Multi-wavefunction Overlap and Multi-Entropy for Topological Ground States in (2+1) Dimensions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2410.08284
• Title: Multi wavefunction overlap and multi entropy for topological ground states in (2+1) dimensions
• Authors: Bowei Liu, Junjia Zhang, Shuhei Ohyama, Yuya Kusuki, Shinsei Ryu
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el, hep-th, quant-ph
• Publication Date: October 14, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.08284

Abstract

This paper investigates multi-wavefunction overlap (MWO)—a generalization of quantum mechanical inner products to more than two quantum many-body states—for gapped ground states in (2+1) dimensions, with particular focus on symmetry-protected topological (SPT) states. The authors demonstrate how to utilize bulk-boundary correspondence and (1+1)-dimensional edge theory (particularly conformal field theory) to compute these overlaps. In SPT phases, topological invariants (interpretable as discrete higher-order Berry phases) can be extracted from multi-wavefunction overlaps of four ground states with appropriately applied symmetry operations. Furthermore, multi-wavefunction overlaps can be expressed in terms of rearrangements of reduced density matrices. The authors also show that the same techniques apply to evaluating multi-entropy (ME)—a quantum information-theoretic quantity associated with multi-partite divisions of quantum many-body states. Combined with numerical calculations, they establish a lower bound on the difference between tripartite multi-entropy and second-order Rényi entropy: $(c_{tot}/4)\ln 2$, where $c_{tot}$ is the central charge of ungappable degrees of freedom.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Need for understanding many-body entanglement: Understanding entanglement patterns in quantum many-body states is crucial for discovering and diagnosing novel (topological) phases of matter. While traditional bipartite entanglement entropy provides some information about topological ground states, it cannot fully characterize them.
2. Limitations of many-body entanglement measurements: Topological entanglement entropy, as a measure of bipartite entanglement, is an important signature of topological ground states, yet different topological states may possess identical topological entanglement entropy while remaining distinct.
3. Rise of multipartite entanglement research: Recent years have witnessed significant attention to multipartite quantum entanglement and correlations, with various entanglement measures such as reflected entropy and entanglement negativity being employed to study topological ground states.

Research Motivation

The core motivation of this paper is to unify multi-wavefunction overlap and multi-entropy within a multipartite entanglement framework for studying (2+1)-dimensional topological ground states. Both quantities are intimately connected to multipartite entanglement in many-body systems, providing new perspectives for understanding topological phases.

Core Contributions

1. Established a computational framework for multi-wavefunction overlap of (2+1)-dimensional topological ground states: Utilizing bulk-boundary correspondence to reduce calculations to path integrals in (1+1)-dimensional conformal field theory.
2. Demonstrated the extraction method for topological invariants in SPT phases: Showed how to extract cohomology classes in the $H^3(G,U(1))$ group from multi-wavefunction overlaps of four ground states with appropriately applied symmetry operations.
3. Developed CFT computational methods for multi-entropy: Provided a systematic computational scheme for multi-entropy of (2+1)-dimensional gapped ground states.
4. Established universal lower bounds for multi-entropy: Proved that $\kappa = G(A:B:C) - \frac{1}{2}(S_2(A) + S_2(B) + S_2(C)) \geq \frac{c_{tot}}{8}\ln 2$.
5. Developed numerical methods for free fermion systems: Proposed a covariance matrix-based method for computing multi-entropy and verified theoretical predictions in Chern insulator models.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Bulk-Boundary Correspondence

The authors utilize the bulk-boundary correspondence of topological phases to express (2+1)-dimensional topological ground states with tripartite division as: $|\Psi\rangle \propto e^{-\beta H_{edge}}|V\rangle$

where $H_{edge} = H_{\partial A} + H_{\partial B} + H_{\partial C}$ represents the boundary CFT Hamiltonian, and $|V\rangle$ is the vertex state defined on $H_{\partial A} \otimes H_{\partial B} \otimes H_{\partial C}$.

Computation of Multi-Wavefunction Overlap

For four invertible states $\Psi_\alpha, \Psi_\beta, \Psi_\gamma, \Psi_\delta$, the multi-wavefunction overlap is expressed as: $MWO(\Psi_\alpha,\Psi_\beta,\Psi_\gamma,\Psi_\delta) = \text{Tr}[(\rho^R_{AB})^\dagger \rho_{AB}]$

where $\rho_{AB} = \text{Tr}_C|\Psi_\alpha\rangle\langle\Psi_\beta|$, and $\rho^R_{AB}$ is its rearrangement.

Extraction of SPT Invariants

For SPT phases, by applying symmetry operations $g_\alpha = g, g_\beta = k, g_\gamma = h, g_\delta = 1$ in different regions, the ratio of multi-wavefunction overlaps yields: $\frac{MWO(\Psi_\alpha,\Psi_\beta,\Psi_\gamma,\Psi_\delta)}{MWO(\Psi_0,\Psi_0,\Psi_0,\Psi_0)} = \omega(g,h,k) \in H^3(G,U(1))$

Multi-Entropy Computation

Definition

For a tripartite state $|\Psi\rangle_{ABC}$, multi-entropy is defined as: $G(A:B:C) = -\frac{1}{2}\ln Z(A:B:C)$$Z(A:B:C) = \langle\Psi|^{\otimes 4}(\pi_A^{(1)} \otimes \pi_B^{(2)} \otimes \pi_C^{(3)})|\Psi\rangle^{\otimes 4}$

where the permutation operators are: $\pi^{(1)} = (12)(34), \quad \pi^{(2)} = (13)(24), \quad \pi^{(3)} = e$

CFT Computation

In the $L/\beta \to \infty$ limit, the path integral decomposes into cylindrical and spherical contributions. The multi-entropy expression is: $S_n^{(3)}(A:B:C) = \left(1+\frac{1}{n}\right)\frac{\pi L(c+\bar{c})}{16\beta} + \left(1+\frac{1}{n}\right)\frac{(c+\bar{c})}{8}\ln\sin\frac{\pi}{3} + \frac{1}{1-n}\frac{1}{n}\ln C_n$

For the $n=2$ case, we obtain: $\kappa = \frac{(c+\bar{c})}{8}\ln 2$

Experimental Setup

Numerical Model

The authors employ a tight-binding Hamiltonian on a two-dimensional square lattice: $H_{Ch} = -\frac{i}{2}\sum_r\sum_{i=x,y}[f_r^\dagger\sigma_i f_{r+a_i} - f_{r+a_i}^\dagger\sigma_i f_r] + \frac{1}{2}\sum_r\sum_{i=x,y}[f_r^\dagger\sigma_z f_{r+a_i} + f_{r+a_i}^\dagger\sigma_z f_r] + u\sum_r f_r^\dagger\sigma_z f_r$

This model realizes a Chern insulator phase with Chern number $Ch = 1$ for $0 < u < 2$.

Tripartite Division Setup

The system is divided into three rectangular regions with dimensions $L_{Ax} = L_{Bx} = L_{Cx} = L/2$ and $2L_{Ay} = 2L_{By} = L_{Cy} = L$.

Covariance Matrix Method

For free fermion systems, the authors developed a multi-entropy computation method based on covariance matrices: $G(A:B:C) = -\frac{1}{2}\sum_l \ln\left[\left(\frac{1-\xi_l^{(2)}}{2}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{1+\xi_l^{(2)}}{2}\right)^2\right] - \sum_k \ln\left[\left(\frac{1-\gamma_k}{2}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{1+\gamma_k}{2}\right)^2\right]$

Experimental Results

Primary Numerical Results

1. Phase dependence of multi-entropy: $G(A:B:C)$ decreases monotonically with increasing $u$, with $\kappa$ exhibiting a peak near the topological phase transition point.
2. Verification of universal lower bound: At the minimum point $u = 1.65$ in the Chern insulator phase, the numerical result $\kappa \approx 3.990 \times (c/8)\ln 2$ is very close to the theoretical prediction of $4 \times (c/8)\ln 2$.
3. Finite-size scaling: Deep in the topological phase, $\kappa$ is insensitive to system size, while strong finite-size effects exist near the phase transition point.

Theoretical Verification

• For GHZ states: $G_{GHZ} = \frac{3}{2}\ln 2$, independent of tripartition
• For W states: $G_W = \ln\frac{N^2}{|A|^2 + |B|^2 + |C|^2}$

Related Work

Topological Entanglement Entropy

Traditional topological entanglement entropy serves as a signature of topological ground states but cannot fully distinguish different topological phases.

Multipartite Entanglement Measures

• Reflected entropy: Captures quantum correlations beyond simple Bell-type bipartite correlations
• Entanglement negativity: Used to detect entanglement in mixed states
• Multi-entropy: Serves as a new measure of multipartite entanglement

Higher-Order Berry Phases

Multi-wavefunction overlap is closely related to the concept of higher-order Berry phases, providing new pathways for extracting topological invariants.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established a systematic method based on bulk-boundary correspondence for computing multi-wavefunction overlaps and multi-entropy of (2+1)-dimensional topological ground states.
2. Demonstrated that topological invariants of SPT phases can be extracted from multi-wavefunction overlaps.
3. Discovered a universal lower bound for multi-entropy: $\kappa \geq (c_{tot}/8)\ln 2$.

Limitations

1. Primarily focuses on invertible ground states; extension to topologically ordered states requires further investigation.
2. Numerical calculations are mainly limited to free fermion systems.
3. Microscopic modeling near triple junctions still requires more precise descriptions.

Future Directions

1. Extension to non-invertible (topologically ordered) ground states
2. Investigation of specific many-body correlations captured by multi-entropy
3. Exploration of relationships between multi-entropy and other entanglement measures

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Unifies multi-wavefunction overlap and multi-entropy within the bulk-boundary correspondence framework, providing new tools for studying topological phases.
2. Systematic Methodology: Provides a complete computational framework from CFT calculations to numerical methods.
3. Universality of Results: The discovered lower bounds possess universal significance, analogous to Markov gap results.
4. Sufficient Numerical Verification: Theoretical predictions are verified in concrete models.

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope of Applicability: Primarily applicable to gapped ground states; discussion of critical systems is limited.
2. Microscopic Modeling: Modeling at triple junctions may lack precision.
3. Physical Interpretation: Lacks in-depth analysis of specific physical correlations captured by multi-entropy.

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for studying topological quantum states.
2. Practical Value: Numerical methods can be applied to research on actual topological materials.
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects condensed matter physics, quantum information, and mathematical topology.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical research on topological insulators and superconductors
2. Analysis of entanglement properties in quantum many-body systems
3. Numerical studies of topological phase transitions
4. Applications of topological protection in quantum devices

References

The paper cites extensive related work, including:

• Pioneering work on topological entanglement entropy Kitaev & Preskill, Levin & Wen
• Theoretical foundations of bulk-boundary correspondence
• Recent advances in multipartite entanglement and reflected entropy
• Higher-order Berry phases and group cohomology theory

This paper provides an important theoretical framework and computational tools for understanding multipartite entanglement properties of topological quantum states, with significant implications at the intersection of topological condensed matter physics and quantum information.