Universal Coarse Geometry of Spin Systems

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.07912
• Title: Universal Coarse Geometry of Spin Systems
• Authors: Ali Elokl (North Carolina State University), Corey Jones (North Carolina State University)
• Classification: quant-ph math-ph math.MG math.MP
• Publication Date: December 30, 2024 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.07912

Abstract

This paper investigates the prospects of implementing highly entangled states on quantum processors with fundamentally different hardware geometries, raising a core question: to what extent do states of quantum spin systems possess intrinsic geometric structure? The authors propose that in the thermodynamic limit, both states and dynamics of spin systems possess canonically associated coarse geometric structures. For abstract spin system states φ on infinite sets X, the authors define a universal coarse structure E_φ such that a state exhibits correlation decay with respect to coarse structure E if and only if E_φ ⊆ E. Under mild assumptions, the coarse connectedness completion (E_φ)_con remains stable under quasi-local perturbations of the state.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The core problem originates from recent advances in quantum information experiments: when implementing highly entangled topologically ordered states on quantum processors, the hardware geometry may be incompatible with the theoretical model's geometry. For example, realizing a 3D spin liquid ground state on 2D hardware requires non-local encoding schemes. This raises a fundamental question: Is there a precise mathematical sense in which the "correct" geometric structure used to define entanglement-based order parameters in spin systems is an intrinsic property of the state?

Research Motivation

1. Experimentally-driven theoretical needs: Recent experiments implementing topologically ordered states on quantum processors demonstrate the need for theoretical frameworks understanding the intrinsic geometric properties of states
2. Theoretical foundations of quantum phase equivalence: Traditionally, quantum phases are defined via Hamiltonian paths, but quantum information perspectives promote state-based equivalence definitions
3. Abstraction of locality: Locality in physical systems is manifested through distance decay of correlation functions, a concept depending only on the large-scale geometric structure of the metric

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional methods rely on pre-given spatial geometric structures
• Lack of systematic frameworks for extracting geometric information from states themselves
• Insufficient theoretical guidance for compatibility with different hardware geometries

Core Contributions

1. Universal Coarse Structure Theory: Defines universal coarse structure E_f for arbitrary functions f: X×X → R⁺, such that f exhibits controlled decay with respect to coarse structure E if and only if E_f ⊆ E
2. Correlation Coarse Structure: Defines correlation coarse structure E_φ and higher-order version E_φ̃ for quantum spin system states φ, characterizing the intrinsic geometric properties of states
3. Dynamical Coarse Structure: Defines dynamical coarse structure E_α for quantum channels α, providing intrinsic characterization of dynamical locality
4. Stability Theorem: Proves that under appropriate conditions, (E_φ)_con and (E_α)_con remain stable under quasi-local perturbations
5. Coarse Dependence of Order Parameters: Proves that important order parameters such as superselection sectors and critical exponents depend only on the coarse equivalence class of the metric
6. State Preparation Complexity: Establishes coarse structure compatibility relationships between quantum circuits for state preparation and the states themselves

Methodology Details

Mathematical Framework: Discrete C*-Algebra Nets

Definition 2.1: A discrete C*-algebra net consists of:

• Countable set X (lattice points)
• Unital C*-algebra A (quasi-local algebra)
• For each finite subset F ⊆ X, unital subalgebra A_F ⊆ A (local subalgebra)

Satisfying conditions:

1. If F ⊆ G, then A_F ⊆ A_G
2. If F ∩ G = ∅, then A_F, A_G = 0
3. ⋃_{F∈F(X)} A_F is dense in A

Coarse Geometric Structures

Definition 3.1: A coarse structure E on set X is a family of subsets of X×X satisfying:

1. Contains the diagonal, closed under subsets and finite unions
2. If E ∈ E, then E⁻¹ ∈ E
3. If E, F ∈ E, then E ∘ F ∈ E

Core Construction: For function f: X×X → R⁺∪{∞}, define:

• E_{f,ε} := {(x,y) ∈ X×X : f(x,y) ≥ ε}
• E_f := ⋃{ε>0} ⟨E{f,ε}⟩

Correlation Coarse Structure

Definition 4.13: For state φ, define the two-point correlation function: $C_φ(x,y) = \sup_{a∈(A_x)_1, b∈(A_y)_1} ‖φ(ab) - φ(a)φ(b)‖$

Higher-order correlation function: $\tilde{C}_φ(F,G) = \sup_{a∈(A_F)_1, b∈(A_G)_1} ‖φ(ab) - φ(a)φ(b)‖$

Correlation coarse structure defined as: E_φ := E_{C_φ}, E_φ̃ := E_{\tilde{C}_φ}

Dynamical Coarse Structure

Definition 4.23: For quantum channel α: A→A, define the tail function: $Q_α(x,y) := \sup_{a∈(A_x)_1, b∈(A_y)_1} ‖[α(a), b]‖$

Dynamical coarse structure: E_α := E_{Q_α}

Universality Theorem

Theorem 4.2: For any function f: X×X → R⁺∪{∞}, there exists coarse structure E_f such that: f exhibits controlled decay with respect to coarse structure E if and only if E_f ⊆ E.

Main Theoretical Results

Stability Theorem

Theorem 5.3 (Correlation Coarse Structure Stability): Let φ: A→B be a ucp map with E_φ genuine and singly generated. Then for any quasi-local perturbation Ψ: A→A, we have (E_{φ∘Ψ}) = (E_φ).

Theorem 5.7 (Dynamical Coarse Structure Stability): Similar stability results hold for dynamical coarse structures.

State Preparation Complexity

Theorem 1.5: If φ is a state and α is a circuit preparing φ from a product state, then E_φ̃ ⊆ E_α̃.

This implies that preparing states with certain coarse complexity requires circuits of at least comparable complexity.

Coarse Dependence of Order Parameters

Proposition 7.6: Definitions of zero correlation length, finite correlation length, and infinite correlation length depend only on the quasi-equivalence class of the metric.

Proposition 7.10: Algebraic decay of correlation functions and critical exponents are independent of the quasi-equivalence class of the metric.

Applications and Examples

Physical System Examples

1. Ground states of gapped Hamiltonians: Exhibit exponentially decaying correlation functions
2. Equilibrium states: Gibbs or KMS states at low and high temperatures exhibit controlled decay
3. Quantum cellular automata: Dynamical coarse structure recovers the original geometric structure
4. Spin systems on Cayley graphs: Coarse structures of translation-invariant factor states are contained in the group's coarse structure

Coarse Geometric Formulation of Topological Order

Definition 7.3: A Hilbert space representation H satisfies the coarse superselection criterion on (X,d) if for any triple L,C,D, there exists constant R ≥ 0 such that for any coarse L,C,D cone f: D→X, H is localizable in f(D)+R.

Proposition 7.4:

1. If d' is quasi-isometric to d, then Sec^d_φ = Sec^{d'}_φ
2. If (X,d) = Z^n, then Sec^d_φ = Sec_φ

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic application of coarse geometry theory to quantum many-body systems, providing rigorous mathematical framework for intrinsic geometric properties of states
2. Universality: Framework applies to classical and quantum systems, as well as more complex algebraic structures
3. Stability Guarantees: Proves stability of coarse structures under physically relevant perturbations, providing theoretical assurance for practical applications
4. Computational Feasibility: Provides methods for estimating coarse structures in finite systems through asymptotic dimension and growth functions
5. Deep Insights: Reveals that many "universal" properties are actually coarse geometric properties, offering new perspectives on renormalization group theory

Limitations

1. Practical Constraints: Theoretical framework primarily applies to thermodynamic limit; applications to finite systems require further development
2. Computational Complexity: Complete determination of coarse structures may be computationally complex in practice, requiring efficient algorithms
3. Physical Intuition: Highly abstract mathematical framework may be difficult to connect directly with physical intuition
4. Experimental Verification: Methods for experimental verification of theoretical predictions remain underdeveloped

Impact

1. Theoretical Physics: Provides new mathematical tools for phase classification and critical phenomena in condensed matter physics
2. Quantum Information: Provides theoretical guidance for geometric compatibility of state implementation on quantum processors
3. Mathematical Physics: Establishes deep connections between operator algebra theory and coarse geometry
4. Interdisciplinary Impact: Methods may apply to network theory, topological data analysis, and other fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Simulation: Guides implementation of target quantum states on different hardware geometries
2. Phase Classification: Quantum phase equivalence classification based on coarse geometry
3. Critical Phenomena: Study of universal properties near critical points
4. Topological Quantum Computing: Understanding geometric dependence of topological order

Conclusion and Outlook

This paper establishes rigorous mathematical theory for the intrinsic geometric structures of states and dynamics in quantum spin systems. Through the coarse geometry framework, the authors prove that many important physical properties depend only on large-scale geometric structure rather than specific metric details. This theory not only provides new perspectives for understanding quantum many-body systems but also offers solutions to geometric compatibility problems in quantum information processing.

Future research directions include:

1. Developing efficient computational methods for coarse structures in finite systems
2. Establishing connections with topological data analysis tools such as persistent homology
3. Exploring applications of coarse geometry framework in quantum field theory
4. Developing quantum phase classification theory based on coarse geometry

This work opens new directions for interdisciplinary research between mathematical physics and quantum information, possessing significant theoretical value and potential practical significance.