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Complete graph KnK_n and target graph HHOutput: Edge coloring c:E(Kn)→Pc: E(K_n) \to P of KnK_nConstraints:

  • HH-odd: No even-chromatic copy of HH exists
  • HH-unique: Every copy of HH has exactly one color occupying a single edge
  • Color count: ∣P∣=no(1)|P| = n^{o(1)}

Core Method: Amalgamation Construction

Amalgamation Operation Definition

For edge coloring cc on KnK_n and edge coloring dd on KmK_m, define the amalgamation c⊗dc \otimes d as an edge coloring on KnmK_{nm}:

(c(x_1,x_2), d(y_1,y_2), +, *) & \text{if } x_1 < x_2, y_1 < y_2 \\ (c(x_1,x_2), d(y_1,y_2), -, *) & \text{if } x_1 < x_2, y_1 > y_2 \\ (*, d(y_1,y_2), \infty, \{y_1,y_2\}) & \text{if } x_1 = x_2 \\ (c(x_1,x_2), *, 0, *) & \text{if } y_1 = y_2 \end{cases}$$ #### Color Count Recurrence Relation $$r_P(nm) \leq (2r_Q(m) + 1)r_P(n) + \binom{m}{2}$$ where $P$ is the target property and $Q$ is an auxiliary property. #### Quasipolynomial Bound Transfer **Lemma 2.5**: If $r_Q(n) = e^{O(\log^q n)}$ with $q \in [0,1)$, then $r_P(n) = e^{O(\log^p n)}$, where $p = \frac{1}{2-q} < 1$. ### Key Technique: Rectangle Structure Analysis **Lemma 3.3**: Let $c$ be a $K_t$-unique (or $K_t$-odd) edge coloring of $K_n$, and let $S$ be a copy of $K_t$ in $K_{nm}$ that does not satisfy the unique-chromatic property (or is even-chromatic). Then $S$ must contain four vertices $(x,y_1), (x,y_2), (x',y_1), (x',y_2)$ forming a "rectangle" structure. This structural result is the foundation of all proofs, obtaining contradictions by analyzing each component of the amalgamated coloring. ## Experimental Setup ### Construction Verification This paper is primarily theoretical, verified through: 1. **Base Cases**: Verifying the existence of colorings for small-scale graphs 2. **Inductive Steps**: Proving that amalgamation operations preserve desired properties 3. **Color Counting**: Verifying quasipolynomial bounds on color counts ### Specific Application Strategies #### $K_4$-Unique Construction - **Property $P$**: $K_4$-uniqueness - **Auxiliary Property $Q$**: None (using trivial coloring) - **Parameters**: $q = 0, p = 1/2$ #### $K_5$-Unique Construction - **Property $P$**: $K_3$-unique and $K_5$-unique - **Auxiliary Property $Q$**: None (using trivial coloring) - **Parameters**: $q = 0, p = 1/2$ #### $K_8$-Odd Construction - **Property $P$**: $K_4$-unique and $K_8$-odd - **Auxiliary Property $Q$**: $K_4$-uniqueness - **Parameters**: $q = 1/2, p = 2/3$ ## Experimental Results ### Main Theoretical Results **Theorem 1.12**: $r_{K_8}(n) = e^{O(\log^{2/3} n)} = n^{o(1)}$ **Proposition 1.15**: $u_{K_4}(n) = e^{O(\log^{1/2} n)} = n^{o(1)}$ **Proposition 1.16**: $u_{K_5}(n) = e^{O(\log^{1/2} n)} = n^{o(1)}$ ### Comparison with Existing Results | Graph | Previous Best | This Paper | Improvement | |-------|---------------|-----------|-------------| | $K_4$ | $e^{O(\log^{1/2} n \log \log n)}$ | $e^{O(\log^{1/2} n)}$ | Removes $\log \log n$ factor | | $K_5$ | $e^{O(\log^{1/2} n \log \log n)}$ | $e^{O(\log^{1/2} n)}$ | Removes $\log \log n$ factor | | $K_8$ | Unknown | $e^{O(\log^{2/3} n)}$ | First resolution | ### Effectiveness of Amalgamation Operations The correctness of the method is verified by proving the following key propositions: - **Proposition 2.6**: Amalgamation of $K_4$-unique coloring with arbitrary coloring remains $K_4$-unique - **Proposition 2.7**: Amalgamation of $K_3$- and $K_5$-unique coloring with arbitrary coloring preserves the property - **Proposition 2.8**: Amalgamation of $K_4$-unique and $K_8$-odd coloring with $K_4$-unique coloring preserves the property ## Related Work ### Classical Erdős-Gyárfás Problem - Conlon et al. proved that $f_{t-1,t}(n) = n^{o(1)}$ - This paper's method provides an alternative proof of this result ### Development of Graph Code Theory - Alon's pioneering work established the connection between graph codes and Ramsey theory - Versteegen defined even-decomposable graphs and proved polynomial lower bounds - This paper extends this theoretical framework ### Status of Related Conjectures - **Versteegen Conjecture 1.8**: $r_H(n) = n^{\Omega(1)}$ if and only if $H$ is even-decomposable - **Ge-Xu-Zhang Conjecture 1.9**: For $t \equiv 0,1 \pmod{4}$, we have $r_{K_t}(n) = n^{o(1)}$ - **Conjecture 1.19 (This Paper)**: For all $t \geq 2$, we have $u_{K_t}(n) = n^{o(1)}$ ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. Successfully resolves the Erdős-Gyárfás variant problem for $K_8$ 2. Establishes a general construction framework based on amalgamation operations 3. Introduces the unique-chromatic property and proves its fundamental properties ### Limitations 1. **Method Limitations**: Current techniques seem difficult to directly extend to larger cases like $K_{12}$ 2. **Tightness of Bounds**: The color count bounds in the construction may not be optimal 3. **Computational Complexity**: The computational complexity of actual constructions is relatively high ### Future Directions 1. **Technical Improvements**: Seek more effective construction methods for larger cliques 2. **Lower Bound Research**: Establish more precise lower bounds to determine optimal color counts 3. **Algorithm Implementation**: Develop efficient algorithms to implement these theoretical constructions 4. **Generalization**: Extend the method to other graph families ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Breakthrough**: Resolves an important open problem in the field 2. **Methodological Innovation**: The amalgamation construction method is general and elegant 3. **Technical Depth**: Rectangle structure analysis demonstrates profound combinatorial insights 4. **Result Improvements**: Improves the best known results in multiple aspects ### Weaknesses 1. **Generalization Difficulty**: Method extension to larger cliques faces technical obstacles 2. **Constant Factors**: Constants in the construction may be large, limiting practical applicability 3. **Proof Complexity**: Proofs of certain technical details are quite involved ### Impact 1. **Academic Value**: Provides new tools for combinatorics and Ramsey theory 2. **Subsequent Research**: May inspire research on related problems 3. **Methodological Contribution**: The inductive construction framework has broad applicability ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical Research**: Extremal combinatorics and Ramsey theory research 2. **Algorithm Design**: Applications in graph coloring and coding theory 3. **Educational Use**: Excellent example demonstrating modern combinatorial mathematics techniques ## References The paper cites key literature in the field, including: - Alon's pioneering work on graph codes - Results on $K_4, K_5$ by Cameron-Heath and Bennett-Heath-Zerbib - Versteegen's theory on even-decomposable graphs - Related research on the classical Erdős-Gyárfás problem --- This paper makes important contributions to combinatorial mathematics, not only resolving a specific open problem but more importantly establishing a theoretical framework that may apply to broader situations. Despite facing challenges in technical generalization, its methodological value and theoretical significance are undeniable.