Holographic Boundary Conformal Field Theory within Horndeski Gravity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2410.18781
• Title: Holographic Boundary Conformal Field Theory within Horndeski Gravity
• Authors: Fabiano F. Santos, Behnam Pourhassan, Emmanuel N. Saridakis, Oleksii Sokoliuk, Alexander Baransky, Emre Onur Kahya
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024 (v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.18781

Abstract

This paper investigates entanglement islands and Page curves within the framework of Horndeski gravity in the context of the Karch-Randall braneworld. Through analytical treatment of holographic boundary conformal field theory, the authors find that Horndeski parameters significantly alter the behavior of Page curves compared to standard general relativity, a feature arising from the non-trivial geometry induced by the Horndeski scalar field. Notably, geometries departing from the AdS limit play a more important role than in previous studies. This demonstrates that Horndeski gravity introduces important corrections to the distribution of quantum information in holographic models. Finally, the authors argue that holographic consistency can be used in reverse to impose constraints on Horndeski gravity itself, providing new tools for probing the validity of modified gravity theories.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

The core problem addressed in this paper is the black hole information paradox, a central issue in theoretical physics since Hawking's seminal work. Specifically:

1. Black Hole Information Paradox: When the fine-grained entropy of Hawking radiation from an evaporating black hole exceeds the entropy of the black hole itself, unitarity may be violated
2. Page Curve Behavior: How the Page curve behaves within modified gravity theories, particularly Horndeski gravity
3. Role of Entanglement Islands: How entanglement islands affect the distribution of quantum information in Horndeski gravity

Research Significance

• Theoretical Importance: Connecting quantum gravity, the holographic principle, and quantum information theory
• Methodological Innovation: Extending the AdS/BCFT correspondence to modified gravity theories
• Constraint Mechanism: Providing a new method to constrain modified gravity theories through holographic consistency

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional research has primarily focused on standard general relativity
• Insufficient understanding of entanglement dynamics in modified gravity theories
• Lack of systematic methods to utilize the holographic principle for constraining gravity theories

Core Contributions

1. Established holographic entanglement entropy formula in Horndeski gravity: Derived modified area functionals containing Horndeski parameters α and γ
2. Discovered significant impact of Horndeski parameters on Page curves: Demonstrated how modified gravity theories alter quantum information dynamics
3. Constructed four-dimensional black string solutions: Found exact solutions of Horndeski gravity in the Karch-Randall braneworld background
4. Proposed reverse constraint mechanism: Imposed constraints on Horndeski gravity theory itself through holographic consistency
5. Revealed enhanced role of geometries away from AdS limit: Non-AdS geometries play a more important role in quantum information distribution than in previous studies

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the evolution of entanglement entropy and Page curve behavior in the Karch-Randall braneworld within Horndeski gravity framework. Inputs are Horndeski theory parameters α, γ and geometric parameters; outputs are corrected Page curves and entanglement island structures.

Model Architecture

1. Horndeski Gravity Action

The fundamental action consists of three parts:

S = κ∫_N d⁴x √(-g) L_H + S^N_mat + 2κ∫_{Q_L ∪ Q_R} d³x √(-h) L_bdry + ...

where the Horndeski Lagrangian is:

L_H = (R - 2Λ) - 1/2(αg^μν - γG^μν)∇_μφ∇_νφ

2. Black String Metric

The four-dimensional black string metric takes the form:

ds²_AdS4 = 1/(r² sin²(u)) (-f(r)dt² + dy² + r²du² + dr²/f(r))

where the horizon function is:

f(r) = 1 + Cr³ + (-3 + α/γ)csc²(u)

3. Entanglement Entropy Functional

The derived entanglement entropy functional for Horndeski gravity is:

S_EE^H = κ/4 ∫d^d x √η [1 - γ/(4κ) η^ij φ^,i φ^,j]

Technical Innovations

1. Modified Area Formula: Compared to the standard Ryu-Takayanagi formula, includes Horndeski correction term χ = 1 + 3(α+γΛ)/(αA(u))
2. Spatial Embedding Formalism: Uses codimension-one submanifold embeddings in four-dimensional Minkowski space to compute Hartman-Maldacena surfaces
3. Field Theory Calculation Verification: Validates gravitational calculations through two-point functions of twist operators ⟨Φ_n(r_R,t)Φ_n(r_L,t)⟩

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Horndeski Parameter Range: α = -8/3, γ ∈ -1, -0.1
• Geometric Parameters: Brane angle u_b, anchor positions r_L, r_R
• Constraints: β₀ = α/(γΛ), requiring β₀ + 1 ≥ 0

Evaluation Metrics

1. Page Time: t_Page = (β/4π)cosh⁻¹...
2. Page Angle: ρ_Page = (1/2)log...
3. Minimum Entanglement Entropy: S = min(S_HM, S_island)

Numerical Analysis Methods

• Solve Euler-Lagrange equations to obtain RT surfaces
• Calculate Page curve evolution under different parameters
• Analyze critical angles and anchor point behavior

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Page Curve Corrections: Horndeski parameters significantly modify Page curve shape, particularly when r approaches 0 or the horizon radius r_h
2. Parameter Dependence:
   • Significant changes in Page angle density as γ varies from -1 to -0.1
   • Variations in α similarly lead to important corrections in entanglement structure
3. Geometric Effects: Geometries departing from the AdS limit play more important roles in quantum information distribution

Key Findings

1. Residual Information: Boundary entropies S^L_bdry and S^R_bdry yield residual information ξq(u_b)/3 in the large subsystem limit
2. Critical Behavior: Critical angles exist where RT surfaces exhibit different entanglement properties
3. Holographic Consistency Constraints: By requiring physically reasonable Page curve behavior, constraints can be imposed on Horndeski parameters

Related Work

Theoretical Foundations

• AdS/CFT Correspondence: Maldacena (1997), Witten (1998)
• Ryu-Takayanagi Formula: Ryu & Takayanagi (2006)
• AdS/BCFT: Takayanagi (2011), Fujita et al. (2011)

Entanglement Island Research

• Island Formula: Almheiri et al. (2020)
• Karch-Randall Braneworld: Karch & Randall (2001)
• Entanglement Islands in BCFT: Rozali et al. (2020), Chen et al. (2020)

Horndeski Gravity Applications

• Holographic Entanglement Entropy: Caceres et al. (2017), Feng et al. (2015)
• AdS/BCFT in Horndeski: Santos et al. (2021-2024)

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Importance of Horndeski Corrections: Horndeski parameters α and γ significantly alter Page curve behavior through non-trivial geometry induced by the scalar field
2. Enhanced Geometric Role: Geometries departing from the AdS limit play more important roles than in previous studies
3. Bidirectional Constraint Mechanism: Holographic consistency not only enables study of quantum information but also allows reverse constraints on modified gravity theories
4. Corrections to Quantum Information Distribution: Horndeski gravity introduces important corrections to quantum information distribution in holographic models

Limitations

1. Parameter Range Restrictions: Horndeski parameters are constrained by solution existence conditions
2. Analytical Solution Limitations: Numerical methods are required in certain cases
3. Dimensional Restrictions: Focus primarily on four-dimensional cases

Future Directions

1. Higher-Dimensional Generalizations: Extend results to higher dimensions
2. Dynamical Studies: Investigate complete dynamics of time evolution
3. Observational Constraints: Further constrain Horndeski parameters through observational data
4. Other Modified Gravity Theories: Apply methods to other modified gravity theories

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Theoretical Innovation: First systematic study of entanglement islands and Page curves in Horndeski gravity
2. Rigorous Methodology: Combines analytical calculations and numerical analysis with mutual verification between field theory and gravitational calculations
3. Deep Physical Insights: Reveals profound effects of modified gravity on quantum information
4. High Practical Value: Provides new tools for constraining modified gravity theories

Weaknesses

1. High Complexity: Involves integration of multiple theoretical frameworks with high entry barriers
2. Strong Parameter Dependence: Results are sensitive to Horndeski parameter choices
3. Difficult Experimental Verification: Currently lacks direct experimental verification methods

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Opens new directions for quantum information research in modified gravity theories
2. Methodological Value: Establishes new paradigm for constraining gravity theories through holographic principle
3. Cross-Disciplinary Impact: Connects gravity theory, quantum information, and holographic principle

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Theoretical constraints on modified gravity theories
2. Cosmological Applications: Early universe and black hole physics
3. Quantum Information: Holographic quantum error correction and information processing

References

This paper cites 88 important references, covering:

• Foundational holographic principle literature: Maldacena (1998), Ryu & Takayanagi (2006)
• Entanglement island theory: Almheiri et al. (2020), Penington (2020)
• Horndeski gravity: Horndeski (1974), Kobayashi (2019)
• AdS/BCFT: Takayanagi (2011), Karch & Randall (2001)

This paper makes important contributions to the frontier of theoretical physics. It not only deepens our understanding of quantum information behavior in modified gravity theories but also provides new methods for constraining gravity theories through the holographic principle, possessing significant theoretical value and potential applications.