Imaging heat transport in suspended diamond nanostructures with integrated spin defect thermometers

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.04065
• Title: Imaging heat transport in suspended diamond nanostructures with integrated spin defect thermometers
• Authors: V. Goblot, K. Wu, E. Di Lucente, Y. Zhu, E. Losero, Q. Jobert, C. Jaramillo Concha, N. Quack, N. Marzari, M. Simoncelli, C. Galland
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall (Condensed Matter Physics - Mesoscopic Physics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.04065v3

Abstract

Single-crystal diamond exhibits one of the highest thermal conductivities among all materials, exceeding 2000 W/m/K at room temperature. This originates from the dominance of momentum-conserving "normal" phonon-phonon scattering processes over momentum-dissipating "Umklapp" processes, making diamond an ideal platform for experimentally investigating phonon heat transport phenomena that violate Fourier's law. This work introduces dilute nitrogen-vacancy color centers as in-situ high-precision spin defect thermometers for imaging temperature inhomogeneities in single-crystal diamond microstructures heated under ambient conditions. Cantilever beams with cross-sectional areas ranging from 0.2 to 2.6 μm² were investigated, revealing significant reduction in thermal conductivity with decreasing width. First-principles simulations based on linearized phonon Boltzmann transport equations and viscous heat equations quantitatively predict the heat transport characteristics of the cantilevers, elucidating how the interplay between intrinsic and extrinsic phonon scattering mechanisms determines the observed non-diffusive behavior.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

This research addresses the experimental observation and theoretical understanding of non-Fourier heat transport phenomena in diamond structures at the nanoscale. Specifically, it encompasses:

1. How to accurately measure temperature distributions at the nanoscale
2. Understanding the mechanisms of size effects on thermal conductivity
3. Validating theoretical predictions of non-diffusive heat transport

Significance

1. Fundamental Scientific Value: The dominance of normal phonon scattering processes in diamond provides an ideal platform for studying heat transport phenomena that violate Fourier's law
2. Application Value: Important implications for optomechanics, nonlinear optics, quantum nanophotonics, and thermal management device development
3. Methodological Contribution: Establishes nanoscale temperature imaging techniques based on solid-state spin defects

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Traditional Temperature Measurement: Resistive sensors require complex sample engineering and cannot provide spatially-resolved temperature maps
2. Scanning Thermal Microscopy: Invasive technique requiring complex probe-sample contact thermal resistance calibration
3. Optical Thermometry: Requires deposition of transduction materials, cannot directly read temperature, and typically lacks precision better than several Kelvin

Core Contributions

1. Innovative Temperature Measurement Method: First use of dilute nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers as in-situ spin defect thermometers, achieving sub-Kelvin precision nanoscale temperature imaging
2. Experimental Verification of Non-Diffusive Heat Transport: Observation of pronounced non-diffusive heat transport behavior in sub-micrometer diamond cantilevers, with thermal conductivity significantly decreasing with size
3. Multi-Scale Theoretical Modeling: First-principles simulations combining linearized phonon Boltzmann transport equations (LBTE) and viscous heat equations (VHE) quantitatively predict experimental results
4. Mechanism Elucidation: Reveals how the interplay between intrinsic phonon interactions and extrinsic boundary scattering effects determines sub-ballistic heat transport behavior

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Design

Sample Preparation

1. Substrate Material: Commercial (100) CVD single-crystal diamond substrate, ¹²C isotopic enrichment >99.95%, containing 1-2 ppm NV centers
2. Cantilever Fabrication:
   • Electron beam lithography defining chromium patches as heat sources
   • Vertical oxygen-based reactive ion etching
   • Focused ion beam (FIB) milling to form triangular cross-sections (θ = 53°)
   • Cantilever width range: 0.8-2.5 μm, length 10 μm

Measurement System

1. Optical System:
   • Dual 515 nm laser beams: one for heating chromium patches, one for reading NV fluorescence
   • Confocal geometry for fluorescence collection, numerical aperture NA = 0.9
   • Spatial resolution: diffraction-limited ~0.44 μm
2. Temperature Readout:
   • Continuous-wave optically detected magnetic resonance (cw-ODMR)
   • Lock-in amplifier combined with microwave frequency modulation
   • Temperature sensitivity: 0.27 K/√Hz

Theoretical Modeling

Viscous Heat Equation (VHE)

For isotropic materials in steady state:

α∇·u(R) = κ∇²T(R)
β∇T(R) - μ∇²u(R) = -γu(R)

Where:

• T(R): mesoscopic temperature field
• u(R): phonon drift velocity field
• μ: phonon viscosity
• α, β: energy-crystal momentum coupling coefficients
• γ: momentum dissipation scattering processes

Effective Thermal Conductivity Calculation

κ_eff = q̄ × L/ΔT

Where q̄ = S⁻¹∫∫_S q·dS is the average heat flux density.

First-Principles Parameterization

• ShengBTE package employed to solve LBTE with complete scattering matrix
• Considers third-order anharmonic phonon-phonon scattering and phonon-impurity scattering
• Boundary scattering handled using Casimir model

Experimental Setup

Temperature Calibration

1. Zero-Field Splitting (ZFS) Temperature Dependence: ΔD(T) = D(T) - D(22°C)
2. Calibration Range: 22°C to 62°C
3. Fitting Model: Dual-mode phonon population model, temperature coefficient dD/dT = -78 kHz/K

Measurement Parameters

• Read laser power: 0.15 mW
• Microwave power: +41 dBm
• Microwave frequency modulation depth: 5 MHz
• Integration time: 3 seconds/point
• Temperature readout accuracy: ±0.15 K

Sample Characterization

Three cantilever beams of different widths were investigated:

• Sample A: w = 0.95 μm
• Sample B: w = 1.43 μm
• Sample C: w = 1.98 μm

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Linear Temperature Response

• Local temperature increase ΔT exhibits linear relationship with heating power Ph
• Linear temperature gradient observed along cantilever direction
• Different temperature gradients observed for different cross-sectional widths

Size Effects

1. Thermal Conductivity Reduction: Effective thermal conductivity significantly decreases with decreasing cantilever width
2. Deviation from Fourier's Law:
   • Fourier's law prediction: ∂T/∂x ∝ w⁻²
   • Pure ballistic limit: ∂T/∂x ∝ w⁻³
   • Experimental results fall between the two

Quantitative Comparison

Experimentally measured effective thermal conductivity shows excellent agreement with theoretical predictions:

• For w = 0.95 μm: κ_eff ≈ 800 W/m/K (60% reduction compared to bulk ~2000 W/m/K)
• For w = 1.98 μm: κ_eff ≈ 1400 W/m/K (30% reduction)

Mechanism Analysis

Transport Mechanism Classification

Through comparison of VHE and apparent diffusion models, the experiment is determined to be in the "apparent diffusion" regime:

• Weak viscous hydrodynamic effects
• Boundary scattering effects dominant
• Heat transport still describable by diffusion equation, but thermal conductivity size-dependent

Scattering Mechanisms

1. Intrinsic Scattering: Normal and Umklapp phonon-phonon scattering
2. Extrinsic Scattering: Boundary scattering with characteristic length equal to half the minimum dimension
3. Interplay: Competition between the two mechanisms determines sub-ballistic transport behavior

Ablation Studies

Fabrication Method Effects

Comparison of cantilevers fabricated with and without FIB shows that FIB-induced surface damage has negligible impact on transport characteristics.

Impurity Concentration Effects

Theoretical calculations considering different vacancy concentrations (0-20 ppm) show optimal fitting corresponds to 10 ppm vacancy concentration, consistent with 1-2 ppm NV concentration in the sample.

Heat Loss Verification

Anti-Stokes emission measurements from metal patches verify:

• Convection and radiation heat losses negligible compared to laser power (5-6 orders of magnitude difference)
• Good thermal equilibrium between metal patches and diamond

Related Work

Non-Diffusive Heat Transport Research

1. Graphene: Observation of ballistic and hydrodynamic heat transport near room temperature
2. Graphite: Second sound phenomena observed above 200K
3. Polycrystalline Diamond: Investigation of grain boundary phonon scattering effects
4. Diamond Microparticles: Reports of unexpected size effects

Nanoscale Temperature Measurement

1. Solid-State Spin Defects: Temperature-sensitive defects in hBN, Si, SiC
2. Scanning Probe Techniques: Scanning thermal microscopy, time-domain/frequency-domain thermoreflectance
3. Optical Methods: Raman sideband thermometry, fluorescence thermometry

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established nanoscale temperature imaging method based on NV centers
2. Observation of pronounced non-diffusive heat transport in sub-micrometer diamond cantilevers
3. First-principles theory perfectly explains experimental phenomena
4. Confirms boundary scattering as the primary source of size effects

Limitations

1. Size Range: Limited by diffraction limit and fabrication techniques to 0.8-2.5 μm range
2. Temperature Range: Calibration range limited to within 40K
3. Material System: Currently limited to diamond containing NV centers

Future Directions

1. Geometric Effects: Investigation of thermal vortices and thermal rectification in complex geometries
2. Surface Engineering: Study of boundary roughness effects through varied etching methods and chemical termination
3. Quantum Limit: Extension to smaller scales to investigate quantized phonon thermal conductivity
4. Material Expansion: Extension to other high thermal conductivity materials containing spin defects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: First application of NV centers to nanoscale heat transport research with novel technical approach
2. Theory-Experiment Integration: Perfect combination of multi-scale first-principles modeling with precision experiments
3. Quantitative Prediction: Theory completely predicts experimental results without fitting parameters, demonstrating strong persuasiveness
4. Mechanism Clarification: Clear distinction of contributions from different transport mechanisms

Weaknesses

1. Size Limitations: Relatively limited size range studied, not reaching true quantum dimensions
2. Material Constraints: Method dependent on specific NV centers, limiting universality
3. Temperature Range: Relatively small temperature variation range may limit exploration of nonlinear effects

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important experimental evidence and theoretical validation for non-diffusive heat transport
2. Technical Advancement: Established temperature imaging method applicable to various nanoscale device research
3. Application Prospects: Important guidance for quantum device thermal management and related fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Nanoscale heat transport research in high thermal conductivity materials
2. Thermal management optimization in quantum devices
3. Phonon engineering and thermal metamaterial design
4. Thermal noise analysis in nanomechanical resonators

References

The paper cites 99 references covering important works in heat transport theory, experimental techniques, materials science, and other relevant fields, providing solid theoretical foundation and technical support for the research.

This work holds significant importance in the field of nanoscale heat transport research, achieving breakthroughs not only in methodology but also providing deep insights into fundamental physics understanding. The established experimental techniques and theoretical framework lay important foundations for future related research.