Velocity fluctuation and force scaling during driven polymer transport through a nanopore

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.04261
• Title: Velocity fluctuation and force scaling during driven polymer transport through a nanopore
• Authors: Martin Charron, Breeana Elliott, Nada Kerrouri, Liqun He, Vincent Tabard-Cossa
• Classification: physics.bio-ph cond-mat.soft
• Institution: Department of Physics, University of Ottawa, Canada
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.04261

Abstract

This study measures instantaneous velocity during polymer translocation through nanopores by constructing patterned DNA nanostructures, revealing fundamental concepts of electrophoretically driven polymer transport. The research demonstrates that velocity profiles can be utilized to investigate nanoscale forces and their dependencies on experimental parameters including polymer length, pore diameter, and applied voltage. This provides an experimental foundation for theoretical model validation and guidance for optimizing nanopore sensing performance.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Biological Significance: Polymer translocation through nanopores is central to many biological processes and plays a critical role in single-molecule sensing techniques such as nucleic acid and protein sequencing, as well as biomarker detection.
2. Detection Principle: When polymers translocate through pores under electric potential gradients, they obstruct ionic current flow, producing transient current blockade signals that can be mapped to the physicochemical properties of the polymer.
3. Theory-Experiment Gap: Although theoretical and simulation studies are abundant, few experimental studies validate predicted translocation properties due to the complexity of non-equilibrium translocation processes.
4. Technical Challenges: At commonly used sensing voltages (50-1000 mV), DNA translocation times are much shorter than corresponding relaxation times, causing the polymer conformation during translocation to differ significantly from its relaxed conformation in solution.

Research Motivation

This study aims to bridge theory and experiment through innovative experimental methods, providing quantitative understanding of polymer translocation dynamics and guidance for optimizing nanopore sensing technology.

Core Contributions

1. Designed Novel Velocity Profile Molecules (VPM): Constructed patterned DNA nanostructures composed of alternating seven double-stranded DNA segments and six triple-helix bundle segments, enabling measurement of instantaneous velocity during translocation.
2. Established Toy Model for Force-Velocity Relationships: Through simple physical insights, converted velocity fluctuations into force measurements, validating experimental predictions of tension propagation theory.
3. Systematically Studied Parameter Dependencies: Quantitatively analyzed velocity profile dependencies on polymer length, pore diameter, and voltage, discovering counterintuitive phenomena (increased translocation time in larger pores).
4. Validated Theoretical Models: Experimental results show good agreement with tension propagation theory predictions while identifying limitations of theoretical models.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Obtain instantaneous velocity profiles by measuring DNA nanostructure translocation with known geometry through nanopores, subsequently investigating nanoscale forces during translocation and their scaling relationships.

Experimental Design

VPM Molecule Design

• Basic Structure: Single-stranded DNA scaffold (7292 nucleotides from m13 phage) assembled with 171 short DNA staples
• Segmented Structure: 13 alternating domains—7 double-stranded DNA segments and 6 triple-helix bundle segments
• Detection Principle: Different cross-sections produce different current blockade depths (3HB segments produce 3× blockade depth of DNA segments)

Nanopore Preparation

• Material: 12 nm thick self-supporting SiNx membrane
• Preparation Method: Controlled breakdown (CBD) technique
• Pore Diameter Range: 9-36 nm

Velocity Extraction Algorithm

• Threshold Crossing Method: Set threshold between DNA and 3HB blockade states
• Velocity Calculation: $v_i = \ell_i/\tau_i$, where $\ell_i$ is the i-th segment length and $\tau_i$ is transit time
• Statistical Analysis: Gaussian fitting of velocity distributions from multiple measurements to extract mean velocity and standard deviation

Theoretical Model

Toy Model

Classified forces acting on translocating polymers into two categories:

• In-pore Forces: Electric field force $F_e$, electroosmotic drag $F_{eo}$, internal fluid drag $\gamma_{in}v$
• Out-of-pore Forces: External drag from tension segment $\gamma_{out}(\ell)v$

Velocity expression: $v(\ell) = \frac{F_e - F_{eo}}{\gamma_{in} + \gamma_{out}(\ell)} = v_{end}\left(1 + \frac{\gamma_{out}(\ell)}{\gamma_{in}}\right)^{-1}$

Key Relationships

Maximum ratio of external to internal drag coefficients: $\frac{\gamma_{out}^{max}}{\gamma_{in}} = \frac{v_{end}}{v_{min}} - 1$

Experimental Setup

Experimental Conditions

• Electrolyte: 3.6 M LiCl, pH 8
• Voltage Range: 100-500 mV
• Temperature: Room temperature
• Sampling Frequency: 4.16 MHz, low-pass filtered to 300 kHz

Data Analysis

• Event Detection: CUSUM+ algorithm for locating and fitting translocation events
• Classification Criteria: VPM classification based on detected number of 3HB segments ($n_{3HB}$)
• Statistical Methods: Log-normal distribution fitting for translocation time distributions

Experimental Results

Major Findings

1. Velocity Profile Characteristics

• Non-uniformity: All velocity profiles exhibit non-uniform, non-monotonic two-step processes
• Deceleration-Acceleration Pattern: Polymers initially decelerate near the profile midpoint, then accelerate upon complete exit
• Boundary Conditions: Initial and final velocities are relatively independent of polymer length

2. Polymer Length Dependency

• Scaling Relationship: Translocation time $\tau \propto L^{1.21 \pm 0.01}$
• Velocity Fluctuations: Longer polymers display greater velocity fluctuations
• Minimum Velocity Location: Shorter polymers show lower $x_{min}$ values

3. Pore Diameter Dependency

• Counterintuitive Phenomenon: Translocation is slower in larger pores
• Translocation Time: Time decreases with reduced pore diameter in small pores; the opposite occurs in large pores
• Relative Fluctuations: Relative velocity fluctuations are more pronounced in large pores

4. Force Scaling Relationships

• Length Dependency: $\gamma_{out}^{max}/\gamma_{in} \propto L^{0.55 \pm 0.04}$, consistent with Flory exponent $\nu = 0.588$
• Pore Diameter Dependency: $\gamma_{in}^{-1} \propto \ln(d_{pore})$, consistent with theoretically predicted logarithmic dependence

Quantitative Results

• Initial Velocity: $v_{ini} = 13.3 \pm 0.6$ bp/μs
• Final Velocity: $v_{end} = 17.6 \pm 0.2$ bp/μs
• Velocity Difference Range: $v_{end} - v_{min} = 6.3-8.5$ bp/μs

Related Work

Theoretical Foundation

1. Tension Propagation Theory: Non-equilibrium translocation theory proposed by Saito & Sakaue et al.
2. Hydrodynamics: Drag theory for polymers in confined environments
3. Electrokinetics: Electrophoresis and electroosmotic effects in nanopores

Experimental Methods

1. Optical Tweezers: For measuring forces under fixed conformations
2. DNA Origami: For constructing structured molecular probes
3. Nanopore Sensing: Single-molecule detection and analysis techniques

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Validated Tension Propagation Theory: Experimental results show good agreement with theoretical predictions regarding polymer length and pore diameter dependencies
2. Revealed Force Scaling Relationships: Established quantitative relationships between velocity fluctuations and nanoscale forces
3. Discovered Novel Phenomena: Counterintuitive phenomenon of increased translocation time in larger pores
4. Provided Design Guidance: Offered practical knowledge for optimizing nanopore sensing performance

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: Toy model neglects out-of-pore electric field effects and end effects
2. Temporal Resolution: Signal bandwidth limitations may affect accurate measurement of rapid events
3. Theoretical Limitations: Existing theoretical models show deviations from experimental results in certain aspects

Future Directions

1. Extension to Other Polymers: Proteins, RNA, and other biological macromolecules
2. Improved Theoretical Models: Considering more complex electric field distributions and polymer-pore interactions
3. Optimized Sensing Applications: Design more efficient sensing strategies based on velocity profile knowledge

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: VPM design is ingenious, enabling direct measurement of instantaneous velocity and filling experimental technique gaps
2. Systematic Approach: Comprehensive investigation of multiple key parameters provides a complete experimental picture
3. Theoretical Validation: First experimental validation of multiple predictions from tension propagation theory
4. Practical Value: Provides direct guidance for optimizing nanopore sensing technology

Weaknesses

1. Incomplete Theoretical Explanation: Large pore phenomenon lacks convincing theoretical explanation
2. Molecular Design Limitations: Relatively fixed VPM structure makes it difficult to investigate more diverse polymer behaviors
3. Temporal Resolution Limitations: Potential measurement errors for rapid events at high voltages

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides important experimental data for polymer physics and nanopore science
2. Technological Application: Offers guidance for DNA sequencing, protein analysis, and related applications
3. Method Generalization: VPM methodology is extensible to other nanopore system studies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Polymer translocation dynamics, non-equilibrium statistical mechanics
2. Technology Development: Nanopore sensor design, single-molecule analysis techniques
3. Biological Applications: DNA/RNA sequencing, protein detection, virus analysis

References

This paper cites 45 important references covering multiple fields including nanopore technology, polymer physics, and tension propagation theory, providing solid theoretical foundation and technical support for the research.